popular articles

France: Justice will rule on May 2 on the renationalization of EDF

The small shareholders of EDF are contesting the share buyback price in the context of the renationalization of the group. Despite their legal action, the French state now holds more than 95% of the capital. The final decision will be made on May 2.

Please share:

The courts will render their decision on May 2 in the battle between small EDF shareholders and the French state to slow down the renationalization of the group, in particular because the share buyback price is considered too low.

The government wanted to complete everything by the end of 2022, but for months, the small employee and retired shareholders of EDF have multiplied the appeals to slow down the operation. At the hearing before the Paris Court of Appeal on Thursday, the public prosecutor’s office requested that the appeal be rejected. The final decision will be made on May 2.

The complete takeover of EDF, announced last July and valued at 9.7 billion euros, is strategic for the State shareholder, which already held 84% of its national flagship before the takeover. Its goal is to free EDF from the stock market to allow it to more easily relaunch nuclear power in France.

At the heart of the debate, the price of 12 euros per share at which the State has decided to buy back from shareholders the shares it lacks to fully control the electric company. A price considered too low: the plaintiffs claim at least 15 euros.

This price of 12 euros has been validated by the report of an independent expert, but the small shareholders believe that the company is undervalued and that it has been unfairly penalized in its revenues by a mechanism imposed by the State (Arenh) forcing it to sell its nuclear electricity at low prices to alternative suppliers. And EDF had to juggle with its corrosion problems in the reactors that caused its production to drop in 2022 and deepened its losses.

The plaintiffs are therefore challenging the compliance decision rendered by the Autorité des marchés financiers (AMF) in November, which had given the green light to the State to launch this takeover. However, the AMF assured that its decision was perfectly in line with the regulations.

Florent Segalen, the lawyer for the employee and retired shareholders of EDF, stressed that the decision to renationalize was taken in the worst year for EDF since its creation in 1946. He also claimed that the independent expert who judged this price fair was based on incorrect assumptions. Moreover, according to the small employee and retired EDF shareholders, the former CEO of EDF, Jean-Bernard Levy, should have abstained from voting at the board meeting that approved the State’s offer, because of a possible conflict of interest.

The minority shareholders are represented by Martine Faure, President of the EDF employee shareholding fund, as well as by the association Energie en actions and ADAM, an association for the defense of minority shareholders. They argued that the AMF’s decision was contrary to the principles of transparency and fairness of the market. The lawyer for the employee and retired shareholders, Florent Segalen, also stressed that the decision to renationalize was taken in a difficult year for EDF, which had its worst year since its creation in 1946.

The AMF, for its part, stated that its decision was perfectly in line with the regulations, and that the AMF Board had held three meetings to support its decision. Patricia Choquet, representative of the AMF, also stated that the protesting shareholders are not asking for better information, but rather a better price, describing their approach as “greedy”. Florian Bouaziz, EDF’s lawyer, also described their challenge as “greedy”.

Despite this challenge, a number of shareholders accepted the price proposed by the State, and the State therefore held 95.82% of the capital and 96.53% of the voting rights of EDF as of February 8. The threshold of compulsory withdrawal, which makes it possible to renationalize EDF by forcing the 4% of remaining shareholders to sell their shares, was also largely exceeded, which testifies according to the public prosecutor’s office to a “broad approval” of the price proposed by the State.

Register free of charge for uninterrupted access.

Publicite

Recently published in

Enel doubled its net profit to €7 billion in 2024, despite the decline in electricity and gas prices. The company also reduced its net debt through asset disposals and implemented a strategy focused on profitability.
US data centre capacity surpassed 92 GW by the end of 2024, with a significant rise in investments and larger projects, driven by the increasing demand for artificial intelligence (AI).
US data centre capacity surpassed 92 GW by the end of 2024, with a significant rise in investments and larger projects, driven by the increasing demand for artificial intelligence (AI).
Viridien S.A. has completed a $925 million senior secured bond issuance to refinance its second-lien debt and strengthen its liquidity profile. Rating agencies have upgraded their assessments following this transaction.
Viridien S.A. has completed a $925 million senior secured bond issuance to refinance its second-lien debt and strengthen its liquidity profile. Rating agencies have upgraded their assessments following this transaction.
JSW Energy has completed the acquisition of KSK Mahanadi Power Company Limited for $1.93 billion, adding 1,800 MW to its operational capacity and bringing its total capacity beyond 10 GW.
JSW Energy has completed the acquisition of KSK Mahanadi Power Company Limited for $1.93 billion, adding 1,800 MW to its operational capacity and bringing its total capacity beyond 10 GW.
Velto Renewables, backed by Caisse de dépôt et placement du Québec (CDPQ), and Q ENERGY have signed an agreement to acquire renewable energy projects in Europe. An initial portfolio of 130 MW has been acquired in France, with an additional 400 MW planned in Spain and Portugal.
In 2024, Getlink reported a 5% drop in net profit, reaching €317 million. This decline is attributed to the temporary suspension of its ElecLink cross-Channel cable and the growing competition from ferries.
In 2024, Getlink reported a 5% drop in net profit, reaching €317 million. This decline is attributed to the temporary suspension of its ElecLink cross-Channel cable and the growing competition from ferries.
Baker Hughes and Woodside Energy have signed an agreement to develop a low-carbon energy production solution using the NET Power platform, targeting the energy and industrial sectors at small scale.
Baker Hughes and Woodside Energy have signed an agreement to develop a low-carbon energy production solution using the NET Power platform, targeting the energy and industrial sectors at small scale.
Vaalco Energy, Inc. has announced the signing of a new $300 million revolving credit facility with The Standard Bank of South Africa Limited, aimed at supporting its growth projects and investments across its African assets.
Vaalco Energy, Inc. has announced the signing of a new $300 million revolving credit facility with The Standard Bank of South Africa Limited, aimed at supporting its growth projects and investments across its African assets.
State-owned companies, such as Saudi Aramco, are responsible for more CO2 emissions than private firms like Shell or ExxonMobil, according to a study by the British think tank InfluenceMap.
Consolidated Edison announces the sale of 6.3 million common shares via Barclays, with proceeds intended to support its capital needs and other business purposes.
Consolidated Edison announces the sale of 6.3 million common shares via Barclays, with proceeds intended to support its capital needs and other business purposes.
Eco Wave Power shows notable financial progress for 2024, with reduced operating expenses and a strengthened cash position. The company continues its international expansion with key projects in Israel, the United States, Portugal, and Asia.
Eco Wave Power shows notable financial progress for 2024, with reduced operating expenses and a strengthened cash position. The company continues its international expansion with key projects in Israel, the United States, Portugal, and Asia.
Industrial group ABB announces a $120 million investment in two new US factories aimed at boosting production capacity to meet the strong demand from data centres.
Industrial group ABB announces a $120 million investment in two new US factories aimed at boosting production capacity to meet the strong demand from data centres.
Spanish banking group La Caixa takes a 5% stake in Veolia, becoming a strategic investor in the French environmental services giant. The collaboration aims to support Veolia's development plan.
Eni and PETRONAS partner to create a joint venture in the energy sector, combining their assets in Indonesia and Malaysia to form a strategic player with reserves estimated at 3 billion barrels of oil equivalent.
Eni and PETRONAS partner to create a joint venture in the energy sector, combining their assets in Indonesia and Malaysia to form a strategic player with reserves estimated at 3 billion barrels of oil equivalent.
Boralex reported financial results for 2024 marked by lower production due to adverse weather conditions but maintains a strong financial position thanks to record financing and the progression of its renewable energy projects.
Boralex reported financial results for 2024 marked by lower production due to adverse weather conditions but maintains a strong financial position thanks to record financing and the progression of its renewable energy projects.
Kineticor Asset Management and Pembina Pipeline Corporation announce a partnership to develop a major project in Alberta, combining an electricity generation plant and a data centre complex. The project aims to meet the growing demand of the local data centre industry.
Kineticor Asset Management and Pembina Pipeline Corporation announce a partnership to develop a major project in Alberta, combining an electricity generation plant and a data centre complex. The project aims to meet the growing demand of the local data centre industry.
Portuguese group Energias de Portugal (EDP) announces a 16% decrease in its 2024 annual profit, affected by disappointing performance in its renewable energy subsidiary, particularly due to the abandonment of wind projects.
Despite a drop in its profits in 2024, Eni confirms its strategy of energy transition and shareholder remuneration. The company plans significant investments in renewable energy and biofuel production.
Despite a drop in its profits in 2024, Eni confirms its strategy of energy transition and shareholder remuneration. The company plans significant investments in renewable energy and biofuel production.
Mainstream Renewable Power has announced the appointment of Morten Henriksen as CEO, effective from April 1, 2025, as part of its strategy to focus on cost reduction and expansion into three key markets.
Mainstream Renewable Power has announced the appointment of Morten Henriksen as CEO, effective from April 1, 2025, as part of its strategy to focus on cost reduction and expansion into three key markets.
Engie aims to accelerate its growth through 2030 by investing in renewable energy, batteries, and electrical grids, with a target of 95 GW of installed capacity by 2030.
Engie aims to accelerate its growth through 2030 by investing in renewable energy, batteries, and electrical grids, with a target of 95 GW of installed capacity by 2030.
In 2024, Technip Energies posted a significant increase in net profit, supported by liquefied natural gas (LNG) markets and decarbonised electricity production. The French group anticipates strong prospects for 2025.
French pipe manufacturer Vallourec reported a 9% decline in net profit for 2024 but plans to pay a dividend of €1.50 per share, its first in ten years.
French pipe manufacturer Vallourec reported a 9% decline in net profit for 2024 but plans to pay a dividend of €1.50 per share, its first in ten years.
Iberdrola achieved a record net profit of €5.61 billion in 2024, a 17% increase over 2022, driven by asset sales and increased investment in renewable energy.
Iberdrola achieved a record net profit of €5.61 billion in 2024, a 17% increase over 2022, driven by asset sales and increased investment in renewable energy.
Italian energy group Eni reports a 45% drop in net profit in 2024, reaching €2.46 billion, impacted by lower gas and oil prices. Its shares fell on the stock market after results fell short of expectations.
Italian energy group Eni reports a 45% drop in net profit in 2024, reaching €2.46 billion, impacted by lower gas and oil prices. Its shares fell on the stock market after results fell short of expectations.

Advertising