popular articles

Favoritism at EDF: The PNF Appeals Henri Proglio’s and the Group’s Acquittal

The Parquet National Financier (PNF) has announced its decision to appeal the Paris Correctional Court’s ruling, which acquitted Henri Proglio, former Chairman and CEO of EDF, along with the group and eleven other individuals, in a case involving allegations of favoritism. The case centers on a series of consulting contracts directly awarded by EDF between 2010 and 2016, raising concerns about the transparency of the company’s contracting practices.

Please share:

At the core of the issue are 44 contracts awarded without competitive bidding, ranging from 40,000 to 4 million euros, to consultants from various sectors, including lawyers, journalists, former corporate executives, and communication experts. The services provided included strategic consulting, crisis management, lobbying, and communication services. Most of these contracts were signed under the leadership of Henri Proglio, at a time when EDF was seeking to refine its strategy in a complex competitive environment.

For the PNF, these engagements should have been subject to a competitive bidding process in accordance with the public procurement rules for a semi-public company. However, the court found that “criminal intent” was not proven, thereby acquitting Proglio and the other defendants, some of whom held influential positions in the energy and media sectors, such as Loïk Le Floch-Prigent, former CEO of Gaz de France, and Jean-Marie Messier, former Chairman of Vivendi.

PNF Criticizes Public Procurement Management

The PNF’s appeal is based on the belief that EDF’s management of public contracts operated outside of the regulatory framework, leading to potential misuse of allocated funds. These contracts, awarded without competitive bidding, raise questions about the transparency of financial resource use in large French companies with state ownership. According to the prosecution, these practices are contrary to public procurement regulations and could harm sector competition.

The decision to appeal reflects a desire to strengthen oversight of large public or semi-public companies in terms of compliance with governance standards. The PNF’s goal is to establish clear accountability for the management of these contracts, particularly in times of economic transition when cost control becomes crucial for the competitiveness of these entities.

Personalities Involved in the Case

The consultants acquitted alongside Henri Proglio include several notable figures, such as criminologist Alain Bauer and former SNCF CEO Loïk Le Floch-Prigent. These individuals received consulting contracts in various fields, often related to risk management or communication strategy. The court emphasized that the missions were legitimate and that the lack of evidence of intent to circumvent the rules made a conviction for favoritism impossible.

The case, dating back a decade, is part of a broader context of scrutiny over contract management within companies where the state holds a significant stake. EDF, as a strategic player in the French energy sector, is regularly subject to rigorous oversight by authorities, particularly in terms of transparency in contractual practices and regulatory compliance.

Towards a New Judicial Evaluation

The PNF’s appeal paves the way for a new trial that could last several years, during which the defense strategy of EDF and Henri Proglio will be closely examined. Proglio, who led the group from 2009 to 2014, implemented a system aimed at standardizing the use of consultants in specific areas, believing that this approach optimized the company’s responsiveness to regulatory and competitive challenges.

If the appeal succeeds, it could signal a tightening of jurisprudence on management practices within large semi-public companies, with implications for procurement policies. The initial judgment had highlighted the non-systematic nature of competitive bidding for consultants, which, according to the PNF, could potentially lead to abuses of position by certain senior executives.

The outcome of this case will be closely monitored by energy sector professionals and regulators, as it could influence how major companies handle contractual relationships and the recruitment of external consultants in an increasingly complex market context.

Register free of charge for uninterrupted access.

Publicite

Recently published in

French electricity exports generated a record €5 billion in 2024, driven by increased volumes despite falling market prices. Italy, Germany, and Belgium are among the main importers.
France’s electricity exports generated €5 billion in 2024, an unprecedented level driven by increased volumes despite declining market prices. Italy, Germany, and Belgium were among the main importers.
France’s electricity exports generated €5 billion in 2024, an unprecedented level driven by increased volumes despite declining market prices. Italy, Germany, and Belgium were among the main importers.
Engie announces an exceptional increase of €50 for energy vouchers benefiting eligible customers and doubles its contribution to the Housing Solidarity Fund (FSL). This measure comes as rising electricity taxes impact consumers.
Engie announces an exceptional increase of €50 for energy vouchers benefiting eligible customers and doubles its contribution to the Housing Solidarity Fund (FSL). This measure comes as rising electricity taxes impact consumers.
La Lituanie, la Lettonie et l'Estonie vont couper leurs derniers liens avec le réseau électrique russe. Ce basculement, prévu le 8 février, marque leur intégration complète au réseau européen après des années de préparation et d'investissements.
La Lituanie, la Lettonie et l'Estonie vont couper leurs derniers liens avec le réseau électrique russe. Ce basculement, prévu le 8 février, marque leur intégration complète au réseau européen après des années de préparation et d'investissements.
Indonesia must manage ambitious climate commitments while maintaining energy stability. The Just Energy Transition Partnership (JETP), aimed at mobilizing $20 billion, faces financial obstacles and uncertainties regarding international funding.
The recent changes in U.S. tariff policies could affect the global energy industry, particularly trade in key products such as natural gas and renewable energy equipment.
The recent changes in U.S. tariff policies could affect the global energy industry, particularly trade in key products such as natural gas and renewable energy equipment.
The Vietnamese government is adjusting its timeline for the implementation of its carbon market. Initially planned for 2028, the official launch will now take place in 2029 after a three-year pilot phase. This delay aims to strengthen the regulatory and technical framework.
The Vietnamese government is adjusting its timeline for the implementation of its carbon market. Initially planned for 2028, the official launch will now take place in 2029 after a three-year pilot phase. This delay aims to strengthen the regulatory and technical framework.
The European Union launches an emergency consultation with automakers to accelerate the transition to electrification in response to current competitive and regulatory challenges.
The European Union launches an emergency consultation with automakers to accelerate the transition to electrification in response to current competitive and regulatory challenges.
The BloombergNEF 2024 report reveals a historic record of global investments in the low-carbon energy transition, driven by electrified transport, renewable energy, and power grids.
The High Council for Climate (HCC) presents six conditions for the energy transition. The opinion outlines areas to strengthen, particularly regarding budget mobilization and planning for the phase-out of fossil fuels.
The High Council for Climate (HCC) presents six conditions for the energy transition. The opinion outlines areas to strengthen, particularly regarding budget mobilization and planning for the phase-out of fossil fuels.
At the heart of the vast northern expanses, Sami communities see their ancestral ways of life challenged by the rise of renewable projects. A factual narrative revealing the tensions between economic modernization and the preservation of millennia-old traditions.
At the heart of the vast northern expanses, Sami communities see their ancestral ways of life challenged by the rise of renewable projects. A factual narrative revealing the tensions between economic modernization and the preservation of millennia-old traditions.
The 15% tariff reduction affects over 24 million subscribers in France, with disparities depending on regulated and market offers, amid fluctuations in energy costs, taxes, and transmission fees.
The 15% tariff reduction affects over 24 million subscribers in France, with disparities depending on regulated and market offers, amid fluctuations in energy costs, taxes, and transmission fees.
Myanmar faces recurrent power outages linked to civil conflict and outdated infrastructure, affecting daily life and economic activities.
The Greenfin label, launched in 2013, is being updated to better match European requirements, particularly in sustainable finance and climate objectives. The revisions published on January 29, 2025, strengthen its alignment with the green taxonomy and European standards.
The Greenfin label, launched in 2013, is being updated to better match European requirements, particularly in sustainable finance and climate objectives. The revisions published on January 29, 2025, strengthen its alignment with the green taxonomy and European standards.
The US Senate has approved the nomination of Lee Zeldin to lead the EPA. The choice made by Donald Trump has been praised by fossil fuel industry players but criticized by environmental NGOs.
The US Senate has approved the nomination of Lee Zeldin to lead the EPA. The choice made by Donald Trump has been praised by fossil fuel industry players but criticized by environmental NGOs.
Sylvain Waserman, CEO of Ademe, reaffirmed the importance of the ecological transition agency during his testimony before the Committee on Sustainable Development, highlighting its key role in reducing France’s energy dependence.
Sylvain Waserman, CEO of Ademe, reaffirmed the importance of the ecological transition agency during his testimony before the Committee on Sustainable Development, highlighting its key role in reducing France’s energy dependence.
The Norwegian Sovereign Fund posted a historic return of 214 billion euros in 2024, driven by investments in major tech companies. However, the dominance of these giants is now being questioned.
In response to geopolitical and economic challenges, the European Union is realigning its energy policy to enhance its competitiveness. Regulatory simplifications and efforts to secure energy supplies are at the heart of the new strategy, while maintaining environmental commitments.
In response to geopolitical and economic challenges, the European Union is realigning its energy policy to enhance its competitiveness. Regulatory simplifications and efforts to secure energy supplies are at the heart of the new strategy, while maintaining environmental commitments.
The Constitutional Council censored a retroactive measure aimed at modifying contracts between EDF and renewable energy producers, citing a disproportionate infringement on contractual rights.
The Constitutional Council censored a retroactive measure aimed at modifying contracts between EDF and renewable energy producers, citing a disproportionate infringement on contractual rights.
The Zambia-Tanzania Interconnector (ZTIP) project, backed by international financing, aims to strengthen electrical exchanges between Zambia and Tanzania, with major implications for energy integration in sub-Saharan Africa.
The Zambia-Tanzania Interconnector (ZTIP) project, backed by international financing, aims to strengthen electrical exchanges between Zambia and Tanzania, with major implications for energy integration in sub-Saharan Africa.
The U.S. Department of Energy grants Pacific Gas and Electric a loan to modernize infrastructure, integrate more renewables, and improve grid reliability.
As the United States considers another withdrawal from the Paris Agreement, major economic powers organize to maintain leadership in a rapidly transforming energy sector.
As the United States considers another withdrawal from the Paris Agreement, major economic powers organize to maintain leadership in a rapidly transforming energy sector.
Zhecho Stankov, Bulgaria's new Minister of Energy, emphasizes energy security and supply diversification while aligning with European goals for sustainable transition.
Zhecho Stankov, Bulgaria's new Minister of Energy, emphasizes energy security and supply diversification while aligning with European goals for sustainable transition.
The Indonesian government’s plan to convert 20 million hectares of forests for food and energy sparks criticism from NGOs, which warn of irreversible environmental consequences.
The Indonesian government’s plan to convert 20 million hectares of forests for food and energy sparks criticism from NGOs, which warn of irreversible environmental consequences.

Advertising