Carbon footprint: TotalEnergies loses court case against Greenpeace

On the occasion of its 100th anniversary, TotalEnergies suffers a legal setback against Greenpeace. The NGO, accused by TotalEnergies of disseminating misleading information about its CO2 emissions, has had its legal action quashed by the courts.
TotalEnergies échec condamnation Greenpeace

Partagez:

TotalEnergies failed to secure a conviction against Greenpeace. The environmental NGO was accused by TotalEnergies of “disseminating false and misleading information” concerning its carbon footprint, a charge dismissed by the courts. The decision comes as TotalEnergies celebrates its centenary on March 28, 2024.

The accusations and Greenpeace’s defense

TotalEnergies is facing two complaints for “misleading commercial practices” in connection with the presentation of its climate policy, one brought before a civil court in Paris and the other leading to a criminal investigation by the Nanterre public prosecutor’s office. In a report published at the end of 2022, Greenpeace estimated that TotalEnergies’ annual emissions were four times higher than the figures reported by the company, i.e. 1.6 billion tonnes of CO2 equivalent versus 455 million declared. In response, TotalEnergies sued the NGO and analysis firm Factor-X in April 2023, for disseminating misleading information, demanding the depublication of the Greenpeace report and 50,000 euros in legal costs.

The judicial decision and its implications

The court quashed TotalEnergies’ summons against Greenpeace and Factor-X, citing a “lack of precision” that did not allow the defendants to prepare adequately. The judge did not consider TotalEnergies’ action an abuse of process, but dismissed the complaint for lack of clarity. The decision comes as TotalEnergies considers the next steps in the case, in what is its first lawsuit in France against an environmental association.

Greenpeace’s reaction and the cost to TotalEnergies

Greenpeace welcomed the court ruling as a victory against what it sees as an attempt to suppress freedom of expression. The court also ordered TotalEnergies to pay 15,000 euros in legal costs to Greenpeace and Factor-X. This legal outcome does not directly open the debate on TotalEnergies’ methods of accounting for CO2 emissions, but it could influence future interactions between companies and climate activists.

The legal battle between TotalEnergies and Greenpeace is not limited to this decision; TotalEnergies has the option of appealing. This case highlights the growing need for clear regulations on greenhouse gas emissions accounting and greenwashing, at a time when environmental transparency is becoming a major issue for companies and climate activists alike.

Citepa confirms limited drop in French emissions in 2024 at -1.8%, a pace significantly slower than previous years, reflecting highly contrasting performances across economic sectors.
The International Energy Agency warns of persistently high methane emissions, despite improved satellite-based monitoring and detection tools.
Swedish prosecutors have sought six-year prison sentences for five executives and partners of Think Pink, accused of unlawfully dumping 200,000 tonnes of toxic waste between 2015 and 2020.
Methane released by the oil, gas and coal sectors remained at near-record levels, according to the International Energy Agency, which flagged the scale of massive leaks detected.
Russian authorities are demanding €903 million from the owners of two tankers that ran aground in the Black Sea following an oil spill linked to unauthorised winter navigation.
Over 100 international organisations are urging a halt to offshore oil and gas exploration ahead of the United Nations Ocean Conference scheduled in June in Nice.
A massive fire broke out following a leak on a gas pipeline operated by Petronas in Selangor state, injuring over 100 people and causing significant damage in a residential area.
Former US Vice President Al Gore stated in Paris that Donald Trump’s decisions will not durably hinder the global rise of renewable energies, driven by falling solar production costs.
Dutch organisation Milieudefensie is suing ING for its alleged role in financing fossil fuel projects, demanding the bank halve its CO2 emissions by 2030.
Environmental groups have announced legal action against the Trump administration over measures aimed at boosting offshore oil and gas production, reigniting the legal battle from his first term in office.
The lawsuit filed by three NGOs and eight plaintiffs accusing TotalEnergies of involuntary manslaughter and harm to biodiversity has been dismissed by the French judiciary, citing insufficient evidence of infractions.
An analysis from the Interdisciplinary Environmental Clinic at Washington University highlights the immediate and long-term health risks posed by coal ash waste from MidAmerican Energy's plants in Iowa, as energy companies push to weaken regulations.
After Storm Eowyn, described as the most powerful in a decade, 577,000 households remained without electricity on Sunday evening in Ireland and the UK. Repairs are ongoing, but further disruptions are expected.
A report by France Stratégie warns of a potential 100% increase in water consumption in France by 2050, with agriculture, energy, and usage conflicts emerging as major challenges.
According to the British Meteorological Office (Met Office), carbon dioxide (CO2) has risen faster than ever, exceeding all projections and raising new questions about the global capacity to contain global warming.
CO2 emissions from global road transport could peak as early as 2025 thanks to the rise of electric vehicles and carbon regulations, according to an ICCT report.
Russia faces a major oil spill in the Kerch Strait. With 30,000 tons of soil already collected, criticisms are growing regarding the management and measures taken to mitigate the impacts.
The sinking of two oil tankers in the Kerch Strait has caused an oil spill, threatening 200,000 tons of soil and severely impacting local coasts and ecosystems.
Global temperatures in 2023 and 2024 shattered records, leaving climatologists grappling with urgent questions about the causes of such unprecedented overheating.
Kazakhstan announced the decontamination of over 360,000 m³ of oil waste inherited from the Soviet era, marking a major effort to reduce pollution on the Caspian Sea coast, which has suffered from decades of environmental degradation.