Henri Proglio and EDF Acquitted in the Consultant Contract Case

EDF and its former CEO Henri Proglio have been acquitted in a favoritism case related to consultancy contracts awarded between 2010 and 2016. The court ruled that there was no evidence of a criminal intent, despite the accusations from the Parquet National Financier.

Share:

EDF and its former CEO, Henri Proglio, have been cleared in a favoritism case. The trial focused on 44 consultancy contracts signed between 2010 and 2016, totaling 36 million euros. These contracts, awarded without competitive bidding, included services such as “lobbying,” “strategic consulting,” and “communication.” The Parquet National Financier (PNF) had called for a two-year suspended prison sentence and a 200,000-euro fine for Proglio, along with a one-million-euro fine against the company. However, the Paris Criminal Court acquitted Henri Proglio and EDF, stating that the prosecution failed to demonstrate a “fraudulent intent.”

The judges thus rejected the 2016 findings of the French Court of Auditors, which had asserted that these consultancy contracts had circumvented competitive bidding rules. The September 2010 internal note, drafted by Alain Tchernonog, then Secretary General of EDF, was intended to regulate the recruitment process for consultants. However, according to the court, this directive was not part of a systematic attempt to bypass legal obligations.

A Career Marred by Controversies

Henri Proglio is a key figure in the energy sector. Before joining EDF, he served as CEO of Veolia Environnement from 2003 to 2009. His career is marked by internal conflicts and strategic decisions that often created divisions. Proglio consistently advocated that EDF should have a dominant role in the nuclear sector, a stance that led to tensions with Anne Lauvergeon, then CEO of Areva. This conflict culminated in Lauvergeon’s dismissal in 2011, further consolidating EDF’s influence in the atomic industry.

Proglio was appointed CEO of EDF by Nicolas Sarkozy, but the election of François Hollande in 2012 weakened his position, although he managed to maintain his influence through strong networks. This judicial episode is just one of many in a career that has been repeatedly clouded by suspicions and controversies. In 2015, he was forced to forgo the non-executive chairmanship of Thales after Emmanuel Macron, then Economy Minister, raised concerns about his connections with Rosatom, the Russian nuclear giant.

A Complex Case with Multiple Ramifications

The accusations also targeted eleven consultants, including high-profile figures such as Loïk Le Floch-Prigent, former head of Gaz de France, and Jean-Marie Messier, former CEO of Vivendi. The PNF alleged that they benefited from consultancy contracts awarded without proper tenders, with amounts ranging from 650,000 to 1.4 million euros. The defense argued that the consultants had not knowingly participated in any illegal process.

During the trial, the financial prosecutor criticized these practices as a “logic of the prince,” where recruitment choices were driven more by personal preferences than by objective needs. However, the court ruled that the consultants did not deliberately engage in illicit practices. This verdict ends a months-long trial, although some of the defendants may still face financial penalties for other similar contracts.

Implications for Public Sector Governance

This decision highlights the challenges faced by large public companies in managing consultancy contracts. Although EDF may find relief in this ruling, it underscores the need for improved internal transparency and oversight in contract management. Following the 2016 investigation by the French Court of Auditors, the company has implemented reforms to enhance its procurement processes.

As for Henri Proglio, while this case is closed, he remains under investigation for corruption and misuse of company assets related to his consulting firm, Henri Proglio Consulting, founded in 2015. Investigators are also looking into the origins of 300,000 euros in cash found in a bank safe. This new investigation could further damage Proglio’s reputation, despite his current legal victory in this case.

Brazil, Mexico, Argentina, Colombia, Chile, and Peru significantly increase renewable electricity production, reaching nearly 70% of the regional electricity mix, according to a recent Wood Mackenzie study on Latin America's energy sector.
The Canadian government announces an investment of more than $40mn to fund 13 energy projects led by Indigenous communities across the country, aiming to improve energy efficiency and increase local renewable energy use.
The German Ministry of Economy plans to significantly expand aid aimed at reducing industrial electricity costs, increasing eligible companies from 350 to 2,200, at an estimated cost of €4bn ($4.7bn).
A major electricity blackout paralyzed large parts of the Czech Republic, interrupting transport and essential networks, raising immediate economic concerns, and highlighting the vulnerability of energy infrastructures to unforeseen technical incidents.
French greenhouse gas emissions are expected to rise by 0.2% in the first quarter of 2025, indicating a global slowdown in reductions forecast for the full year, according to Citepa, an independent organisation responsible for national monitoring.
The Republican budget bill passed by the U.S. Senate accelerates the phase-out of tax credits for renewable energies, favoring fossil fuels and raising economic concerns among solar and wind industry professionals.
Rapid growth in solar and wind capacities will lead to a significant rise in electricity curtailment in Brazil, as existing transmission infrastructure remains inadequate to handle this massive influx of energy, according to a recent study by consulting firm Wood Mackenzie.
In April 2025, fossil fuels represented 49.5% of South Korea's electricity mix, dropping below the symbolic threshold of 50% for the first time, primarily due to a historic decline in coal-generated electricity production.
The US Senate Finance Committee modifies the '45Z' tax credit to standardize the tax treatment of renewable fuels, thereby encouraging advanced biofuel production starting October 2025.
According to the 2025 report on global energy access, despite notable progress in renewable energy, insufficient targeted financing continues to hinder electricity and clean cooking access, particularly in sub-Saharan Africa.
While advanced economies maintain global energy leadership, China and the United States have significantly progressed in the security and sustainability of their energy systems, according to the World Economic Forum's annual report.
On the sidelines of the US–Africa summit in Luanda, Algiers and Luanda consolidate their energy collaboration to better exploit their oil, gas, and mining potential, targeting a common strategy in regional and international markets.
The UK's Climate Change Committee is urging the government to quickly reduce electricity costs to facilitate the adoption of heat pumps and electric vehicles, judged too slow to achieve the set climate targets.
The European Commission will extend until the end of 2030 an expanded state-aid framework, allowing capitals to fund low-carbon technologies and nuclear power to preserve competitiveness against China and the United States.
Japan's grid operator forecasts an energy shortfall of up to 89 GW by 2050 due to rising demand from semiconductor manufacturing, electric vehicles, and artificial intelligence technologies.
Energy-intensive European industries will be eligible for temporary state aid to mitigate high electricity prices, according to a new regulatory framework proposed by the European Commission under the "Clean Industrial Deal."
Mauritius seeks international investors to swiftly build a floating power plant of around 100 MW, aiming to secure the national energy supply by January 2026 and address current production shortfalls.
Madrid announces immediate energy storage measures while Lisbon secures its electrical grid, responding to the historic outage that affected the entire Iberian Peninsula in late April.
Indonesia has unveiled its new national energy plan, projecting an increase of 69.5 GW in electricity capacity over ten years, largely funded by independent producers, to address rapidly rising domestic demand.
French Minister Agnès Pannier-Runacher condemns the parliamentary moratorium on new renewable energy installations, warning of the potential loss of 150,000 industrial jobs and increased energy dependence on foreign countries.