popular articles

The United States Orders Enel to Dismantle a 150 MW Wind Farm

A U.S. court demands the removal of the Smokey Hills wind farm, located on Osage tribal lands, citing illegal operations and imposing a $300,000 fine.

Please share:

The U.S. justice system has issued a binding ruling against Enel, the Italian energy group, requiring the dismantling of its Smokey Hills wind farm, with a capacity of 150 megawatts (MW). The site, spanning 8,400 acres in Osage County, Oklahoma, was found in violation of federal and tribal laws protecting the mineral rights of the Osage Nation. In addition to restoring the land to its original state by December 2025, the company must pay $300,000 in compensation.

Legal and Financial Context

This ruling concludes more than a decade of legal proceedings initiated in 2014 by U.S. authorities on behalf of the Osage Nation. The dispute centered on the lack of a required permit for the exploitation of underlying mineral resources, despite Enel securing surface rights for the project. Judge Choe-Groves emphasized the importance of respecting laws that safeguard indigenous communities’ rights to their lands and natural resources.

The judgment also requires Enel to cover the legal costs incurred by the Osage Nation and the United States. The protracted nature of the conflict highlights the complexities of interactions between energy developments and protected land rights.

Impact on the Renewable Energy Sector

This verdict sheds light on the regulatory challenges faced by companies involved in the energy transition, particularly when operating on tribal or protected lands. Market players now face increased pressure to adhere strictly to local and federal laws, under the risk of significant financial and reputational consequences.

For investors and operators in the sector, this case underscores the importance of conducting thorough due diligence on regulatory and environmental aspects before launching large-scale projects. The necessity for consultations and explicit agreements with local stakeholders has become a strategic imperative.

Outlook for Operators

Enel’s case could set a precedent in other disputes involving energy projects on sensitive lands. Companies will need to adapt their development strategies by taking greater account of local community demands and complex legal frameworks to safeguard their investments.

Register free of charge for uninterrupted access.

Publicite

Recently published in

RWE has obtained pre-qualification to provide a 60 MW secondary reserve through its offshore wind farm, Amrumbank West. Starting in 2025, this capacity will be auctioned on the balancing energy market, strengthening the stability of the German power grid.
Cadeler has signed a Vessel Reservation Agreement with Ocean Winds for the installation of turbines at the BC-Wind offshore wind farm in the Polish Baltic Sea. The contract, estimated between EUR 48 and 56 million, reinforces the company’s position in this expanding market.
Cadeler has signed a Vessel Reservation Agreement with Ocean Winds for the installation of turbines at the BC-Wind offshore wind farm in the Polish Baltic Sea. The contract, estimated between EUR 48 and 56 million, reinforces the company’s position in this expanding market.
Amazon has signed a Power Purchase Agreement (PPA) with CleanMax for the development of a 100 MW wind farm in India. The project, which will be connected to the national grid, is expected to be operational by the second quarter of 2026.
Amazon has signed a Power Purchase Agreement (PPA) with CleanMax for the development of a 100 MW wind farm in India. The project, which will be connected to the national grid, is expected to be operational by the second quarter of 2026.
Faced with the rise of renewable energies, the United Kingdom is committing 42 billion euros to modernizing its electrical grid by 2031. This project, led by National Grid, aims to adapt infrastructure despite local tensions caused by the installation of new high-voltage power lines.
Faced with the rise of renewable energies, the United Kingdom is committing 42 billion euros to modernizing its electrical grid by 2031. This project, led by National Grid, aims to adapt infrastructure despite local tensions caused by the installation of new high-voltage power lines.
Danish wind energy giant Ørsted reports a modest net profit of 16 million kroner in 2024, after recording losses in 2023. Facing rising costs and delays in the U.S., the company is scaling back its investments through 2030.
Independent renewable energy producer ERG has signed a long-term power purchase agreement (PPA) with Amazon. The deal involves energy from the Corlacky wind farm in Northern Ireland, which is expected to be operational by the end of 2025.
Independent renewable energy producer ERG has signed a long-term power purchase agreement (PPA) with Amazon. The deal involves energy from the Corlacky wind farm in Northern Ireland, which is expected to be operational by the end of 2025.
The world leader in wind energy, Vestas, multiplied its net profit sixfold in 2024, reaching €499 million. With a record order backlog of €68.4 billion, the Danish group is betting on offshore wind power to sustain its growth.
The world leader in wind energy, Vestas, multiplied its net profit sixfold in 2024, reaching €499 million. With a record order backlog of €68.4 billion, the Danish group is betting on offshore wind power to sustain its growth.
SSE Renewables, APB/APG, and TenneT have signed a realization agreement for the connection of the IJmuiden Ver Alpha offshore wind farm in the Netherlands. This 2GW project marks a major step in the Dutch high-voltage grid and is expected to be operational by 2029.
SSE Renewables, APB/APG, and TenneT have signed a realization agreement for the connection of the IJmuiden Ver Alpha offshore wind farm in the Netherlands. This 2GW project marks a major step in the Dutch high-voltage grid and is expected to be operational by 2029.
Amazon and Iberdrola are expanding their energy partnership with the addition of 476 MW of new power purchase agreements (PPAs). These agreements span five countries and mark a first entry into Portugal, further consolidating their presence in the European market.
Mitsubishi Corporation is reassessing its offshore wind projects in Japan due to macroeconomic turbulence. Inflation, yen depreciation, and rising interest rates are complicating the viability of these projects, initially awarded in 2021. The company is now evaluating its next steps.
Mitsubishi Corporation is reassessing its offshore wind projects in Japan due to macroeconomic turbulence. Inflation, yen depreciation, and rising interest rates are complicating the viability of these projects, initially awarded in 2021. The company is now evaluating its next steps.
Denmark, a pioneer in offshore wind energy, is revising its model after the failure of a 3 GW tender. At the same time, the country is accelerating its green hydrogen infrastructure to strengthen its energy ties with Germany.
Denmark, a pioneer in offshore wind energy, is revising its model after the failure of a 3 GW tender. At the same time, the country is accelerating its green hydrogen infrastructure to strengthen its energy ties with Germany.
The Polish Prime Minister announces the Baltica 2 project, carried out in partnership with Ørsted and PGE, aiming for 1.5 GW over 190 km² in the Baltic Sea, with a launch this year and commissioning scheduled for 2027.
The Polish Prime Minister announces the Baltica 2 project, carried out in partnership with Ørsted and PGE, aiming for 1.5 GW over 190 km² in the Baltic Sea, with a launch this year and commissioning scheduled for 2027.
Ørsted, a Danish renewable energy specialist, is undergoing a major reshuffle following difficulties in the U.S., with the resignation of its CEO and the appointment of his deputy.
The Government of Canada, in partnership with Nova Scotia, implements new legislative provisions governing offshore wind energy development to stimulate the economy and attract significant investments.
The Government of Canada, in partnership with Nova Scotia, implements new legislative provisions governing offshore wind energy development to stimulate the economy and attract significant investments.
TGS has secured an offshore wind site characterization contract off the coast of the UK, with a duration of 30 days and mobilization scheduled for Q2 2025.
TGS has secured an offshore wind site characterization contract off the coast of the UK, with a duration of 30 days and mobilization scheduled for Q2 2025.
EDF Renewables' subsidiary will fund the restoration of a dry forest in Guadeloupe following uncontrolled land clearing at a wind farm site. This alternative to legal proceedings has been approved by local authorities.
EDF Renewables' subsidiary will fund the restoration of a dry forest in Guadeloupe following uncontrolled land clearing at a wind farm site. This alternative to legal proceedings has been approved by local authorities.
Hydro-Québec accelerates its wind energy development with massive investments and large-scale projects. However, this expansion has sparked growing opposition from local communities demanding more transparency and consultation.
Qualitas Energy has finalized the acquisition of four wind energy projects totaling 250 MW in Germany. These projects, located in strategic regions, mark an important step for the company in this key market.
Qualitas Energy has finalized the acquisition of four wind energy projects totaling 250 MW in Germany. These projects, located in strategic regions, mark an important step for the company in this key market.
Suzlon and Torrent Power consolidate their strategic partnership with a 486 MW order in Gujarat, achieving a significant milestone of 1 GW in installed wind energy capacity.
Suzlon and Torrent Power consolidate their strategic partnership with a 486 MW order in Gujarat, achieving a significant milestone of 1 GW in installed wind energy capacity.
Copenhagen Infrastructure Partners and Vena Energy move forward with the Taean offshore wind project, strengthening South Korea's energy independence and optimizing synergies with the local supply chain.
Copenhagen Infrastructure Partners and Vena Energy move forward with the Taean offshore wind project, strengthening South Korea's energy independence and optimizing synergies with the local supply chain.
The Inch Cape offshore wind farm, owned by ESB and Red Rock Renewables, has secured £3.5 billion in funding to begin its construction phase. This flagship 1,080 MW project aims to bolster the United Kingdom's energy security.
The Sri Lankan government has canceled a power purchase agreement with Adani, citing corruption concerns and criticism over the project’s costs. This decision marks a shift in the country’s energy policies under the new administration.
The Sri Lankan government has canceled a power purchase agreement with Adani, citing corruption concerns and criticism over the project’s costs. This decision marks a shift in the country’s energy policies under the new administration.
Pine Wind Power acquires 26% of the offshore wind farm Formosa 2, a strategic move reflecting the growing interest of investors in renewable energy assets within a transforming Taiwanese market.
Pine Wind Power acquires 26% of the offshore wind farm Formosa 2, a strategic move reflecting the growing interest of investors in renewable energy assets within a transforming Taiwanese market.
Copper 360, a key player in South Africa's copper sector, invests in a 55 MW wind power project to secure its energy supply while reducing operational expenses and its carbon footprint.
Copper 360, a key player in South Africa's copper sector, invests in a 55 MW wind power project to secure its energy supply while reducing operational expenses and its carbon footprint.

Advertising