popular articles

Germany receives European aid to move away from coal

Germany wins Brussels' approval to compensate for the energy transition in the coal-mining region of Lusatia, a key milestone in its efforts to reduce its carbon footprint.
Subsidized German coal transition

Please share:

Committed to a low-carbon future, Germany faces the immense challenge of gradually moving away from its dependence on coal, a particularly polluting fossil fuel. In line with its ambitious climate targets, the country has set itself the goal of completely abandoning this energy by 2038, while ensuring a smooth transition for its mining regions historically dependent on this industry. These coal bastions include Lusatia, a vast region of former East Germany renowned for its prolific lignite deposits. This border region with Poland, marked by decades of intensive mining, now needs to reinvent itself and project itself into a low-carbon energy future.

EU gives green light to state aid for Leag

Against this backdrop, the German government announced on Tuesday that it had obtained the precious green light from the EC (European Commission) for a 1.75 billion euro payment to Leag, the main operator of the lignite mines in Lusatia. This state aid is intended to offset the astronomical costs incurred by the early closure of the company’s coal-fired power plants in the region. Negotiations between Berlin and Brussels on this thorny issue proved particularly difficult. In 2021, the EC, the guardian of fair competition, opened an in-depth investigation into this state aid, which is likely to constitute market distortions that do not comply with EU rules.

Breakdown of funding

Of the 1.75 billion euros granted, 1.2 billion will be specifically earmarked for the staggering costs of renaturating the gigantic abandoned open-cast mines, veritable ecological scars on the Lusakian landscape. A section will also be devoted to social support for the thousands of workers affected by the closure of extraction sites and associated power plants. The remaining 550 million euros will be paid to Leag once the company has effectively taken all its coal-fired power plants in the region off the grid, marking the end of an era for Lusatia.

Striking a delicate balance between transition and competitiveness

A year after approving a similar €2.6 billion aid plan with energy company RWE to support North Rhine-Westphalia’s accelerated coal phase -out by 2030, Brussels has now given the go-ahead for the Lusaka project. However, negotiations proved more complex with Leag, which initially wanted to retain the 2038 horizon rather than phase out lignite early by 2030, as demanded by the German government. This green light confirms Berlin’s firm commitment to financially supporting the profound transformation of the former East German coal-mining regions, while preserving their economic competitiveness as far as possible. It’s a delicate balancing act for the government, which has to reconcile climate ambitions, industrial realities and social justice imperatives in this crucial energy transition.

Outlook and challenges for Lusatia

For Lusatia, a region heavily dependent on the coal industry for decades, this definitive turning of the page opens up a new chapter full of uncertainties and opportunities. We now need to take a wide-ranging look at how to reindustrialize these areas, in order to develop new job-creating economic activities in line with climate objectives. The conversion of former mines into natural reservoirs or sites for the production of renewable energies such as photovoltaics is one of the avenues being explored. But beyond the technical and financial challenges, a profound socio-economic upheaval awaits local populations, whose future is now irrevocably decarbonized.
By financially supporting this huge transition effort, Germany hopes to draw a definitive line under a part of its energy history, while paving the way for a reinvented Lusatia, promoted to the rank of pioneer of a new sustainable economic model.

Register free of charge for uninterrupted access.

Publicite

Recently published in

The dockworkers' strike on the U.S. East and Gulf Coasts, which began on October 1st, has not significantly raised thermal coal prices, despite logistical disruptions. This situation is mainly due to an existing oversupply and weak global demand. Key importers, such as India, are reducing their dependence on U.S. coal in favor of cheaper domestic alternatives like petroleum coke. According to the latest assessment by S&P Global Commodity Insights, the existing oversupply continues to weigh heavily on U.S. coal prices, limiting the potential impact of the strike.
The closure of the UK's last coal-fired power plant marks a major shift in the country's energy strategy, aiming for carbon neutrality by 2050. The UK thus becomes the first G7 member to eliminate this energy source.
The closure of the UK's last coal-fired power plant marks a major shift in the country's energy strategy, aiming for carbon neutrality by 2050. The UK thus becomes the first G7 member to eliminate this energy source.
The Australian government is extending the operation of three coal mines, raising questions within the energy sector about the impact of this decision on climate commitments and the transition to renewable energies.
The Australian government is extending the operation of three coal mines, raising questions within the energy sector about the impact of this decision on climate commitments and the transition to renewable energies.
EDF abandons plans to convert the Cordemais power plant. Electricity production will cease in 2027, with major repercussions for employment and the region's energy balance.
EDF abandons plans to convert the Cordemais power plant. Electricity production will cease in 2027, with major repercussions for employment and the region's energy balance.
The thermal coal derivatives market rose by 4% in August, supported by volatile prices, mainly in Europe. Volumes reached 32.3 million metric tons, according to data from the London Energy Brokers Association (LEBA).
Enea, awaiting clarification on its coal assets and regulatory framework, postpones its dividend policy. The company expects to develop its renewable capacities rapidly, subject to secure financing.
Enea, awaiting clarification on its coal assets and regulatory framework, postpones its dividend policy. The company expects to develop its renewable capacities rapidly, subject to secure financing.
India is at a critical juncture, faced with growing energy demand and ambitious climate commitments. Increasing coal production is raising major concerns about methane emissions, threatening the country's environmental goals.
India is at a critical juncture, faced with growing energy demand and ambitious climate commitments. Increasing coal production is raising major concerns about methane emissions, threatening the country's environmental goals.
South-East Asia, with countries such as Vietnam and the Philippines, should see its coal imports grow, while Chinese demand stabilizes.
South-East Asia, with countries such as Vietnam and the Philippines, should see its coal imports grow, while Chinese demand stabilizes.
The Polish government is drawing up a model for transferring the coal assets of state-owned enterprises, with the aim of finalizing it in less than a year to allay investors' fears and adapt to new financial constraints.
Russia extends export duty exemption for thermal coal until December. Despite this measure, logistical restrictions and sanctions continue to hold back global demand.
Russia extends export duty exemption for thermal coal until December. Despite this measure, logistical restrictions and sanctions continue to hold back global demand.
Ørsted stopped using coal for good with the closure of its Esbjerg power plant on August 31, completing its shift away from fossil fuels and towards renewable energies.
Ørsted stopped using coal for good with the closure of its Esbjerg power plant on August 31, completing its shift away from fossil fuels and towards renewable energies.
India is developing 38 rail projects to optimize coal logistics, reduce costs and guarantee a stable supply to power and industrial plants.
India is developing 38 rail projects to optimize coal logistics, reduce costs and guarantee a stable supply to power and industrial plants.
India aims to eliminate thermal coal imports by 2025-26. Challenges related to the quality of domestic coal and technical constraints could, however, put the brakes on this ambition.
Russian exports of thermal coal have risen sharply, boosted by strong demand in the Asia-Pacific and Mediterranean regions, as well as a temporary reduction in export tariffs.
Russian exports of thermal coal have risen sharply, boosted by strong demand in the Asia-Pacific and Mediterranean regions, as well as a temporary reduction in export tariffs.
Glencore decided to retain its coal activities, despite shareholder and environmental pressure, while leaving the door open to a possible demerger in the future.
Glencore decided to retain its coal activities, despite shareholder and environmental pressure, while leaving the door open to a possible demerger in the future.
A study reveals that mining companies in Indonesia ignore methane emissions, exacerbating their environmental impact.
A study reveals that mining companies in Indonesia ignore methane emissions, exacerbating their environmental impact.
Thermal coal exports from Russia to South Korea exceeded those from Colombia in July, thanks to lower freight costs and weather disruptions in Colombia.
The International Energy Agency (IEA) forecasts a 19% reduction in coal demand in the EU, reaching 287 million tonnes in 2025, due to increased adoption of renewable energies.
The International Energy Agency (IEA) forecasts a 19% reduction in coal demand in the EU, reaching 287 million tonnes in 2025, due to increased adoption of renewable energies.
China is developing green ammonia projects to reduce emissions from its coal-fired power plants, marking a shift towards cleaner energy.
China is developing green ammonia projects to reduce emissions from its coal-fired power plants, marking a shift towards cleaner energy.
Pakistan is asking Chinese power plants to switch from imported coal to local Thar coal, as part of IMF-backed energy reforms aimed at reducing the sector's costs and debt.
Pakistan is asking Chinese power plants to switch from imported coal to local Thar coal, as part of IMF-backed energy reforms aimed at reducing the sector's costs and debt.
Coal production in China reached a half-year high in June, boosted by increased summer demand and the easing of previous safety inspections.
The British Labour government is abandoning plans for a metallurgical coal mine in Cumbria, a decision in line with its election promises and environmental concerns.
The British Labour government is abandoning plans for a metallurgical coal mine in Cumbria, a decision in line with its election promises and environmental concerns.
Employees at the Émile-Huchet power plant in Saint-Avold are concerned about the current political uncertainty that is holding back energy conversion projects. The need for a stable contact at Bercy is crucial for the future of the site.
Employees at the Émile-Huchet power plant in Saint-Avold are concerned about the current political uncertainty that is holding back energy conversion projects. The need for a stable contact at Bercy is crucial for the future of the site.
Zambia approves the construction of a 300 MW coal-fired power plant, in the face of the worst drought in four decades, reducing hydroelectric production.
Zambia approves the construction of a 300 MW coal-fired power plant, in the face of the worst drought in four decades, reducing hydroelectric production.

Advertising