popular articles

EPA carbon plan: impossible to adapt warns IEE

U.S. power plant owners are challenging the Biden administration's plan to reduce carbon emissions because of the use of expensive technologies that have not been proven on a large scale, according to EEI. This resistance poses a challenge to the administration's goal of achieving zero net emissions in the electricity sector by 2035.
plan carbone de l'EPA

Please share:

U.S. power plant owners warned the Biden administration on Tuesday that its sweeping plan to reduce carbon emissions from the electricity sector was unworkable. In their view, it relies too heavily on expensive technologies that have yet to prove themselves on a large scale.

IEE resistance to EPA’s carbon plan vision: Challenges for the US climate agenda

The Edison Electric Institute (EEI), one of the world’s leading utility trade groups, has asked the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to review proposed standards for power plants. They depend on the widespread commercial availability of carbon capture and storage (CCS) and low-emission green hydrogen, adding that the agency’s vision was “not legally or technically sound”.

“The utilities are not confident that the new technologies designated by the EPA to serve as the basis for the proposed standards for new and existing fossil-fired generation will meet the performance and cost requirements within the EPA’s time frame,” the EEI said in a public comment released Tuesday, on the agency’s deadline for receiving information.

Resistance from IEE and other energy-related groups represents a potentially significant challenge to the administration’s climate agenda. U.S. President Joe Biden has set the goal of reducing net emissions from the electricity sector to zero by 2035. It is responsible for a quarter of the country’s greenhouse gases. This objective is at the heart of Washington’s commitment to an international agreement to combat global climate change. It aims to halve US greenhouse gas production by 2030.

Zero emissions: The burning issues in the EPA’s carbon plan for power plants

In May, the EPA proposed a plan that would limit for the first time the amount of carbon dioxide that power plants can emit, following the judicial overturning of previous efforts. West Virginia, which led a lawsuit against the Obama-era Clean Power Plan, also said it and 20 other states opposed the rule because the standards would leave coal-fired plant operators no choice but to shut down.

The proposed limits for new and existing power plants assume the existence of CO2 capture and storage technology that can siphon CO2 from a power plant stack before it reaches the atmosphere, or the use of hydrogen as a fuel. The EPA said that last year’s passage of the Inflation Reduction Act, which subsidizes these technologies, makes them cost-effective and viable. Environmental groups Clean Air Task Force and Natural Resources Defense Council said the proposal “provides generous lead times for implementation and compliance, and would not cause reliability problems if finalized”.

Industry is particularly concerned about the standards proposed for existing natural gas power plants, believing that they would find it difficult to adapt these facilities to CCS or hydrogen due to space constraints and other limitations. PJM Interconnection, the largest power grid operator in the USA, along with three other operators serving a total of 154 million customers, have expressed concern about a scenario where the numerous retirements of dispatchable generation would not be compensated in time by the widespread commercialization of the necessary technologies.

Cracks in the EPA’s carbon plan: Challenges and concerns from players in the electricity industry

In a joint statement, the grid operators urged the EPA not to adopt the plan until it had examined in detail its impact on power grid reliability, highlighting its “chilling effect” on investments to maintain existing dispatchable generation units. The EPA’s plan would require existing large gas-fired power plants that operate at least 50% of the time to install a carbon capture system by 2035, or to use 30% hydrogen by 2032. The IEE asked the agency to “repropose or significantly supplement” the proposed rules for existing gas-fired power plants.

One investor-owned utility, Baltimore-based Constellation (CEG.O), distanced itself from the IEE’s position and said it supported the EPA’s proposed guidelines. However, the company has made it clear that it is working to improve the rule. The National Rural Electric Cooperative Association, which represents 900 member-owned utilities, asked the EPA to withdraw the proposed rule, saying it would compromise reliability and affordability, said CEO Jim Matheson.

Unions, the United Mine Workers of America and the International Brotherhood of Electricity Workers, also called on the EPA to review the settlement and criticized its reliance on CSC, saying it put jobs at risk. The EPA had drawn up the proposal taking into account the constraints imposed by the Supreme Court the previous year, following its ruling that the Obama-era Clean Power plan had overstepped the mark in forcing a system-wide transition from fossil fuels to renewables.

Register free of charge for uninterrupted access.

Publicite

Recently published in

The Mauritanian government and the Millennium Challenge Corporation signed a 27 million USD grant agreement to modernize the country's electricity infrastructure and strengthen climate resilience.
Despite ambitious climate commitments, the United States only reduced its greenhouse gas emissions by 0.2% in 2024. A report from the Rhodium Group highlights a concerning trajectory for achieving the targets set in the Paris Agreement.
Despite ambitious climate commitments, the United States only reduced its greenhouse gas emissions by 0.2% in 2024. A report from the Rhodium Group highlights a concerning trajectory for achieving the targets set in the Paris Agreement.
The French Minister of Ecological Transition, Agnès Pannier-Runacher, sees her responsibilities adjusted but remains in charge of combating climate change and leading decarbonization efforts despite losing direct control over energy.
The French Minister of Ecological Transition, Agnès Pannier-Runacher, sees her responsibilities adjusted but remains in charge of combating climate change and leading decarbonization efforts despite losing direct control over energy.
When Justin Trudeau came to power in 2015, he symbolized the hope of a Canada that would lead the world in climate action. Nearly a decade later, he is leaving the political stage, leaving behind a controversial record. Carbon taxes, energy transition, and provincial tensions marked his tenure. With conservatives leading in the polls, the country is on the brink of a potential shift in its climate policy.
When Justin Trudeau came to power in 2015, he symbolized the hope of a Canada that would lead the world in climate action. Nearly a decade later, he is leaving the political stage, leaving behind a controversial record. Carbon taxes, energy transition, and provincial tensions marked his tenure. With conservatives leading in the polls, the country is on the brink of a potential shift in its climate policy.
Germany’s energy transition slowed in 2024, with a mere 3% reduction in greenhouse gas emissions. Political and economic uncertainty hampers investments in key sectors, particularly industry and transport.
Moldova and Gazprom are at odds over a debt estimated between $9 million and $700 million, exacerbating Transnistria's energy crisis. The separatist region faces the risk of total power outages in the midst of winter.
Moldova and Gazprom are at odds over a debt estimated between $9 million and $700 million, exacerbating Transnistria's energy crisis. The separatist region faces the risk of total power outages in the midst of winter.
In France, the energy check program recorded more than 200,000 requests in the last two days of 2024, highlighting growing pressure to meet the needs of low-income households amid the energy crisis.
In France, the energy check program recorded more than 200,000 requests in the last two days of 2024, highlighting growing pressure to meet the needs of low-income households amid the energy crisis.
The electricity volume traded on the Indian Energy Exchange surged by 29% in December, reaching an all-time high, driven by a significant drop in day-ahead market prices.
The electricity volume traded on the Indian Energy Exchange surged by 29% in December, reaching an all-time high, driven by a significant drop in day-ahead market prices.
With 707 TWh produced in 2024, SPIC illustrates the impact of public investments on the management and expansion of energy resources in China.
Joe Biden announces a ban on offshore drilling over an immense maritime area, challenging Donald Trump's energy production ambitions days before the presidential transition.
Joe Biden announces a ban on offshore drilling over an immense maritime area, challenging Donald Trump's energy production ambitions days before the presidential transition.
Three weeks after Cyclone Chido, nearly a third of Mayotte's households remain without electricity, while recovery efforts advance with increased mobilization of EDF and EDM teams.
Three weeks after Cyclone Chido, nearly a third of Mayotte's households remain without electricity, while recovery efforts advance with increased mobilization of EDF and EDM teams.
In 2024, Germany set a new record with 59% of its electricity produced from renewable sources, marking a key milestone after the complete shutdown of nuclear power. A balance of ecological progress and energy challenges.
In 2024, Germany set a new record with 59% of its electricity produced from renewable sources, marking a key milestone after the complete shutdown of nuclear power. A balance of ecological progress and energy challenges.
With the end of the Arenh mechanism in 2025, Aluminium Dunkerque is calling on EDF to offer competitive prices to remain internationally competitive while meeting decarbonization requirements.
The United Kingdom achieved a historic record of 58% low-carbon electricity in 2024, marking a key step in its energy transition and sending a strong signal to European political and economic actors.
The United Kingdom achieved a historic record of 58% low-carbon electricity in 2024, marking a key step in its energy transition and sending a strong signal to European political and economic actors.
India reaches an installed energy capacity of 457 GW in 2023, doubling in a decade. This growth highlights the delicate balance between energy transition and the need to meet rising electricity demand.
India reaches an installed energy capacity of 457 GW in 2023, doubling in a decade. This growth highlights the delicate balance between energy transition and the need to meet rising electricity demand.
In 2024, renewable energy in Portugal accounted for 71% of electricity consumption, a record driven by significant growth in photovoltaic and hydropower production, according to the national grid operator REN.
In 2024, renewable energy in Portugal accounted for 71% of electricity consumption, a record driven by significant growth in photovoltaic and hydropower production, according to the national grid operator REN.
Iran will meet European diplomats in Geneva on January 13 amidst controversy over its 60% uranium enrichment, according to the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA).
A massive power outage plunged Puerto Rico into darkness on New Year's Eve, affecting more than a million households. The structural challenges of the energy grid reveal significant shortcomings.
A massive power outage plunged Puerto Rico into darkness on New Year's Eve, affecting more than a million households. The structural challenges of the energy grid reveal significant shortcomings.
A suspected sabotage of the EstLink 2 cable connecting Finland to Estonia results in travel bans for seven sailors. A thorough investigation highlights significant geopolitical implications.
A suspected sabotage of the EstLink 2 cable connecting Finland to Estonia results in travel bans for seven sailors. A thorough investigation highlights significant geopolitical implications.
ADNOC forecasts 1.744 million barrels per day for its Murban crude exports in December 2025, a slight drop compared to November. March 2025 will experience a significant reduction of 70,000 barrels per day.
ADNOC forecasts 1.744 million barrels per day for its Murban crude exports in December 2025, a slight drop compared to November. March 2025 will experience a significant reduction of 70,000 barrels per day.
EDF and its representative unions finalize a salary agreement for 2025. The deal includes a global increase of 2.7%, while negotiations remain open in several gas sector companies.
The Environmental Authority calls for increased efforts to ensure France meets European climate goals, emphasizing a significant reduction in energy consumption to align with the requirements of the "Fit for 55" plan.
The Environmental Authority calls for increased efforts to ensure France meets European climate goals, emphasizing a significant reduction in energy consumption to align with the requirements of the "Fit for 55" plan.
Re-elected with 55% of the votes, Maia Sandu embodies the pro-European choice of Moldovans. This decision, however, faces external interference and a growing energy crisis.
Re-elected with 55% of the votes, Maia Sandu embodies the pro-European choice of Moldovans. This decision, however, faces external interference and a growing energy crisis.
The new American plan aims for a 66% reduction in emissions by 2035, focusing on local policies and investments in clean energy, with significant implications for markets and regulation.
The new American plan aims for a 66% reduction in emissions by 2035, focusing on local policies and investments in clean energy, with significant implications for markets and regulation.

Advertising