popular articles

France: ASN/IRSN merger to be the subject of a specific bill

The planned merger of France's nuclear safety institutions raises concerns about its impact on expertise and independence. The government ensures a specific parliamentary debate to respond to criticism.
fusion IRSN ASN

Please share:

The Ministry of Energy Transition has announced that the new bill on the merger of France’s nuclear safetyThe new law, which will apply to the Institut de Radioprotection et Sûreté Nucléaire (IRSN) and the Autorité de Sûreté Nucléaire (ASN), will be specific and will not be incorporated into another bill.

IRSN-ASN nuclear merger: the quest for an independent, safe authority

This assurance was given in response to the concerns expressed by IRSN’s inter-union group, which is firmly opposed to the merger. The government is planning a dedicated parliamentary debate and a specific legislative vehicle to address this issue.

The idea of merging IRSN, the safety expert, and ASN, the nuclear regulator, came about following a meeting of the Nuclear Policy Council at the Élysée Palace. This project had been tried before, but was rejected by Parliament a few months ago.

According to statements from the Élysée Palace, the merger of these two institutions should result in the creation of a new “major independent authority” responsible for making decisions on safety issues for nuclear power plants. This announcement comes a week after the publication of a parliamentary report advocating the merger of the two entities in order to cope with the growing workload associated with current and future nuclear reactors. The government justifies this decision by highlighting the three challenges of the nuclear revival: the extension of the existing reactor fleet, the construction of new EPR reactors and the development of innovative small modular reactors.

Apprehensions and challenges: dissenting voices against the IRSN-ASN merger

However, a number of players in the nuclear sector, including IRSN employees, nuclear experts and members of parliament, have expressed their concerns about the proposed merger. In particular, they fear that experts will lose their independence, skills and ability to express themselves. As nuclear safety is a major issue, they are concerned about the possible consequences of this merger on decision-making and the safety of nuclear power plants in France.

In response to these concerns, Minister Agnès Pannier-Runacher sought to reassure by asserting that fusion will make it possible to adapt nuclear safety to the challenges of the nuclear revival. However, it remains to be seen how the government will address the legitimate concerns of the parties concerned during the ad hoc parliamentary debate.

The bill to merge France’s nuclear safety institutions is proving highly controversial. While the government claims that this merger is necessary to meet the challenges of the nuclear revival, many players in the sector are expressing concern about its impact on the independence and expertise of the institutions involved. The forthcoming parliamentary debate will be crucial in determining the future of fusion and its influence on nuclear safety in France.

Register free of charge for uninterrupted access.

Publicite

Recently published in

The French group Orano (formerly Areva) has signed a crucial agreement in Mongolia for the exploitation of a vast uranium deposit. This initiative involves a major investment and arouses the interest of observers, both for supply security and industrial implications.
Vinci calls for private funding to speed up EPR reactors
Vinci calls for private funding to speed up EPR reactors
The new nuclear safety authority reaffirms transparency
The new nuclear safety authority reaffirms transparency
In 2025, nuclear energy will reach an unprecedented production level, driven by China and the growing global electricity demand. Former leaders, such as the United States and Europe, see their influence diminish amidst these changes.
In 2025, nuclear energy will reach an unprecedented production level, driven by China and the growing global electricity demand. Former leaders, such as the United States and Europe, see their influence diminish amidst these changes.
Fermi Energia has submitted an application to Estonia's Ministry of Economic Affairs to begin the spatial planning process for a 600 MW nuclear power plant, marking a key step in the country's energy transition.
Vietnam revives its nuclear power plant project with Russia's support, consolidating a strategic alliance to meet soaring energy demands.
Vietnam revives its nuclear power plant project with Russia's support, consolidating a strategic alliance to meet soaring energy demands.
The KRONOS MMR™, a modular nuclear reactor developed by NANO Nuclear, achieves regulatory progress and targets key industrial applications, including hydrogen and artificial intelligence.
The KRONOS MMR™, a modular nuclear reactor developed by NANO Nuclear, achieves regulatory progress and targets key industrial applications, including hydrogen and artificial intelligence.
The British government refutes Financial Times claims about the doubling of costs for the Sizewell C nuclear power plant project led by EDF in eastern England.
The British government refutes Financial Times claims about the doubling of costs for the Sizewell C nuclear power plant project led by EDF in eastern England.
Following the termination of its agreement with Anfield Energy, IsoEnergy redirects its efforts toward optimizing its uranium assets in North America and Australia amidst a changing market landscape.
The Court of Audit highlights significant uncertainties surrounding the EPR2 program, revealing persistent financial and technical risks. A critical report calls for resolving these issues before proceeding with new investments.
The Court of Audit highlights significant uncertainties surrounding the EPR2 program, revealing persistent financial and technical risks. A critical report calls for resolving these issues before proceeding with new investments.
Doosan Enerbility and the International Nuclear Non-proliferation Center join forces to boost exports and develop modular reactors, addressing growing energy demands.
Doosan Enerbility and the International Nuclear Non-proliferation Center join forces to boost exports and develop modular reactors, addressing growing energy demands.
The new Czech energy plan projects a rise to 68% nuclear electricity by 2040, alongside a boost in renewables to meet the European Union's climate targets.
The new Czech energy plan projects a rise to 68% nuclear electricity by 2040, alongside a boost in renewables to meet the European Union's climate targets.
The United States announces the lifting of 200 restrictions on Indian nuclear entities, marking a key step in their strategic cooperation and creating opportunities for the civil energy sector.
EDF steps up its efforts with the Nuward SMR, a 400 MW reactor designed to meet the strategic energy needs of industries and public utilities in Europe.
EDF steps up its efforts with the Nuward SMR, a 400 MW reactor designed to meet the strategic energy needs of industries and public utilities in Europe.
Novatron Fusion Group and Oxford Sigma partner to accelerate the development of fusion power plants in Sweden, combining innovative technologies and advanced materials for reliable industrial solutions.
Novatron Fusion Group and Oxford Sigma partner to accelerate the development of fusion power plants in Sweden, combining innovative technologies and advanced materials for reliable industrial solutions.
Halden Kjernekraft is studying the construction of a 1200 MWe nuclear power plant based on small modular reactors (SMR). This project could reshape Norway’s energy landscape.
Halden Kjernekraft is studying the construction of a 1200 MWe nuclear power plant based on small modular reactors (SMR). This project could reshape Norway’s energy landscape.
New U.S. tax rules now allow some existing nuclear power plants to qualify for hydrogen production tax credits, targeting 200 MW per reactor at risk of closure and boosting regional projects.
The NRC extends the license of the Monticello nuclear plant until 2050, confirming its strategic capacity of 671 MWe. This decision aligns with the United States' strict and sustainable energy policy.
The NRC extends the license of the Monticello nuclear plant until 2050, confirming its strategic capacity of 671 MWe. This decision aligns with the United States' strict and sustainable energy policy.
The Koeberg nuclear power plant, operated by Eskom in South Africa, resumes activity with Unit 2, adding 930 MW to the national grid after a prolonged strategic maintenance program.
The Koeberg nuclear power plant, operated by Eskom in South Africa, resumes activity with Unit 2, adding 930 MW to the national grid after a prolonged strategic maintenance program.
The Nuclear Safety and Radiation Protection Authority (ASNR) restructures the French nuclear sector by integrating 2,000 employees. This reform, at the heart of political and economic challenges, raises questions about governance and transparency.
The Nuclear Safety and Radiation Protection Authority (ASNR) restructures the French nuclear sector by integrating 2,000 employees. This reform, at the heart of political and economic challenges, raises questions about governance and transparency.
The merger of IRSN and ASN into the new ASNR raises concerns about expertise independence and a budget impasse expected as early as February 2025, according to unions.
After years of focusing on renewable energy, the European Union is channeling resources into developing small modular reactors (SMRs) and strengthening its nuclear infrastructure.
After years of focusing on renewable energy, the European Union is channeling resources into developing small modular reactors (SMRs) and strengthening its nuclear infrastructure.
Mongolia and Orano have reached a preliminary agreement for the exploitation of a strategic uranium mine, a $1.6 billion investment that could place the country among the world’s top 10 uranium resource holders.
Mongolia and Orano have reached a preliminary agreement for the exploitation of a strategic uranium mine, a $1.6 billion investment that could place the country among the world’s top 10 uranium resource holders.
NuScale Power appoints Diana J. Walters to its board of directors. With over 35 years of experience, she will strengthen governance as the company secures $227.7 million through a strategic warrant buyback.
NuScale Power appoints Diana J. Walters to its board of directors. With over 35 years of experience, she will strengthen governance as the company secures $227.7 million through a strategic warrant buyback.

Advertising