popular articles

ASN-IRSN merger desirable in the face of future workloads

Against a backdrop of debate and contestation, the proposed merger of IRSN and ASN is raising questions about its legitimacy and impact on the governance of nuclear safety.
IRSN

Please share:

A merger of the two institutions responsible for nuclear safety in France is desirable in view of the expected increase in the workload involved in monitoring present and future power plants, the authors of a parliamentary report said on Wednesday. The report, published on Tuesday, recommends merging the Institut de Radioprotection et Sûreté Nucléaire (IRSN), a safety expert, and the Autorité de Sûreté Nucléaire (ASN), responsible for decisions on power plants.

ASN-IRSN Merger: Towards a Simplification of Nuclear Safety Governance

In April, Parliament rejected this reform, which came from the Elysée Palace, amid criticism of the method and concerns about the transparency and quality of expertise. The Senate then commissioned a report from the Office parlementaire des choix scientifiques (Opecst).

“What led us to this recommendation (to merge) is the scale of the work before the decision-making body: the ASN makes over 2,000 decisions a year, of which only 400 come under the IRSN. So there’s a kind of dispersal of expertise,” Senator Stéphane Piednoir, one of the rapporteurs, told the press. “To cope with the coming decades, with the construction of EPR2s, ten-yearly inspections (of existing reactors), plus start-ups involving new technologies, it seems to us that, to improve the speed of decision-making, this is the right solution”, he said, adding that there is “no criticism of the quality of the work of either side”.

His fellow MP Jean-Luc Fugit (Renaissance) believes that new companies entering the sector would see things “more clearly”.

“With new operators, and the rise in power (of new nuclear power), perhaps it’s better to have a single safety organization, a simpler system, what we might call fluidification,” he said, estimating that this would make it possible to “simplify the governance of safety and even its financing”.

ASN-IRSN Merger: Controversial Report Calls for Delicate Reform

The report does not provide any further details on the organization of the new entity, noting “points still to be clarified” (what to do with IRSN’s commercial activities, in defense, etc.). Asked about the risk of destabilizing the system, Mr. Piednoir responds by calling for action to be taken from the start of the school year, “so that the system stabilizes by the beginning of 2025”. To achieve this, we’ll need a bill that can be debated, which can be “a short text” but “under no circumstances within a budgetary text that could be submitted to the 49-3, for example”, said Mr. Piednoir.

Since the announcement of the President’s intentions, IRSN employees, nuclear experts and members of parliament have been up in arms against the planned merger. On Wednesday, IRSN’s trade unions described the report as “partial and biased”, saying that Opecst was “at the service of the government”.

For former minister Barbara Pompili (Renaissance), “after careful reading… NOTHING in the body of the report seriously justifies the recommendation”. “Almost all of the desirable improvements can be made without a merger. So why propose it as a priority?” she tweeted.

Register free of charge for uninterrupted access.

Publicite

Recently published in

The Nuclear Safety and Radiation Protection Authority (ASNR) restructures the French nuclear sector by integrating 2,000 employees. This reform, at the heart of political and economic challenges, raises questions about governance and transparency.
In 2024, France achieved an unprecedented net electricity export level of 89 TWh, driven by a restored nuclear production and strengthened renewable performance.
In 2024, France achieved an unprecedented net electricity export level of 89 TWh, driven by a restored nuclear production and strengthened renewable performance.
The merger of IRSN and ASN into the new ASNR raises concerns about expertise independence and a budget impasse expected as early as February 2025, according to unions.
The merger of IRSN and ASN into the new ASNR raises concerns about expertise independence and a budget impasse expected as early as February 2025, according to unions.
After years of focusing on renewable energy, the European Union is channeling resources into developing small modular reactors (SMRs) and strengthening its nuclear infrastructure.
After years of focusing on renewable energy, the European Union is channeling resources into developing small modular reactors (SMRs) and strengthening its nuclear infrastructure.
Mongolia and Orano have reached a preliminary agreement for the exploitation of a strategic uranium mine, a $1.6 billion investment that could place the country among the world’s top 10 uranium resource holders.
NuScale Power appoints Diana J. Walters to its board of directors. With over 35 years of experience, she will strengthen governance as the company secures $227.7 million through a strategic warrant buyback.
NuScale Power appoints Diana J. Walters to its board of directors. With over 35 years of experience, she will strengthen governance as the company secures $227.7 million through a strategic warrant buyback.
NANO Nuclear Energy acquires MMR and Pylon reactors during an auction within the bankruptcy of Ultra Safe Nuclear Corporation for $8.5 million.
NANO Nuclear Energy acquires MMR and Pylon reactors during an auction within the bankruptcy of Ultra Safe Nuclear Corporation for $8.5 million.
A government report recommends ending Sweden's ban on uranium extraction, paving the way for exploitation under the Minerals Act by 2026.
A government report recommends ending Sweden's ban on uranium extraction, paving the way for exploitation under the Minerals Act by 2026.
Fourteen international experts evaluated Ghana's nuclear regulatory framework, highlighting significant progress while identifying major structural challenges to ensure sustainable safety.
The EPR of Flamanville symbolizes the challenges of French nuclear energy: delays, cost overruns, and loss of expertise. As the future shifts toward EPR2, the revival of this strategic sector remains fraught with uncertainties.
The EPR of Flamanville symbolizes the challenges of French nuclear energy: delays, cost overruns, and loss of expertise. As the future shifts toward EPR2, the revival of this strategic sector remains fraught with uncertainties.
Argentine President Javier Milei has unveiled plans to build a modular nuclear reactor to address a 9% increase in energy demand in 2024, largely driven by the rise of artificial intelligence.
Argentine President Javier Milei has unveiled plans to build a modular nuclear reactor to address a 9% increase in energy demand in 2024, largely driven by the rise of artificial intelligence.
The Swiss government proposes lifting the ban on new nuclear power plants to offset the imminent loss of 29% of electricity supplied by aging reactors.
The Swiss government proposes lifting the ban on new nuclear power plants to offset the imminent loss of 29% of electricity supplied by aging reactors.
HD Hyundai and TerraPower collaborate on the Natrium project, a 345 MW nuclear reactor planned in Wyoming by 2030. This project represents a major step forward in the modular reactor sector to enhance the global energy transition.
MAIRE S.p.A. and newcleo Holding launch Italy's first nuclear project under the Meloni government, featuring a 200 MWe advanced modular reactor.
MAIRE S.p.A. and newcleo Holding launch Italy's first nuclear project under the Meloni government, featuring a 200 MWe advanced modular reactor.
Driven by favorable public policies and growing energy demand, the global nuclear energy market is projected to reach USD 44.71 billion by 2029, with an annual growth rate of 2.9%. Major powers are intensifying investments in the sector.
Driven by favorable public policies and growing energy demand, the global nuclear energy market is projected to reach USD 44.71 billion by 2029, with an annual growth rate of 2.9%. Major powers are intensifying investments in the sector.
Two American grants will finance studies on radioactive waste management and modular nuclear reactors in Bulgaria, strengthening bilateral cooperation and supporting the country's energy objectives.
Two American grants will finance studies on radioactive waste management and modular nuclear reactors in Bulgaria, strengthening bilateral cooperation and supporting the country's energy objectives.
The Flamanville EPR will be connected to the grid this Friday. After two decades of delays and cost overruns, this next-generation reactor marks a major milestone for French nuclear energy.
Westinghouse and Aecon announce partnerships to develop AP1000 reactors in Canada, with an economic impact estimated at 20 billion CAD and thousands of jobs at stake.
Westinghouse and Aecon announce partnerships to develop AP1000 reactors in Canada, with an economic impact estimated at 20 billion CAD and thousands of jobs at stake.
EPH, a Czech group owned by Daniel Kretinsky, acquires a majority stake in Slovenske Elektrarne for 150 million euros, consolidating its presence in the European nuclear energy market.
EPH, a Czech group owned by Daniel Kretinsky, acquires a majority stake in Slovenske Elektrarne for 150 million euros, consolidating its presence in the European nuclear energy market.
Three associations withdrew from the public debate on the recycling of low-level radioactive metals in Fessenheim, citing a biased and unbalanced process.
Three associations withdrew from the public debate on the recycling of low-level radioactive metals in Fessenheim, citing a biased and unbalanced process.
NANO Nuclear and Digihost submit a proposal to NYSERDA to evaluate the integration of advanced nuclear technologies at a 60-megawatt energy site in New York State.
Standard Uranium engages Fleet Space Technologies to conduct multiphysics surveys combining ambient noise tomography and gravimetry. This project targets uranium-bearing corridors in the southwest of the Athabasca Basin.
Standard Uranium engages Fleet Space Technologies to conduct multiphysics surveys combining ambient noise tomography and gravimetry. This project targets uranium-bearing corridors in the southwest of the Athabasca Basin.
An independent economic analysis concludes that including nuclear energy in Australia's electricity market could yield substantial savings, with a cost reduction estimated at 44% compared to a scenario relying solely on renewable energy.
An independent economic analysis concludes that including nuclear energy in Australia's electricity market could yield substantial savings, with a cost reduction estimated at 44% compared to a scenario relying solely on renewable energy.
Iran surpasses critical limits, increasing uranium enrichment to 60%, while agreeing to stricter monitoring by the IAEA. This development heightens international tensions and revives diplomatic concerns.
Iran surpasses critical limits, increasing uranium enrichment to 60%, while agreeing to stricter monitoring by the IAEA. This development heightens international tensions and revives diplomatic concerns.

Advertising