Energy Vouchers and Tariff Shield Reshape Energy Policy

The abandonment of the "tariff shield" in favor of "energy vouchers" marks a turning point in French energy policy.

Share:

The Senate’s recent decision to replace the “tariff shield” on electricity with targeted “energy vouchers” raises many questions about the effectiveness and fairness of this measure. Initially to be introduced in autumn 2021, the “tariff shield” was intended to limit the increase in electricity tariffs. However, the Senate opted for a more targeted approach, favoring the most modest households.

Budget impact and expected savings

The amendment adopted by the senators envisages putting an end to the current system and introducing a system of energy vouchers, aimed specifically at the six lowest income deciles. This measure is expected to generate savings of at least one billion euros for public finances. However, it also implies a potential rise in costs for wealthier families, polarizing the debate on questions of equity and efficiency.

Political Debates and Government Divergences

Jean-François Husson, general rapporteur and member of the Les Républicains party, defended the decision, calling it necessary to make the richest households more responsible. On the other hand, the government, through the voice of Public Accounts Minister Thomas Cazenave, has been reticent, deeming the measure costly and advocating a gradual increase in taxation. This opposition from the government, despite the initial approval of Economy Minister Bruno Le Maire, underlines the tensions and divergent perspectives within the executive branch.

Consequences for Wealthy and Modest Households

The Senate’s proposal, while welcomed by several political parties, including the right, center and ecologists, remains controversial. In addition, Senator Christine Lavarde (LR) criticized the government for not protecting the most vulnerable households sufficiently. In response, Thomas Cazenave defended the government’s position as balanced.

The challenges of energy transition in France

This situation illustrates the complexity of energy policy in France, where the need to protect the most vulnerable households must be balanced with budgetary constraints and environmental imperatives. The decisions taken will have a significant impact on purchasing power, resource distribution and the country’s energy transition.
In addition, the executive’s use of article 49.3 of the Constitution in the National Assembly on this draft budget indicates a potential legislative conflict. Indeed, although the government has the capacity to reject this measure in the end, the ongoing debate reveals a deep political divide and crucial questions concerning the future of energy policy in France.

The transition from “tariff shields” to “energy vouchers” raises critical questions about the balance between equity and budget efficiency.

Nearly USD92bn will be invested by major American and international groups in new data centres and energy infrastructure, responding to the surge in electricity demand linked to the rise of artificial intelligence.
Nouakchott has endured lengthy power interruptions for several weeks, highlighting the financial and technical limits of the Mauritanian Electricity Company as Mauritania aims to widen access and green its mix by 2030.
Between 2015 and 2024, four multilateral climate funds committed nearly eight bn USD to clean energy, attracting private capital through concessional terms while Africa and Asia absorbed more than half of the volume.
The Global Energy Policies Hub shows that strategic reserves, gas obligations, cybersecurity and critical-mineral policies are expanding rapidly, lifting oil coverage to 98 % of world imports.
According to a report by Ember, the Chinese government’s appliance trade-in campaign could double residential air-conditioner efficiency gains in 2025 and trim up to USD943mn from household electricity spending this year.
Washington is examining sectoral taxes on polysilicon and drones, two supply chains dominated by China, after triggering Section 232 to measure industrial dependency risks.
The 2025-2034 development plan presented by Terna includes strengthening Sicily’s grid, new interconnections, and major projects to support the region’s growing renewable energy capacity.
Terna and NPC Ukrenergo have concluded a three-year partnership in Rome aimed at strengthening the integration of the Ukrainian grid into the pan-European system, with an in-depth exchange of technological and regulatory expertise.
GE Vernova has secured a major contract to modernise the Kühmoos substation in Germany, enhancing grid reliability and integration capacity for power flows between Germany, France and Switzerland.
The National Energy System Operator forecasts electricity demand to rise to 785 TWh by 2050, underlining the need to modernise grids and integrate more clean energy to support the UK’s energy transition.
Terna has signed a guarantee agreement with SACE and the European Investment Bank to finance the Adriatic Link project, totalling approximately €1bn ($1.08bn) and validated as a major transaction under Italian regulations.
India unveils a series of reforms on oil and gas contracts, introducing a fiscal stability clause to enhance the sector’s attractiveness for foreign companies and boost its growth ambitions in upstream energy.
The European Commission is launching a special fund of EUR2.3bn ($2.5bn) to boost Ukraine’s reconstruction and attract private capital to the energy and infrastructure sectors.
Asia dominated global new renewable energy capacity in 2024 with 71% of installations, while Africa recorded limited growth of only 7.2%, according to the latest annual report from IRENA.
US President Donald Trump's One Big Beautiful Bill Act dramatically changes energy investment rules, imposing restrictions on renewables while favouring hydrocarbons, according to a recent report by consultancy firm Wood Mackenzie.
On July 8, 2025, the Senate validated the Gremillet bill, aimed at structuring France's energy transition with clear objectives for nuclear power, renewable energies, and energy renovation.
Brazil, Mexico, Argentina, Colombia, Chile, and Peru significantly increase renewable electricity production, reaching nearly 70% of the regional electricity mix, according to a recent Wood Mackenzie study on Latin America's energy sector.
The Canadian government announces an investment of more than $40mn to fund 13 energy projects led by Indigenous communities across the country, aiming to improve energy efficiency and increase local renewable energy use.
The German Ministry of Economy plans to significantly expand aid aimed at reducing industrial electricity costs, increasing eligible companies from 350 to 2,200, at an estimated cost of €4bn ($4.7bn).
A major electricity blackout paralyzed large parts of the Czech Republic, interrupting transport and essential networks, raising immediate economic concerns, and highlighting the vulnerability of energy infrastructures to unforeseen technical incidents.