U.S. court rejects TC Energy’s Keystone XL claim

A U.S. arbitral tribunal rejects TC Energy's $15 billion claim to cancel the Keystone XL project, marking a crucial step in the dispute between the Canadian company and the U.S. government.

Share:

Comprehensive energy news coverage, updated nonstop

Annual subscription

8.25$/month*

*billed annually at 99$/year for the first year then 149,00$/year ​

Unlimited access • Archives included • Professional invoice

OTHER ACCESS OPTIONS

Monthly subscription

Unlimited access • Archives included

5.2$/month*
then 14.90$ per month thereafter

FREE ACCOUNT

3 articles offered per month

FREE

*Prices are excluding VAT, which may vary depending on your location or professional status

Since 2021: 35,000 articles • 150+ analyses per week

TC Energy, a Canadian company specializing in energy transmission, recently had its $15 billion claim rejected by an American arbitration tribunal. This claim followed the cancellation of the Keystone XL pipeline project by the U.S. government. The project, which was to transport 830,000 barrels of oil per day from Alberta to the U.S., was cancelled by President Joe Biden in 2021, shortly after the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) was terminated and replaced by the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement (U.S.-Mexico-Canada Agreement).
The court ruled that TC Energy did not have the authority to decide whether the revocation of the presidential permit violated NAFTA obligations. This decision is a major blow for the company, which had hoped to obtain compensation for lost investments and costs associated with the cancellation of the project.

TC Energy’s position

In an official statement, TC Energy expressed its disappointment at this decision, saying it does not correspond to their interpretation of the protections provided by NAFTA and the AEUMC. The company stressed that these agreements were intended to offer guarantees against such unilateral and unexpected actions by signatory governments.
Despite this decision, TC Energy continues to focus on its other energy infrastructure projects in North America, seeking to diversify and strengthen its operations in a context of global energy transition. The company is considering further legal action to obtain compensation.

Implications for the Energy Sector

The cancellation of Keystone XL and the rejection of TC Energy’s claim have major implications for the North American energy sector. The pipeline was destined to become a vital artery for transporting Canadian oil to U.S. refineries, but it met with fierce opposition from environmental groups and some local communities due to concerns about greenhouse gas emissions and the risk of spills.
This decision could discourage future investment in similar projects, as companies fear significant financial losses in the event of government policy changes. It also highlights the need for companies to adapt to a rapidly changing energy landscape, marked by growing demand for more sustainable, less polluting solutions.

Political and economic repercussions

Politically, this case reflects the tensions between Canada and the United States over energy and environmental policies. The Canadian government, notably the province of Alberta, had also initiated a commercial challenge to recoup its C$1.3 billion investment in the project.
Economically, the cancellation of Keystone XL represents a significant loss for TC Energy and its partners. However, it could also accelerate the transition to renewable energy sources, as investment shifts to cleaner technologies.
The arbitral tribunal’s decision marks a crucial step in the dispute between TC Energy and the US government, but it also leaves the door open to further legal action and discussions on the future of major energy infrastructure projects in North America.

Manila plans to expand gas and renewable energy production to meet a 6.6% increase in electricity demand over the next two years.
Ottawa and London increased bilateral exchanges to structure strategic cooperation on nuclear energy and critical minerals supply chains, as part of Canada’s G7 presidency.
Donald Trump says he secured Narendra Modi’s commitment to end Russian oil imports, adding political pressure to India-Russia trade relations.
Under intense diplomatic pressure from Washington, member states of the International Maritime Organization agreed to postpone by one year the adoption of a carbon pricing mechanism for global maritime transport.
Washington confirms it has mandated the CIA to carry out secret actions against Nicolas Maduro’s government, escalating tensions between the United States and Venezuela amid geostrategic and energy stakes.
Two European Parliament committees propose to advance the full halt of Russian hydrocarbon imports to 2026 and 2027, including oil, gas, and LNG, strengthening the European Union’s geopolitical position.
The COP30 conference hosted in the Amazon by Brazil faces low participation from global leaders, amid geopolitical tensions and major logistical challenges.
The United States has granted Trinidad and Tobago a special licence to resume negotiations with Venezuela on the Dragon gas field, partially lifting restrictions imposed on the Venezuelan energy sector.
Ambassadors of European Union member states have approved the transmission of a legislative proposal to phase out Russian fossil fuel imports by January 2028 to the Council of Ministers.
The State Duma has approved Russia’s formal withdrawal from a treaty signed with the United States on the elimination of military-grade plutonium, ending over two decades of strategic nuclear cooperation.
Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk said it was not in Poland’s interest to extradite to Germany a Ukrainian citizen suspected of taking part in the explosions that damaged the Nord Stream gas pipelines in 2022.
Al-Harfi and SCLCO signed agreements with Syrian authorities to develop solar and wind capacity, amid an ongoing energy rapprochement between Riyadh and Damascus.
Faced with risks to Middle Eastern supply chains, Thai and Japanese refiners are turning to US crude, backed by tariff incentives and strategies aligned with ongoing bilateral trade discussions.
France intercepted a tanker linked to Russian exports, prompting Emmanuel Macron to call for a coordinated European response to hinder vessels bypassing oil sanctions.
The activation of the snapback mechanism reinstates all UN sanctions on Iran, directly affecting the defence, financial and maritime trade sectors.
Commissioner Dan Jørgensen visits Greenland to expand energy ties with the European Union, amid plans to double EU funding for the 2028–2034 period.
European and Iranian foreign ministers meet in New York to try to prevent the reinstatement of UN sanctions linked to Tehran’s nuclear programme.
Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney announces a bilateral agreement with Mexico including targeted investments in energy corridors, logistics infrastructure and cross-border security.
The US president has called for an immediate end to Russian oil imports by NATO countries, denouncing a strategic contradiction as sanctions against Moscow are being considered.
Tehran withdrew a resolution denouncing attacks on its nuclear facilities, citing US pressure on IAEA members who feared suspension of Washington’s voluntary contributions.

All the latest energy news, all the time

Annual subscription

8.25$/month*

*billed annually at 99$/year for the first year then 149,00$/year ​

Unlimited access - Archives included - Pro invoice

Monthly subscription

Unlimited access • Archives included

5.2$/month*
then 14.90$ per month thereafter

*Prices shown are exclusive of VAT, which may vary according to your location or professional status.

Since 2021: 30,000 articles - +150 analyses/week.