popular articles

Nagorno-Karabakh: a Primarily Energetic Conflict?

Nagorno-Karabakh is once again in the grip of war. This disputed region is the scene of violent clashes between Armenia and Azerbaijan.
nagorno-karabakh conflict

Please share:

Nagorno-Karabakh is once again in the grip of war. This disputed region is the scene of violent clashes between Armenia and Azerbaijan. According to official figures, more than 800 people lost their lives on the Armenian side, mainly soldiers. On the Azerbaijani side, the government has so far refused to publish any casualty figures.

Nagorno-Karaback: the region of discord

Historically, this conflict dates back to Stalin’s decision in the early 1920s to include Armenian minorities in Azerbaijani territory. The consequence of this choice was to fuel national hatreds once the Soviet Union had disappeared. In 1994, the Armenian minority in Nagorno-Karabakh expelled the Baku authorities with the support of Yerevan. Since then, the two countries have regularly engaged in armed clashes without finding a definitive solution to the conflict.

The war that began on September 27 nevertheless marked an important turning point in the history of the conflict. Russia, the traditional mediator, is currently unable to impose a lasting ceasefire. The same applies to the Minsk Group, made up of Russia, the United States and France. This turnaround can be explained by the new role Turkey is playing in the region.

Supported by Baku, this is the first time the latter has become directly involved in the conflict. Ankara supplies its ally with military equipment and provides fighting units from Syria. This direct commitment is largely explained by energy considerations.

This is a major change, as in previous conflicts, energy was only considered as a consequence of the conflict. Armed clashes could threaten energy supplies in the region. Today, however, energy rivalries are no longer a consequence, but in fact the main cause of conflict. Indeed, we cannot understand Turkey’s involvement and Russia’s weakening without mentioning the changing energy balance of power.

Nagorno-Karabakh

Energy at the heart of developments in the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict

The changing nature of the conflict in Nagorno-Karabakh is justified by a major shift in the region’s energy balance. In recent years, Azerbaijan has established itself as a key player in gas supplies to Turkey. The start-up of the Shah Deniz II gas project in 2018 has doubled Azerbaijan’s exports. Since last year, the country has supplied more than 9 billion cubic meters (bcm) of gas to Turkey.

This year, Baku even became Ankara’s leading gas supplier, ahead of Moscow. This development is all the more important as it is accompanied by a weakening of Russia’s position on the transit issue. The inauguration of the TANAP trans-Anatolian pipeline in 2017 has enabled Azerbaijan to bypass Russia as a transit country. The same applies to the country’s oil exports.

By passing through Georgia, this pipeline gives the Ankara-Baku axis greater room for maneuver vis-à-vis Moscow. In this context, Turkish military support for Azerbaijan is easy to understand. Sometimes passing just a few kilometers from the Armenian border, TANAP is vulnerable to attacks from Yerevan. Ankara is therefore turning the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict into a real energy security issue for the country.

Energy at the heart of rivalries between Moscow and Ankara

In addition to security of supply, the Turkish intervention can also be interpreted in terms of Russian-Turkish relations. The Nagorno-Karabakh conflict comes just a few months before the renegotiation of gas contracts with Gazprom. For Ankara, this is a key factor in lowering the price of gas for Turkish consumers. In December 2021, more than 8 bcm will be renegotiated with the Russian company.

However, the contracts signed with Gazprom were signed in the 80s and 90s under radically different conditions than today. Being long-term and indexed to the price of oil, these contracts no longer correspond to market prices. It is now estimated that Turkey pays 20% more for gas from Russia than Europe. Under these conditions, Ankara would like to renegotiate contracts with Russia that are more in line with spot market prices.

Turkey has therefore embarked on a policy of diversifying its supplies, notably towards Azerbaijan and LNG. Gazprom has seen its market share plummet from 50% in 2017 to 30% today. In fact, relations with Baku have become a key element in Ankara’s game with Moscow. Any weakening of Azerbaijan would therefore mean a weakening of Turkey’s position at the negotiating table.

This support is all the more important as Turkey remains dependent on gas imports, at least in the short term. The giant deposit discovered in the Black Sea will not be operational until 2023 at the earliest. As a result, Azerbaijan will remain a key ally until the field comes on stream. Nevertheless, this discovery in the Black Sea considerably strengthens Ankara’s position in the forthcoming negotiations with Moscow.

turkstream

Behind the conflict, the ambition of a Turkish gas hub

One of the key issues in the renegotiation of Russian-Turkish gas contracts will be to put an end to destination clauses. These clauses prohibit the buyer from reselling unused gas on other markets. This ban is particularly problematic for Ankara, which aims to become a veritable gas hub in the region.

To achieve this goal, Turkey can count on a number of assets. Firstly, it is a secure transit country for Russian gas to Europe. Inaugurated at the end of 2019, TurkStream can supply the continent with up to 31.5 bcm of gas each year. For the moment, this pipeline is only connected to Europe via Bulgaria, but an extension to Greece is planned.

This would give TurkStream the capacity to supply the countries of Southern and Eastern Europe. This route is all the more important for Moscow as its North Stream 2 project now appears compromised. Moreover, transit through Ukraine and Poland is made difficult by geopolitical tensions. Turkey therefore represents an essential supply route for Moscow, giving Ankara considerable influence in the future.

Turkey is also involved in the TAP project, the trans-Adriatic gas pipeline linking Azerbaijan to Italy. In fact, it’s a new gas pipeline scheduled to be operational next month, linked to the Trans-Anatolian Pipeline (TANAP). Ankara’s aim here is to connect the European market with the producer countries of Central Asia, primarily Turkmenistan. With Nagorno-Karabakh just around the corner, Turkey cannot afford to abandon its Azerbaijani ally.

Moreover, the ambition to be a hub explains Ankara’s head-on opposition to the East Med project linking Israel to Greece. The aim of the project is to supply gas from the Mediterranean, and possibly later from the Middle East, bypassing Turkey. Libya, whose territorial waters straddle the pipeline, is a key country for Ankara. As in Nagorno-Karabakh, Turkish intervention in Libya is largely explained by energy issues.

The ambition to be a gas hub between Asia and Europe therefore largely determines Turkish policy in its regional environment. Located close to TANAP, Nagorno-Karabakh has thus become a major issue for the country. As a result, energy is no longer just a consequence, but the main cause of the current conflict.

Register free of charge for uninterrupted access.

Publicite

Recently published in

European Commissioner Dan Jørgensen is in Baku to reaffirm energy cooperation with Azerbaijan, focusing on the expansion of the gas corridor and regional green energy projects.
German Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock ruled out any possibility of reactivating the Nord Stream 2 pipeline, shut down since 2022, despite discussions mentioned by Russia and growing pressure on energy supply.
German Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock ruled out any possibility of reactivating the Nord Stream 2 pipeline, shut down since 2022, despite discussions mentioned by Russia and growing pressure on energy supply.
The United States has sanctioned a Chinese refinery processing Iranian crude, increasing pressure on Tehran and raising concerns over global oil market stability.
The United States has sanctioned a Chinese refinery processing Iranian crude, increasing pressure on Tehran and raising concerns over global oil market stability.
The United States has cancelled oil operation authorisations in Venezuela for foreign companies, disrupting exports and reinforcing the country's economic isolation following Nicolás Maduro's contested re-election.
The United States has cancelled oil operation authorisations in Venezuela for foreign companies, disrupting exports and reinforcing the country's economic isolation following Nicolás Maduro's contested re-election.
The Algerian energy group Sonelgaz is offering its technical expertise to Burkina Faso to strengthen its electrical infrastructure, illustrating Algeria's strategic intention to consolidate its presence in sub-Saharan Africa’s energy markets.
Washington again delays the enforcement of sanctions against NIS, the Serbian energy company controlled by Gazprom, extending the status quo until the end of April according to Serbian President Aleksandar Vucic.
Washington again delays the enforcement of sanctions against NIS, the Serbian energy company controlled by Gazprom, extending the status quo until the end of April according to Serbian President Aleksandar Vucic.
The United States has strengthened its support for Guyana amid Venezuela’s claims over the Essequibo, warning Caracas of a military response in case of aggression targeting the territory or American oil interests.
The United States has strengthened its support for Guyana amid Venezuela’s claims over the Essequibo, warning Caracas of a military response in case of aggression targeting the territory or American oil interests.
No attacks on energy installations have been reported since a partial agreement announced by the United States, marking a pause in hostilities targeting critical infrastructure.
No attacks on energy installations have been reported since a partial agreement announced by the United States, marking a pause in hostilities targeting critical infrastructure.
During a visit to Guyana, U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio announced that any Venezuelan attack on the territory or oil infrastructure of Guyana would trigger a military response, heightening regional tensions.
US Secretary of State Marco Rubio launches meetings with Caribbean leaders to discuss energy security, trade pressures and regional instability, including in Haiti and Guyana.
US Secretary of State Marco Rubio launches meetings with Caribbean leaders to discuss energy security, trade pressures and regional instability, including in Haiti and Guyana.
Hungary’s Foreign Minister travelled to Moscow for talks with Russian authorities on energy security, reinforcing a strategic energy partnership already bolstered by record gas and oil deliveries in 2024.
Hungary’s Foreign Minister travelled to Moscow for talks with Russian authorities on energy security, reinforcing a strategic energy partnership already bolstered by record gas and oil deliveries in 2024.
Donald Trump imposes 25% tariffs against importers of Venezuelan oil, particularly targeting China, which has already condemned an infringement on its economic sovereignty, signaling increased tensions in global energy markets.
Donald Trump imposes 25% tariffs against importers of Venezuelan oil, particularly targeting China, which has already condemned an infringement on its economic sovereignty, signaling increased tensions in global energy markets.
The planned visit of senior US officials to Greenland sparks political backlash in Nuuk, as no new government has been formed since the 11 March elections.
Starting 2 April, the United States will apply a 25% customs duty on all goods from countries trading with Venezuela’s oil or gas sector, Donald Trump announced.
Starting 2 April, the United States will apply a 25% customs duty on all goods from countries trading with Venezuela’s oil or gas sector, Donald Trump announced.
Washington imposes sanctions on Luqing Petrochemical, the first independent Chinese refinery targeted for its alleged ties to Iranian oil, as part of its intensified economic pressure campaign against Tehran.
Washington imposes sanctions on Luqing Petrochemical, the first independent Chinese refinery targeted for its alleged ties to Iranian oil, as part of its intensified economic pressure campaign against Tehran.
A Panama-flagged vessel suspected of belonging to the Russian shadow fleet was detained by German customs after suffering an engine failure in the Baltic Sea in January.
A Panama-flagged vessel suspected of belonging to the Russian shadow fleet was detained by German customs after suffering an engine failure in the Baltic Sea in January.
Amidst war and geopolitical uncertainty, Ukraine must choose between European influence and the strategic promises of the United States, a choice that could redefine its economic and security future, particularly in terms of natural resources.
As Russian gas deliveries via Nord Stream have ceased, Europe is exploring possible solutions to repurpose or replace this major infrastructure within a complex energy transition and diversification of supply sources.
As Russian gas deliveries via Nord Stream have ceased, Europe is exploring possible solutions to repurpose or replace this major infrastructure within a complex energy transition and diversification of supply sources.
Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin are set to discuss the sharing of rare earth resources in Ukraine on Tuesday, including energy production plants and territories rich in raw materials. These resources are at the heart of the ceasefire negotiations.
Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin are set to discuss the sharing of rare earth resources in Ukraine on Tuesday, including energy production plants and territories rich in raw materials. These resources are at the heart of the ceasefire negotiations.
UK Energy Minister Ed Miliband met Chinese officials in Beijing to discuss energy cooperation and reducing greenhouse gas emissions, despite disagreements over Hong Kong, forced labour, and the war in Ukraine.
UK Energy Minister Ed Miliband met Chinese officials in Beijing to discuss energy cooperation and reducing greenhouse gas emissions, despite disagreements over Hong Kong, forced labour, and the war in Ukraine.
American and Vietnamese companies have signed several commercial agreements totaling $4.15 billion, primarily in the energy and aviation sectors, aiming to reduce the trade imbalance between the two countries.
Presidents Vladimir Putin and Nicolás Maduro announced an agreement to expand their cooperation, particularly in the energy sector. This initiative comes amid increased U.S. sanctions against Caracas.
Presidents Vladimir Putin and Nicolás Maduro announced an agreement to expand their cooperation, particularly in the energy sector. This initiative comes amid increased U.S. sanctions against Caracas.
A tripartite meeting between China, Russia and Iran will be held in Beijing to address the Iranian nuclear dossier as tensions surrounding Iran's nuclear programme continue to rise.
A tripartite meeting between China, Russia and Iran will be held in Beijing to address the Iranian nuclear dossier as tensions surrounding Iran's nuclear programme continue to rise.
Guyana’s President, Mohamed Irfaan Ali, reaffirmed his commitment to a diplomatic resolution of the territorial dispute with Venezuela over the Essequibo region as tensions escalate over offshore oil resources.
Guyana’s President, Mohamed Irfaan Ali, reaffirmed his commitment to a diplomatic resolution of the territorial dispute with Venezuela over the Essequibo region as tensions escalate over offshore oil resources.

Advertising