popular articles

The Future of Nord Stream Without Russia: A Reevaluation of European Gas Infrastructure

As Russian gas deliveries via Nord Stream have ceased, Europe is exploring possible solutions to repurpose or replace this major infrastructure within a complex energy transition and diversification of supply sources.

Please share:

The Nord Stream pipeline, which for years enabled the transport of Russian natural gas to Europe, is now at a standstill following the complete suspension of Russian flows. This shift, driven by geopolitical, economic, and environmental factors, raises important questions about the future of this infrastructure and the potential alternatives to ensure Europe’s energy security.

Habeck and Germany’s Position on Nord Stream

German Economy Minister Robert Habeck clearly stated on March 17, 2025, that resuming Russian gas deliveries via Nord Stream would be a “wrong direction.” According to him, Europe should not replace its dependency on Russian gas with a new dependency on liquefied natural gas (LNG) from the United States. Furthermore, Habeck emphasized the importance of supporting Ukraine and focusing on a gradual reduction of fossil fuel imports in favor of developing renewable energy sources. These comments come at a time when Russia continues to influence European energy discussions, especially after Vladimir Putin’s proposal on March 13, 2025, for renewed energy cooperation with Washington to provide more gas to Europe.

Economic Costs of Infrastructure Conversion

One scenario being considered by Europe for the future of the Nord Stream pipelines is to repurpose them for transporting hydrogen (H₂). However, this option represents a significant investment. Experts estimate that converting the existing pipelines to infrastructure for hydrogen could cost between 4 and 5 billion euros for both Nord Stream pipelines. This cost includes necessary modifications to compressor stations, turbines, and pipeline materials, which must be adapted to support hydrogen, a lighter and more aggressive gas for metal infrastructure.

Hydrogen is still an emerging energy source, and its production cost remains high. In 2023, the production price of renewable hydrogen was between 4 and 6 euros per kg, while the price of natural gas remains below 2.5 euros per kg. Additionally, the profitability of converting Nord Stream into hydrogen infrastructure will heavily depend on EU policies, which will need to implement tax incentives and regulations that support this transition.

Alternatives and Necessary Investments

Another option considered by Europe would be to redirect the existing pipelines to new gas suppliers, such as Norway. However, this solution would require additional investments in subsea infrastructure, with the cost estimated at around 3 to 4 billion euros for the new connections. This option remains economically uncertain, as it would compete with existing solutions, such as recently installed LNG terminals in Germany.

LNG, while essential for diversifying supply sources, remains an expensive solution. In 2022, benchmark gas prices in Europe reached record levels of 319.98 €/MWh. Although these prices decreased in 2023 to stabilize around 42.22 €/MWh, LNG supply is still more expensive than pipeline gas deliveries, placing pressure on the energy costs of European businesses.

Asset Depreciation and Abandonment Costs

In the event of abandoning the Nord Stream pipelines, Europe would face a significant economic loss. The construction of the two Nord Stream pipelines cost around 10 billion euros for Gazprom, not including maintenance and operational costs. A total abandonment of this infrastructure would result in a major depreciation of assets, reducing their market value. This depreciation could amount to several billion euros, and the abandonment process would incur additional costs for dismantling and repurposing the infrastructure for other uses.

The impact on European financial markets would also be significant. The suspension of Russian gas flows has already caused price hikes and increased volatility in the energy market, with consequences for production costs in several industrial sectors. European companies must also face considerable investments to replace Russian gas with other sources of supply.

Future Scenarios: An Expensive Energy Transition

The choice between converting Nord Stream infrastructure for hydrogen transport or completely abandoning it represents a major strategic challenge for Europe. Conversion could allow Europe to secure a cleaner long-term gas supply while contributing to the energy transition. However, this option would involve high conversion costs and uncertainties about the profitability of hydrogen as a competitive energy source.

Furthermore, abandoning the pipelines and relying more on LNG imports and renewable energy would increase costs in the short and medium term. According to the International Energy Agency (IEA), transitioning to a decarbonized energy economy in Europe could require investments of more than 30 billion euros over the coming decades to secure the necessary infrastructure and ensure energy supply without relying on fossil fuels.

Register free of charge for uninterrupted access.

Publicite

Recently published in

Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin are set to discuss the sharing of rare earth resources in Ukraine on Tuesday, including energy production plants and territories rich in raw materials. These resources are at the heart of the ceasefire negotiations.
UK Energy Minister Ed Miliband met Chinese officials in Beijing to discuss energy cooperation and reducing greenhouse gas emissions, despite disagreements over Hong Kong, forced labour, and the war in Ukraine.
UK Energy Minister Ed Miliband met Chinese officials in Beijing to discuss energy cooperation and reducing greenhouse gas emissions, despite disagreements over Hong Kong, forced labour, and the war in Ukraine.
The European Union has announced a €4.7 billion investment to support South Africa’s energy transition. This initiative is part of a broader strategy of economic cooperation and strategic repositioning of international partners.
The European Union has announced a €4.7 billion investment to support South Africa’s energy transition. This initiative is part of a broader strategy of economic cooperation and strategic repositioning of international partners.
American and Vietnamese companies have signed several commercial agreements totaling $4.15 billion, primarily in the energy and aviation sectors, aiming to reduce the trade imbalance between the two countries.
American and Vietnamese companies have signed several commercial agreements totaling $4.15 billion, primarily in the energy and aviation sectors, aiming to reduce the trade imbalance between the two countries.
Presidents Vladimir Putin and Nicolás Maduro announced an agreement to expand their cooperation, particularly in the energy sector. This initiative comes amid increased U.S. sanctions against Caracas.
A tripartite meeting between China, Russia and Iran will be held in Beijing to address the Iranian nuclear dossier as tensions surrounding Iran's nuclear programme continue to rise.
A tripartite meeting between China, Russia and Iran will be held in Beijing to address the Iranian nuclear dossier as tensions surrounding Iran's nuclear programme continue to rise.
Guyana’s President, Mohamed Irfaan Ali, reaffirmed his commitment to a diplomatic resolution of the territorial dispute with Venezuela over the Essequibo region as tensions escalate over offshore oil resources.
Guyana’s President, Mohamed Irfaan Ali, reaffirmed his commitment to a diplomatic resolution of the territorial dispute with Venezuela over the Essequibo region as tensions escalate over offshore oil resources.
Donald Trump applies his negotiation methods to the energy sector, leveraging tariffs and targeted statements to influence markets and trading partners. Behind these decisions lies an ambiguous commercial strategy blending bluff and concrete actions.
Donald Trump applies his negotiation methods to the energy sector, leveraging tariffs and targeted statements to influence markets and trading partners. Behind these decisions lies an ambiguous commercial strategy blending bluff and concrete actions.
Newcleo and Danieli have signed a strategic agreement to integrate advanced nuclear reactors into steel production processes, aiming to eliminate fossil fuel use amid rising energy costs in Europe's industrial sectors.
The U.S. Secretary of Energy has announced a strategic shift towards fossil fuels, abandoning several climate-related policies from the previous administration, creating uncertainty among energy professionals about long-term market stability.
The U.S. Secretary of Energy has announced a strategic shift towards fossil fuels, abandoning several climate-related policies from the previous administration, creating uncertainty among energy professionals about long-term market stability.
The United States has decided not to renew Iraq’s exemption, granted since 2018, allowing Baghdad to import electricity from Iran despite U.S. sanctions. This measure increases pressure on Iraq, whose energy supply largely depends on its neighbour.
The United States has decided not to renew Iraq’s exemption, granted since 2018, allowing Baghdad to import electricity from Iran despite U.S. sanctions. This measure increases pressure on Iraq, whose energy supply largely depends on its neighbour.
The United Kingdom has removed 24 Syrian entities from its sanctions list, including the Central Bank, allowing for the resumption of financial and commercial activities. This decision forms part of a broader trend of easing restrictions on Syria.
The United Kingdom has removed 24 Syrian entities from its sanctions list, including the Central Bank, allowing for the resumption of financial and commercial activities. This decision forms part of a broader trend of easing restrictions on Syria.
Ukraine and the United States have signed a framework agreement aimed at jointly exploiting Ukraine’s mineral resources, including rare earth elements, oil, and natural gas. The agreement comes amid the ongoing war with Russia and seeks to strengthen economic cooperation between the two nations.
Quebec has signed a letter of intent with the Netherlands to strengthen their cooperation on critical and strategic minerals, aiming to diversify markets and attract new investments.
Quebec has signed a letter of intent with the Netherlands to strengthen their cooperation on critical and strategic minerals, aiming to diversify markets and attract new investments.
China has announced new fiscal measures in response to the increase in US customs duties, excluding energy products such as liquefied natural gas (LNG) from these measures.
China has announced new fiscal measures in response to the increase in US customs duties, excluding energy products such as liquefied natural gas (LNG) from these measures.
Guyana has expressed its protest following the incursion of a Venezuelan military ship into its waters near an oil block. The incident occurs amidst ongoing territorial tensions between the two nations.
Guyana has expressed its protest following the incursion of a Venezuelan military ship into its waters near an oil block. The incident occurs amidst ongoing territorial tensions between the two nations.
Russia has once again accused Ukraine of attacking the TurkStream pipeline with drones, marking the second attack in two months aimed at disrupting Russian gas deliveries to Europe.
Washington has granted a 30-day delay before imposing sanctions on NIS, Serbia's largest oil and gas company, majority-controlled by Russian Gazprom, as announced by Serbian President Aleksandar Vucic.
Washington has granted a 30-day delay before imposing sanctions on NIS, Serbia's largest oil and gas company, majority-controlled by Russian Gazprom, as announced by Serbian President Aleksandar Vucic.
France has been negotiating with Ukraine since October to secure access to strategic raw materials necessary for its defence industry. This move is part of a broader strategy to diversify supply sources.
France has been negotiating with Ukraine since October to secure access to strategic raw materials necessary for its defence industry. This move is part of a broader strategy to diversify supply sources.
On 22 February, Gabon launched the first phase of its electricity interconnection project with Equatorial Guinea, aiming to import 10 MW of electricity for several Gabonese localities.
On 22 February, Gabon launched the first phase of its electricity interconnection project with Equatorial Guinea, aiming to import 10 MW of electricity for several Gabonese localities.
The U.S. government announced new sanctions targeting 22 individuals, companies, and 13 vessels accused of circumventing sanctions on Iranian oil, as part of its "maximum pressure" policy.
Gabon and Equatorial Guinea have interconnected their power grids, allowing the immediate import of 3 megawatts to supply northern Gabon, which has been facing persistent shortages.
Gabon and Equatorial Guinea have interconnected their power grids, allowing the immediate import of 3 megawatts to supply northern Gabon, which has been facing persistent shortages.
Amid rising Russian threats, Norway and the UK will enhance their collaboration to safeguard their vital underwater infrastructure.
Amid rising Russian threats, Norway and the UK will enhance their collaboration to safeguard their vital underwater infrastructure.
A drone strike in Russia has forced the shutdown of a key pumping station on the Caspian Pipeline Consortium (CPC) pipeline, temporarily reducing its capacity to transport Kazakh oil to Europe. The incident comes amid heightened diplomatic tensions surrounding the Ukraine conflict.
A drone strike in Russia has forced the shutdown of a key pumping station on the Caspian Pipeline Consortium (CPC) pipeline, temporarily reducing its capacity to transport Kazakh oil to Europe. The incident comes amid heightened diplomatic tensions surrounding the Ukraine conflict.

Advertising