U.S. elections: Pennsylvania’s shale gas dilemma

Natural gas development in Pennsylvania is becoming a crucial issue in the US presidential elections. Between economic opportunities and environmental concerns, voters are divided, making this topic central to the debate between Donald Trump and Kamala Harris.

Share:

Comprehensive energy news coverage, updated nonstop

Annual subscription

8.25$/month*

*billed annually at 99$/year for the first year then 149,00$/year ​

Unlimited access • Archives included • Professional invoice

OTHER ACCESS OPTIONS

Monthly subscription

Unlimited access • Archives included

5.2$/month*
then 14.90$ per month thereafter

FREE ACCOUNT

3 articles offered per month

FREE

*Prices are excluding VAT, which may vary depending on your location or professional status

Since 2021: 35,000 articles • 150+ analyses per week

In the current context of the American presidential elections, the question of natural gas development in Pennsylvania is becoming a central issue.
This territory, known for its vast gas resources and production via hydraulic fracturing, is turning into an ideological battleground between the two main candidates, Donald Trump and Kamala Harris.
Views diverge among the local population, who use economic, political and sometimes personal reasons to choose sides.
The interconnection between the local economy and energy production delights farmers, while the environmental impact raises concerns for others.
The exploitation of shale gas by hydraulic fracturing has enabled Pennsylvania to position itself as a major player on the energy scene, even surpassing renowned producer states such as Qatar in 2022.
This method of extraction, although controversial, is seen by some as a vector of economic prosperity, generating income and opportunities for families who manage agricultural land.
Reflection on these issues raises questions about the sustainability of this industry, particularly at a time when proponents of an alternative energy transition are advocating more environmentally-friendly models.

The opinion divide

The water divide represents a major dilemma for voters.
On the one hand, it generates jobs and financial resources; on the other, it is at the heart of debates concerning public health and environmental preservation.
Opinions within the local population remain divided.
The latest surveys show that 48% of residents express support for gas extraction, against 44% who oppose it.
The balance between economic benefits and environmental concerns continues to fuel heated debate.
Candidates rarely ignore this thorny issue during their campaigns.
During a debate, Donald Trump warned of the risks associated with his opponent’s possible curtailment of shale gas development, asserting that “if Kamala Harris wins the election, hydraulic fracturing in Pennsylvania will be gone from day one”.
This statement is intended to mobilize voters worried about their economic future, while testing his opponent’s responsiveness on an issue that Trump believes could undermine the local economy.

Revealing electoral stakes

The divergence of opinions can also be seen in the testimonies of voters.
Farmer George Wherry, fundamentally committed to hydraulic fracturing, points out that the extra income will enable him to modernize his farm and improve his living conditions.
Laura Jean Kahl, on the other hand, while committed to selling farm produce, mentions her choice for Kamala Harris, in deplorable disagreement with the continuity of these extraction practices, which she considers harmful in the long term.
It’s interesting to note the complexity of opinions and motivations behind these electoral choices.
While some stressed the need to maintain the current economic model, others did not lose sight of the environmental impact of fracking, illustrating the existing tension between the quest for immediate profitability and long-term sustainability.

Implications for the future of energy

Election day in November is approaching, with major consequences for US energy policy.
The ability of candidates to manipulate these issues to suit their local audience could influence their success.
Pennsylvania’s energy context, based on hydraulic fracturing, appears to be a microcosm of the broader debates on energy transition in the United States.
As mobilization for more virtuous energy alternatives gathers momentum at national level, election results could also reshape the US energy landscape, both in terms of legislation and industrial practices.
This election, rooted in immediate economic considerations, could thus turn out to be a decisive turning point for the future of energy in the United States, marking the beginning of a new chapter in the management of natural resources.

Naftogaz urges the European Union to use Ukraine’s gas storage capacity as part of a strategic reserve system, while calling for the end of storage filling obligations after 2027.
Spanish gas infrastructure operator Enagás is in advanced talks to acquire the 32% stake held by Singapore’s sovereign wealth fund GIC in Terega, valued at around €600mn ($633mn), according to sources familiar with the matter.
BP has awarded Valaris a $140mn drilling contract for a Mediterranean offshore campaign aimed at reinforcing Egypt’s declining gas output since 2021.
Egypt’s petroleum ministry will launch 480 exploration wells by 2030 with investments exceeding $5.7bn, aiming to revive production and reduce reliance on imports.
Faced with declining domestic consumption, Japanese liquefied natural gas (LNG) importers are ramping up commercial optimisation strategies and favouring shorter contracts to protect profitability.
European inventories curbed price declines as liquefied natural gas (LNG) supply expands and demand stays weak. Cargo arbitrage favours Europe, but winter will determine the equilibrium level. —
Sonatrach and Midad Energy North Africa signed a production-sharing hydrocarbon contract in the Illizi South perimeter, involving a total investment estimated at $5.4bn for exploration and exploitation of the site.
Kuwait Petroleum Corporation annonce une découverte majeure dans la zone offshore avec le champ de Jazah, soutenant les efforts publics d’investissement dans les infrastructures énergétiques nationales.
Rockpoint Gas Storage finalised its initial public offering in Canada with an upsized offer of 32 million shares for gross proceeds of C$704mn ($512mn), marking a new step in Brookfield’s partial divestment strategy.
Africa Energy postpones submission of its environmental impact assessment for Block 11B/12B following a recent court ruling affecting offshore exploration authorisations in South Africa.
The European Union’s gas system shows reinforced resilience for winter 2025-2026, even without Russian imports, according to the latest forecast by European gas transmission network operators.
US LNG producer Venture Global saw its market value drop sharply after an arbitral ruling in favour of BP reignited concerns over ongoing contractual disputes tied to the Calcasieu Pass project.
Pembina Pipeline Corporation has completed a $225mn subordinated note offering to fund the redemption of its Series 9 preferred shares, marking a new step in its capital management strategy.
A jihadist attack targeted Palma, a strategic area in northern Mozambique, marking a return of insecurity near TotalEnergies' suspended gas project since 2021.
Fermi America has signed an agreement with Energy Transfer to secure a firm natural gas supply for powering Phase One of its HyperGrid energy campus, dedicated to artificial intelligence, near Amarillo, Texas.
Rockpoint Gas Storage priced its initial public offering at C$22 per share, raising C$704mn ($515mn) through the sale of 32 million shares, with an over-allotment option expanding the transaction to 36.8 million shares.
Tailwater Capital secures $600mn in debt and $500mn in equity to recapitalise Producers Midstream II and support infrastructure development in the southern United States.
An economic study reveals that Germany’s gas storage levels could prevent up to €25 billion in economic losses during a winter supply shock.
New Fortress Energy has initiated the initial ignition of its 624 MW CELBA 2 power plant in Brazil, starting the commissioning phase ahead of commercial operations expected later this year.
Talen Energy launches $1.2bn debt financing and expands credit facilities to support strategic acquisitions of two combined-cycle natural gas power plants.

All the latest energy news, all the time

Annual subscription

8.25$/month*

*billed annually at 99$/year for the first year then 149,00$/year ​

Unlimited access - Archives included - Pro invoice

Monthly subscription

Unlimited access • Archives included

5.2$/month*
then 14.90$ per month thereafter

*Prices shown are exclusive of VAT, which may vary according to your location or professional status.

Since 2021: 30,000 articles - +150 analyses/week.