Restarting the Palisades nuclear power plant between hope and financial uncertainty

The restart of the Palisades nuclear power plant in Michigan, after a two-year shutdown, raises technical and financial concerns. The challenges encountered could influence the future of nuclear power in the United States and public confidence in the sector.

Share:

Centrale nucléaire de Palisades

The restart of the Palisades nuclear power plant in Michigan is the subject of intense debate in the US energy sector.
After a two-year shutdown, Holtec International, owner of the facility, plans to restart operation of the plant by the end of 2025.
This initiative follows a $1.52 billion conditional loan from the U.S. Department of Energy, which prompted Holtec to modify its initial decommissioning strategy.
Rising energy demand, fueled by booming sectors such as electric vehicles, artificial intelligence and cryptocurrencies, is driving this decision.

Technical challenges and inspections

However, recent inspections by the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) have highlighted significant technical problems.
A large number of steam generator tubes require further analysis or repair, which could delay the restart process.
Holtec has acknowledged the need for additional maintenance work, but has not yet provided a precise estimate of costs or additional lead times.
These uncertainties raise questions about the viability of the project, both technically and economically.
Alan Blind, former Technical Director of Palisades, has estimated that steam generator repairs could exceed $500 million and delay restart by two to three years.
This estimate highlights the financial challenges Holtec could face, despite its assurances that these contingencies had been factored into the original financial forecasts.
The current situation raises concerns about the economic feasibility of the project, especially in a context of ever-changing energy costs and investor expectations.

Criticism and concerns of experts

Industry experts also express concern about the transparency of the information provided by Holtec.
Edwin Lyman, physicist and nuclear safety expert, stresses that more in-depth details on the plant’s condition are needed before committing further public funds to the project.
He states,

“The public deserves the un-embellished truth before any more taxpayer and consumer dollars are invested in what could be a very deep money pit.”

This statement highlights the need for clear and honest communication about the risks associated with restarting the plant.
The restart of Palisades, if realized, would mark a first in the United States, where a closed nuclear power plant would be reopened to meet growing energy demand.
However, the technical and financial challenges remain considerable.
The NRC said that additional analysis, testing and repairs would be required in the coming months, which could further complicate the restart schedule.

Future prospects

The current situation at the Palisades plant raises crucial questions about the future of nuclear power in the United States.
While the federal government sees nuclear power as a key element in the fight against climate change, the technical and financial challenges associated with reopening closed plants could put the brakes on this ambition.
Industry players have to navigate a complex environment, where growing energy demand has to be balanced with safety and sustainability considerations.
Decisions taken by Holtec and regulators in the coming months will have repercussions not only for the Palisades plant, but for the US nuclear industry as a whole.
The ability to overcome technical hurdles and ensure adequate transparency will be crucial to investor and public confidence in the future of nuclear power.
The stakes are high, and the success or failure of this project could influence energy policy and investment in nuclear infrastructure nationwide.

Bahrain has concluded a civil nuclear agreement with the United States and formalised a commitment of $17bn in public investments in the US market, further strengthening bilateral cooperation.
Kairos Power has installed the vessel for its third test prototype in Oak Ridge, aiming to validate manufacturing methods for its future Hermes reactor supported by the US Department of Energy.
London and Prague formalise a strategic partnership to develop the nuclear sector, focusing on small modular reactors and industrial cooperation on supply chains.
Experts have broadly approved France’s Cigéo deep nuclear waste repository project, highlighting technical uncertainties that demand stronger guarantees for long-term safety.
Uzbekistan advances its nuclear project by signing a protocol with Hungary for the supply and local assembly of dry cooling systems, expanding its industrial partnerships in the region.
Polskie Elektrownie Jądrowe is asking the European Commission to review its $49bn investment to build Poland’s first nuclear power plant, a step required under the Euratom Treaty before any construction permit can be issued.
The International Atomic Energy Agency mission completed on July 11 warns that the National Nuclear Safety Administration must hire staff to oversee a fleet of 59 reactors in operation and 32 more under construction.
Energoatom signed strategic agreements with Westinghouse and Holtec at the Ukraine Recovery Conference, aiming to establish nuclear fuel production and small modular reactor capabilities in the country.
Tehran agrees to reopen its nuclear facilities to the IAEA, aiming to resume negotiations with Washington, while Moscow pushes for a “zero enrichment” agreement without getting involved in supervision.
TerraPower has selected three new American suppliers for its advanced Natrium nuclear reactor, confirming progress on the project located in Kemmerer, Wyoming, intended to replace a retiring coal-fired power plant.
Energy Exploration Technologies acquires Daytona Lithium, an Australian subsidiary of Pantera Lithium, for AUD40mn ($27mn), bringing its strategic lithium basin footprint in Smackover, USA to nearly 50,000 acres.
The Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission has identified no major barriers to licensing the ARC-100 reactor, announces ARC Clean Technology.
SE Ignalina, the Lithuanian nuclear operator, has signed a memorandum of understanding with French firm Newcleo to explore the integration of small modular reactors (SMRs) using lead-cooled fast reactor (LFR) technology in Lithuania.
Egyptian President Abdel Fattah al-Sisi oversaw the signing of new agreements for the construction of the El Dabaa nuclear power plant, thus strengthening the strategic cooperation between Egypt and Russia.
Vistra Corp receives green light to extend Perry nuclear plant operations in Ohio by 20 years, securing regional electricity supply until 2046 and ensuring operational continuity for all its nuclear reactors in the United States.
EDF will hold a 12.5% stake in the Sizewell C nuclear project in the UK, a €1.3 billion investment announced during Emmanuel Macron’s official visit to London, confirming the strategic nuclear energy alignment between the two countries.
The French Cigéo project, designed to bury the most hazardous radioactive waste deep underground, obtains a crucial technical validation before its final authorization, expected by the end of 2027.
EDF confirms the continuation of its industrial project in Fessenheim for recycling very low-level radioactive metals, a first in France requiring specific regulatory authorizations, following a public debate concluded last February.
NANO Nuclear Energy Inc. formalizes its collaboration with UrAmerica Ltd. to strengthen Argentina’s uranium supply, aiming to secure future nuclear fuel supply chains for the U.S. market.
American companies SHINE Technologies and Standard Nuclear partner to recycle uranium and plutonium, supplying advanced fuel to the nuclear reactor sector and enhancing the national energy security of the United States.