United States: Energy transition at the expense of energy security?

US Republican lawmakers disagree with the International Energy Agency's forecasts for oil demand and the energy transition.

Share:

Républicains US critique IEA transition énergétique

Senior US Republican lawmakers sent a critical letter to Fatih Birol, Executive Director of the International Energy Agency (IEA), on March 20. They accuse the organization of actively promoting energy transition at the expense of energy security. The letter, signed by John Barrasso and Cathy McMorris Rodgers, criticizes the IEA for discouraging investment in traditional energy sources. They argue that this posture could exploit IEA forecasts to promote policies that compromise energy security.

Pressure on IEA forecasts

The controversy comes against a backdrop of increasing pressure on the IEA regarding its long-term oil demand forecasts. The US election year is intensifying attention on these forecasts, particularly those suggesting that oil demand could peak as early as 2030. The IEA, established after the oil shock of the 1970s, is facing criticism from OPEC and specifically Saudi Arabia for its projections. The IEA’s predictions have attracted intense scrutiny, reflecting the tensions between expectations of continued oil demand growth and energy transition scenarios.

Questions about IEA funding

The letter from the Republican legislators also calls into question US funding of the IEA over the past decade. It suggests a reassessment of US financial support for the IEA depending on the outcome of the forthcoming US elections. Discussions among Republican lawmakers are considering the potential reduction of federal funding to the IEA. This indicates a willingness to look closely at all aspects of US involvement with the IEA, including its funding.

Reactions to the energy transition

Republican lawmakers’ criticism of the IEA is part of the debate over the speed of the energy transition. At CERAWeek in Houston, the heads of major oil companies disputed the feasibility of a rapid shift away from fossil fuels. Amin Nasser, CEO of Saudi Aramco, called calls to phase out fossil fuels a “fantasy”. The CEOs of ExxonMobil, Chevron and TotalEnergies also voiced their concerns, underlining the continuing need for investment in oil.

The IEA’s analyses and positions on the energy transition and the future of fossil fuels have long irritated some producers, particularly in the Persian Gulf economies. OPEC, with its Secretary General Haitham al-Ghais, accused the IEA of demonizing oil and gas producers. These tensions between the IEA and traditional energy players highlight the diverging perspectives on the global energy future and the pace of the transition to cleaner energy sources.

Brazil, Mexico, Argentina, Colombia, Chile, and Peru significantly increase renewable electricity production, reaching nearly 70% of the regional electricity mix, according to a recent Wood Mackenzie study on Latin America's energy sector.
The Canadian government announces an investment of more than $40mn to fund 13 energy projects led by Indigenous communities across the country, aiming to improve energy efficiency and increase local renewable energy use.
The German Ministry of Economy plans to significantly expand aid aimed at reducing industrial electricity costs, increasing eligible companies from 350 to 2,200, at an estimated cost of €4bn ($4.7bn).
A major electricity blackout paralyzed large parts of the Czech Republic, interrupting transport and essential networks, raising immediate economic concerns, and highlighting the vulnerability of energy infrastructures to unforeseen technical incidents.
French greenhouse gas emissions are expected to rise by 0.2% in the first quarter of 2025, indicating a global slowdown in reductions forecast for the full year, according to Citepa, an independent organisation responsible for national monitoring.
The Republican budget bill passed by the U.S. Senate accelerates the phase-out of tax credits for renewable energies, favoring fossil fuels and raising economic concerns among solar and wind industry professionals.
Rapid growth in solar and wind capacities will lead to a significant rise in electricity curtailment in Brazil, as existing transmission infrastructure remains inadequate to handle this massive influx of energy, according to a recent study by consulting firm Wood Mackenzie.
In April 2025, fossil fuels represented 49.5% of South Korea's electricity mix, dropping below the symbolic threshold of 50% for the first time, primarily due to a historic decline in coal-generated electricity production.
The US Senate Finance Committee modifies the '45Z' tax credit to standardize the tax treatment of renewable fuels, thereby encouraging advanced biofuel production starting October 2025.
According to the 2025 report on global energy access, despite notable progress in renewable energy, insufficient targeted financing continues to hinder electricity and clean cooking access, particularly in sub-Saharan Africa.
While advanced economies maintain global energy leadership, China and the United States have significantly progressed in the security and sustainability of their energy systems, according to the World Economic Forum's annual report.
On the sidelines of the US–Africa summit in Luanda, Algiers and Luanda consolidate their energy collaboration to better exploit their oil, gas, and mining potential, targeting a common strategy in regional and international markets.
The UK's Climate Change Committee is urging the government to quickly reduce electricity costs to facilitate the adoption of heat pumps and electric vehicles, judged too slow to achieve the set climate targets.
The European Commission will extend until the end of 2030 an expanded state-aid framework, allowing capitals to fund low-carbon technologies and nuclear power to preserve competitiveness against China and the United States.
Japan's grid operator forecasts an energy shortfall of up to 89 GW by 2050 due to rising demand from semiconductor manufacturing, electric vehicles, and artificial intelligence technologies.
Energy-intensive European industries will be eligible for temporary state aid to mitigate high electricity prices, according to a new regulatory framework proposed by the European Commission under the "Clean Industrial Deal."
Mauritius seeks international investors to swiftly build a floating power plant of around 100 MW, aiming to secure the national energy supply by January 2026 and address current production shortfalls.
Madrid announces immediate energy storage measures while Lisbon secures its electrical grid, responding to the historic outage that affected the entire Iberian Peninsula in late April.
Indonesia has unveiled its new national energy plan, projecting an increase of 69.5 GW in electricity capacity over ten years, largely funded by independent producers, to address rapidly rising domestic demand.
French Minister Agnès Pannier-Runacher condemns the parliamentary moratorium on new renewable energy installations, warning of the potential loss of 150,000 industrial jobs and increased energy dependence on foreign countries.