Is a fair Energy Transition possible?

transition énergétique

Partagez:

A just energy transition can be defined as an equitable transition that benefits the entire population. This concept is designed to ensure that no community is left behind. In fact, this “justice” plays a central role in getting people on board with the energy transition. Yet today, it seems difficult to implement, as the obstacles remain so high.

The concept of “justice” in the energy transition is receiving increasing attention from governments. In its Green New Deal, Europe made this issue a central element of its strategy. After all, energy justice refers to notions of equity, solidarity and accessibility of the energy system.

Fairness as a condition for a just energy transition

Equity in the energy sector

Equity is defined as the fair distribution of the benefits and costs of the energy transition. It’s not a question of absolute equality, but of everyone contributing according to their means. The UN’s “principle of common but differentiated responsibility” is fully in line with this definition.

Equity is achieved when developed countries contribute more to climate efforts than poor countries. In fact, it was during the climate negotiations that this concept took root and began to make its way into the discourse. Emerging countries in particular have made extensive use of this principle to reduce their climate efforts.

Fairness undermined in recent years

Often celebrated since COP 21, fairness is now being undermined when it comes to energy. Indeed, there is a significant gap between countries when it comes to climate efforts. Only 20 of the 196 signatories to the Paris Agreement have announced carbon-neutral targets.

This divergence is proving problematic in a context of heightened international economic competition. For example, differences in fossil fuel subsidies completely disadvantage certain countries, creating a sense of injustice among populations. In fact, the development of a fair energy transition requires genuine equity in climate efforts worldwide.

The importance of solidarity

Winners and losers in the energy transition

In addition to fairness, a just energy transition will require significant support for the industries losing out in the energy transition. We’re obviously thinking of oil, where demand is expected to peak as early as 2030. For many energy-producing countries, the de facto energy transition represents a considerable social risk. The challenge will be for them to diversify their economies by taking advantage of new energy opportunities such ashydrogen.

Because of its impact on pollution, coal will be the other big loser in the energy transition. According to the International Energy Agency, production is likely to stagnate at best between now and 2040, then decline sharply after that date. If the Paris Agreement is respected, coal should account for only 6% of the electricity mix.

Solidarity is needed with the losers in the energy transition

This gradual decline in fossil fuels will have a significant impact on employment in a number of countries. Entire regions could be deprived of economic activity for years to come. We can therefore understand their reluctance to commit to the energy transition. In order to overcome this obstacle, it will be necessary to implement policies to assist the conversion of affected regions.

Through its “just transition mechanism”, the European Union is committed to promoting the retraining of workers. Similarly, Germany has adopted an ambitious plan for the economic conversion of coal-mining regions by 2038. Nevertheless, the plan will cost Berlin almost €40 billion. In other words, the question of financing will be central to ensuring that no one is harmed by the energy transition.

Accessibility: a sine qua non condition

Accessibility still a long way off

The question of energy accessibility is a fundamental element in promoting a fair energy transition. Indeed, this transition can only succeed if the entire population benefits from the opportunities it creates. In its Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), the UN is aiming for 100% accessibility by 2030.

Today, this objective is still far from being achieved, with 10% of the population deprived of access to electricity. Africa alone accounts for 85% of this population. Since the start of the pandemic, this figure has actually risen by 2%, putting an end to 7 years of improvement.

The impact of Covid-19

This rise can be explained by the increase in borrowing costs, which considerably limits the States’ financial leeway. Deprived of funding, the latter have consequently chosen to prioritize urgent measures to the detriment of electrification programs. In Uganda, for example, the government decided to end subsidies for access to electricity due to a lack of available resources.

The pandemic is also having an impact on the deployment of micro-networks, with a major impact on value chains. Yet these microgrids play a vital role in the electrification of rural areas, particularly in Africa. The solar sector has been particularly hard hit by the crisis, with a 10% drop in sales on the continent. As a result, the World Bank estimates that universal access to electricity will not be achieved by 2030.

As a result, the energy transition will be far from a smooth ride. It will have to successfully combine notions of equity, solidarity and accessibility to energy systems. With its Green New Deal, however, Europe could set itself up as a model for a fair energy transition on a global scale.

In 2024, US CO₂ emissions remain stable at 5.1bn tonnes, as the Trump administration prepares hydrocarbon-friendly energy policies, raising questions about the future evolution of the American market.
The early publication of France's energy decree triggers strong parliamentary reactions, as the government aims to rapidly secure investments in nuclear and other energy sectors.
Seven weeks after the major Iberian power outage, Spain identifies technical network failures, while the European Investment Bank approves major funding to strengthen the interconnection with France.
The European Union has announced a detailed schedule aiming to definitively halt Russian gas imports by the end of 2027, anticipating internal legal and commercial challenges to overcome.
Madagascar plans the imminent opening of a 105 MW thermal power plant to swiftly stabilise its electricity grid, severely affected in major urban areas, while simultaneously developing renewable energy projects.
India's Central Electricity Regulatory Commission proposes a new financial instrument enabling industrial companies to meet renewable energy targets through virtual contracts, without physical electricity delivery, thus facilitating compliance management.
At a conference held on June 11, Brussels reaffirmed its goal to reduce energy costs for households and businesses by relying on targeted investments and greater consumer involvement.
The European Commission held a high-level dialogue to identify administrative obstacles delaying renewable energy and energy infrastructure projects across the European Union.
Despite increased generation capacity and lower tariffs, Liberia continues to rely on electricity imports to meet growing demand, particularly during the dry season.
South Korea's new president, Lee Jae-myung, is reviewing the national energy policy, aiming to rebalance nuclear regulations without immediately shutting down reactors currently in operation.
The French Energy Regulatory Commission released its 2024 annual report, highlighting sustained activity on grid infrastructure, pricing, and evolving European regulatory frameworks.
The United States is easing proposed penalties for foreign LNG tankers and vehicle carriers, sharply reducing initial costs for international operators while maintaining strategic support objectives for the American merchant marine.
While capital is flowing into clean technologies globally, Africa remains marginalised, receiving only a fraction of the expected flows, according to the International Energy Agency.
The Mexican government aims to mobilise up to $9bn in private investment by 2030, but the lack of a clear commercial framework raises doubts within the industry.
The U.S. Department of Transportation is withdrawing strict fuel economy standards adopted under Biden, citing overreach in legal authority regarding the integration of electric vehicles into regulatory calculations for automakers.
In 2024, renewable energies covered 33.9% of electricity consumption in metropolitan France, driven by increased hydropower output and solar capacity expansion.
The French Energy Regulatory Commission (CRE) has announced its strategic guidelines for 2030, focusing on the energy transition, European competitiveness and consumer needs.
Madrid paid an arbitration award to Blasket Renewable Investments after more than ten years of litigation related to the withdrawal of tax advantages for renewable energy investors.
The global renewable energy market continues to grow, reaching $1,200 billion in 2024, according to a report by the International Energy Agency (IEA), supported by investments in solar and wind energy.
The Québec government is granting $3.43mn to the Saint-Jean-Baptiste Electric Cooperative to deploy smart meters and upgrade infrastructure across 16 municipalities.