Yasuni referendum: dilemma between biodiversity and oil in Oriente

The Yasuni referendum in Ecuador marked a turning point in the debate over the country's oil industry, with a 58.95% majority in favor of halting oil production in the Yasuni-ITT reserve. This decision underlines the continuing tension between the oil industry and environmentalists, and could influence other South American countries.

Share:

The recent Yasuni referendum in Ecuador has sparked a crucial debate about the future of the country’s oil industry. This consultation marked a decisive step in Ecuador’s history, highlighting the persistent tension between the oil industry and environmentalists.

Yasuni-ITT: The conflict between the oil industry and environmental protection in Ecuador

Oil production from Yasuni Park, in particular “Block 43”, comprising the Ishpingo, Tambococha and Tiputini (ITT) fields, currently accounts for 12% of Ecuador’s oil production. Yet the population voted overwhelmingly, at 58.95%, in favor of halting oil production in Yasuni-ITT.

The ITT block in Yasuni Park, Ecuador

Ecuador’s oil-dependent economy is under increasing environmental pressure from environmental groups and indigenous communities. The recent Yasuni referendum was the culmination of many years of struggle between the oil industry and environmentalists. However, these claims are not new.

Texaco in Ecuador: The quest for environmental justice

As early as 1993, fourteen associations formed the Amazon Defense Front, representing 30,000 victims of the activities of Texaco, an American company that operated Ecuador’s oil fields between 1964 and 1992. The environmental damage caused by Texaco is alarming, with 2 million hectares of forest contaminated by 64 million liters of spilled crude oil, 880 leaking oil waste pits, and 60 billion liters of contaminated water discharged into rivers. Added to this are the serious consequences for local populations, such as cancers, illnesses linked to water pollution, and the violation of human rights.

This environmental movement also led to the recognition of a “right to nature” in Ecuador’s new Constitution in 2008. It also gave rise to the Yasunidos group, the environmental group calling for national consultation on the fate of oil development in the heart of the Yasuni reserve, home to indigenous peoples such as the Waorani.

The delicate dance between the Amazon jungle and oil resources

At the heart of South America, Ecuador, named after the equatorial line that crosses it, offers an opulent biodiversity, despite its relatively modest size compared to France. In addition to its pristine beaches and snow-capped Andean peaks, this country is home to a precious part of the Amazon, geographically referred to as the “Oriente”. This region is a nugget of biological diversity, attested to by eminent scientists such as Alexander von Humboldt and Charles Darwin.

And yet, alongside this wealth of biodiversity, Ecuador is also rich in hydrocarbons. The heart of Oriente is home to the country’s largest oil reserves, making Ecuador South America’s fifth-largest oil producer. Its economy is largely based on these fossil resources, in particular oil and natural gas, as well as on mining, fishing, tourism and banana cultivation, among others.

However, this economic dependence on oil presents complex challenges. The closure of the Yasuni-ITT oilfield will have a direct impact on the country’s revenues, highlighting the delicate equation between environmental preservation and economic stability.

 

Ecuador’s economic and political challenges in 2023

The hydrocarbon industry plays a significant role in the Ecuadorian economy, contributing 32% of total foreign sales. Despite Ecuador’s exit from OPEC, stable international oil prices have maintained this source of revenue, generating a current account surplus forecast for 2023. However, rising global borrowing costs and environmental pressures have slowed investment in the oil sector, with potential long-term consequences for production and revenues.

President Guillermo Lasso has faced governance challenges, notably due to protests over rising fuel prices. The introduction of a differentiated fuel price mechanism to target subsidies on the most vulnerable populations reflects the complexity of the country’s political and social situation. Environmental concerns linked to the oil industry also remain a source of concern, with suspensions of mining concessions and worries about long-term oil production.

The environmentalists’ referendum victory: a game-changer

Ecuador is faced with a thorny dilemma that reflects the crucial challenges of our time: the preservation of its exceptional biodiversity or the temptation of oil exploitation, the mainstay of its economy. The August 20 referendum crystallized this dilemma. The victory of the “yes” vote marked a major turning point, bringing a halt to oil exploitation in the country’s iconic Yasuni Park, but the decision could also influence other oil-producing countries in South America, such as Brazil.

Ecuador’s dependence on hydrocarbons is therefore a complex and nuanced reality. Although the oil sector makes a significant contribution to exports and government revenues, environmental, social and political challenges continue to weigh heavily on its future. The country’s ability to maintain stable governance and adapt to the changing realities of the global hydrocarbon market will be key to ensuring a sustainable economic recovery in 2023 and beyond.

Yasuni: A precedent for South America in the battle between oil and biodiversity

The example of Yasuni Park is not limited to Ecuador. It could inspire similar initiatives in South America, home to the planet’s green lung. This region abounds in precious hydrocarbon reserves, notably Venezuela, which holds the world’s largest oil reserves, accounting for 18% of the global total. Despite this wealth, Brazil is Latin America’s leading producer.

Nevertheless, the preservation of biodiversity and the fight against climate change often take second place to oil production. Ecuador’s historic decision could influence its neighbors. It could also provoke reflection within the Brazilian giant, a member of the BRICS, which is seeking to preserve its growing economy.

What’s more, this decision could be paralleled by that of Colombia’s new president, Gustavo Petro, who chose to halt oil exports, despite the fact that they accounted for 40% of all exports and 12% of government revenues.

Petróleos de Venezuela S.A. (PDVSA) recorded $17.52bn in export sales in 2024, benefiting from increased volumes due to U.S. licences granted to foreign partners, according to an internal document seen by Reuters.
The detection of zinc in Mars crude extracted off the coast of Louisiana forced the US government to draw on its strategic reserves to support Gulf Coast refineries.
Commissioning of a 1.2-million-ton hydrocracking unit at the TANECO site confirms the industrial expansion of the complex and its ability to diversify refined fuel production.
Oil stocks in the United States saw an unexpected rise of 7.1 million barrels as of July 4, defying analyst expectations of a decline, according to the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA).
Petro-Victory Energy announces the completion of drilling operations for the AND-5 well in the Andorinha field, Brazil, with positive reservoir results and next steps for production.
The Colombian prosecutor’s office has seized two offices belonging to the oil company Perenco in Bogotá. The company is accused of financing the United Self-Defense Forces of Colombia (AUC) in exchange for security services between 1997 and 2005.
Indonesia has signed a memorandum of understanding with the United States to increase its energy imports. This deal, involving Pertamina, aims to diversify the country's energy supply sources.
VAALCO Energy continues to operate the Baobab field by renovating its floating platform, despite modest production. This strategy aims to maintain stable profitability at low cost.
An empty reservoir exploded at a Lukoil-Perm oil facility in Russia, causing no injuries according to initial assessments pointing to a chemical reaction with oxygen as the cause of the accident.
The British Lindsey refinery has resumed fuel deliveries after reaching a temporary agreement to continue operations, while the future of this strategic site remains under insolvency proceedings.
BP and Shell intensify their commitments in Libya with new agreements aimed at revitalizing major oil field production, amid persistent instability but rising output in recent months.
The private OCP pipeline has resumed operations in Ecuador following an interruption caused by heavy rains, while the main SOTE pipeline remains shut down, continuing to impact oil exports from the South American country.
McDermott secures contract worth up to $50 million with BRAVA Energia to install subsea equipment on the Papa-Terra and Atlanta oil fields off the Brazilian coast.
A bulk carrier operated by a Greek company sailing under a Liberian flag suffered a coordinated attack involving small arms and explosive drones, prompting an Israeli military response against Yemen's Houthis.
The Canadian government is now awaiting a concrete private-sector proposal to develop a new oil pipeline connecting Alberta to the Pacific coast, following recent legislation intended to expedite energy projects.
Petrobras is exploring various strategies for its Polo Bahia oil hub, including potentially selling it, as current profitability is challenged by oil prices around $65 per barrel.
Brazilian producer Azevedo & Travassos will issue new shares to buy Petro-Victory and its forty-nine concessions, consolidating its onshore presence while taking on net debt of about USD39.5mn.
Major oil producers accelerate their return to the market, raising their August quotas more sharply than initially expected, prompting questions about future market balances.
Lindsey refinery could halt operations within three weeks due to limited crude oil reserves, according to a recent analysis by energy consultancy Wood Mackenzie, highlighting an immediate slowdown in production.
The flow of crude between the Hamada field and the Zawiya refinery has resumed after emergency repairs, illustrating the mounting pressure on Libya’s ageing pipeline network that threatens the stability of domestic supply.