India: Overproduction and regulation drive down I-REC prices

International Renewable Energy Certificate (I-REC) prices for wind and solar technologies in India reached an all-time low in 2024, due to a persistent glut and uncertainty surrounding new regulations. This situation highlights the challenges facing renewable energy producers in India, between regulatory changes and insufficient demand that fails to absorb supply.

Share:

Since the new regulations came into force in December 2022, the REC market in India has changed significantly.
The Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (CERC) has abolished floor and ceiling prices, making the market more volatile.
In addition, the introduction of Over-the-Counter (OTC) trading aims to increase trading flexibility, but has not yet succeeded in resolving the fundamental imbalances between supply and demand.
This increased volatility has accentuated the decline in I-REC prices, which have been estimated at between $0.7/MWh and $1.7/MWh in 2023, well below local REC prices which are around ten times higher.

Imbalance between supply and demand

One of the major problems facing the I-RECs market in India is the massive surplus of untraded certificates, which exceeded 11 million by mid-2024.
Although demand for green energy attributes is on the rise, supported by voluntary sustainability targets and increased Renewable Portfolio Holder (RPO) responsibility requirements, inconsistent policies between states and the federal government are creating a gap.
Indeed, state RPO targets are often 30% lower than those set at the federal level, limiting local demand for certificates and contributing to the glut.

Comparison with international markets

I-RECs offer an alternative to local RECs in India, enabling renewable energy producers to sell their green energy attributes on the international market.
However, the significantly lower prices of I-RECs make this market less attractive to Indian producers than the local market, which offers prices around ten times higher.
This leads some producers to turn to the local market despite the competitiveness of I-RECs.
This situation could change if the I-REC market manages to develop further and introduce more sophisticated financial instruments.

Influence of the Carbon Market and Future Development

The planned introduction of a carbon market in India could also restructure the energy certificate landscape.
As carbon credit standards such as the Verified Carbon Standard and the Gold Standard gradually exit the renewable energy carbon credit market in middle-income countries, many Indian producers are turning to I-RECs as an alternative.
This transition could be accelerated by higher carbon credit emission costs and an increased perception of the value of I-RECs in a sustainability context.

Market players’ outlook

Analysts and market participants expect the I-REC market to evolve rapidly, influenced by regulatory adjustments and carbon market developments.
The Indian market could see a significant transformation of its current dynamics if incentives for local RECs and I-RECs mechanisms become more aligned, potentially offering arbitrage opportunities for producers and buyers.
The key will lie in the market’s ability to balance supply and demand while meeting corporate sustainability expectations.
The future of the I-RECs market in India remains uncertain and will depend on a number of factors, including regulatory adjustments, carbon market trends, and the ability to narrow the gap between supply and demand.
In the meantime, renewable energy producers must navigate a complex environment where trading strategy becomes essential to ensure profitability.

Final energy consumption in the European industrial sector dropped by 5% in 2023, reaching a level not seen in three decades, with renewables taking a growing role in certain key segments.
Réseau de transport d’électricité is planning a long-term modernisation of its infrastructure. A national public debate will begin on September 4 to address implementation methods, challenges and conditions.
The Spanish Parliament has rejected a package of reforms aimed at preventing another major power outage, plunging the national energy sector into uncertainty and revealing the fragility of the government's majority.
The U.S. government has supported Argentina’s request for a temporary suspension of an order to hand over its stake in YPF, a 16.1 billion USD judgment aimed at satisfying creditors.
The United States Environmental Protection Agency extends compliance deadlines for coal-fired power plant operators regarding groundwater monitoring and the closure of waste ponds.
Eskom aims to accelerate its energy transition through a new dedicated unit, despite a USD22.03bn debt and tariff uncertainties slowing investment.
Several major U.S. corporations announce investments totaling nearly USD 90 billion to strengthen energy infrastructure in Pennsylvania, aimed at powering data centers vital to the rapid growth of the artificial intelligence sector.
Nearly USD92bn will be invested by major American and international groups in new data centres and energy infrastructure, responding to the surge in electricity demand linked to the rise of artificial intelligence.
Nouakchott has endured lengthy power interruptions for several weeks, highlighting the financial and technical limits of the Mauritanian Electricity Company as Mauritania aims to widen access and green its mix by 2030.
Between 2015 and 2024, four multilateral climate funds committed nearly eight bn USD to clean energy, attracting private capital through concessional terms while Africa and Asia absorbed more than half of the volume.
The Global Energy Policies Hub shows that strategic reserves, gas obligations, cybersecurity and critical-mineral policies are expanding rapidly, lifting oil coverage to 98 % of world imports.
According to a report by Ember, the Chinese government’s appliance trade-in campaign could double residential air-conditioner efficiency gains in 2025 and trim up to USD943mn from household electricity spending this year.
Washington is examining sectoral taxes on polysilicon and drones, two supply chains dominated by China, after triggering Section 232 to measure industrial dependency risks.
The 2025-2034 development plan presented by Terna includes strengthening Sicily’s grid, new interconnections, and major projects to support the region’s growing renewable energy capacity.
Terna and NPC Ukrenergo have concluded a three-year partnership in Rome aimed at strengthening the integration of the Ukrainian grid into the pan-European system, with an in-depth exchange of technological and regulatory expertise.
GE Vernova has secured a major contract to modernise the Kühmoos substation in Germany, enhancing grid reliability and integration capacity for power flows between Germany, France and Switzerland.
The National Energy System Operator forecasts electricity demand to rise to 785 TWh by 2050, underlining the need to modernise grids and integrate more clean energy to support the UK’s energy transition.
Terna has signed a guarantee agreement with SACE and the European Investment Bank to finance the Adriatic Link project, totalling approximately €1bn ($1.08bn) and validated as a major transaction under Italian regulations.
India unveils a series of reforms on oil and gas contracts, introducing a fiscal stability clause to enhance the sector’s attractiveness for foreign companies and boost its growth ambitions in upstream energy.
The European Commission is launching a special fund of EUR2.3bn ($2.5bn) to boost Ukraine’s reconstruction and attract private capital to the energy and infrastructure sectors.