popular articles

South Africa: Complex Energy Transition after Komati’s Closure

The closure of the Komati coal plant, intended to become a flagship of the energy transition, has revealed the major challenges South Africa must overcome to achieve its decarbonation goals, particularly in terms of job reallocation and infrastructure.

Please share:

The Komati coal plant, located in Middelburg, east of Johannesburg, closed its doors in 2022 to be converted into a flagship energy transition site in South Africa. However, two years later, the conversion is far from complete, and the project is now a source of controversy.

Komati was one of the oldest power plants in the country, supplying 121 megawatts (MW) of electricity to the national grid. Its closure, along with that of five other plants planned by 2030, is part of the Just Energy Transition Partnership (JETP) implemented by the South African government in collaboration with international partners. The project benefits from a $497 million funding from the World Bank to transform the site into an energy complex capable of producing 150 MW of solar, 70 MW of wind, and 150 MW of battery storage.

Delays and Implementation Challenges

Despite the project’s scale, the conversion work has not yet truly begun, due to administrative delays and poor organization. The plant’s general manager, Theven Pillay, admits that mistakes were made from the start: “We should have anticipated more. We consider that this project is not a success at the moment.”

For her part, Deputy Minister of Energy Samantha Graham acknowledged that the closure has left employees in a critical situation. Before its closure, Komati employed 393 people, but only 162 of them still work on-site, with others being reassigned or accepting severance packages.

A Difficult Social Impact to Manage

The closure of Komati also had a major impact on the small mining town of Middelburg, where the plant was the main source of employment. Many houses have been abandoned, and the remaining workers face significant financial challenges. Sizwe Shandu, an employee since 2008, describes the situation as a trauma for local families. “We now rely on government aid to meet our needs,” he says.

Eskom, the state-owned electricity company that operates the plant, plans to create 363 permanent jobs and 2,733 temporary jobs on the site, but the conversion projects, such as fish farming and vegetable growing integrated with solar installations, are progressing slowly. Seven people have been trained for these activities, far short of the 21 initially planned.

An Example for Future Closures

The experience of Komati has become a case study for the authorities who are trying to avoid the same mistakes during the next plant closures. The delays have revealed the complexity of conversion and the need to better plan the transition of workers before shutting down facilities.

Since the launch of the JETP in South Africa, other countries such as Indonesia, Vietnam, and Senegal have entered into similar partnerships. However, the pace of implementation remains slow, and few plants have been closed to date.

Towards a Sustainable Energy Mix

South Africa remains heavily dependent on coal, which accounts for about 80% of its electricity production. “We still have 200 years of coal reserves in our subsoil,” says Eskom. The country plans to continue exploiting these resources while gradually increasing the share of renewables in the energy mix.

Today, only 7% of South Africa’s energy comes from renewable sources, an increase of 1% compared to ten years ago. Nevertheless, the government hopes to achieve a “stable and sustainable energy mix,” while balancing international pressures and its own economic imperatives.

Register free of charge for uninterrupted access.

Publicite

Recently published in

Bosnia faces the coal challenge between dependence and environmental pressures
China, the world's largest emitter of greenhouse gases, is expected to reach its peak coal consumption by 2025, according to a recent report. This represents a key step toward energy transition despite the challenges of a rapidly growing economy.
China, the world's largest emitter of greenhouse gases, is expected to reach its peak coal consumption by 2025, according to a recent report. This represents a key step toward energy transition despite the challenges of a rapidly growing economy.
The British mining giant Anglo American sells its steelmaking coal mines in Australia to Peabody Energy for $3.775 billion, marking its strategic withdrawal from this sector.
The British mining giant Anglo American sells its steelmaking coal mines in Australia to Peabody Energy for $3.775 billion, marking its strategic withdrawal from this sector.
In Ankara Province, Turkey, 500 miners occupy a coal mine to protest a privatization project, fearing job losses and worsening working conditions.
In Ankara Province, Turkey, 500 miners occupy a coal mine to protest a privatization project, fearing job losses and worsening working conditions.
The restart of the Cordemais coal plant, planned to address the cold wave, has been halted by a strike. Workers oppose the scheduled closure and demand guarantees for their future.
At COP29 in Baku, 25 nations, including the United Kingdom and Australia, pledged to stop building coal power plants. This initiative aims to curb global warming despite a 2% increase in global coal capacity in 2023.
At COP29 in Baku, 25 nations, including the United Kingdom and Australia, pledged to stop building coal power plants. This initiative aims to curb global warming despite a 2% increase in global coal capacity in 2023.
Global and domestic coal consumption could support U.S. thermal coal markets in 2025, driven by increased demand in Asia and Europe, despite challenges linked to the energy transition.
Global and domestic coal consumption could support U.S. thermal coal markets in 2025, driven by increased demand in Asia and Europe, despite challenges linked to the energy transition.
The British government has decided to end new licenses for coal mining, reaffirming its commitment to energy transition and reducing greenhouse gas emissions.
The British government has decided to end new licenses for coal mining, reaffirming its commitment to energy transition and reducing greenhouse gas emissions.
The Saint-Avold plant has resumed production to secure French energy supply with the onset of winter, despite controversy over its environmental impact and plans for reconversion.
Facing growing energy demand due to a record-breaking summer, Japan reports a surge in coal imports, exploring new suppliers to secure its electricity needs.
Facing growing energy demand due to a record-breaking summer, Japan reports a surge in coal imports, exploring new suppliers to secure its electricity needs.
EDF has launched disciplinary procedures against seven CGT activists at the Cordemais power plant following incidents related to the Ecocombust project, prompting strong reactions from the union.
EDF has launched disciplinary procedures against seven CGT activists at the Cordemais power plant following incidents related to the Ecocombust project, prompting strong reactions from the union.
Despite the dockworkers' strike in British Columbia, coal shipments from Westshore Terminals continue without major disruptions, confirming the terminal's operational independence amid union blockades.
Despite the dockworkers' strike in British Columbia, coal shipments from Westshore Terminals continue without major disruptions, confirming the terminal's operational independence amid union blockades.
Russian thermal coal exports are facing severe liquidity losses, exacerbated by logistical restrictions and rising costs, prompting buyers to turn to alternative sources.
US Elections 2024: The Disappearance of "King Coal" from the Political Scene
US Elections 2024: The Disappearance of "King Coal" from the Political Scene
Australian coal producers reduce the processing of lower grades due to rising exports to China, while South Korean demand for higher grades declines.
Australian coal producers reduce the processing of lower grades due to rising exports to China, while South Korean demand for higher grades declines.
Eight deputies and senators from Loire-Atlantique are calling on Emmanuel Macron to reverse the decision to close the Cordemais coal power plant by 2027, accusing the government of breaking its environmental commitments.
Eight deputies and senators from Loire-Atlantique are calling on Emmanuel Macron to reverse the decision to close the Cordemais coal power plant by 2027, accusing the government of breaking its environmental commitments.
The daily flow of coal from Mongolia to China rebounded in mid-October, leading to a notable increase in metallurgical coal stocks in the country.
NextGen CDR signs agreement with Alt Carbon for the purchase of carbon sequestration credits in India, marking its first operation outside Europe and the United States.
NextGen CDR signs agreement with Alt Carbon for the purchase of carbon sequestration credits in India, marking its first operation outside Europe and the United States.
In the heart of Donbass, Ukrainian miners continue to extract essential coal despite bombings. Their work, a true energy front, is crucial to maintaining Ukraine's electricity supply during wartime.
In the heart of Donbass, Ukrainian miners continue to extract essential coal despite bombings. Their work, a true energy front, is crucial to maintaining Ukraine's electricity supply during wartime.
French Banks Continue Investing in Coal through 2023
French Banks Continue Investing in Coal through 2023
The joint venture HVO, comprising Yancoal and Glencore, is seeking a temporary extension for its two main coal mines in New South Wales amidst concerns over greenhouse gas emissions.
The consecutive decrease in coal-based electricity production in India in September 2024 reflects a major energy transition, supported by rapid growth in renewable energy and a reduction in energy demand.
The consecutive decrease in coal-based electricity production in India in September 2024 reflects a major energy transition, supported by rapid growth in renewable energy and a reduction in energy demand.
A report by the Transition Pathway Initiative (TPI) reveals that the majority of major banks continue to finance coal-related activities, thereby undermining their commitments to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.
A report by the Transition Pathway Initiative (TPI) reveals that the majority of major banks continue to finance coal-related activities, thereby undermining their commitments to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.
Russia intensifies its coal sales to India to meet growing energy demand, despite Western sanctions impacting its other energy exports.
Russia intensifies its coal sales to India to meet growing energy demand, despite Western sanctions impacting its other energy exports.

Advertising