Shell’s new climate strategy sparks controversy

Shell revises its climate strategy, reducing the carbon intensity target while maintaining global neutrality. A decision that has drawn widespread criticism from environmental organizations.

Share:

Shell objectifs climatiques critiques

Subscribe for unlimited access to all the latest energy sector news.

Over 150 multisector articles and analyses every week.

For less than €3/week*

*For an annual commitment

*Engagement annuel à seulement 99 € (au lieu de 149 €), offre valable jusqu'au 30/07/2025 minuit.

Shell recently modified its carbon intensity reduction targets, opting for a 15-20% reduction by 2030 compared to 2016, against an initial more ambitious target. This decision prompted a wave of criticism from environmental organizations. The latter see the readjustment as a step backwards in the face of climate emergencies, pointing…

Shell recently modified its carbon intensity reduction targets, opting for a 15-20% reduction by 2030 compared to 2016, against an initial more ambitious target. This decision prompted a wave of criticism from environmental organizations. The latter see the readjustment as a step backwards in the face of climate emergencies, pointing to a potential discrepancy between the company’s public declarations and its concrete actions. In addition, the company had already come under fire following the announcement in 2022 of record remuneration for Shell’s ex-CEO, Ben van Beurden.

Analysis of Ecologist Reactions

Reactions from environmental groups, including Follow This, point to a perceived downgrading of Shell’s climate ambitions. Critics argue that, despite a significant reduction in methane emissions and announced investments in low-carbon energies, the adjustment of carbon intensity targets signals a weakening of the company’s environmental commitment.

Technical implications of adjustments

At the heart of the criticism, the adjustment of Shell’s carbon intensity targets can be analyzed through the prism of the technical and operational challenges of the energy transition. Critics argue that, although Shell emphasizes a quality rather than volume strategy in its electricity sales, this change could slow the shift to cleaner energy sources. What’s more, the emphasis on LNG as a transitional alternative is viewed with skepticism by environmental organizations, which favor direct investment in renewable energies.

Shell meets sustainability expectations

An analysis of environmental criticism reveals a growing tension between societal expectations of sustainability and the strategies of major energy companies. Shell’s ability to navigate this complex landscape is crucial, not only for its own energy transition but also for its reputation and alignment with global climate goals. In this sense, environmental organizations play a watchdog role with regard to companies’ commitments and actions on the environmental scene.

Shell’s revision of its carbon intensity targets, and the reaction it has provoked among environmentalists, underlines the importance of a transparent and ambitious approach in the fight against climate change. These criticisms call for a constant reassessment of corporate environmental strategies, with a view to a coherent and effective energy transition.

Energiekontor launches a €15 million corporate bond at 5.5% over eight years, intended to finance wind and solar projects in Germany, the United Kingdom, France, and Portugal.
The 2025 EY study on 40 groups shows capex driven by mega-deals, oil reserves at 34.7 billion bbl, gas at 182 Tcf, and pre-tax profits declining amid moderate prices.
Australian fuel distributor Ampol reports a 23% drop in net profit, impacted by weak refining margins and operational disruptions, while surpassing market forecasts.
Puerto Rico customers experienced an average of 73 hours of power outages in 2024, a figure strongly influenced by hurricanes, according to the U.S. Energy Information Administration.
CITGO returns to profitability in Q2 2025, supported by maximum utilization of its refining assets and adjusted capital expenditure management.
MARA strengthens its presence in digital infrastructure by acquiring a majority stake in Exaion, a French provider of secure high-performance cloud services backed by EDF Pulse Ventures.
ACEN strengthens its international strategy with over 2,100 MWdc of attributable renewable capacity in India, marking a major step in its expansion beyond the Philippines.
German group RWE maintains its annual targets after achieving half its earnings-per-share forecast, despite declining revenues in offshore wind and trading.
A Dragos report reveals the scale of cyber vulnerabilities in global energy infrastructures. Potential losses reach historic highs.
The US liquefied natural gas producer is extending its filing deadlines with the regulator, citing ongoing talks over additional credit support.
Australian company NRN has closed a $67.2m funding round, combining equity and debt, to develop its distributed energy infrastructure platform and expand its decentralised storage and generation network.
The American manufacturer is seeking a licence from the UK energy regulator to distribute electricity in the United Kingdom, marking its first move into this sector outside Texas.
The US oil and gas producer increased production and cash flow, driven by the Maverick integration and a $2 billion strategic partnership with Carlyle.
Boralex saw its earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization fall by 13% in the second quarter of 2025, despite a 14% increase in production, due to less favourable prices in France and lower revenues from joint ventures.
The Canadian supplier of chemical solutions for the oil industry generated CAD574 mn ($419.9 mn) in revenue in the second quarter, up 4% year-on-year, and announced a quarterly dividend.
EnBW posted adjusted EBITDA of €2.4 billion in the first half of 2025, supported by its diversified operations, and confirmed its annual targets despite unfavourable weather conditions.
Joule, Caterpillar and Wheeler have signed a partnership to provide four gigawatts of energy to a next-generation data centre campus in Utah, integrating battery storage and advanced cooling solutions.
GFL Environmental announces the recapitalization of Green Infrastructure Partners at an enterprise value of $4.25bn, involving new institutional investors and a major redistribution of capital to its shareholders.
Uniper reaffirms its targets for the year, narrows its forecast range, and strengthens its transformation strategy while launching cost-cutting measures in a demanding market environment.
BrightNight’s Asian subsidiary becomes Yanara and positions itself as an independent player to strengthen the development of large-scale renewable energy solutions in the Asia-Pacific region.

We are making technical adjustments to our item access system.
Temporary display or access problems may occur.
Thank you for your understanding.

Consent Preferences