French Energy Crisis: Criticism from the Cour des Comptes

The recent energy crisis in France has raised growing concerns about the fairness of government measures. The Cour des Comptes raises questions about the contribution made by electricity producers, highlighting significant financial implications.

Share:

Crise Énergétique Française: Des Réformes Nécessaires

For several years now, the issue ofa fair energy transition has been in the headlines. Indeed, the current energy crisis in France, exacerbated by the Russian invasion of the Ukraine and the bombardment of its energy sites, has further highlighted the flaws in the energy regulation system. In a recent report, the French Court of Auditors called into question the effectiveness and fairness of the contribution imposed on electricity producers. Despite the government’s efforts to support consumers – most notably in 2022, when EDF tried unsuccessfully to introduce a price cap measure – shortcomings persist in the fair return of accumulated margins.

Analysis of the Contribution sur les Rentes des Producteurs d’Électricité (Contribution on the income of electricity producers)

The contribution on infra-marginal rents (CRI) of electricity producers, introduced in the initial finance law for 2023, is at the heart of concerns. The Cour des Comptes considers that this measure does not guarantee an adequate return for consumers, despite the substantial profit margins recorded by energy companies. This contribution, which is supposed to return to consumers the margins accumulated during the crisis-induced price surge, falls short of levels deemed fair.

Impact on consumers

The financial implications of the pension contribution are far-reaching. The projected revenues do not offset the costs borne by consumers, who see their bills rise without benefiting from a fair return of electricity producers’ profit margins. This raises concerns about the government’s ability to protect consumer interests while maintaining the economic viability of the energy sector.

Future prospects

Faced with this criticism, the French government is called upon to review its energy policies to ensure a more optimal distribution of costs and benefits. In-depth reform is needed to ensure the stability of the electricity market and protect the interests of consumers. The Cour des Comptes’ recommendations highlight the need for swift, effective government action to resolve the challenges posed by the current energy crisis.

This raises concerns about the effectiveness and fairness of the contribution on electricity producers’ pensions. It is imperative that the government takes decisive action to guarantee the stability of the electricity market and protect the interests of consumers in the face of growing economic and energy challenges.

French greenhouse gas emissions are expected to rise by 0.2% in the first quarter of 2025, indicating a global slowdown in reductions forecast for the full year, according to Citepa, an independent organisation responsible for national monitoring.
The Republican budget bill passed by the U.S. Senate accelerates the phase-out of tax credits for renewable energies, favoring fossil fuels and raising economic concerns among solar and wind industry professionals.
Rapid growth in solar and wind capacities will lead to a significant rise in electricity curtailment in Brazil, as existing transmission infrastructure remains inadequate to handle this massive influx of energy, according to a recent study by consulting firm Wood Mackenzie.
In April 2025, fossil fuels represented 49.5% of South Korea's electricity mix, dropping below the symbolic threshold of 50% for the first time, primarily due to a historic decline in coal-generated electricity production.
The US Senate Finance Committee modifies the '45Z' tax credit to standardize the tax treatment of renewable fuels, thereby encouraging advanced biofuel production starting October 2025.
According to the 2025 report on global energy access, despite notable progress in renewable energy, insufficient targeted financing continues to hinder electricity and clean cooking access, particularly in sub-Saharan Africa.
While advanced economies maintain global energy leadership, China and the United States have significantly progressed in the security and sustainability of their energy systems, according to the World Economic Forum's annual report.
On the sidelines of the US–Africa summit in Luanda, Algiers and Luanda consolidate their energy collaboration to better exploit their oil, gas, and mining potential, targeting a common strategy in regional and international markets.
The UK's Climate Change Committee is urging the government to quickly reduce electricity costs to facilitate the adoption of heat pumps and electric vehicles, judged too slow to achieve the set climate targets.
The European Commission will extend until the end of 2030 an expanded state-aid framework, allowing capitals to fund low-carbon technologies and nuclear power to preserve competitiveness against China and the United States.
Japan's grid operator forecasts an energy shortfall of up to 89 GW by 2050 due to rising demand from semiconductor manufacturing, electric vehicles, and artificial intelligence technologies.
Energy-intensive European industries will be eligible for temporary state aid to mitigate high electricity prices, according to a new regulatory framework proposed by the European Commission under the "Clean Industrial Deal."
Mauritius seeks international investors to swiftly build a floating power plant of around 100 MW, aiming to secure the national energy supply by January 2026 and address current production shortfalls.
Madrid announces immediate energy storage measures while Lisbon secures its electrical grid, responding to the historic outage that affected the entire Iberian Peninsula in late April.
Indonesia has unveiled its new national energy plan, projecting an increase of 69.5 GW in electricity capacity over ten years, largely funded by independent producers, to address rapidly rising domestic demand.
French Minister Agnès Pannier-Runacher condemns the parliamentary moratorium on new renewable energy installations, warning of the potential loss of 150,000 industrial jobs and increased energy dependence on foreign countries.
The European battery regulation, fully effective from August 18, significantly alters industrial requirements related to electric cars and bicycles, imposing strict rules on recycling, supply chains, and transparency for companies.
The European Parliament calls on the Commission to strengthen energy infrastructure and accelerate the implementation of the Clean Industrial Deal to enhance the continent's energy flexibility and security amid increased market volatility.
The European Commission unveils an ambitious plan to modernize electricity grids and introduces the Clean Industrial Deal, mobilizing hundreds of billions of euros to strengthen the continent's industrial and energy autonomy.
In the United States, regulated electric grid operators hold a decisive advantage in connecting new data centres to the grid, now representing 134 GW of projects, according to a Wood Mackenzie report published on June 19.