popular articles

Fukushima Nuclear Power Plant: 10 Years Later

The Fukushima nuclear power plant is back in the spotlight on March 11, 2021. At 11:46 a.m., Japan stopped in tribute to the victims.
fk

Please share:

The Fukushima nuclear power plant is back in the spotlight this March 11, 2021, 10 years after the disaster. At 11:46 a.m., Japan paused to pay tribute to the 22,000 victims, commemorating events whose consequences are still very much with us. Following the accident, Japan wanted to get rid of nuclear power for good.

However, the current government is aware that the country will not be able to decarbonize its economy without atomic energy. What’s more, since the disaster, the entire nuclear industry has had to guarantee the safety and control of its facilities. EDF and others are also committed to this objective.

Fukushima nuclear power plant: Japan remembers

On March 11, 2011, Japan was hit by a tsunami caused by a magnitude 9 earthquake. According to the IAEA, waves of over 15 meters are inundating the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power plant, which is only resistant to earthquakes of magnitude 7. The cooling systems jammed and failed to prevent core meltdown, leading to the explosion of the plant’s boiling water reactors.

Over 160,000 inhabitants fled as radiation spread through the air and water. These displacements in the confusion claimed 2,000 new victims. Japan’s Prime Minister at the time, Naoto Kan, even feared he would have to evacuate Tokyo’s 14 million inhabitants.

Japan marked for the rest of its history

The Japanese government will have to spend USD 300 billion to rebuild the Tohoku region, devastated by the tsunami. The contaminated zone around the Fukushima nuclear power plant remains off-limits due to high radiation levels. Its dismantling still raises many questions and is expected to take decades.

Since the Fukushima nuclear accident, nuclear reactors have been cooled with water that comes out loaded with radioactive components. The contaminated water is then stored on site by the Tokyo-based electricity company Tepco and its partners, such as Orano. The contaminated water, which has already reached a million cubic meters, is expected to saturate the reservoirs as early as 2022.

“Fukushima is marked for the rest of its history by nuclear power,” says Kiyoshi Kurokawa, head of the Fukushima nuclear accident investigation.

As a result of the accident, public opinion massively rejected this energy source. This presents decision-makers with a major dilemma.

Japanese nuclear

Hiroshima, Nagasaki, Daigo Fukuryu, then Fukushima

The outlook for public opinion on nuclear power remains poor. Indeed, the country’s painful relationship with the atom is deeply rooted in its history. The bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, followed by the contamination of Daigo Fukuryu by radioactive fallout, are lasting historical traumas.

What alternative to the Fukushima nuclear power plant?

The tsunami and explosion at the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power plant have caused lasting damage. They convinced the government of the day that the risks of nuclear power far outweighed its benefits. Immediately after the Fukushima nuclear disaster, Japan shut down its 54 reactors, around a third of which were permanently scrapped.

The country has decided to turn away from nuclear power in favor of renewable energies (RE). Fukushima prefecture is becoming a testing ground for the energy transition, with the government joining forces with local communities and businesses. In 2012, the prefecture set its sights on 100% renewable electricity by 2040, reaching 35% of its energy mix by 2019.

100% RE, a utopia

Despite our best efforts, it seems unlikely that renewable energies will be able to replace nuclear power in the country’s energy supply. Indeed, Japan lacks flat land for solar panels, and the depth of the oceans increases the cost of offshore wind power. According to the Minister of the Economy, Mr. Kajiyama, it will be difficult for Japan to cover more than 60% of its needs from renewable energy.

In the first half of 2020, renewable energies supplied 23% of the country’s electricity. Japan is therefore a long way behind Germany, which is also nuclear-free and whose energy mix is 46% RE.

fukushima

10 years on, time for the Fukushima nuclear power plant to return?

Conservative Prime Minister Yoshihide Suga has promised the Japanese people carbon neutrality by 2050. However, with 70% of the country’s energy mix made up of fossil fuels, most of which are imported, this goal is utopian. For Mr. Suga, as for his predecessor Shinzo Abe, Japan’s energy transition means a return to nuclear power.

Japan’s nuclear program is therefore slowly getting back on track, with the Takahama reactors due to come back on stream shortly. Despite being 40 years old, the regulatory authority has extended their use for a further 20 years.

But the deadlines Japan has set itself for achieving its decarbonization targets already seem too short. To reduce emissions by just 26% by 2030, Japan would have to restart all its reactors and build more. Otherwise, only 18 reactors will be in service in 2050, even if the life of existing reactors is extended.

53% of Japanese oppose restarting reactors

Society’s support for widespread nuclear power remains uncertain. This is why many Japanese authorities are reluctant to approve the restarting of reactors. Some courts have also approved requests for the temporary closure of operating reactors.

It has to be said that while the mass anti-nuclear protests observed after March 11, 2021 have faded, mistrust persists. An Asahi survey revealed in February that 53% of Japanese are opposed to restarting the reactors, against 32% in favor. In Fukushima, only 16% supported restarting the units.

At the political level, the opposition is also up in arms against the return of nuclear power. Critics point to cost, insecurity and the problems of storing nuclear waste as the main drawbacks.

“Those who talk about atomic energy are people from the ‘nuclear village’, who want to protect their interests,” says former Prime Minister Naoto Kan.

fukushima

UN says radiation impact minimal

Yet the latest UNSCEAR report states that the meltdown of the reactors has not harmed the health of the local population. According to the UN organization, there is no credible evidence of excessive birth defects or premature deliveries linked to radioactive releases. It also denies the link between the accident and the rise in thyroid cancer among exposed children.

UNSCEAR has also assessed information on transfers of radioactive materials released into terrestrial, freshwater and marine environments. It therefore considers that the impact on flora and fauna remains low. The report does, however, point out that adverse effects on certain species have been observed in areas of increased radiation.

EDF, expert in nuclear safety

Nuclear power generates 10% of the world’s electricity, compared with 18% in the mid-90s. The construction of new nuclear power plants is lagging far behind the pace of closures, according to the IEA.

Nevertheless, nuclear power remains an important solution for achieving global climate objectives. The industry is therefore trying to bounce back by providing guarantees of radiation protection and nuclear safety. The French sector is particularly dynamic in this area, as evidenced by the numerous projects piloted by EDF.
METIS project: channelling knowledge about seismic risk

The EDF Group’s METIS project aims to consolidate scientific knowledge of the seismic risk posed by power plants. The project is led by an international consortium comprising 13 European partners and three American and Japanese organizations. With a budget of €5 million, it aims to improve and standardize seismic safety assessments for power plants.

The results of this project will enable a better understanding of risks in the European context. METIS will then help optimize the use of existing and future reactors, ultimately boosting the competitiveness of the nuclear industry.

The digital reactor, towards augmented nuclear power plants

EDF is also piloting an association of eight organizations that is concentrating skills to develop the digital reactor.
According to Benoît Levesque of EDF’s R&D department, this reactor is a “digital and functional replica of a nuclear power plant”.
It will enable operators to train in virtual reality to carry out maintenance or operating tasks in a nuclear reactor. At the same time, engineers will be able to study the behavior and environment of the reactors. Ultimately, these studies will help prepare the population for as many eventualities as possible. This is an essential step forward for a disaster that Kiyoshi Kurokawa describes as “profoundly human in origin”.

Register free of charge for uninterrupted access.

Publicite

Recently published in

Three trade trajectories projected by Wood Mackenzie show how tariff tensions could shift demand, prices and investment in the global energy sector.
The European Commission states the Union is on track to cut emissions by 54% by 2030, following updated national plans.
The European Commission states the Union is on track to cut emissions by 54% by 2030, following updated national plans.
South Korea announces two major tenders totaling 2.25 GW, split between offshore wind and solar, introducing new economic and technical criteria designed to strengthen energy security and attract international investors.
South Korea announces two major tenders totaling 2.25 GW, split between offshore wind and solar, introducing new economic and technical criteria designed to strengthen energy security and attract international investors.
Ember anticipates that a third of ASEAN data centre electricity demand could be met by wind and solar by 2030, without batteries, if appropriate political measures are implemented.
Ember anticipates that a third of ASEAN data centre electricity demand could be met by wind and solar by 2030, without batteries, if appropriate political measures are implemented.
A Rocky Mountain Institute report reveals India’s energy ambition, with electricity demand potentially tripling by 2050, backed by an industrial policy focused on renewable energy.
The Indonesian government targets a mixed energy expansion involving coal, gas, renewables, and nuclear, requiring IDR2,967.4tn ($235bn) in investment by the end of 2034.
The Indonesian government targets a mixed energy expansion involving coal, gas, renewables, and nuclear, requiring IDR2,967.4tn ($235bn) in investment by the end of 2034.
Canadian Natural Resources Minister Tim Hodgson announces reforms to the energy permitting process, aiming to stimulate investments and strengthen relations between the government and industry.
Canadian Natural Resources Minister Tim Hodgson announces reforms to the energy permitting process, aiming to stimulate investments and strengthen relations between the government and industry.
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency is finalising a proposal to lift emissions caps for thermal power plants, amid a broader shift toward national energy security.
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency is finalising a proposal to lift emissions caps for thermal power plants, amid a broader shift toward national energy security.
The Pakistani government is releasing 2,000 megawatts of power to support the development of data centres focused on artificial intelligence and Bitcoin mining, as part of a strategy to attract foreign investment.
In April, China generated 26% of its electricity from wind and solar, according to Ember, marking a historic first that reflects a rapid rebalancing of its energy mix.
In April, China generated 26% of its electricity from wind and solar, according to Ember, marking a historic first that reflects a rapid rebalancing of its energy mix.
Belgium’s federal parliament has adopted a law authorising the extension of Doel-4 and Tihange-3 reactors and allowing new nuclear construction, ending the nuclear phase-out policy established in 2003.
Belgium’s federal parliament has adopted a law authorising the extension of Doel-4 and Tihange-3 reactors and allowing new nuclear construction, ending the nuclear phase-out policy established in 2003.
The re-elected Australian government is investing heavily in storage, critical minerals and domestic production to meet its target of 82% renewable electricity by 2030.
The re-elected Australian government is investing heavily in storage, critical minerals and domestic production to meet its target of 82% renewable electricity by 2030.
The US House budget bill outlines a gradual phaseout of tax credits, affecting financing for solar, wind, storage, and clean hydrogen initiatives.
China's gas, oil and coal volumes remain above last year’s levels, despite a decline in April compared to the record highs of March.
China's gas, oil and coal volumes remain above last year’s levels, despite a decline in April compared to the record highs of March.
The UK’s energy price cap is expected to fall to £1,720 ($2,187) in July, according to Cornwall Insight, due to recent movements in wholesale markets.
The UK’s energy price cap is expected to fall to £1,720 ($2,187) in July, according to Cornwall Insight, due to recent movements in wholesale markets.
The European Commission releases data on the REPowerEU plan, confirming a sharp drop in Russian fossil fuel purchases and announcing new legislative measures by June.
The European Commission releases data on the REPowerEU plan, confirming a sharp drop in Russian fossil fuel purchases and announcing new legislative measures by June.
A partnership between the Indian government and GEAPP provides financial and operational support to early-stage climate-tech firms as part of a national energy strategy.
A $150mn financing package, including $100mn from the World Bank, will support the modernisation of Uzbekistan’s power grid and integration of renewable energy in key regions.
A $150mn financing package, including $100mn from the World Bank, will support the modernisation of Uzbekistan’s power grid and integration of renewable energy in key regions.
A report from the Public Policy Forum calls for accelerating over 500 energy, critical minerals and infrastructure projects to generate CAD1 100bn in Canadian GDP growth.
A report from the Public Policy Forum calls for accelerating over 500 energy, critical minerals and infrastructure projects to generate CAD1 100bn in Canadian GDP growth.
Quebec opens public consultation on draft regulations to revise gas standards and frame the integration of hydrogen, with feedback expected by 27 June.
Quebec opens public consultation on draft regulations to revise gas standards and frame the integration of hydrogen, with feedback expected by 27 June.
The Spanish government confirmed no signs of cyberattack were identified after the 28 April blackout that affected much of the Iberian Peninsula.
South African authorities are advocating for an approach that integrates economic development and environmental protection, highlighting global imbalances in climate responsibility.
South African authorities are advocating for an approach that integrates economic development and environmental protection, highlighting global imbalances in climate responsibility.
The European Commission is considering changing environmental laws to accelerate the granting of permits for renewable energy projects across the European Union.
The European Commission is considering changing environmental laws to accelerate the granting of permits for renewable energy projects across the European Union.
Spain’s competition authority has launched its own investigation into the April 28 power outage, joining ongoing inquiries into an incident that disrupted 60% of the country's electricity consumption.
Spain’s competition authority has launched its own investigation into the April 28 power outage, joining ongoing inquiries into an incident that disrupted 60% of the country's electricity consumption.

Advertising