popular articles

Schneider Electric, Rexel, Sonepar and Legrand fined 470 million euros for anticompetitive collusion

The French Competition Authority has imposed fines totaling 470 million euros on Schneider Electric, Rexel, Sonepar, and Legrand for collusion in the low-voltage electrical equipment sector. These sanctions represent a strong response against market manipulation.

Please share:

The four companies in the electrical equipment and distribution sector—Schneider Electric, Rexel, Sonepar, and Legrand—have been ordered to pay a total of 470 million euros in fines. This decision by the Competition Authority addresses collusion practices between manufacturers and distributors in the low-voltage electrical equipment sector, covering the period from 2012 to 2018. The penalties were imposed for practices aimed at maintaining the retail prices of their products at artificially high levels.

The Competition Authority explained in its statement that these behaviors constitute a serious violation of competition law in France. This type of collusion, characterized as “vertical” between manufacturers and distributors, is often considered one of the most severe violations in the sector. The fines imposed exceed the total penalties levied by the same organization in 2022 and 2023, highlighting the regulator’s view of the gravity of these practices.

Individual sanctions and disputes

Among the sanctioned companies, Schneider Electric received the largest fine, amounting to 207 million euros. The company has stated that it firmly contests the Competition Authority’s conclusion, indicating its intent to appeal. Rexel and Sonepar, fined 124 and 96 million euros respectively, have also expressed their disagreement, with Rexel mentioning that it may appeal the decision.

Legrand, on the other hand, was fined 43 million euros and is also considering legal actions to contest this sanction. The companies involved defend their actions, claiming they benefit their customers, though the Competition Authority finds these justifications insufficient to explain the imposed pricing practices observed in the market.

Derogation practices and price setting

According to the Authority’s report, the practices in question include a “derogation” system that allowed manufacturers like Schneider Electric and Legrand to compensate distributors for discounts granted to final customers. This system allegedly enabled them to maintain control over final prices by limiting competition among distributors. In a normal market situation, distributors would be expected to freely set their retail prices based on market conditions.

However, within this system, manufacturers directly influenced prices, preventing genuine competition among brands. The Competition Authority stressed that this situation was particularly concerning due to the concentration of the low-voltage electrical equipment sector, both among manufacturers and distributors, which exacerbates the negative impacts of such practices on consumers and the economy in general.

Market implications and recurrence

Rexel’s case is particularly notable, as the company actively participated in reforming the derogation system. However, the Competition Authority took this involvement into account, applying a 20% reduction to Rexel’s fine due to its partial cooperation with regulators.

This case echoes a 2007 precedent, where the European Union imposed a 750 million euro fine on eleven electrical equipment manufacturers, including Schneider, for similar cartel practices. The recurrence of sanctions against the same players highlights the persistent regulatory challenges in the electrical equipment sector and raises questions about the effectiveness of sanctions in preventing the repetition of such practices.

Register free of charge for uninterrupted access.

Publicite

Recently published in

Mark Noyes, a seasoned expert in renewable energy, joins TerraForm Power as CEO to steer the company’s growth strategy in the face of industry challenges and opportunities.
Wood Mackenzie anticipates a protectionist shift under Trump’s presidency, marked by a retreat from net-zero ambitions. However, renewables and the IRA will continue shaping the U.S. energy future.
Wood Mackenzie anticipates a protectionist shift under Trump’s presidency, marked by a retreat from net-zero ambitions. However, renewables and the IRA will continue shaping the U.S. energy future.
The Italian group Enel plans to invest €43 billion by 2027, focusing on networks and renewable energies, while increasing dividends for its shareholders.
The Italian group Enel plans to invest €43 billion by 2027, focusing on networks and renewable energies, while increasing dividends for its shareholders.
Hundreds of complaints highlight major failures at Primagaz due to a change in its IT system. The Energy Ombudsman demands immediate action to protect affected consumers.
Hundreds of complaints highlight major failures at Primagaz due to a change in its IT system. The Energy Ombudsman demands immediate action to protect affected consumers.
Despite a 3% drop in production for the third quarter of 2024, Boralex is pushing forward with new strategic renewable energy projects and strengthening its operational resilience.
The new CEO of Schneider Electric, Olivier Blum, moves to Dubai to oversee growth in India and the Middle East, strategic regions for the company's energy and digital transition efforts.
The new CEO of Schneider Electric, Olivier Blum, moves to Dubai to oversee growth in India and the Middle East, strategic regions for the company's energy and digital transition efforts.
At COP29, TotalEnergies CEO Patrick Pouyanné defended the oil industry's commitment to reducing methane emissions, emphasizing the importance of gradual progress in addressing the climate crisis.
At COP29, TotalEnergies CEO Patrick Pouyanné defended the oil industry's commitment to reducing methane emissions, emphasizing the importance of gradual progress in addressing the climate crisis.
The French industrial giant Vallourec reported a slight drop in net income to €73 million in Q3 2024. This stability is attributed to its premiumization strategy and strong margins despite challenging market conditions.
The French industrial giant Vallourec reported a slight drop in net income to €73 million in Q3 2024. This stability is attributed to its premiumization strategy and strong margins despite challenging market conditions.
Nexans aims for increased financial performance by 2028, supported by significant investments in global electrification and a strategy focused on energy transition and recycling.
Masdar and KESH sign a strategic partnership to develop large-scale renewable energy projects, positioning Albania as a key player in the European energy market.
Masdar and KESH sign a strategic partnership to develop large-scale renewable energy projects, positioning Albania as a key player in the European energy market.
Polish energy giant Orlen partners with the European Investment Bank to modernize its energy distribution network, aiming to integrate renewable solutions and strengthen operational efficiency.
Polish energy giant Orlen partners with the European Investment Bank to modernize its energy distribution network, aiming to integrate renewable solutions and strengthen operational efficiency.
The Energy Infrastructure Partners (EIP) fund strengthens its investment in Plenitude, Eni's renewable energy subsidiary, valued at over 10 billion euros, to support its strategic growth.
The Energy Infrastructure Partners (EIP) fund strengthens its investment in Plenitude, Eni's renewable energy subsidiary, valued at over 10 billion euros, to support its strategic growth.
In the third quarter, Halliburton reports a 20% drop in net profit, mainly impacted by a cyberattack and slowing demand in North America, its key market.
Energias de Portugal (EDP) posts a 37% drop in profits for the third quarter of 2024. The Portuguese group nevertheless continues its investments in renewable energies to support its energy transition.
Energias de Portugal (EDP) posts a 37% drop in profits for the third quarter of 2024. The Portuguese group nevertheless continues its investments in renewable energies to support its energy transition.
The Italian energy giant Enel announces a 38% increase in net profit over nine months, reaching 5.9 billion euros, despite a context of falling electricity prices.
The Italian energy giant Enel announces a 38% increase in net profit over nine months, reaching 5.9 billion euros, despite a context of falling electricity prices.
Cable manufacturer Nexans announces the creation of Lynxeo, a distinct entity for its industrial cable business, aiming for greater clarity and market visibility.
Cable manufacturer Nexans announces the creation of Lynxeo, a distinct entity for its industrial cable business, aiming for greater clarity and market visibility.
The Global Battery Alliance reveals the results of a collaborative project involving the world’s largest battery manufacturers to harmonize transparency and sustainability in the battery supply chain.
Engie targets the top of its 2024 forecasts after strong quarterly performance
Engie targets the top of its 2024 forecasts after strong quarterly performance
Akastor ASA acquires Mitsui's shares in AKOFS Offshore for USD 22.5 million, increasing its stake to 75% and consolidating its position in the subsea intervention sector.
Akastor ASA acquires Mitsui's shares in AKOFS Offshore for USD 22.5 million, increasing its stake to 75% and consolidating its position in the subsea intervention sector.
Struggling in 2022, German energy company Uniper initiates a 530 million euro repayment to the German state. This payment represents a significant step toward reducing public influence within the company.
Struggling in 2022, German energy company Uniper initiates a 530 million euro repayment to the German state. This payment represents a significant step toward reducing public influence within the company.
ADNOC, the national oil company of the United Arab Emirates, deploys autonomous artificial intelligence to optimize operations, reduce costs, and enhance energy efficiency.
TotalEnergies projects a peak in global oil demand after 2030, influenced by population growth and infrastructure shortfalls, contrasting with BP's earlier forecast.
TotalEnergies projects a peak in global oil demand after 2030, influenced by population growth and infrastructure shortfalls, contrasting with BP's earlier forecast.
Dangote denounces the import of low-quality fuel undermining the growth of his refinery in Nigeria. The lack of control infrastructure hampers the enforcement of the country’s new fuel standards.
Dangote denounces the import of low-quality fuel undermining the growth of his refinery in Nigeria. The lack of control infrastructure hampers the enforcement of the country’s new fuel standards.
Schneider Electric announced the sudden departure of its CEO Peter Herweck, who had been in office since May 2023, due to disagreements over the company’s strategy. Olivier Blum takes over immediately.
Schneider Electric announced the sudden departure of its CEO Peter Herweck, who had been in office since May 2023, due to disagreements over the company’s strategy. Olivier Blum takes over immediately.

Advertising