popular articles

The United States Orders Enel to Dismantle a 150 MW Wind Farm

A U.S. court demands the removal of the Smokey Hills wind farm, located on Osage tribal lands, citing illegal operations and imposing a $300,000 fine.

Please share:

The U.S. justice system has issued a binding ruling against Enel, the Italian energy group, requiring the dismantling of its Smokey Hills wind farm, with a capacity of 150 megawatts (MW). The site, spanning 8,400 acres in Osage County, Oklahoma, was found in violation of federal and tribal laws protecting the mineral rights of the Osage Nation. In addition to restoring the land to its original state by December 2025, the company must pay $300,000 in compensation.

Legal and Financial Context

This ruling concludes more than a decade of legal proceedings initiated in 2014 by U.S. authorities on behalf of the Osage Nation. The dispute centered on the lack of a required permit for the exploitation of underlying mineral resources, despite Enel securing surface rights for the project. Judge Choe-Groves emphasized the importance of respecting laws that safeguard indigenous communities’ rights to their lands and natural resources.

The judgment also requires Enel to cover the legal costs incurred by the Osage Nation and the United States. The protracted nature of the conflict highlights the complexities of interactions between energy developments and protected land rights.

Impact on the Renewable Energy Sector

This verdict sheds light on the regulatory challenges faced by companies involved in the energy transition, particularly when operating on tribal or protected lands. Market players now face increased pressure to adhere strictly to local and federal laws, under the risk of significant financial and reputational consequences.

For investors and operators in the sector, this case underscores the importance of conducting thorough due diligence on regulatory and environmental aspects before launching large-scale projects. The necessity for consultations and explicit agreements with local stakeholders has become a strategic imperative.

Outlook for Operators

Enel’s case could set a precedent in other disputes involving energy projects on sensitive lands. Companies will need to adapt their development strategies by taking greater account of local community demands and complex legal frameworks to safeguard their investments.

Register free of charge for uninterrupted access.

Publicite

Recently published in

Mainstream Renewable Power sold its entire Colombian portfolio to Celsia, marking its exit from the country to focus operations on three strategic markets.
Ocean Winds has completed the installation of 32 Biohut modules on a floater of its EFGL pilot project, marking a global first for floating offshore wind incorporating artificial habitats for biodiversity.
Ocean Winds has completed the installation of 32 Biohut modules on a floater of its EFGL pilot project, marking a global first for floating offshore wind incorporating artificial habitats for biodiversity.
A recently published study shows that over 50 Connecticut companies are actively participating in offshore wind projects, with growth potential for 450 other companies in the region.
A recently published study shows that over 50 Connecticut companies are actively participating in offshore wind projects, with growth potential for 450 other companies in the region.
US authorities have ordered the halt of Equinor's Empire Wind 1 offshore wind project located off New York, citing insufficient environmental analysis according to the Biden administration. Construction had been underway since 2024.
US authorities have ordered the halt of Equinor's Empire Wind 1 offshore wind project located off New York, citing insufficient environmental analysis according to the Biden administration. Construction had been underway since 2024.
Belgian group DEME has signed an agreement to acquire Norway’s Havfram for €900 mn, consolidating its fleet and global presence in the offshore wind market.
Developer Energiequelle has secured five projects totalling 143 MW through a national onshore wind tender, expanding its footprint across four German federal states.
Developer Energiequelle has secured five projects totalling 143 MW through a national onshore wind tender, expanding its footprint across four German federal states.
The United States recorded its lowest volume of wind installations in a decade in 2024, according to Wood Mackenzie data, due to tax timing effects and persistent regulatory uncertainty.
The United States recorded its lowest volume of wind installations in a decade in 2024, according to Wood Mackenzie data, due to tax timing effects and persistent regulatory uncertainty.
Three European energy sector players are partnering to develop an offshore wind farm near Saaremaa, reinforcing Estonia’s strategic position in the Baltic region.
Three European energy sector players are partnering to develop an offshore wind farm near Saaremaa, reinforcing Estonia’s strategic position in the Baltic region.
RWE has signed a 20-year electricity supply agreement with Sanofi, committing to deliver 21 GWh annually from a wind farm located in the Marne region.
RWE led the latest onshore wind tender launched by the Commission de régulation de l’énergie, securing seven projects representing a prorated capacity of 151 megawatts.
RWE led the latest onshore wind tender launched by the Commission de régulation de l’énergie, securing seven projects representing a prorated capacity of 151 megawatts.
The Montpellier court has ordered a one-year suspension of the Bernagues wind farm, finding Énergie Renouvelable du Languedoc responsible for the death of a golden eagle, a protected species, in January 2023.
The Montpellier court has ordered a one-year suspension of the Bernagues wind farm, finding Énergie Renouvelable du Languedoc responsible for the death of a golden eagle, a protected species, in January 2023.
ScottishPower Renewables awards HSM Offshore Energy the design and construction of the offshore substation and its foundation for the East Anglia TWO wind farm off the Suffolk coast.
ScottishPower Renewables awards HSM Offshore Energy the design and construction of the offshore substation and its foundation for the East Anglia TWO wind farm off the Suffolk coast.
Ocean Winds is leading the installation of 61 offshore wind turbines off the Vendée coast, with up to 600 workers mobilised in Saint-Nazaire and commercial commissioning targeted by the end of November.
Chantiers de l’Atlantique invests €100 mn to expand its production capacity in offshore wind, a strategic segment now central to its industrial recovery.
Chantiers de l’Atlantique invests €100 mn to expand its production capacity in offshore wind, a strategic segment now central to its industrial recovery.
The Aumelas wind farm, operated by EDF Renouvelables, must halt operations for four months following a court ruling tied to the protection of endangered species in Hérault.
The Aumelas wind farm, operated by EDF Renouvelables, must halt operations for four months following a court ruling tied to the protection of endangered species in Hérault.
PNE Group has obtained the necessary permits to develop two onshore wind farms in Hesse and a ground-mounted solar power plant in Brandenburg, totalling 184.8 MW of capacity.
PNE Group has obtained the necessary permits to develop two onshore wind farms in Hesse and a ground-mounted solar power plant in Brandenburg, totalling 184.8 MW of capacity.
The La Lande wind farm, developed by VSB France for Blue EnerFreeze, has begun operations in Ille-et-Vilaine with a capacity of 12 MW, intended to cover 6% of STEF Group's annual electricity consumption in France.
A 63-turbine project developed by EDF Renouvelables and Renner Energies was cancelled on appeal in Nancy due to visual saturation, despite over 20 years of development.
A 63-turbine project developed by EDF Renouvelables and Renner Energies was cancelled on appeal in Nancy due to visual saturation, despite over 20 years of development.
Aker Horizons and Mitsui have finalised a structured financing agreement with DNB to support Mainstream Renewable Power’s targeted strategy in South Africa, Australia and the Philippines.
Aker Horizons and Mitsui have finalised a structured financing agreement with DNB to support Mainstream Renewable Power’s targeted strategy in South Africa, Australia and the Philippines.
Octopus Energy has acquired a 10% stake in the East Anglia One offshore wind farm, expanding its European portfolio and surpassing $2 billion in offshore wind investments.
Octopus Energy has acquired a 10% stake in the East Anglia One offshore wind farm, expanding its European portfolio and surpassing $2 billion in offshore wind investments.
French company Eolink plans to launch a 5 MW floating wind turbine in Brest, targeting a 2027 grid connection as part of the sector’s industrial progression.
EDF Renewables is centralising condition monitoring of over 5GW of wind turbines through ONYX Insight’s fleetMONITOR platform, reinforcing its global predictive maintenance strategy.
EDF Renewables is centralising condition monitoring of over 5GW of wind turbines through ONYX Insight’s fleetMONITOR platform, reinforcing its global predictive maintenance strategy.
Boralex has launched operations at the 106 MW Limekiln Wind Farm in Scotland, marking its first operational facility in the United Kingdom, supported by a 15-year public contract and a power purchase agreement.
Boralex has launched operations at the 106 MW Limekiln Wind Farm in Scotland, marking its first operational facility in the United Kingdom, supported by a 15-year public contract and a power purchase agreement.
Nexif Ratch Energy has received preliminary environmental approval from the Philippine government to initiate technical studies for its 500 MW San Miguel Bay offshore wind project.
Nexif Ratch Energy has received preliminary environmental approval from the Philippine government to initiate technical studies for its 500 MW San Miguel Bay offshore wind project.

Advertising