popular articles

EPA carbon plan: impossible to adapt warns IEE

U.S. power plant owners are challenging the Biden administration's plan to reduce carbon emissions because of the use of expensive technologies that have not been proven on a large scale, according to EEI. This resistance poses a challenge to the administration's goal of achieving zero net emissions in the electricity sector by 2035.
plan carbone de l'EPA

Please share:

U.S. power plant owners warned the Biden administration on Tuesday that its sweeping plan to reduce carbon emissions from the electricity sector was unworkable. In their view, it relies too heavily on expensive technologies that have yet to prove themselves on a large scale.

IEE resistance to EPA’s carbon plan vision: Challenges for the US climate agenda

The Edison Electric Institute (EEI), one of the world’s leading utility trade groups, has asked the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to review proposed standards for power plants. They depend on the widespread commercial availability of carbon capture and storage (CCS) and low-emission green hydrogen, adding that the agency’s vision was “not legally or technically sound”.

“The utilities are not confident that the new technologies designated by the EPA to serve as the basis for the proposed standards for new and existing fossil-fired generation will meet the performance and cost requirements within the EPA’s time frame,” the EEI said in a public comment released Tuesday, on the agency’s deadline for receiving information.

Resistance from IEE and other energy-related groups represents a potentially significant challenge to the administration’s climate agenda. U.S. President Joe Biden has set the goal of reducing net emissions from the electricity sector to zero by 2035. It is responsible for a quarter of the country’s greenhouse gases. This objective is at the heart of Washington’s commitment to an international agreement to combat global climate change. It aims to halve US greenhouse gas production by 2030.

Zero emissions: The burning issues in the EPA’s carbon plan for power plants

In May, the EPA proposed a plan that would limit for the first time the amount of carbon dioxide that power plants can emit, following the judicial overturning of previous efforts. West Virginia, which led a lawsuit against the Obama-era Clean Power Plan, also said it and 20 other states opposed the rule because the standards would leave coal-fired plant operators no choice but to shut down.

The proposed limits for new and existing power plants assume the existence of CO2 capture and storage technology that can siphon CO2 from a power plant stack before it reaches the atmosphere, or the use of hydrogen as a fuel. The EPA said that last year’s passage of the Inflation Reduction Act, which subsidizes these technologies, makes them cost-effective and viable. Environmental groups Clean Air Task Force and Natural Resources Defense Council said the proposal “provides generous lead times for implementation and compliance, and would not cause reliability problems if finalized”.

Industry is particularly concerned about the standards proposed for existing natural gas power plants, believing that they would find it difficult to adapt these facilities to CCS or hydrogen due to space constraints and other limitations. PJM Interconnection, the largest power grid operator in the USA, along with three other operators serving a total of 154 million customers, have expressed concern about a scenario where the numerous retirements of dispatchable generation would not be compensated in time by the widespread commercialization of the necessary technologies.

Cracks in the EPA’s carbon plan: Challenges and concerns from players in the electricity industry

In a joint statement, the grid operators urged the EPA not to adopt the plan until it had examined in detail its impact on power grid reliability, highlighting its “chilling effect” on investments to maintain existing dispatchable generation units. The EPA’s plan would require existing large gas-fired power plants that operate at least 50% of the time to install a carbon capture system by 2035, or to use 30% hydrogen by 2032. The IEE asked the agency to “repropose or significantly supplement” the proposed rules for existing gas-fired power plants.

One investor-owned utility, Baltimore-based Constellation (CEG.O), distanced itself from the IEE’s position and said it supported the EPA’s proposed guidelines. However, the company has made it clear that it is working to improve the rule. The National Rural Electric Cooperative Association, which represents 900 member-owned utilities, asked the EPA to withdraw the proposed rule, saying it would compromise reliability and affordability, said CEO Jim Matheson.

Unions, the United Mine Workers of America and the International Brotherhood of Electricity Workers, also called on the EPA to review the settlement and criticized its reliance on CSC, saying it put jobs at risk. The EPA had drawn up the proposal taking into account the constraints imposed by the Supreme Court the previous year, following its ruling that the Obama-era Clean Power plan had overstepped the mark in forcing a system-wide transition from fossil fuels to renewables.

Register free of charge for uninterrupted access.

Publicite

Recently published in

The French government activates five funding mechanisms to support industrial decarbonisation projects through the France 2030 plan, targeting major sites, SMEs and high-emission industrial zones.
Paris releases a new €400mn funding package to support industrial projects aimed at reducing emissions under the France 2030 programme.
Paris releases a new €400mn funding package to support industrial projects aimed at reducing emissions under the France 2030 programme.
The massive withdrawal of American financial support and the reduction of European aid could jeopardize energy projects in Africa, profoundly altering their financing structure and the continent's commitments.
The massive withdrawal of American financial support and the reduction of European aid could jeopardize energy projects in Africa, profoundly altering their financing structure and the continent's commitments.
The Vietnamese government has raised its renewable energy targets in a new version of its national energy plan, responding to continued growth in electricity demand.
The Vietnamese government has raised its renewable energy targets in a new version of its national energy plan, responding to continued growth in electricity demand.
A massive outage plunged Puerto Rico into darkness on Wednesday, leaving approximately 1.1 million households without electricity after an unexpected shutdown of all its power plants.
The Czech Republic has ended its dependency on Russian oil after more than six decades, a major shift made in response to Russia's invasion of Ukraine.
The Czech Republic has ended its dependency on Russian oil after more than six decades, a major shift made in response to Russia's invasion of Ukraine.
The European power purchase agreement (PPA) market for renewables reached 19 GW of new capacity in 2024, with growing momentum for hybrid contracts including storage.
The European power purchase agreement (PPA) market for renewables reached 19 GW of new capacity in 2024, with growing momentum for hybrid contracts including storage.
Industry Minister Marc Ferracci criticised the Rassemblement National's stance on energy, accusing it of hindering planned investments in renewables in favour of fossil fuel imports.
Industry Minister Marc Ferracci criticised the Rassemblement National's stance on energy, accusing it of hindering planned investments in renewables in favour of fossil fuel imports.
Bill 69 sparks protests in Saint-Jean-sur-Richelieu, where several organisations denounce a risk of privatising Quebec’s electricity sector.
Wind and solar energy accounted for nearly one-fifth of Türkiye’s electricity generation in 2024, according to an analysis by think tank Ember, driven by a strong increase in installed capacity.
Wind and solar energy accounted for nearly one-fifth of Türkiye’s electricity generation in 2024, according to an analysis by think tank Ember, driven by a strong increase in installed capacity.
The Acerez consortium has signed a 35-year agreement to build and operate over 240 km of high-voltage lines in Australia, marking the country's first public-private partnership in the sector.
The Acerez consortium has signed a 35-year agreement to build and operate over 240 km of high-voltage lines in Australia, marking the country's first public-private partnership in the sector.
France’s multi-year energy strategy shifts focus away from photovoltaics toward flexibility measures, including battery storage, to address growing imbalances in the electricity market.
France’s multi-year energy strategy shifts focus away from photovoltaics toward flexibility measures, including battery storage, to address growing imbalances in the electricity market.
France’s energy regulator unveils its first observatory dedicated to renewable electricity purchase agreements, highlighting a recent but still marginal growth compared to State-backed mechanisms.
The French government plans to adopt within two weeks a decree outlining the decade’s energy objectives, restarting nuclear power and preparing for a parliamentary debate on energy sovereignty.
The French government plans to adopt within two weeks a decree outlining the decade’s energy objectives, restarting nuclear power and preparing for a parliamentary debate on energy sovereignty.
The expansion of solar and wind capacity is multiplying hours of negative prices on European electricity markets, weakening the sector's economic balance while reshaping export and storage dynamics.
The expansion of solar and wind capacity is multiplying hours of negative prices on European electricity markets, weakening the sector's economic balance while reshaping export and storage dynamics.
The National Assembly will discuss national energy security on 28 April at the government’s request, in connection with the upcoming Multiannual Energy Programming covering the 2025-2035 period.
The National Assembly will discuss national energy security on 28 April at the government’s request, in connection with the upcoming Multiannual Energy Programming covering the 2025-2035 period.
Despite a predominantly decarbonised electricity production, demand in Europe remains subdued, hindered by uncompetitive prices and limited industrial usage.
Data from think tank Ember reveals that fossil fuels accounted for just 49.2% of US electricity generation in March 2025, marking an unprecedented threshold.
Data from think tank Ember reveals that fossil fuels accounted for just 49.2% of US electricity generation in March 2025, marking an unprecedented threshold.
The global electricity mix shifted in 2024 with 40.9% of production from low-carbon sources, according to Ember, driven by historic solar power growth.
The global electricity mix shifted in 2024 with 40.9% of production from low-carbon sources, according to Ember, driven by historic solar power growth.
Facing recurring shortages, Tajikistan tightens energy laws by introducing prison sentences of up to ten years for electricity fraud to protect its ageing hydropower network.
Facing recurring shortages, Tajikistan tightens energy laws by introducing prison sentences of up to ten years for electricity fraud to protect its ageing hydropower network.
Burundi’s main opposition coalition warns of direct consequences from the energy crisis on the organisation of the June legislative elections.
In Cienfuegos, Cuba is deploying an ambitious photovoltaic programme supported by China to reduce its dependence on oil and stabilise its failing power grid.
In Cienfuegos, Cuba is deploying an ambitious photovoltaic programme supported by China to reduce its dependence on oil and stabilise its failing power grid.
The Panama Canal Authority has approved a strategic gas pipeline project amid political tensions and diverging interests over regional energy control.
The Panama Canal Authority has approved a strategic gas pipeline project amid political tensions and diverging interests over regional energy control.
The European Investment Bank is funding a €732 mn expansion plan to modernise and stabilise the electricity network in the Ostsachsen region by 2027.
The European Investment Bank is funding a €732 mn expansion plan to modernise and stabilise the electricity network in the Ostsachsen region by 2027.

Advertising