ScottishPower halts green hydrogen projects despite public funding

ScottishPower pauses its renewable hydrogen projects in the United Kingdom, despite receiving public subsidies, citing a lack of commercial viability under the HAR1 programme.

Share:

Gain full professional access to energynews.pro from 4.90$/month.
Designed for decision-makers, with no long-term commitment.

Over 30,000 articles published since 2021.
150 new market analyses every week to decode global energy trends.

Monthly Digital PRO PASS

Immediate Access
4.90$/month*

No commitment – cancel anytime, activation in 2 minutes.

*Special launch offer: 1st month at the indicated price, then 14.90 $/month, no long-term commitment.

Annual Digital PRO Pass

Full Annual Access
99$/year*

To access all of energynews.pro without any limits

*Introductory annual price for year one, automatically renewed at 149.00 $/year from the second year.

ScottishPower has decided to suspend the development of all its renewable hydrogen projects, citing unfavourable market conditions. The decision comes as two of its projects had been selected under the first Hydrogen Allocation Round (HAR1) launched by the UK government.

The company has not yet drawn on the public funds allocated, as the projects had not reached the final investment decision stage. The Whitelee project, with a capacity of 7.1 MW, was intended to supply the transport and industry sectors in Scotland, while the 10.6 MW Cromarty project, developed in partnership with Storegga, was aimed at whisky distilleries. ScottishPower stated that despite supporting the development of this technology, the lack of sufficient commercial prospects led it to suspend its activities in this field.

Public support facing uncertain profitability

The HAR1 programme, launched in December 2024, awarded subsidies to 11 projects totalling 125 MW, with an average guaranteed price of GBP241/MWh, equivalent to about GBP9.50/kg ($12.50/kg). In comparison, the estimated production cost of hydrogen via alkaline electrolysis, including capital expenditure, was assessed at GBP5.46/kg ($7.31/kg) on September 1, based on forward electricity prices.

ScottishPower had signed subsidy agreements for both projects, with tariffs of GBP188.56/MWh for Whitelee and GBP214.27/MWh for Cromarty. Ten of the eleven HAR1 projects have now signed their funding contracts. One of them, HyMarnham Power, began production in July with an initial volume of 8 tonnes per week, expected to reach 30 tonnes weekly by October.

A contrast between public subsidy and private withdrawal

The suspension by ScottishPower comes as the company continues to invest in renewable energy and electricity infrastructure in the United Kingdom, with more than GBP24bn ($32bn) committed through 2028. This situation raises questions about the alignment between public funding support and the actual engagement of beneficiary companies.

The UK Department for Energy Security and Net Zero did not respond to requests regarding this suspension. Cromarty’s project partner, Storegga, has also not made any public comment on ScottishPower’s decision.

Dissonance between industrial strategy and public support

While some HAR1 projects are progressing quickly, ScottishPower’s withdrawal highlights divergences between the public objectives of supporting green hydrogen and the economic reality for private operators. This situation raises questions about the effectiveness of public incentive mechanisms compared with industrial strategies driven by profitability.

The H2 Créteil station, powered by an Energy Recovery Unit, will produce up to two tonnes of renewable hydrogen per day starting in October 2025.
Driven by technological advances and supportive policies, the global hydrogen fuel cell market is rapidly expanding, with a projected valuation of $42.3bn by 2035.
With four sites now RFNBO certified in France and Germany, Lhyfe reaches 21 MW of installed capacity, strengthening its position as a European leader in renewable hydrogen production through water electrolysis.
ACWA Power and Larsen & Toubro will collaborate on renewable infrastructure for a green hydrogen project in Yanbu, Saudi Arabia, targeting 4 GW of electrolysis capacity by 2030.
HIF Global has chosen American-made electrolyser technology from Electric Hydrogen for its large-scale e-methanol production project in Texas, marking a major industrial milestone in the synthetic fuels sector.
French manufacturer HRS will supply Element 2 with a mobile HRX14 hydrogen station for Glasgow, marking its fourth installation in the UK and strengthening its position in the British market.
A regional study in Auvergne-Rhône-Alpes shows that pooling hydrogen infrastructure could generate up to 20% in savings and enhance the national electricity system’s flexibility.
Elcogen opens a 14,000 m² facility near Tallinn, increasing annual capacity to 360 MW for Solid Oxide fuel cells and electrolysers, with backing from Baker Hughes and HD Hyundai.
Several subsurface stimulation techniques aim to generate hydrogen in situ at low cost. Pilots are advancing, but heterogeneous Technology Readiness Levels (TRL), geological uncertainties, and monitoring requirements are slowing investment.
Viridien takes a strategic stake in Mantle8 to boost natural hydrogen exploration across Europe, the Middle East and Africa by combining geological data and seismic detection technologies.
A partnership between AquaVentus and Hydrogen Scotland aims to connect Scottish offshore wind farms to a cross-border green hydrogen production and export infrastructure in the North Sea.
Electric Hydrogen announces the acquisition of Ambient Fuels and an alliance with Generate Capital to offer up to $400 mn in hydrogen project financing worldwide starting in 2026.
Hynfra PSA strengthens its presence in West Africa with a $1.5bn green ammonia project, backed by the Mauritanian government, with commercial operations expected to start by 2030.
Over 500 hydrogen projects are now under construction or operational worldwide, with total committed investments reaching USD110 billion, representing an increase of USD35 billion in one year.
From 2029, Verso Energy will supply hydrogen produced in Moselle to steel group SHS, supported by a cross-border pipeline and an industrial investment exceeding €100mn.
The success of SGN’s test on a gas pipeline converted to hydrogen confirms Terra Firma Energy’s technological choices, with sites already equipped to accommodate this type of energy investment.
Lhyfe has started supplying Essent with renewable green hydrogen under a multi-year contract, marking a major commercial debut in the Netherlands for the French producer.
The Dutch government grants major funding to RWE to develop an offshore wind-powered electrolysis facility, marking a key step in the OranjeWind project.
thyssenkrupp nucera has completed the purchase of key assets from Green Hydrogen Systems, strengthening its position in pressurised alkaline electrolysis for industrial hydrogen production.
GH2 Solar Ltd partners with AHES Ltd to build an electrolyzer plant in Gwalior, targeting 500 MW capacity by 2030 with $19mn government support.

Log in to read this article

You'll also have access to a selection of our best content.