popular articles

TotalEnergies : Complaint inadmissible for “complicity” in Ukraine

TotalEnergies escapes legal action in France for complicity in war crimes in Ukraine, following a dismissal on procedural grounds.
TotalEnergies plainte irrecevable Ukraine

Please share:

TotalEnergies has temporarily closed a legal front after the French courts declared inadmissible a complaint against the group for complicity in war crimes in Ukraine. This decision, taken by the senior investigating judge of the crimes against humanity division of the Paris judicial court, rejected the arguments of the Bordeaux-based NGO Darwin Climax Coalition and the Ukrainian Razom We Stand.

Details of legal proceedings

The plaintiff associations, whose aim was to obtain an embargo on fossil fuel imports from Russia, had their initial complaint rejected by the National Anti-Terrorist Prosecutor’s Office (Pnat) for “insufficiently characterized offences”. Despite an appeal, their new complaint was also rejected on procedural grounds, notably the failure to meet the five-year seniority requirement and the inappropriateness of the corporate purpose for this type of case.

Reactions and implications

The NGOs’ lawyers, William Bourdon and Vincent Brengarth, criticized the decision, calling it an “impediment” to civil action and emphasizing the evidence accumulated against TotalEnergies. They expressed their frustration at what they saw as obstruction of investigations into complicity in war crimes, despite the continuing Russian invasion of Ukraine.

TotalEnergies’ position

In response, a TotalEnergies spokesman said that the court ruling confirmed the Group’s position, arguing that the accusations were “devoid of any basis in law or fact”. The group also reiterated its efforts to comply with European sanctions, notably by ceasing production of kerosene for use by the Russian army and selling its shares in certain Russian operations.

Outlook and global context

This case is part of a wider context in which TotalEnergies has been one of the most exposed French groups in Russia in terms of energy. The Group has taken steps to reduce its involvement in Russia following the start of the conflict in Ukraine, but is maintaining certain contracts, such as that for the Yamal LNG gas field, for Europe’s energy security.

The outcome of this court case highlights the complexity of the legal and ethical issues associated with the international operations of major corporations in conflict zones. It also raises questions about the role of civil society in monitoring corporate activities abroad.

Register free of charge for uninterrupted access.

Publicite

Recently published in

To meet its climate targets, French industry will need to double its electricity consumption by 2050, reaching 207 TWh. This energy transition, essential for decarbonization, poses significant technological and economic challenges.
The 2025 budget, debated in Parliament, foresees a 2 billion euro increase for Energy Transition. Agnès Pannier-Runacher applauds additional amendments for industrial decarbonization and other key measures.
The 2025 budget, debated in Parliament, foresees a 2 billion euro increase for Energy Transition. Agnès Pannier-Runacher applauds additional amendments for industrial decarbonization and other key measures.
In 2024, France reaches an unprecedented level of electricity exports in 22 years, supported by increased nuclear and hydropower production and moderated domestic demand. A strategic success in the European energy market.
In 2024, France reaches an unprecedented level of electricity exports in 22 years, supported by increased nuclear and hydropower production and moderated domestic demand. A strategic success in the European energy market.
The Chinese vice premier announced revised commitments aimed at achieving carbon neutrality before 2060, while pledging increased financial contributions to support developing countries in addressing climate challenges.
The Chinese vice premier announced revised commitments aimed at achieving carbon neutrality before 2060, while pledging increased financial contributions to support developing countries in addressing climate challenges.
At COP29, Brazilian Environment Minister Marina Silva responded to the Azerbaijani president's remarks, advocating for the measured use of natural resources, especially oil, while affirming Brazil’s climate commitments.
Low Risk for France’s Electricity Supply This Winter, Says RTE
Low Risk for France’s Electricity Supply This Winter, Says RTE
At COP29 in Baku, the United Kingdom unveiled an ambitious plan to cut greenhouse gas emissions by 81% by 2035, asserting its leading role in global climate diplomacy.
At COP29 in Baku, the United Kingdom unveiled an ambitious plan to cut greenhouse gas emissions by 81% by 2035, asserting its leading role in global climate diplomacy.
The French government proposes a "rendezvous clause" to adjust the electricity tax increase, ensuring a 9% decrease in regulated electricity bills for the majority of households by February 2025.
The French government proposes a "rendezvous clause" to adjust the electricity tax increase, ensuring a 9% decrease in regulated electricity bills for the majority of households by February 2025.
Thai authorities have dismantled nine illegal Bitcoin mining farms accused of stealing over €270,000 worth of electricity. Two suspects have been arrested for large-scale energy fraud.
On the eve of a possible Trump presidency, the United States seeks to reassure its partners on its climate commitment at COP29, amidst North-South tensions and a debate on financial aid for developing countries.
On the eve of a possible Trump presidency, the United States seeks to reassure its partners on its climate commitment at COP29, amidst North-South tensions and a debate on financial aid for developing countries.
Two environmental NGOs are challenging in Scottish court the authorization to drill in the Rosebank and Jackdaw oil and gas fields in the North Sea, denouncing their impact on the UK's climate objectives.
Two environmental NGOs are challenging in Scottish court the authorization to drill in the Rosebank and Jackdaw oil and gas fields in the North Sea, denouncing their impact on the UK's climate objectives.
The German energy sector urges the government to pass key reforms before the planned dissolution of parliament in January, fearing prolonged gridlock following the coalition's collapse.
The German energy sector urges the government to pass key reforms before the planned dissolution of parliament in January, fearing prolonged gridlock following the coalition's collapse.
The White House completes its oil purchasing program to replenish strategic reserves, marking the end of a controversial initiative aimed at strengthening energy security after massive releases in 2022.
As a contender to host COP31, Australia is pushing for ambitious climate commitments at COP29 in Azerbaijan, while promoting green hydrogen initiatives for Asian markets.
As a contender to host COP31, Australia is pushing for ambitious climate commitments at COP29 in Azerbaijan, while promoting green hydrogen initiatives for Asian markets.
France: uncertainties surrounding the future Nuclear Safety Authority scheduled for January
France: uncertainties surrounding the future Nuclear Safety Authority scheduled for January
China has ratified an ambitious legislation aimed at promoting carbon neutrality and framing sustainable energy development in response to growing climate challenges.
China has ratified an ambitious legislation aimed at promoting carbon neutrality and framing sustainable energy development in response to growing climate challenges.
Brazil has increased its greenhouse gas reduction target from 59% to 67% by 2035 as part of its commitment to the Paris Agreement.
In response to a fuel shortage threatening the power plants, Iran has announced electricity rationing in Tehran and several provinces. The duration of this measure remains unknown.
In response to a fuel shortage threatening the power plants, Iran has announced electricity rationing in Tehran and several provinces. The duration of this measure remains unknown.
Voters in Washington rejected Initiative 2117, ensuring the continuation of the carbon market established in 2021. This decision could drive up carbon allowance prices.
Voters in Washington rejected Initiative 2117, ensuring the continuation of the carbon market established in 2021. This decision could drive up carbon allowance prices.
Donald Trump's election in the United States, with his open climate skepticism, could reverse American environmental commitments, jeopardizing global climate goals and increasing greenhouse gas emissions.
Donald Trump's election in the United States, with his open climate skepticism, could reverse American environmental commitments, jeopardizing global climate goals and increasing greenhouse gas emissions.
The recent U.S. elections could reshape energy policies, influencing global markets, trade relations, and climate commitments. The opposing candidates’ positions, between protecting fossil industries and promoting clean energy, outline divergent prospects.
A new report from the International Energy Agency reveals that Namibia could boost its socioeconomic development by capitalizing on its renewable resources, provided effective support policies are implemented.
A new report from the International Energy Agency reveals that Namibia could boost its socioeconomic development by capitalizing on its renewable resources, provided effective support policies are implemented.
Amid concerns over potential job cuts, approximately 10% of GRDF employees mobilized in response to a call from the CGT, denouncing a plan to reduce payroll, affecting thousands of jobs.
Amid concerns over potential job cuts, approximately 10% of GRDF employees mobilized in response to a call from the CGT, denouncing a plan to reduce payroll, affecting thousands of jobs.
The French operator RTE is investing nearly one billion euros to acquire 5,000 km of underground cables from five European cable suppliers to modernize and strengthen its high-voltage electricity network.
The French operator RTE is investing nearly one billion euros to acquire 5,000 km of underground cables from five European cable suppliers to modernize and strengthen its high-voltage electricity network.

Advertising