popular articles

The new nuclear safety authority reaffirms transparency

The new nuclear safety authority reaffirms transparency

Please share:

This new body, the Nuclear Safety and Radiation Protection Authority (ASNR), now brings together the Nuclear Safety Authority (ASN) and the Institute for Radiological Protection and Nuclear Safety (IRSN). It is the only entity responsible for nuclear safety across the national territory, succeeding the ASN, formerly the “nuclear watchdog,” and the IRSN, which previously handled expert assessments. This merger, implemented at the initiative of the executive branch, has been officially justified by the need for more direct and coherent decision-making. However, it raises questions regarding the preservation of technical independence and the assurance of transparent public information.

Reorganization and framework for assessments

The ASN previously oversaw the monitoring and regulation of the nuclear sector, while the IRSN focused on risk evaluations and scientific studies. Several observers have expressed concern that merging these two functions may blur the lines between managing a case and providing the necessary expert assessment. Within the ASNR, some worry about maintaining a boundary between the decision-maker and the technical advisory role. The ASNR’s representatives, for their part, indicate that the new structure is designed to ensure a clear distinction between these two components.

The Office for the Evaluation of Scientific and Technological Choices (Opecst), which advises elected officials on complex subjects, questioned Pierre-Marie Abadie, president of the ASNR. According to him, the merger does not imply any rollback in terms of transparency or independence, since internal procedures are intended to prevent conflicts of interest. The technical opinions would be made public, in most cases, at the same time as the decisions for which they were requested. The president of the ASNR also mentions the possibility of publishing expert assessments earlier, if this addresses an urgent need for information.

Principles of referral and self-referral

Until now, assessments were based on a “commission” given by the decision-making body to the analytical body. According to Pierre-Marie Abadie, the new internal regulations replace this notion of “commission” with a “referral,” reinforcing the idea of a formal and transparent process. The document also grants the experts the ability to act on their own initiative, allowing them to investigate a subject without waiting for a hierarchical request. This feature is viewed as a measure designed to maintain a high level of scientific independence within the new authority.

The head of the ASNR emphasizes the desire to organize rigorous exchanges between expertise and review, while avoiding an overly strict compartmentalization. He cites the removal of overly restrictive wording in the initial version of the regulations, to allow flexibility in how analyses are conducted. Internal working groups are required to document each step of their evaluations, thus ensuring clear traceability of their findings. The relevant teams can therefore propose deeper investigations of any points they consider important, so that no aspect is left unexplored.

Parliamentary reactions

Several members of the Opecst welcomed the improvements made to the final text. Nonetheless, they emphasized the need to closely monitor how the announced measures are implemented, particularly regarding the separation between technical assessment and decision-making. The parliamentarians stress that this merger must not diminish the experts’ ability to express their concerns or issue alerts if necessary. They also believe that systematically publishing technical opinions and decisions will be a good indicator of the level of transparency.

La France Insoumise (LFI), represented by a deputy opposed to the reform, continues to consider the guarantees offered by the new authority on the question of independence to be insufficient. This political group remains highly attentive to the balance established between scientific expertise and administrative decisions. The option for self-referral and the systematic publication of research studies remain key areas of scrutiny that were highlighted during these discussions. Other elected officials also express their concern about preserving the possibility of external counter-expertise, so as to maintain a variety of analyses in the nuclear sector.

Transparency, publications, and further discussions

Numerous observers believe that public information remains a critical issue. Publications must include detailed evaluation procedures, clarifying how the conclusions were validated and according to which criteria. The president of the ASNR confirms that a wide range of reports, whether they concern inspections or specific studies, will remain available online. This accessibility aims to foster trust among operators, the administration, and external stakeholders.

Some environmentalist elected officials point out that this merger is recent and must prove its effectiveness over time. Certain representatives are already calling for regular assessments of the real impact of this reorganization, through reports made available to the relevant committees. Others believe it is necessary to continue dialogue with former IRSN personnel, to address their concerns about preserving a strictly scientific approach. This process, in their view, requires ongoing follow-up and attention at each step of the decision chain.

Many parliamentarians believe that the final version of the internal regulations has made progress on sensitive issues, in particular the separation between review and expert assessment. Better defining the roles of those involved, and allowing self-referral, is seen as a step toward greater technical independence. Some, however, fear that having everyone under one umbrella may influence the scope of expert opinions over the long term. This concern supports the idea of enhanced oversight, which both elected officials and observers intend to maintain.

Certain critics finally suggest that the ASNR must demonstrate, through its first decisions, the strength of its model in terms of transparency, rigor, and objectivity. Several feedback reports are awaited to determine if the separation between expertise and decision-making remains effective in all situations. Parliamentarians from various political backgrounds have already announced their intention to conduct additional hearings to ensure that the commitments set out in the regulations are faithfully followed. This diversity of views underscores the importance of the debate surrounding nuclear safety and encourages all parties to evaluate the concrete effects of the merger on the core principles of oversight.

Register free of charge for uninterrupted access.

Publicite

Recently published in

Eletronuclear has announced a restructuring plan aimed at improving governance and the economic viability of its nuclear projects. The commissioning of Angra 3 is now scheduled for 2031, following multiple construction interruptions and budget adjustments.
Reactor 2 of the Beznau nuclear power plant, the oldest in Europe, was shut down in an emergency following an incorrect operation during a routine inspection. The Axpo group assures that safety was maintained and that a restart is under review.
Reactor 2 of the Beznau nuclear power plant, the oldest in Europe, was shut down in an emergency following an incorrect operation during a routine inspection. The Axpo group assures that safety was maintained and that a restart is under review.
The European project EU-CONVERSION aims to develop new fuels to convert research reactors that currently use highly enriched uranium. This initiative, supported by scientific institutions and industry players, represents a key issue for nuclear safety and non-proliferation.
The European project EU-CONVERSION aims to develop new fuels to convert research reactors that currently use highly enriched uranium. This initiative, supported by scientific institutions and industry players, represents a key issue for nuclear safety and non-proliferation.
French microreactor developer Naarea has launched its industrial test center, the I-Lab, designed to validate the components and technologies of its molten salt XAMR reactor. This 2,400 m² facility marks a new step in the industrialization of this technology.
French microreactor developer Naarea has launched its industrial test center, the I-Lab, designed to validate the components and technologies of its molten salt XAMR reactor. This 2,400 m² facility marks a new step in the industrialization of this technology.
The International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) has confirmed Spain’s progress in nuclear and radiological safety. A review mission highlighted the improvement of the regulatory framework and the implementation of recommendations made in 2018.
The UK government is easing restrictions on nuclear power plant construction, particularly small modular reactors (SMRs). While this technology is still under development, it attracts several companies but poses technical and financial challenges.
The UK government is easing restrictions on nuclear power plant construction, particularly small modular reactors (SMRs). While this technology is still under development, it attracts several companies but poses technical and financial challenges.
Canadian Nuclear Laboratories (CNL) is expanding its energy technology siting program to include fusion, hydrogen, and battery storage. This initiative aims to attract investors and industrial players to accelerate the development and commercialization of new energy solutions in Canada.
Canadian Nuclear Laboratories (CNL) is expanding its energy technology siting program to include fusion, hydrogen, and battery storage. This initiative aims to attract investors and industrial players to accelerate the development and commercialization of new energy solutions in Canada.
The new Belgian government, led by Bart De Wever, plans to expand the country's nuclear capacity to 8 gigawatts, including the extension of existing reactors and the construction of new units. This decision requires a revision of the 2003 law on nuclear phase-out.
The new Belgian government, led by Bart De Wever, plans to expand the country's nuclear capacity to 8 gigawatts, including the extension of existing reactors and the construction of new units. This decision requires a revision of the 2003 law on nuclear phase-out.
The Indian government is considering amending the Atomic Energy Act to facilitate private sector involvement in civil nuclear energy. Tata Power is closely monitoring these developments, particularly regarding the development of small modular reactors (SMRs), a technology still in the research phase.
A mission from the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) has assessed safety practices at the Novovoronezh nuclear power plant, operated by Rosatom. The audit highlighted advancements in operational safety while recommending targeted improvements.
A mission from the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) has assessed safety practices at the Novovoronezh nuclear power plant, operated by Rosatom. The audit highlighted advancements in operational safety while recommending targeted improvements.
Swedish developer Blykalla has begun construction of a pilot facility to test a prototype of an advanced modular reactor. This project aims to validate key components and safety systems, with the support of industrial partners and public funding.
Swedish developer Blykalla has begun construction of a pilot facility to test a prototype of an advanced modular reactor. This project aims to validate key components and safety systems, with the support of industrial partners and public funding.
Indonesia is accelerating the development of its nuclear program and could become the first country in Southeast Asia to deploy a small modular reactor (SMR) by 2030. Despite competition from renewable energy, Jakarta is betting on nuclear power to diversify its energy mix.
Indonesia is accelerating the development of its nuclear program and could become the first country in Southeast Asia to deploy a small modular reactor (SMR) by 2030. Despite competition from renewable energy, Jakarta is betting on nuclear power to diversify its energy mix.
Georgia Power plans to increase the capacity of its Hatch and Vogtle nuclear plants to address an estimated demand growth of 8200 MW by 2030. The company is focusing on uprates and exploring the addition of new nuclear capacity in the long term.
GEN energija has selected Westinghouse and EDF to conduct a technical feasibility study on Slovenia's JEK2 nuclear project. KHNP, initially in the race, has decided not to submit a bid due to a strategic shift.
GEN energija has selected Westinghouse and EDF to conduct a technical feasibility study on Slovenia's JEK2 nuclear project. KHNP, initially in the race, has decided not to submit a bid due to a strategic shift.
The Sizewell C nuclear power plant project in the UK is progressing as planned, without delays or cost overruns. Project leaders presented an initial progress report to parliamentarians, highlighting significant financial and industrial advancements.
The Sizewell C nuclear power plant project in the UK is progressing as planned, without delays or cost overruns. Project leaders presented an initial progress report to parliamentarians, highlighting significant financial and industrial advancements.
The EDF group revises upward its nuclear electricity production estimates for 2025, 2026 and 2027, incorporating the EPR (European Pressurized Reactor) of Flamanville 3 despite delays and fluctuations observed in recent years.
The EDF group revises upward its nuclear electricity production estimates for 2025, 2026 and 2027, incorporating the EPR (European Pressurized Reactor) of Flamanville 3 despite delays and fluctuations observed in recent years.
The Nuclear Safety Authority (ASNR) has validated the continuation of tests on the Flamanville EPR by authorizing EDF to exceed the 25% nominal power threshold, a crucial step in the power ramp-up program.
The CRE (Commission of Energy Regulation) states that the new nuclear price regulation mechanism aims to protect consumers, despite the RN's political opposition.
The CRE (Commission of Energy Regulation) states that the new nuclear price regulation mechanism aims to protect consumers, despite the RN's political opposition.
EDF's project to build a technocenter for recycling low-level radioactive metal waste on the site of the former Fessenheim nuclear power plant is reigniting local tensions, between economic hopes and environmental concerns.
EDF's project to build a technocenter for recycling low-level radioactive metal waste on the site of the former Fessenheim nuclear power plant is reigniting local tensions, between economic hopes and environmental concerns.
Standard Lithium and Equinor announced Smackover Lithium as the official name of their joint venture developing direct lithium extraction projects in Southwest Arkansas and East Texas.
Standard Lithium and Equinor announced Smackover Lithium as the official name of their joint venture developing direct lithium extraction projects in Southwest Arkansas and East Texas.
Since the startup of the Flamanville EPR reactor in May 2024, nearly 50 significant events have been reported by the ASN, with no impact on safety or the environment. These anomalies are mainly related to human factors and team coordination.
Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and his Polish counterpart, Donald Tusk, signed a landmark nuclear cooperation agreement, marking a new chapter in the energy relationship between the two countries.
Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and his Polish counterpart, Donald Tusk, signed a landmark nuclear cooperation agreement, marking a new chapter in the energy relationship between the two countries.
In 2024, the Nuclear Safety and Radiation Protection Authority (ASNR) handled 71 reports of irregularities in the nuclear industry, compared to 43 in 2023. This marked increase is seen as a sign of stronger oversight and better alert reporting by operators.
In 2024, the Nuclear Safety and Radiation Protection Authority (ASNR) handled 71 reports of irregularities in the nuclear industry, compared to 43 in 2023. This marked increase is seen as a sign of stronger oversight and better alert reporting by operators.
Bayridge Resources Corp. has received a level 2 drilling permit to explore up to 30 drilling sites at its Constellation project in the Athabasca Basin. The company plans to launch a multi-phase drilling program, with the first phase fully funded.
Bayridge Resources Corp. has received a level 2 drilling permit to explore up to 30 drilling sites at its Constellation project in the Athabasca Basin. The company plans to launch a multi-phase drilling program, with the first phase fully funded.

Advertising