The United States Orders Enel to Dismantle a 150 MW Wind Farm

A U.S. court demands the removal of the Smokey Hills wind farm, located on Osage tribal lands, citing illegal operations and imposing a $300,000 fine.

Partagez:

The U.S. justice system has issued a binding ruling against Enel, the Italian energy group, requiring the dismantling of its Smokey Hills wind farm, with a capacity of 150 megawatts (MW). The site, spanning 8,400 acres in Osage County, Oklahoma, was found in violation of federal and tribal laws protecting the mineral rights of the Osage Nation. In addition to restoring the land to its original state by December 2025, the company must pay $300,000 in compensation.

Legal and Financial Context

This ruling concludes more than a decade of legal proceedings initiated in 2014 by U.S. authorities on behalf of the Osage Nation. The dispute centered on the lack of a required permit for the exploitation of underlying mineral resources, despite Enel securing surface rights for the project. Judge Choe-Groves emphasized the importance of respecting laws that safeguard indigenous communities’ rights to their lands and natural resources.

The judgment also requires Enel to cover the legal costs incurred by the Osage Nation and the United States. The protracted nature of the conflict highlights the complexities of interactions between energy developments and protected land rights.

Impact on the Renewable Energy Sector

This verdict sheds light on the regulatory challenges faced by companies involved in the energy transition, particularly when operating on tribal or protected lands. Market players now face increased pressure to adhere strictly to local and federal laws, under the risk of significant financial and reputational consequences.

For investors and operators in the sector, this case underscores the importance of conducting thorough due diligence on regulatory and environmental aspects before launching large-scale projects. The necessity for consultations and explicit agreements with local stakeholders has become a strategic imperative.

Outlook for Operators

Enel’s case could set a precedent in other disputes involving energy projects on sensitive lands. Companies will need to adapt their development strategies by taking greater account of local community demands and complex legal frameworks to safeguard their investments.

German operator Encavis AG strengthens its portfolio by acquiring two wind farms in Lower Saxony and Saxony, totalling 59 MW, in a transaction with Energiequelle GmbH, thereby expanding its renewable energy assets.
Ocergy officially launches an industrial project aiming to install by 2028 a new-generation floating wind turbine of over 15 MW, in partnership with EnBW, Kyuden Mirai, and TEPCO Renewable Power.
France officially commissions its first floating wind farm, consisting of three turbines with a combined capacity of 25 megawatts, introducing strategic technology in the Mediterranean, vital for national energy goals.
Inaugurated on 20 June, the five-turbine plant of wpd onshore France feeds 18 MW into the grid and unlocks new tax revenue for four Côtes-d’Armor municipalities.
Statkraft refocuses investments on flexible Nordic hydropower and reduces commitments in offshore wind and hydrogen to lower operating costs, amid an uncertain economic environment and pressured profitability.
Suzlon Group receives third consecutive order from AMPIN Energy Transition to supply 170.1 MW of wind turbines for a project in India's Andhra Pradesh state, strengthening their strategic industrial partnership.
The Muir Mhòr floating wind project secures Aberdeenshire's onshore consent, paving the way for the potential production of one gigawatt of electricity, enough to power up to 1.2 million British homes by the early 2030s.
Iberdrola España and Renfe conclude a virtual power purchase agreement for 370 GWh per year for ten years, strengthening the use of renewable energy in Spanish railway transport.
TotalEnergies has been awarded a concession in the North Sea enabling the development of a 1GW offshore wind project, reinforcing its strategic presence in Germany.
With an annual increase of 14%, global offshore wind capacity now reaches 85.2 gigawatts, driven mainly by China, the United Kingdom, and Germany, while another 27.3 gigawatts are currently under construction.
Seabed exploration begins in Jammerland Bay to validate the placement of sixteen turbines and the cable corridor, the first tangible step before construction of the project led by TotalEnergies and European Energy.
RWE and Østermark Entreprenørforretning celebrate advanced construction of the operational building for Denmark's largest offshore wind farm, promising up to 60 permanent local jobs by 2026.
RWE and Amazon Web Services enter a strategic collaboration to supply renewable energy for data centres and accelerate digital capabilities within the global energy sector.
SSE Renewables inaugurated its first wind farm in Southern Europe in Chaintrix-Bierges and Vélye, with eight Siemens Gamesa turbines and an investment exceeding €30mn ($32.3mn).
The Astenn Avel consortium, led by Elicio and Q ENERGY, brings in VALOREM to bid for the 500 MW floating wind project planned off the coast of Southern Brittany.
The Canada Infrastructure Bank supports the construction of the Mesgi'g Ugju's'n 2 wind farm, co-owned by Mi'gmaq communities and Innergex, through a combined equity and debt financing package.
The first turbine of the Éoliennes Flottantes du Golfe du Lion project was assembled at Port-La Nouvelle, marking a major industrial milestone for Ocean Winds and its partners.
RWE inaugurated an onshore wind farm in Plounérin and Plounévez-Moëdec, featuring four turbines with a capacity of 14.7 MW, in partnership with the local SEM Lannion-Trégor.
The Moulins wind farm, made up of five turbines, was inaugurated on June 6 across three municipalities in the Douaisis region. It will generate €70,000 in annual tax revenue for local authorities.
Chinese firm SANY Renewable Energy enters Serbia through a 168 MW wind deal aimed at powering the local grid from 2028.