popular articles

Regulatory inconsistencies hold back carbon projects in Malaysia

Malaysia is struggling to harmonize its policies for the development of natural carbon projects, threatening their viability and reputation.
Inconsistencies Policies Carbon Projects

Please share:

Despite its vast forest resources, Malaysia is making slow progress in developing natural carbon projects. Market players express concern about fragmented state policies that expose these projects to significant regulatory and reputational risks. Comprising 11 states to the west on the Malay Peninsula and two to the east on the island of Borneo, Federal Malaysia is developing national economic plans and legislative frameworks. However, for nature-based projects, state governments set local rules for land administration, forest management and agriculture.

Regulatory frameworks and carbon projects

Since 2021, the federal government has published non-binding general guidelines for the development of the voluntary carbon market, defining the types of projects feasible in the country, the stakeholders involved and the requirements for implementing and reporting emission reductions. Western states such as Terengganu, Johor and Kelantan plan to develop policies within the federal government framework. In contrast, Sarawak and Sabah in the east have formulated their own laws to accelerate project development. Proactive initiatives by the Sarawak and Sabah governments have effectively accelerated the development of nature-based projects in their territories. The Kuamut forest conservation project in Sabah, registered with Verra, has already started generating carbon credits. Meanwhile, the Marudi forest conservation project in Sarawak, also registered with Verra, is marked as “under development”. However, these initiatives have also created policy inconsistencies across the country, notably with regard to carbon licensing requirements, benefit-sharing conditions between stakeholders and governments, and measures to protect indigenous communities.

Different approaches by States

These inconsistencies, if not properly managed, could hamper the delivery of carbon credits and damage the reputation of buyers. Comparing the two pilot states, Sarawak has relatively detailed regulations in place, but the sophisticated rules also pose greater challenges and lengthen project development times. Sabah’s simpler regulations speed up projects, but leave grey areas that can trigger disputes. Sarawak is considered the most advanced among Malaysian states in terms of carbon policies, according to the VCM Handbook published in October 2023 by Bursa Malaysia, which hosts the national carbon exchange. Project proponents must first obtain a carbon study permit to conduct a feasibility study, then submit detailed plans for project implementation. Then they have to apply for a carbon license to start trading carbon credits. Sarawak has also listed the fees and royalties to be paid, and requires project developers to set aside part of the carbon credits to meet the state’s climate targets.

Effects of inconsistencies

A detailed regulatory framework, such as Sarawak’s, helps prevent disputes, but can slow down the process. On the other hand, the simplicity of Sabah’s regulations facilitates rapid implementation, but leaves uncertainties that can lead to disputes. Projects already in place in Sabah before all the regulations were established are seeing their carbon credits and returns on investment become uncertain, which poses a problem. Regulatory differences between Malaysian states pose challenges for project developers and investors. A local project developer pointed out that the existence of projects prior to the establishment of clear regulations makes the volume of tradable carbon credits and returns on investment uncertain.

Impact on aboriginal communities

Mitigating negative impacts on indigenous communities is another crucial challenge for the development of the Malaysian carbon market. Indigenous groups make up more than half the population of Sarawak and Sabah, with many living in forest reserves. Carbon projects have already been accused of violating indigenous rights. In December 2023, the UN Human Rights Council questioned the government of Sabah over an agreement with Singaporean company Hoch Standard, signed without the consent of indigenous communities, transferring the carbon rights of 2 million hectares of local forests.

Special cases and testimonials

A Save Rivers NGO report published in May 2024 criticizes the Jalin forest carbon management project in Sarawak, accusing the developers of forcing Penan communities to sign documents and denying them access to their forests. According to national guidelines, carbon project developers must consult affected indigenous stakeholders. At a webinar in May, Permian Malaysia, developer of the Kuamut pilot project in Sabah, claimed that their project areas are for commercial use only, with no indigenous communities. A SaraCarbon official indicated that they bypassed certain areas inhabited by indigenous people to develop the Marudi project. A Singapore-based carbon trader points out that foreign investors perceive Malaysian carbon credits as a whole, with no distinction between states. Any shortcomings therefore affect the overall image of Malaysian carbon credits. Another local project developer adds that credits would have to be earmarked to meet state climate targets, which could compromise the amount of credits available for trade.

Reputation and reliability of carbon credits

The reliability and reputation of Malaysian carbon credits depend on harmonized regulations and adequate protection of the rights of local communities. Investors need clear guarantees before committing to carbon projects in Malaysia. The sustainable development of these projects requires close collaboration between federal and state governments, as well as the active involvement of indigenous communities.
The development of natural carbon projects in Malaysia is hampered by inconsistent policies and risks for indigenous communities. To succeed, the country must harmonize its regulations and ensure adequate protection of the rights of local populations, while offering clear guarantees to investors.

Register free of charge for uninterrupted access.

Publicite

Recently published in

François Bayrou souhaite engager un débat sans vote au Parlement sur la programmation énergétique 2025-2035, alors que le projet alimente les tensions politiques et que le Rassemblement national menace de déposer une motion de censure.
The European Court of Auditors warns of the urgency of massive investments in the Union’s ageing power grids, hampered by administrative delays and inadequate planning.
The European Court of Auditors warns of the urgency of massive investments in the Union’s ageing power grids, hampered by administrative delays and inadequate planning.
Several lawmakers and former energy executives are demanding a moratorium on PPE3, criticising a plan they view as disconnected from current economic and geopolitical realities.
Several lawmakers and former energy executives are demanding a moratorium on PPE3, criticising a plan they view as disconnected from current economic and geopolitical realities.
The head of Framatome will be heard on 30 April by both chambers to validate his nomination to lead EDF, following the non-renewal of Luc Rémont by the executive.
The head of Framatome will be heard on 30 April by both chambers to validate his nomination to lead EDF, following the non-renewal of Luc Rémont by the executive.
Following a series of major electricity outages on the island of Upolu, the Samoan government has declared a state of emergency to prioritise essential services and mobilise foreign aid.
The Minister of Industry and Energy expressed openness to a debate and a vote on the 2025–2035 energy strategy, amid criticism from opposition parties over the lack of democratic consultation.
The Minister of Industry and Energy expressed openness to a debate and a vote on the 2025–2035 energy strategy, amid criticism from opposition parties over the lack of democratic consultation.
France’s Ministry of Industry and Energy postpones the 2025 energy voucher to November, citing delayed budget approval and announcing revised allocation rules.
France’s Ministry of Industry and Energy postpones the 2025 energy voucher to November, citing delayed budget approval and announcing revised allocation rules.
France’s decarbonisation pace slowed significantly in 2024, according to Citepa, putting its 2030 climate targets at risk.
France’s decarbonisation pace slowed significantly in 2024, according to Citepa, putting its 2030 climate targets at risk.
Luc Rémont was dismissed as head of EDF by the French executive due to disagreements over industrial contract strategy and financing of the EPR2 nuclear programme.
Just Stop Oil will end its high-profile actions after one of its core demands was integrated into the British government's energy policy.
Just Stop Oil will end its high-profile actions after one of its core demands was integrated into the British government's energy policy.
The surge in solar production and the slow upgrade of electricity infrastructure are blocking thousands of projects in the Netherlands, affecting energy security and consumer costs.
The surge in solar production and the slow upgrade of electricity infrastructure are blocking thousands of projects in the Netherlands, affecting energy security and consumer costs.
The development of French power grids is facing a structural shortage of skilled labour, despite €200bn in projected investments by 2040.
The development of French power grids is facing a structural shortage of skilled labour, despite €200bn in projected investments by 2040.
Luc Rémont's departure exposes ongoing disagreements between EDF and the French State over electricity pricing for industry and the financing terms of the nuclear programme.
The European Investment Bank approves a final tranche of PLN1.7bn for Orlen to modernise electricity distribution infrastructure in Poland via its subsidiary Energa Operator.
The European Investment Bank approves a final tranche of PLN1.7bn for Orlen to modernise electricity distribution infrastructure in Poland via its subsidiary Energa Operator.
Luc Rémont is replaced as head of EDF as French manufacturers criticise a pricing strategy seen as incompatible with national industrial competitiveness.
Luc Rémont is replaced as head of EDF as French manufacturers criticise a pricing strategy seen as incompatible with national industrial competitiveness.
Luc Rémont will not be reappointed as Chairman of Électricité de France, two years after his nomination, despite record profits in 2024 and the revival of the nuclear fleet.
Luc Rémont will not be reappointed as Chairman of Électricité de France, two years after his nomination, despite record profits in 2024 and the revival of the nuclear fleet.
The French government has appointed Bernard Fontana to lead EDF, relying on his experience in nuclear energy and energy-intensive industries, amid strategic restructuring and rising tariff pressures.
Kazakhmys, the leading copper producer in Kazakhstan, partially suspends its operations after the death of eight workers. The company is conducting an inspection of its facilities to ensure operational safety.
Kazakhmys, the leading copper producer in Kazakhstan, partially suspends its operations after the death of eight workers. The company is conducting an inspection of its facilities to ensure operational safety.
The European Southern Observatory (ESO) warns of the potentially devastating consequences of a power plant project near its telescopes in the Atacama Desert, highlighting irreversible light pollution.
The European Southern Observatory (ESO) warns of the potentially devastating consequences of a power plant project near its telescopes in the Atacama Desert, highlighting irreversible light pollution.
The recent elections in Greenland resulted in a victory for the Demokraatit party, which advocates gradual independence from Denmark and increased support for the exploitation of natural resources, prioritizing the mining and energy sectors. This election comes amid heightened international tensions, notably due to proposals by Donald Trump to annex the territory.
The recent elections in Greenland resulted in a victory for the Demokraatit party, which advocates gradual independence from Denmark and increased support for the exploitation of natural resources, prioritizing the mining and energy sectors. This election comes amid heightened international tensions, notably due to proposals by Donald Trump to annex the territory.
The National Federation of Mines and Energy of the General Confederation of Labour (FNME-CGT) has elected Fabrice Coudour as secretary general. He succeeds Sébastien Ménesplier and inherits strategic issues, including the opening of hydropower concessions to competition.
Nigerien authorities have ordered the expulsion of three Chinese executives from oil companies and shut down a hotel owned by a Chinese company. This decision is part of a policy aimed at strengthening national control over the country’s energy resources.
Nigerien authorities have ordered the expulsion of three Chinese executives from oil companies and shut down a hotel owned by a Chinese company. This decision is part of a policy aimed at strengthening national control over the country’s energy resources.
The French government has issued a decree expanding the use of treated wastewater to industrial and nuclear sectors, aiming to reduce pressure on water resources.
The French government has issued a decree expanding the use of treated wastewater to industrial and nuclear sectors, aiming to reduce pressure on water resources.
An incident in a private power plant caused a nationwide blackout in Panama on Saturday night. The national power grid was severely impacted, leading to an interruption in the potable water supply. Authorities are investigating the causes of the event.
An incident in a private power plant caused a nationwide blackout in Panama on Saturday night. The national power grid was severely impacted, leading to an interruption in the potable water supply. Authorities are investigating the causes of the event.

Advertising