Shell’s new climate strategy sparks controversy

Shell revises its climate strategy, reducing the carbon intensity target while maintaining global neutrality. A decision that has drawn widespread criticism from environmental organizations.
Shell objectifs climatiques critiques

Partagez:

Shell recently modified its carbon intensity reduction targets, opting for a 15-20% reduction by 2030 compared to 2016, against an initial more ambitious target. This decision prompted a wave of criticism from environmental organizations. The latter see the readjustment as a step backwards in the face of climate emergencies, pointing to a potential discrepancy between the company’s public declarations and its concrete actions. In addition, the company had already come under fire following the announcement in 2022 of record remuneration for Shell’s ex-CEO, Ben van Beurden.

Analysis of Ecologist Reactions

Reactions from environmental groups, including Follow This, point to a perceived downgrading of Shell’s climate ambitions. Critics argue that, despite a significant reduction in methane emissions and announced investments in low-carbon energies, the adjustment of carbon intensity targets signals a weakening of the company’s environmental commitment.

Technical implications of adjustments

At the heart of the criticism, the adjustment of Shell’s carbon intensity targets can be analyzed through the prism of the technical and operational challenges of the energy transition. Critics argue that, although Shell emphasizes a quality rather than volume strategy in its electricity sales, this change could slow the shift to cleaner energy sources. What’s more, the emphasis on LNG as a transitional alternative is viewed with skepticism by environmental organizations, which favor direct investment in renewable energies.

Shell meets sustainability expectations

An analysis of environmental criticism reveals a growing tension between societal expectations of sustainability and the strategies of major energy companies. Shell’s ability to navigate this complex landscape is crucial, not only for its own energy transition but also for its reputation and alignment with global climate goals. In this sense, environmental organizations play a watchdog role with regard to companies’ commitments and actions on the environmental scene.

Shell’s revision of its carbon intensity targets, and the reaction it has provoked among environmentalists, underlines the importance of a transparent and ambitious approach in the fight against climate change. These criticisms call for a constant reassessment of corporate environmental strategies, with a view to a coherent and effective energy transition.

Baker Hughes has reached an agreement to sell its precision sensor product line to Crane Company for $1.15bn, thereby refocusing its operations on core competencies in industrial and energy technologies.
Baker Hughes has reached an agreement to sell its precision sensor product line to Crane Company for $1.15bn, thereby refocusing its operations on core competencies in industrial and energy technologies.
American conglomerate American Electric Power sold 19.9% of two transmission subsidiaries to KKR and PSP Investments, raising $2.82bn to support its five-year $54bn investment plan.
American conglomerate American Electric Power sold 19.9% of two transmission subsidiaries to KKR and PSP Investments, raising $2.82bn to support its five-year $54bn investment plan.
The new mapping by Startup Nation Central identifies 165 active companies in Israel’s energy technologies, amid strong private funding and growing global market interest.
The new mapping by Startup Nation Central identifies 165 active companies in Israel’s energy technologies, amid strong private funding and growing global market interest.
CMS Energy Corporation has announced a cash tender offer for debt securities totalling $125 million, issued by Consumers Energy. The offer expires on July 3, 2025, with priority given to bonds submitted before June 17, 2025.
CMS Energy Corporation has announced a cash tender offer for debt securities totalling $125 million, issued by Consumers Energy. The offer expires on July 3, 2025, with priority given to bonds submitted before June 17, 2025.
Vermilion Energy is exiting the U.S. market permanently by selling its assets for C$120mn ($87.88mn), refocusing its operations on Canada and Europe while reducing its debt and investment budget.
Vermilion Energy is exiting the U.S. market permanently by selling its assets for C$120mn ($87.88mn), refocusing its operations on Canada and Europe while reducing its debt and investment budget.
In 2024, Italian energy giant Eni paid approximately €8.4 billion to various global governments. These payments, primarily concentrated in Africa and Asia, reflect its commitments in the international energy sector.
In 2024, Italian energy giant Eni paid approximately €8.4 billion to various global governments. These payments, primarily concentrated in Africa and Asia, reflect its commitments in the international energy sector.
The International Energy Agency projects a record-high global energy investment in 2025, driven by electricity and low-carbon technologies despite geopolitical and economic uncertainty.
The International Energy Agency projects a record-high global energy investment in 2025, driven by electricity and low-carbon technologies despite geopolitical and economic uncertainty.
The Czech regulatory authority launches an investigation into suspected collusion involving several major actors in the awarding of a thermal power plant, putting transparency of a strategic transaction for the energy sector at stake.
The Czech regulatory authority launches an investigation into suspected collusion involving several major actors in the awarding of a thermal power plant, putting transparency of a strategic transaction for the energy sector at stake.
The Democratic Republic of Congo is set to replace its temporary ban on cobalt hydroxide exports with quotas, aiming to balance global demand, secure revenue, and stabilize market fluctuations.
The Democratic Republic of Congo is set to replace its temporary ban on cobalt hydroxide exports with quotas, aiming to balance global demand, secure revenue, and stabilize market fluctuations.
European Energy secured EUR 145mn in financing from SEB and Swedbank to support wind, solar, and storage assets in Lithuania, reinforcing its regional expansion strategy.
European Energy secured EUR 145mn in financing from SEB and Swedbank to support wind, solar, and storage assets in Lithuania, reinforcing its regional expansion strategy.
Greenvolt Group finalised the sale of 28 solar and wind projects to Transiziona, valued at €195mn, bringing total asset sales to €530mn in 2025 as part of its pan-European strategy.
Greenvolt Group finalised the sale of 28 solar and wind projects to Transiziona, valued at €195mn, bringing total asset sales to €530mn in 2025 as part of its pan-European strategy.
Royal Vopak’s Indian joint venture rose nearly 3% on its first trading day in Mumbai, reaching an implied valuation of €2.7bn ($2.93bn).
Royal Vopak’s Indian joint venture rose nearly 3% on its first trading day in Mumbai, reaching an implied valuation of €2.7bn ($2.93bn).
US investment fund Davidson Kempner has reached an agreement to acquire Swire Energy Services, a provider of offshore equipment, strengthening its position in the global energy market.
US investment fund Davidson Kempner has reached an agreement to acquire Swire Energy Services, a provider of offshore equipment, strengthening its position in the global energy market.
Saudi-based ACWA Power has signed strategic agreements in Malaysia to develop up to 12.5 GW of energy capacity by 2040, with a potential investment of $10 billion.
Saudi-based ACWA Power has signed strategic agreements in Malaysia to develop up to 12.5 GW of energy capacity by 2040, with a potential investment of $10 billion.
Fusion Fuel Green has signed a preliminary agreement to acquire a private UK-based fuel distribution company generating $58mn in revenue, through a £50mn debt-equity structured transaction.
Fusion Fuel Green has signed a preliminary agreement to acquire a private UK-based fuel distribution company generating $58mn in revenue, through a £50mn debt-equity structured transaction.
ExxonMobil plans to sell its 82.89% stake in Esso S.A.F. to North Atlantic France, valuing shares based on €1.49bn cash holdings and a price subject to several adjustments.
ExxonMobil plans to sell its 82.89% stake in Esso S.A.F. to North Atlantic France, valuing shares based on €1.49bn cash holdings and a price subject to several adjustments.
Patrick Pouyanné reassures shareholders by confirming TotalEnergies' strategic direction, combining hydrocarbons and low-carbon electricity, despite an unstable economic environment and climate activist protests in Paris.
Patrick Pouyanné reassures shareholders by confirming TotalEnergies' strategic direction, combining hydrocarbons and low-carbon electricity, despite an unstable economic environment and climate activist protests in Paris.
UK-based SSE recorded an adjusted operating profit of £2.42bn for fiscal year 2024/25, supported by record investments in networks and renewable energy.
UK-based SSE recorded an adjusted operating profit of £2.42bn for fiscal year 2024/25, supported by record investments in networks and renewable energy.
Iberdrola has signed an agreement to acquire the distribution, supply and energy generation activities of Electra del Maestrazgo, a family-owned company operating in Castellón and Teruel, for an undisclosed amount.
Iberdrola has signed an agreement to acquire the distribution, supply and energy generation activities of Electra del Maestrazgo, a family-owned company operating in Castellón and Teruel, for an undisclosed amount.
John Bryson, a key figure in the American energy sector, has died at the age of 81. The former CEO of Edison International played a decisive role during California’s electricity crisis.
John Bryson, a key figure in the American energy sector, has died at the age of 81. The former CEO of Edison International played a decisive role during California’s electricity crisis.