BarMar: the Franco-German-Spanish dispute on nuclear energy

France has decided to focus on its aging nuclear fleet to produce more hydrogen as a replacement for non-renewable polluting sources. However, the French objectives have been jeopardized by differences of opinion among EU member countries as to the classification of this hydrogen as "clean" and renewable.

Share:

Comprehensive energy news coverage, updated nonstop

Annual subscription

8.25$/month*

*billed annually at 99$/year for the first year then 149,00$/year ​

Unlimited access • Archives included • Professional invoice

OTHER ACCESS OPTIONS

Monthly subscription

Unlimited access • Archives included

5.2$/month*
then 14.90$ per month thereafter

FREE ACCOUNT

3 articles offered per month

FREE

*Prices are excluding VAT, which may vary depending on your location or professional status

Since 2021: 35,000 articles • 150+ analyses per week

A new dispute has broken out between France, Germany and Spain overnuclear energy. Paris is angered by the lack of support from Berlin and Madrid for its efforts to have nuclear-derived hydrogen labeled“green” in European legislation. The dispute is delaying the process of implementing the new EU renewable energy directives and threatens to come into open conflict at a key summit on Thursday.

 

The French position

France has based its campaign on its aging nuclear fleet to produce more hydrogen to replace non-renewable polluting sources. The French objective is to have this production recognized as “clean” and included in the objectives of the European directives concerning renewable energy.

The French Minister of Energy, Agnès Pannier-Runacher, expressed her deep frustration with the behavior of some member countries towards this initiative: “These negotiations are not going well. She added: “It would be incomprehensible if Spain and Germany adopted different positions in Brussels and did not keep their commitments.

 

A Franco-Spanish alliance?

In October 2020, French President Emmanuel Macron validated a draft agreement for an industrial project dedicated to the massive production of hydrogen (H2Med or BarMar). This project, which will lead to the creation of a pipeline connecting Barcelona and Marseille, thus creating a Franco-Spanish alliance, was officially decreed in January 2021. Germany has just joined this consortium after having attended a meeting organized by Paris a few days ago. The goal is simple: to be able to import massively this Spanish hydrogen to compensate for the Russian gas haggling which it often suffers.

 

A divergence in discourse

In spite of this Franco-Spanish-German union, for a few weeks now a lively controversy has been raging around the “clean” character of this hydrogen produced thanks to French nuclear sources (red hydrogen). During the Barcelona summit, some commitments were made mentioning that this particular type of hydrogen could be classified as green if very strict conditions were respected. On their side, neither Berlin nor Madrid recognize such a promise, even claiming that neither nuclear power nor this particular type of hydrogen could be considered “clean” or “green”. Indeed, a senior Spanish politician will be even more incisive stating: “this (“Red hydrogen”) cannot be renewable because nuclear is not a ‘clean’ source. It is impossible!

 

The main issues concerning BarMar

The BarMar pipeline is a large-scale European project to facilitate the circulation of hydrogen (red) between France and Spain. Red hydrogen is essential to the European goals of decarbonizing heavy industry and helping the EU meet its climate targets.

At a time when the European Commission plans to invest up to €300 billion to deliver green or low-carbon hydrogen, some EU member countries fear that the current conflict could extend even beyond oil and gas. This could delay the legislation needed to achieve these goals.

The new gas market regulations, however, seek to integrate more hydrogen into this network, as well as a “hydrogen bank” to finance new projects. However, France would like its red hydrogen to be included in this bank; however, it must first and foremost be considered as renewable.

However, while the European Commission is seeking a common definition of what constitutes “renewable” hydrogen, the European Parliament has postponed negotiations on the RED-3 directive.

 

The French position on the BarMar blockage

The French threat is clearly visible: it would be willing to give the green light to the BarMar pipeline if it is allowed to send its red hydrogen to Iberia via this conduit. Without French approval, there can be no BarMar pipeline – which puts the French government in a strong position vis-à-vis other EU member countries. The dispute is therefore mainly based on a political question: should red hydrogen be considered as renewable?

The United States has granted Trinidad and Tobago a special licence to resume negotiations with Venezuela on the Dragon gas field, partially lifting restrictions imposed on the Venezuelan energy sector.
Ambassadors of European Union member states have approved the transmission of a legislative proposal to phase out Russian fossil fuel imports by January 2028 to the Council of Ministers.
The State Duma has approved Russia’s formal withdrawal from a treaty signed with the United States on the elimination of military-grade plutonium, ending over two decades of strategic nuclear cooperation.
Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk said it was not in Poland’s interest to extradite to Germany a Ukrainian citizen suspected of taking part in the explosions that damaged the Nord Stream gas pipelines in 2022.
Al-Harfi and SCLCO signed agreements with Syrian authorities to develop solar and wind capacity, amid an ongoing energy rapprochement between Riyadh and Damascus.
Faced with risks to Middle Eastern supply chains, Thai and Japanese refiners are turning to US crude, backed by tariff incentives and strategies aligned with ongoing bilateral trade discussions.
France intercepted a tanker linked to Russian exports, prompting Emmanuel Macron to call for a coordinated European response to hinder vessels bypassing oil sanctions.
The activation of the snapback mechanism reinstates all UN sanctions on Iran, directly affecting the defence, financial and maritime trade sectors.
Commissioner Dan Jørgensen visits Greenland to expand energy ties with the European Union, amid plans to double EU funding for the 2028–2034 period.
European and Iranian foreign ministers meet in New York to try to prevent the reinstatement of UN sanctions linked to Tehran’s nuclear programme.
Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney announces a bilateral agreement with Mexico including targeted investments in energy corridors, logistics infrastructure and cross-border security.
The US president has called for an immediate end to Russian oil imports by NATO countries, denouncing a strategic contradiction as sanctions against Moscow are being considered.
Tehran withdrew a resolution denouncing attacks on its nuclear facilities, citing US pressure on IAEA members who feared suspension of Washington’s voluntary contributions.
Poland’s energy minister calls on European Union member states to collectively commit to halting Russian oil purchases within two years, citing increasing geopolitical risks.
Athens and Tripoli engage in a negotiation process to define their exclusive economic zones in the Mediterranean, amid geopolitical tensions and underwater energy stakes.
European powers demand concrete steps from Tehran on nuclear issue or United Nations sanctions will be reinstated, as IAEA inspections remain blocked and tensions with Washington persist.
Brussels confirms its target to end all Russian energy imports by 2028, despite growing diplomatic pressure from Washington amid the ongoing conflict in Ukraine.
Donald Trump threatens to escalate US sanctions against Russia, but only if NATO member states stop all Russian oil imports, which remain active via certain pipelines.
The two countries agreed to develop infrastructure dedicated to liquefied natural gas to strengthen Europe's energy security and boost transatlantic trade.
Ayatollah Ali Khamenei calls for modernising the oil industry and expanding export markets as Tehran faces the possible reactivation of 2015 nuclear deal sanctions.

All the latest energy news, all the time

Annual subscription

8.25$/month*

*billed annually at 99$/year for the first year then 149,00$/year ​

Unlimited access - Archives included - Pro invoice

Monthly subscription

Unlimited access • Archives included

5.2$/month*
then 14.90$ per month thereafter

*Prices shown are exclusive of VAT, which may vary according to your location or professional status.

Since 2021: 30,000 articles - +150 analyses/week.