Italy competes with Germany on Gas

In Italy, following the beginning of the Russian-Ukrainian conflict, the CEO of Eni embarked on a tour of African gas suppliers.

Share:

Following the Russian-Ukrainian conflict, Italy has engaged an import strategy that is now paying off. At the end of February, the country embarked on a tour of the main African gas producers. While Germany, for its part, was stalling to find sustainable solutions to replace Russian gas by mid-2024. However, this goal still seems a bit too ambitious for some players such as RWE who believe that it could take longer.

The Italian anticipation

In the wake of the Ukrainian conflict, Mario Draghi, then government representative, and the CEO of Eni embarked on a tour of the main gas producing countries. These visits were planned according to a well constructed roadmap. In fact, since the end of February, Italian officials have been able to establish relationships that have paid off, especially with the Algerian SONATRACH in February and then the following month, talks with the governments of Angola,Egypt and the Republic of Congo.

Eni, then takes advantage of its existing supply relationships to obtain additional gas. The objective is to replace a large part of the volumes coming from its main supplier, Russia. This is an agile change that many European countries are making as the Russian-Ukrainian conflict continues.

Germany, an economic powerhouse and long synonymous with prudent planning, is on the verge of recession. Its industry is preparing for gas and electricity rationing.

Italy, a country used to economic crises, seems relatively resilient. The country obtains additional supplies and manages to convince that it will not need to ration gas. In addition, the government gratifies itself by hailing the country as the best in Europe in terms of energy security.

European disparities

The two countries are in contrasting circumstances as a severe energy crisis weighs unevenly on a continent. A large part of the continent is facing a winter supply crisis, especially Germany, Hungary and Austria. Conversely, the least affected countries such as Italy, Sweden or the UK do not rely on Russia.

While Italy relied on Russia as its largest gas supplier, its diversity of suppliers is a valuable asset. Thus, the country has the opportunity to build on and intensify its long-standing ties with Africa. The country was thus in the best position to withstand an interruption of supplies from Russia.

The energy shortage caused by the conflict is forcing governments to confront the risks of over-reliance on one supplier. It echoes the energy crisis of the 1970s which led the West to rethink its dependence on the Middle East. This change stimulated global exploration and the search for alternative suppliers such as Venezuela and Mexico.

The German Ministry of Economics says it wanted to get off Russian gas imports as soon as possible. In particular, Germany will lease five floating terminals for liquefied natural gas (LNG). Currently, the country has no LNG terminal, while Italy has three in operation and recently purchased two more.

Diversification of gas deliveries

Italy consumed 29 billion cubic meters of Russian gas last year, about 40% of its imports. The country is gradually replacing approximately 10.5 billion cubic meters of Russian gas with increased imports. Thus, from this winter on, the gas comes from other countries.

Most of the additional gas will come from Algeria. The country says it would increase its total deliveries to Italy by nearly 20%. Gas deliveries from Algeria to Italy would reach 25.2 billion cubic meters of gas this year.

From spring 2023, an increasing flow of LNG will start to arrive in Italy. The LNG will come from Egypt, Qatar, Congo, Nigeria and Angola, among others. Thus, Rome will replace 4 billion cubic meters of additional Russian gas.

Last year, Germany imported 58 billion cubic meters of Russian gas. This figure represented 58% of the country’s consumption. However, supplies from Nord Stream 1 have not taken place since August.

Divergent trajectories

Germany is unable to secure sufficient long-term replacement supplies from other countries. Moreover, the country does not have a national oil and gas company producing abroad like Italy with Eni. Thus, the country is forced to turn to the spot market.

Germany does not benefit from Italy’s proximity to North Africa. Nor does it enjoy the wealth of Great Britain and Norway in the North Sea. Finally, it does not have significant oil or gas reserves.

German leaders have made many miscalculations in recent years, especially after the attachment of Crimea to Russia. In 2006, it was Italy that was the fastest to obtain supplies of Russian gas. At the time, Eni signed the largest gas contract ever signed by a European company with the giant Gazprom.

However, over the past eight years, the two countries have diverged. Germany doubled its share of Russian gas until it became more and more dependent. Conversely, Italy sought to cover itself.

The warning of 2014

Italy was beginning to chart a different course in 2014, when a new government replaced that of Silvio Berlusconi, a friend of Putin. At the same time, the arrival of Descalzi at the head of Eni confirmed the change in Italy’s energy strategy. Thus, from the moment he joined Eni, Descalzi focused on exploring Africa.

In 2015, Eni scored a success in Egypt with the discovery of the largest gas field in the Mediterranean Sea, Zohr. Thus, the company started production in less than two and a half years, marking a rapid development in comparison to the industry. In addition, in Algeria, Eni concluded an agreement in 2019 to renew gas imports until 2027.

The attachment of Crimea to the Russian Federation in 2014 was a turning point. Rome withdrew its support for Gazprom’s $40 billion South Stream project. Thus, Eni abandoned South Stream within a year, before the project was no longer a priority for Moscow.

Italy turned to the construction of the trans-Adriatic gas pipeline, starting from Azerbaijan and passing through Greece and Albania. For its part, Germany did not reduce its exposure to Russia. In addition, Germany formed a consortium with Gazprom and companies in 2015 to build the Nord Stream 2 gas pipeline.

The Hague court has authorised the release of Gazprom’s shares in Wintershall Noordzee, following a judicial decision after several months of legal proceedings involving Ukrainian companies.
SSE plc invests up to €300mn ($326mn) in a new 170MW power plant in County Meath, aiming to ensure energy security and support the growing demand on Ireland's power grid.
The Egyptian government has paid over $1 billion to oil majors to secure natural gas production and restore international investor confidence.
CMA CGM and TotalEnergies announce a strategic partnership with the creation of a joint venture to operate a liquefied natural gas (LNG) bunkering vessel with a capacity of 20,000 m³, based in Rotterdam.
The amount of gas flared globally surged to 151 billion cubic meters, the highest level in nearly twenty years, resulting in losses estimated at 63 billion USD and raising concerns for energy security.
Since early April, Europe has imported nearly 45 billion cubic meters (bcm) of liquefied natural gas (LNG), with storage prospects for winter putting pressure on gas prices.
The Sharjah Electricity, Water and Gas Authority has completed a natural gas network in Al Hamriyah, spanning over 89 kilometres at a total cost of $3.81mn.
The European ban on fuels refined from Russian crude is reshaping import flows, adding pressure to already low inventories and triggering an immediate diesel price rally.
Subsea 7 S.A. has announced a major contract signed with Equinor for the engineering and installation of subsea infrastructure at the Fram Sør gas field, located in the North Sea off the coast of Norway.
The Republic of Congo and Eni confirm the expansion of the Congo LNG project and multiply industrial initiatives to strengthen energy supply and strategic sectors.
Italian group Eni signs a twenty-year liquefied natural gas supply contract with US-based Venture Global, covering two mn tonnes per year and marking a first for the company from the United States.
The discovery of the Gajajeira field marks a major step for Angola, strengthening its natural gas development strategy and diversifying national energy resources in a context of sector transition.
The Voskhod vessel, under US sanctions, docked at the Arctic LNG 2 plant in Russia, marking the second visit by a sanctioned ship to the site this year, according to maritime tracking data.
Japan has urgently secured several additional cargoes of liquefied natural gas from the United States to avert an imminent electricity supply shortage caused by rapidly declining national reserves expected at the end of July.
The European Commission has unveiled a proposal to prohibit the import of Russian gas into the Union, sparking intense debate on its feasibility, contractual impact and consequences for supply security among several Member States.
CNOOC Limited announces the discovery of a significant oil and gas reservoir in the buried hills of the Beibu Gulf, opening new opportunities for shallow water exploration off the coast of China.
TotalEnergies’ Mozambique LNG gas project is at the centre of a legal challenge in Washington, following the approval of a $4.7 bn loan by the US Exim Bank, amid security concerns and opposition from civil society groups.
Investors are closely watching U.S. midstream companies’ announcements regarding new gas pipeline expansions targeting promising markets in the West and Northeast, beyond traditional regions in Texas and the Southeast.
PPL Corporation and Blackstone Infrastructure announce a strategic partnership to develop new gas-fired power plants to supply electricity to data centers through long-term contracts in Pennsylvania.
Falcon Oil & Gas Ltd announces a new record initial flow test result at the Shenandoah S2-2H ST1 well and the start of its 2025 drilling campaign in the Beetaloo Basin.