The International Court of Justice opinion increases legal risks for fossil fuel projects

The advisory opinion issued by the International Court of Justice increases legal exposure for states and companies involved in the licensing or expansion of oil and gas projects, according to several international law experts.

Share:

Gain full professional access to energynews.pro from 4.90$/month.
Designed for decision-makers, with no long-term commitment.

Over 30,000 articles published since 2021.
150 new market analyses every week to decode global energy trends.

Monthly Digital PRO PASS

Immediate Access
4.90$/month*

No commitment – cancel anytime, activation in 2 minutes.

*Special launch offer: 1st month at the indicated price, then 14.90 $/month, no long-term commitment.

Annual Digital PRO Pass

Full Annual Access
99$/year*

To access all of energynews.pro without any limits

*Introductory annual price for year one, automatically renewed at 149.00 $/year from the second year.

The opinion delivered by the International Court of Justice (ICJ) on state obligations regarding climate change could reshape the legal environment of the oil and gas sector. While non-binding, the opinion introduces an interpretation of international law that potentially exposes stakeholders to new litigation and re-evaluation of already granted exploration or exploitation permits.

According to the Court, a state’s failure to take sufficient measures to limit the use or production of fossil fuels may constitute a breach of international law. The opinion specifically mentions the granting of exploration permits or subsidies for fossil fuels as potentially unlawful under climate commitments.

A more uncertain legal framework for industry players

For companies operating in hydrocarbons, this development adds regulatory uncertainty and could influence investment decisions. National courts may now invoke the ICJ’s opinion to challenge permits or ongoing projects, particularly in countries where international law is directly applicable, such as the Netherlands or France.

Several legal experts believe the opinion will also affect commercial disputes, especially in cases where investors challenge states over the withdrawal or suspension of exploitation licences. This risk is heightened when new climate pledges contradict existing regulatory frameworks.

Potential international-level litigation

In dualist legal systems, where international law requires transposition, the influence remains indirect but tangible. Constitutional courts may rely on the ICJ’s interpretive authority to justify rulings unfavourable to oil companies. The Court’s recognition of an “existential threat” reinforces the ability of vulnerable states to seek redress from polluting nations before international tribunals.

The opinion could also serve as a defence for countries facing claims from corporations after altering their climate policies. Italy’s condemnation to compensate an oil operator for revoking a drilling permit illustrates the growing complexity of balancing energy sovereignty and climate obligations.

Expected impact on contracts and arbitration

The opinion’s reach is likely to affect stability clauses and legal guarantees traditionally embedded in agreements between governments and energy operators. Financial institutions may also reconsider their risk assessment models for fossil fuel projects, anticipating challenges to the legality of funded developments.

“It will be more difficult to claim a legitimate expectation to operate a fossil fuel project without obstruction,” said Lorenzo Cotula, an expert in international law. Legal risk assessment now explicitly integrates climate considerations, with potentially lasting effects on the structure of the global oil and gas market.

The example of OML 17 highlights the success of an African-led oil production model based on local accountability, strengthening Nigeria’s position in public energy investment.
ExxonMobil has signed a memorandum of understanding with the Iraqi government to develop the Majnoon oil field, marking its return to the country after a two-year absence.
Cenovus Energy modifies terms of its acquisition of MEG Energy by increasing the offer value and adjusting the cash-share split, while reporting record third-quarter results.
Hungarian oil group MOL and Croatian operator JANAF are negotiating an extension of their crude transport agreement as the region seeks to reduce reliance on Russian oil.
Rail shipments of Belarusian gasoline to Russia surged in September as Moscow sought to offset fuel shortages caused by Ukrainian attacks on its energy infrastructure.
Denmark is intensifying inspections of ships passing through Skagen, a strategic point linking the North Sea and the Baltic Sea, to counter the risks posed by the Russian shadow fleet transporting sanctioned oil.
Nicola Mavilla succeeds Kevin McLachlan as TotalEnergies' Director of Exploration, bringing over two decades of international experience in the oil and gas industry.
Sahara Group is making a major investment in Nigeria with seven new drilling rigs, aiming to become the country’s top private oil producer by increasing output to 350,000 barrels per day.
Senegal aims to double its oil refining capacity with a project estimated between $2bn and $5bn, as domestic demand exceeds current output.
Chevron is working to restart several units at its El Segundo refinery in California after a fire broke out in a jet fuel production unit, temporarily disrupting regional fuel supplies.
Ethiopia has begun construction of its first crude oil refinery in Gode, a $2.5bn project awarded to GCL, aimed at strengthening the country’s energy security amid ongoing reliance on fuel imports.
Opec+ slightly adjusts its quotas for November, continuing its market share recovery strategy amid stagnant global demand and a pressured market.
China has established a clandestine oil-for-projects barter system to circumvent US sanctions and support Iran’s embargoed economy, according to an exclusive Wall Street Journal investigation.
TotalEnergies EP Norge signed two agreements to divest its non-operated interests in three inactive Norwegian fields, pending an investment decision expected in 2025.
The US Supreme Court will hear ExxonMobil’s appeal for compensation from Cuban state-owned firms over nationalised oil assets, reviving enforcement of the Helms-Burton Act.
A major fire has been extinguished at Chevron’s main refinery on the US West Coast. The cause of the incident remains unknown, and an investigation has been launched to determine its origin.
Eight OPEC+ countries are set to increase oil output from November, as Saudi Arabia and Russia debate the scale of the hike amid rising competition for market share.
The potential removal by Moscow of duties on Chinese gasoline revives export prospects and could tighten regional supply, while Singapore and South Korea remain on the sidelines.
Vladimir Putin responded to the interception of a tanker suspected of belonging to the Russian shadow fleet, calling the French operation “piracy” and denying any direct Russian involvement.
After being intercepted by the French navy, the Boracay oil tanker, linked to Russia's shadow fleet, left Saint-Nazaire with its oil cargo, reigniting tensions over Moscow’s circumvention of European sanctions.