SUBSCRIBE
PROFILE

The “knot in the stomach” and the ethical fears of IRSN’s nuclear watchdogs

The abolition of the Institute for Radiation Protection and Nuclear Safety (IRSN) announced by the French government worries researchers and employees of the organization. Cécile Cunin and Jean Desquines, two experts in nuclear research, explain why this independent body is essential to guarantee the credibility of scientific opinions in a sensitive sector.

Share:

Subscribe for unlimited access to all energy sector news.

Over 150 multisector articles and analyses every week.

Your 1st year at 99 $*

then 199 $/year

SUBSCRIBE — 99 $ for the 1st year

Create a free account to read this article

*renews at 199$/year, cancel anytime before renewal.

On February 8, 2023, the French government announced its intention to abolish the Institute for Radiation Protection and Nuclear Safety (IRSN), an independent organization that provides scientific advice in the nuclear field. This announcement has raised the concern of many researchers, including Cécile Cunin and Jean Desquines, who express their fears about the loss of transparency in a sensitive sector.

Independent body to ensure credibility

Cécile Cunin, radiochemist, has been working for 20 years in nuclear research. She explains that the IRSN was created to restore confidence after the Chernobyl disaster. Thanks to this independent organization, the public has a guarantee that experts are impartially monitoring nuclear power plants to protect their safety. The IRSN was also recognized worldwide during the Fukushima disaster in Japan.

Jean Desquines, a researcher on the behavior of nuclear fuel in accident situations, explains that their research is fragile because it is very specific. He fears that if the IRSN is dissolved and integrated into another group, their research will no longer be guided by safety imperatives, but rather by the operator’s considerations. He believes that the existence of the IRSN guarantees the credibility of scientific opinions.

A brutal decision that worries employees

Beyond the ethical and safety issues, the researchers also mention the anguish of the 1,725 IRSN employees after the government’s announcement. They don’t know what their professional future will be and feel like they are being moved around like pawns. They have loans, children and do not know where they will be tomorrow.

A questioning of transparency in the nuclear field

The abolition of the IRSN raises fears about the loss of transparency in a sensitive sector. At present, IRSN’s work can be published with some restrictions, but this does not affect transparency. However, much of the research of the French Atomic Energy Commission (CEA) is not published, at the request of the sponsors of the studies, generally EDF or Framatome.

 

  • Popular on energynews.pro
Commonwealth Fusion Systems raises $863mn for its ARC fusion power plant
Mondi invests €120mn in biomass power plant in Slovakia to cut energy reliance
Avangrid invests $122 million in Meyer substation to strengthen interconnection
Bangladesh finalises memorandum with Aramco for LNG supply deals
NNPC Ltd keeps Port Harcourt refinery and focuses on rehabilitation
Paris and Berlin agree on an energy roadmap including nuclear power
France and Germany have validated a joint energy roadmap, including a commitment to the non-discrimination of nuclear energy in European financing.
Putin and Pezeshkian to discuss Iranian nuclear program under European pressure
Russia and Iran seek to strengthen their nuclear cooperation as the E3 activates the sanctions mechanism against Tehran, reigniting tensions over compliance with the 2015 Vienna agreement.
Natura Resources secures federal and Texas backing for molten salt reactor
US-based Natura Resources has secured strategic funding and key permits for its MSR-1 nuclear reactor, backed by public funds and enriched fuel allocation from the Department of Energy.
Seoul and Washington open talks on nuclear fuel reprocessing
The United States and South Korea have agreed to initiate discussions on reprocessing spent nuclear fuel, marking a potential strategic shift in the long-standing bilateral agreement.
AP1000 reactor certification extended in the US until 2046
The United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission has granted a 40-year extension for the AP1000 reactor design certification, supporting its long-term construction domestically and deployment abroad.
Nano Nuclear partners with Dioxitek to strengthen Argentina’s nuclear supply chain
Nano Nuclear Energy has signed a memorandum of understanding with Dioxitek, Argentina’s only uranium supplier for nuclear fuel, to assess the development of local conversion and enrichment capacities.
Sweden lifts uranium mining ban to revive nuclear industry
Stockholm plans to restart uranium extraction by lifting the 2018 ban, aiming to secure strategic supply chains and support domestic nuclear electricity production.
CEA considers deploying a small Calogena nuclear reactor in Cadarache
The French Atomic Energy Commission has signed a letter of intent with start-up Calogena to study the installation of a 30 MW thermal small nuclear reactor at its Cadarache site.
Guidehouse forecasts $8.1 billion revenues for modular reactors by 2034
A Guidehouse Research report anticipates strong growth in the global nuclear modular reactor market, with revenues rising from $375.8 million in 2025 to $8.1 billion in 2034.
Several South Korean groups back $50bn nuclear projects in the United States
KHNP, Doosan, POSCO and Samsung C&T join US partners to develop 5 GW of modular reactors, expand uranium enrichment and build an 11 GW energy complex in Texas.
Washington activates Defense Production Act to secure enriched uranium
The US Department of Energy is creating an industrial consortium to accelerate domestic enriched uranium production and reduce reliance on foreign imports ahead of the Russian supply ban in 2027.
One of the drones from last weekend’s Ukrainian attack struck the Kursk nuclear power plant
The kamikaze drone damaged an auxiliary transformer at the Kursk plant, halving the output of its only reactor in operation, according to Rosatom and the International Atomic Energy Agency.
EDF restarts Gravelines reactors after shutdown caused by jellyfish
The four production units at the Gravelines nuclear power plant, shut down in mid-August by a massive jellyfish incursion, are back online, restoring the site’s full capacity.
enCore Energy completes $115M convertible notes offering
enCore Energy Corp. has completed a $115 million fundraising through convertible notes maturing in 2030, strengthening its financial capacity for upcoming operations.
Vattenfall selects GE Vernova and Rolls-Royce for future nuclear reactors
Vattenfall advances its nuclear project in Sweden by selecting two modular reactor suppliers, GE Vernova and Rolls-Royce SMR, for a potential installation on the Värö Peninsula.
NANO Nuclear Advances to Final Round of US Army’s xTechSearch 9 Competition
NANO Nuclear Energy has been selected to compete in the final round of xTechSearch 9, a US Army initiative aimed at identifying high-potential dual-use technology solutions.
Aalo Atomics raises USD 100 million to launch its first nuclear power plant
Aalo Atomics completes Series B funding, bringing its total to USD 136 million, to build its first modular nuclear power plant dedicated to data centers.
Malaysia Launches Strategic Study on Civil Nuclear Potential
The Malaysian government initiates a national assessment on nuclear energy feasibility, targeting regions facing energy supply constraints and integrating international regulatory requirements.
Premier American Uranium finalizes the acquisition of Nuclear Fuels with Court approval
The merger between Premier American Uranium and Nuclear Fuels reaches a key milestone following final approval of the arrangement plan by the Supreme Court of British Columbia.
Google and Kairos Power to Build a 50 MW Nuclear Reactor in Tennessee
TVA, Google, and Kairos Power formalize an agreement to connect an advanced reactor to the grid, supporting data center energy growth and reinforcing the U.S. nuclear industry.

Log in to read this article

You'll also have access to a selection of our best content.

or

Go unlimited with our annual offer: $99 for the 1styear year, then $ 199/year.

SUBSCRIBE - €99