popular articles

Le Bras de Fer Greenpeace-TotalEnergies: Climate Impact Debate

Against a backdrop of growing tensions, Greenpeace is challenging TotalEnergies in court, contesting the accusation that it disseminated false information about the multinational's carbon footprint.
Greenpeace vs TotalEnergies: Conflit Climatique

Please share:

In a climate of growing mistrust between environmental organizations and industrial giants, the situation between Greenpeace France and TotalEnergies takes a notable judicial turn. Indeed, this legal confrontation highlights the growing difficulties in finding common ground between ecological imperatives and economic interests.

The Controversial Greenpeace Report

At the end of 2022, Greenpeace published a revealing report, claiming that TotalEnergies’ greenhouse gas emissions were four times higher than the company officially declared. However, this report raises a crucial question: the reliability of methods used to calculate companies’ carbon footprints. TotalEnergies, reacting quickly, criticized the report’s methodology, calling it dubious and pointing out numerous errors and approximations.

TotalEnergies: Reaction and Lawsuits

TotalEnergies’ response was swift. In April, the multinational filed a civil suit against Greenpeace and Factor-X, the firm that produced the report, for disseminating false information. However, the company is demanding that the report be withdrawn from their sites, that its distribution be halted, that a symbolic one euro be paid in damages, and that 50,000 euros be paid in legal costs. This approach illustrates a strategy aimed at protecting its reputation and economic interests.

Greenpeace Defense: Freedom of Expression and Transparency

Greenpeace is not sitting on the sidelines. Clara Gonzales, a lawyer with the NGO, denounces TotalEnergies’ attempt to restrict freedom of expression. Indeed, the environmental organization emphasizes its role in raising awareness of corporate responsibility in the climate crisis. Greenpeace stresses the importance of companies being transparent about their greenhouse gas emissions, pointing the finger at TotalEnergies’ carbon neutrality strategy, which it considers insufficient.

Legal Issues and Intimidation Strategies

Greenpeace’s argument goes further, criticizing TotalEnergies’ choice to use stock market law for its lawsuit rather than a criminal defamation action. Greenpeace interprets this maneuver as an attempt to circumvent press freedom laws, which provide guarantees for the use of freedom of expression. In addition, the NGO highlights a worrying trend: the increase in attempts at judicial intimidation against civil society, not only in France but also internationally, with similar cases in the UK and Italy.

The debate raised by this case goes beyond the borders of these two entities. It highlights the need for reliable, transparent carbon accounting, which is essential if we are to define a climate strategy appropriate to the current emergency. Moreover, TotalEnergies’ lawsuit against Greenpeace is not just a legal dispute, but also a symbol of the challenges encountered in the quest for greater corporate environmental responsibility.

This face-off between Greenpeace and TotalEnergies underlines the complexity and urgency of the climate issue. It highlights the crucial role of transparency and accountability in the fight against climate change, and opens up an essential debate on the reliability and methodology of corporate carbon accounting.

Register free of charge for uninterrupted access.

Publicite

Recently published in

Global temperatures in 2023 and 2024 shattered records, leaving climatologists grappling with urgent questions about the causes of such unprecedented overheating.
Kazakhstan announced the decontamination of over 360,000 m³ of oil waste inherited from the Soviet era, marking a major effort to reduce pollution on the Caspian Sea coast, which has suffered from decades of environmental degradation.
Kazakhstan announced the decontamination of over 360,000 m³ of oil waste inherited from the Soviet era, marking a major effort to reduce pollution on the Caspian Sea coast, which has suffered from decades of environmental degradation.
The year 2024 marks a climate turning point: the threshold of 1.5°C global warming is surpassed, fueling natural disasters and increasing pressure for more ambitious climate commitments.
The year 2024 marks a climate turning point: the threshold of 1.5°C global warming is surpassed, fueling natural disasters and increasing pressure for more ambitious climate commitments.
With a 1.5°C increase over the historical average, China experiences its hottest autumn since 1961. This phenomenon illustrates the growing impacts of climate change on the country and raises global concerns.
With a 1.5°C increase over the historical average, China experiences its hottest autumn since 1961. This phenomenon illustrates the growing impacts of climate change on the country and raises global concerns.
At COP29 in Baku, NGOs criticized the G20 for lacking leadership on energy transition. Despite progress on climate finance, the absence of commitments on fossil fuels provoked sharp disappointment.
A Carbon Tracker report warns about the shortcomings in oil and gas companies' commitments to curb methane leaks, despite their critical climate impact.
A Carbon Tracker report warns about the shortcomings in oil and gas companies' commitments to curb methane leaks, despite their critical climate impact.
Despite the rise of renewable energy, CO2 emissions from fossil fuels continue to grow, reaching 37.4 billion metric tons in 2024. The long-awaited peak remains uncertain, raising critical questions at COP29.
Despite the rise of renewable energy, CO2 emissions from fossil fuels continue to grow, reaching 37.4 billion metric tons in 2024. The long-awaited peak remains uncertain, raising critical questions at COP29.
At COP29, the European Union unveiled an international initiative aimed at limiting methane emissions linked to fossil fuels. This strategic effort relies on global cooperation and strengthened regulations.
At COP29, the European Union unveiled an international initiative aimed at limiting methane emissions linked to fossil fuels. This strategic effort relies on global cooperation and strengthened regulations.
CO2 emissions from fossil fuels will reach a record 37.4 billion tons in 2024, according to the Global Carbon Budget report. Despite progress in energy transition, fossil fuel demand persists.
Facing the threat of surpassing the 1.5 °C warming threshold, COP29 calls for an ambitious energy transformation. IRENA emphasizes the need to triple renewable energy capacities by 2030 to keep the energy transition on track.
Facing the threat of surpassing the 1.5 °C warming threshold, COP29 calls for an ambitious energy transformation. IRENA emphasizes the need to triple renewable energy capacities by 2030 to keep the energy transition on track.
As COP29 approaches, several indicators suggest progress in the fight against climate change. From reducing warming projections to stabilizing fossil emissions and renewable energy growth, the outlook is less bleak.
As COP29 approaches, several indicators suggest progress in the fight against climate change. From reducing warming projections to stabilizing fossil emissions and renewable energy growth, the outlook is less bleak.
The European Union recorded a historic reduction of 8.3% in its greenhouse gas emissions in 2023. This decrease marks progress towards climate goals, yet challenges remain to achieve carbon neutrality.
The European Union recorded a historic reduction of 8.3% in its greenhouse gas emissions in 2023. This decrease marks progress towards climate goals, yet challenges remain to achieve carbon neutrality.
Beyond CO2, methane, nitrous oxide, and fluorinated gases actively contribute to global warming, driving specific measures to limit their emissions. These lesser-known gases are at the core of researchers' and policymakers' concerns.
One year after storm Ciaran, Enedis strengthens the electrical network in Brittany. By burying 1,100 kilometers of lines and modernizing cables, the company aims to reduce outages related to weather disruptions.
One year after storm Ciaran, Enedis strengthens the electrical network in Brittany. By burying 1,100 kilometers of lines and modernizing cables, the company aims to reduce outages related to weather disruptions.
An NGO report warns of environmental risks associated with oil and gas concessions in the "Coral Triangle," one of the world’s richest marine ecosystems, threatened by maritime traffic and oil spills.
An NGO report warns of environmental risks associated with oil and gas concessions in the "Coral Triangle," one of the world’s richest marine ecosystems, threatened by maritime traffic and oil spills.
GenZero warns that limiting global warming to 1.5°C is becoming difficult without massive investments in energy transition technologies in the Asia-Pacific region.
GenZero warns that limiting global warming to 1.5°C is becoming difficult without massive investments in energy transition technologies in the Asia-Pacific region.
French emissions of atmospheric pollutants have significantly decreased between 2000 and 2023. However, France continues to face exceedances of air quality standards and occasional pollution episodes.
For several years, the notion of ecological debt has gained importance alongside public debt. This article explores its meaning, quantification, and the challenges related to its reduction, while examining the implications for future generations.
For several years, the notion of ecological debt has gained importance alongside public debt. This article explores its meaning, quantification, and the challenges related to its reduction, while examining the implications for future generations.
A tanker caught fire off Rostock, in the Baltic Sea, on Friday. Seven sailors were rescued, and the fire is now largely under control, according to German authorities.
A tanker caught fire off Rostock, in the Baltic Sea, on Friday. Seven sailors were rescued, and the fire is now largely under control, according to German authorities.
According to DNV, global energy-related CO2 emissions are peaking this year due to the decreasing costs of renewables. However, increased efforts are necessary to meet the climate targets set by the Paris Agreement.
According to DNV, global energy-related CO2 emissions are peaking this year due to the decreasing costs of renewables. However, increased efforts are necessary to meet the climate targets set by the Paris Agreement.
Duke Energy Foundation is committing $1 million to support recovery efforts in southeastern U.S. states following Hurricane Helene, further reinforcing its previous contributions to disaster preparedness and response initiatives.
Waste management in India remains a major environmental challenge, with only 20% of the 65 million tons generated each year being processed, despite local initiatives involving people with disabilities in recycling programs.
Waste management in India remains a major environmental challenge, with only 20% of the 65 million tons generated each year being processed, despite local initiatives involving people with disabilities in recycling programs.
California is suing ExxonMobil for allegedly misleading the public about the effectiveness of its advanced recycling technologies, accusing the company of contributing to the global plastic pollution crisis.
California is suing ExxonMobil for allegedly misleading the public about the effectiveness of its advanced recycling technologies, accusing the company of contributing to the global plastic pollution crisis.
Global methane emissions, which are rising steadily, require an immediate political and industrial response to stabilize the climate and control the associated economic costs.
Global methane emissions, which are rising steadily, require an immediate political and industrial response to stabilize the climate and control the associated economic costs.

Advertising