Lure photovoltaic power plant: French government and Boralex condemned on appeal

The French state and Boralex have been condemned for failing to find alternative sites less harmful to biodiversity for their photovoltaic plant on the Lure mountain.
Condamnation photovoltaïque Lure

Partagez:

The Marseille Administrative Court of Appeal recently condemned the French state and the Canadian company Boralex, responsible for operating a photovoltaic power plant on the Lure mountain in the Alpes-de-Haute-Provence region. This decision comes after several environmental associations, initially rejected by the court of first instance, appealed against the 2020 prefectoral decree. This order granted Boralex an exemption for the destruction and intentional disturbance of specimens and habitats of protected species. The judges found that “no alternative solution for siting the project beyond the municipal territory had been sought”, despite the fact that the area identified by the municipality had not been artificially developed. They also pointed out that the existence of several photovoltaic park projects in the immediate vicinity suggested that alternatives existed.

Environmental impact and project progress

The construction site for the photovoltaic power plant, almost complete and already impacted by environmental activists, covers an area of 17 hectares near Cruis, at the gateway to the Luberon Regional Nature Park. The plant, equipped with 20,000 solar panels, is designed to produce 26 GWh of green energy per year, equivalent to the annual electricity consumption of around 12,000 inhabitants. However, the project required the felling of hundreds of trees in a protected area, classified as a biosphere reserve by UNESCO in 2010. The cancellation of the derogation by the administrative court does not, however, call into question Boralex’s right to operate the power station or the finishing work in progress. In response, Boralex stated that “the cancellation of the protected species exemption does not call into question our presence on the site or the finishing work on the power plant”. However, Boralex’s lawyer, Antoine Guiheux, has indicated that the company, which is also active in the wind power sector in France, is considering appealing to the French Supreme Court.

Futurist Reactions and Perspectives

For environmental associations, this court ruling represents a major victory against the State and industrial interests. Pierre Lavoie, a member of Amilure’s board of directors, declared that alternatives were possible on already degraded land, thus avoiding sacrificing remarkable biodiversity. For his part, Pierrot Pantel, an environmental engineer and coordinator of environmental struggles, asserted that the ruling is suspensive, preventing Boralex from continuing to operate the plant for the time being. Looking ahead to a possible favorable decision by the Conseil d’Etat, Pierrot Pantel suggested that the associations could ask for the site to be restored, although this process could take some time.
This case highlights the growing importance of environmental considerations in the planning of energy projects. Industry professionals need to take these concerns on board to avoid similar conflicts and promote a sustainable energy transition that respects biodiversity.

T1 Energy commits $850 million to build a five-gigawatt photovoltaic facility in Texas, selecting Yates Construction and benefiting from local tax incentives, with 1,800 jobs anticipated by the end of 2026.
The German solar developer has completed the 90-megawatt-peak Postomino photovoltaic park in north-western Poland, integrating it with an existing wind farm’s high-voltage line in a cable-pooling arrangement set to supply electricity to about 32,000 homes.
EDF Renouvelables plans a floating solar plant in Isère by 2027, featuring 70,000 panels integrated with an existing hydroelectric dam, targeting an annual production of 60 GWh.
Scatec ASA finalises financing for its hybrid solar-battery Obelisk project in Egypt, securing $479.1 million from international financial institutions for a planned capacity of 1.1 GW solar and 100 MW storage.
The 800 MW Horizeo photovoltaic project spanning 680 hectares in Gironde awaits governmental authorization linked to France’s Zero Net Artificialization (ZAN) objective to advance permits submitted in early 2024.
Global photovoltaic tracker shipments rose 20% in 2024, driven by India and Saudi Arabia, pushing the United States to a less dominant market position.
Chinese manufacturer Astronergy will supply its ASTRO N8 photovoltaic modules for a solar project developed in Spain by engineering firm GES Siemsa, marking a strategic advance in the European market.
SMEG and the City of Mâcon have started construction of a 6 MWc solar power plant on a former landfill site, with commissioning scheduled for early 2026.
Producer Corsica Sole is inaugurating a 5.4 MWc photovoltaic plant in Cirey-sur-Vezouze on a former industrial site, with 8,700 panels and an estimated annual output of 6.1 GWh.
The Kashgar region has connected over 10 GW of solar projects to the grid, representing more than three-quarters of its total power capacity, initiating the development of a new power system in southern Xinjiang.
U.S.-based Soltage raises $260mn to support the construction of 250 MW in solar and storage projects within a development pipeline exceeding 2 GW.
Origis Energy has closed financing for the Wheatland project in Indiana as part of a $530mn portfolio, in partnership with MUFG and several financial institutions.
Germany’s solar capture price fell to a five-year low in May, driven by rising negative price hours and excess photovoltaic capacity.
Albioma Solaire Guyane has commissioned five photovoltaic plants totalling 1.4 MWc, spread across Mana and Macouria, to strengthen local electricity supply in a region isolated from the national grid.
South African group NOA and Standard Bank have finalised the financing of the 349 MW Khauta South solar site, now the largest developed on a single site in South Africa.
Enfinity Global signed new power purchase agreements for a 420 MW solar portfolio with a US technology company operating in Italy, reinforcing its position in the Italian energy market.
The American solar sector saw strong industrial growth in Q1, but tax and trade uncertainties could hinder its momentum and affect local investments.
Global solar leaders doubled shipments in one year, but combined losses of $4 billion highlight intense margin pressure in the sector.
Growth in the U.S. solar sector is expected to slow by 2030 due to political shifts in Washington directly impacting tax incentives and imposing tariffs on essential materials, creating sectoral uncertainty.
The $176 million agreement between Pine Gate Renewables and Waaree Solar Americas strengthens the US solar supply chain with locally manufactured modules.