The Future of Nord Stream Without Russia: A Reevaluation of European Gas Infrastructure

As Russian gas deliveries via Nord Stream have ceased, Europe is exploring possible solutions to repurpose or replace this major infrastructure within a complex energy transition and diversification of supply sources.

Share:

Gain full professional access to energynews.pro from 4.90$/month.
Designed for decision-makers, with no long-term commitment.

Over 30,000 articles published since 2021.
150 new market analyses every week to decode global energy trends.

Monthly Digital PRO PASS

Immediate Access
4.90$/month*

No commitment – cancel anytime, activation in 2 minutes.

*Special launch offer: 1st month at the indicated price, then 14.90 $/month, no long-term commitment.

Annual Digital PRO Pass

Full Annual Access
99$/year*

To access all of energynews.pro without any limits

*Introductory annual price for year one, automatically renewed at 149.00 $/year from the second year.

The Nord Stream pipeline, which for years enabled the transport of Russian natural gas to Europe, is now at a standstill following the complete suspension of Russian flows. This shift, driven by geopolitical, economic, and environmental factors, raises important questions about the future of this infrastructure and the potential alternatives to ensure Europe’s energy security.

Habeck and Germany’s Position on Nord Stream

German Economy Minister Robert Habeck clearly stated on March 17, 2025, that resuming Russian gas deliveries via Nord Stream would be a “wrong direction.” According to him, Europe should not replace its dependency on Russian gas with a new dependency on liquefied natural gas (LNG) from the United States. Furthermore, Habeck emphasized the importance of supporting Ukraine and focusing on a gradual reduction of fossil fuel imports in favor of developing renewable energy sources. These comments come at a time when Russia continues to influence European energy discussions, especially after Vladimir Putin’s proposal on March 13, 2025, for renewed energy cooperation with Washington to provide more gas to Europe.

Economic Costs of Infrastructure Conversion

One scenario being considered by Europe for the future of the Nord Stream pipelines is to repurpose them for transporting hydrogen (H₂). However, this option represents a significant investment. Experts estimate that converting the existing pipelines to infrastructure for hydrogen could cost between 4 and 5 billion euros for both Nord Stream pipelines. This cost includes necessary modifications to compressor stations, turbines, and pipeline materials, which must be adapted to support hydrogen, a lighter and more aggressive gas for metal infrastructure.

Hydrogen is still an emerging energy source, and its production cost remains high. In 2023, the production price of renewable hydrogen was between 4 and 6 euros per kg, while the price of natural gas remains below 2.5 euros per kg. Additionally, the profitability of converting Nord Stream into hydrogen infrastructure will heavily depend on EU policies, which will need to implement tax incentives and regulations that support this transition.

Alternatives and Necessary Investments

Another option considered by Europe would be to redirect the existing pipelines to new gas suppliers, such as Norway. However, this solution would require additional investments in subsea infrastructure, with the cost estimated at around 3 to 4 billion euros for the new connections. This option remains economically uncertain, as it would compete with existing solutions, such as recently installed LNG terminals in Germany.

LNG, while essential for diversifying supply sources, remains an expensive solution. In 2022, benchmark gas prices in Europe reached record levels of 319.98 €/MWh. Although these prices decreased in 2023 to stabilize around 42.22 €/MWh, LNG supply is still more expensive than pipeline gas deliveries, placing pressure on the energy costs of European businesses.

Asset Depreciation and Abandonment Costs

In the event of abandoning the Nord Stream pipelines, Europe would face a significant economic loss. The construction of the two Nord Stream pipelines cost around 10 billion euros for Gazprom, not including maintenance and operational costs. A total abandonment of this infrastructure would result in a major depreciation of assets, reducing their market value. This depreciation could amount to several billion euros, and the abandonment process would incur additional costs for dismantling and repurposing the infrastructure for other uses.

The impact on European financial markets would also be significant. The suspension of Russian gas flows has already caused price hikes and increased volatility in the energy market, with consequences for production costs in several industrial sectors. European companies must also face considerable investments to replace Russian gas with other sources of supply.

Future Scenarios: An Expensive Energy Transition

The choice between converting Nord Stream infrastructure for hydrogen transport or completely abandoning it represents a major strategic challenge for Europe. Conversion could allow Europe to secure a cleaner long-term gas supply while contributing to the energy transition. However, this option would involve high conversion costs and uncertainties about the profitability of hydrogen as a competitive energy source.

Furthermore, abandoning the pipelines and relying more on LNG imports and renewable energy would increase costs in the short and medium term. According to the International Energy Agency (IEA), transitioning to a decarbonized energy economy in Europe could require investments of more than 30 billion euros over the coming decades to secure the necessary infrastructure and ensure energy supply without relying on fossil fuels.

Donald Trump threatens to escalate US sanctions against Russia, but only if NATO member states stop all Russian oil imports, which remain active via certain pipelines.
The two countries agreed to develop infrastructure dedicated to liquefied natural gas to strengthen Europe's energy security and boost transatlantic trade.
Ayatollah Ali Khamenei calls for modernising the oil industry and expanding export markets as Tehran faces the possible reactivation of 2015 nuclear deal sanctions.
The Ukrainian president demanded that Slovakia end its imports of Russian crude, offering an alternative supply solution amid ongoing war and growing diplomatic tensions over the Druzhba pipeline.
The United States cuts tariffs on Japanese imports to 15%, while Tokyo launches a massive investment plan targeting American energy, industry, and agriculture.
Brazil’s Cop 30 presidency aims to leverage the Dubai commitments to mobilise public and private actors despite ongoing deadlock in international negotiations.
Brasília has officially begun the process of joining the International Energy Agency, strengthening its strategic position on the global energy stage after years of close cooperation with the Paris-based organisation.
During a meeting in Beijing, Vladimir Putin called on Slovakia to suspend its energy deliveries to Ukraine, citing Ukrainian strikes on Russian energy infrastructure as justification.
Vladimir Putin and Robert Fico met in China to address the war in Ukraine, regional security and energy relations between Russia and Slovakia.
Slovak Prime Minister Robert Fico plans to meet Vladimir Putin in Beijing before receiving Volodymyr Zelensky in Bratislava, marking a diplomatic shift in his relations with Moscow and Kyiv.
The three European powers activate the UN sanctions mechanism against Iran, increasing pressure on the country's oil exports as Tehran maintains high production despite Western measures.
Iran once again authorises the International Atomic Energy Agency to inspect its nuclear sites, following a suspension triggered by a dispute over responsibility for Israeli strikes.
First suspect linked to the Nord Stream pipeline explosions, a Ukrainian citizen challenged by Berlin opposes his judicial transfer from Italy.
Ukrainian drones targeted a nuclear power plant and a Russian oil terminal, increasing pressure on diplomatic talks as Moscow and Kyiv accuse each other of blocking any prospect of negotiation.
A Ukrainian national suspected of coordinating the Nord Stream pipeline sabotage has been apprehended in Italy, reigniting a judicial case with significant geopolitical implications across Europe.
Russia continues hydrocarbon deliveries to India and explores new outlets for liquefied natural gas, amid escalating trade tensions with the United States.
Azerbaijani energy infrastructure targeted in Ukraine raises concerns over the security of gas flows between Baku and Kyiv, just as a new supply agreement has been signed.
The suspension of 1,400 MW of electricity supplied by Iran to Iraq puts pressure on the Iraqi grid, while Tehran records a record 77 GW demand and must balance domestic consumption with regional obligations.
Beijing opposes the possible return of European trio sanctions against Iran, as the nuclear deal deadline approaches and diplomatic tensions rise around Tehran.
The United States plans to collaborate with Pakistan on critical minerals and hydrocarbons, exploring joint ventures and projects in strategic areas such as Balochistan.

Log in to read this article

You'll also have access to a selection of our best content.