The French Constitutional Council rules on the Cigéo Project

The French Constitutional Council rules on the Cigéo project for nuclear waste burial at Bure, which puts at stake the rights of future generations and the balance between the environment and industrial sovereignty.
Projet CIGEO

Partagez:

In a landmark decision for environmental protection, the French Constitutional Council on Friday ruled on the rights of future generations invoked by opponents of the Cigéo project to bury the most radioactive waste from nuclear power plants in Bure (Meuse).

The Cigéo project for geological disposal 500 meters underground has already reached a number of milestones, despite having been contested for over twenty years. However, it has been validated by the government, which declared it to be in the public interest in 2022.

Appeals against the project

The latest appeal: the declaration of public utility has been challenged before the Conseil d’État by local residents, 14 local and 7 national organizations, including Attac, France Nature Environnement, Greenpeace and “Sortir du nucléaire”. This appeal provided the opportunity to submit a Question prioritaire de Constitutionnalité (QPC) to the French Constitutional Council, in order to verify whether the planned waste treatment method in the Bure clay subsoil complies with constitutional principles, namely those set out in the preamble to the 2005 Charter of the Environment.

What’s at stake?

The issue is crucial: “This may have consequences for the authorization of new projects, which will be assessed on the basis of their immediate and future consequences”, argues environmental lawyer Vincent Brenot, a partner at August Debouzy, who usually defends industrialists, but is not involved in this case. “There’s a subtle balance to be found on the part of the Constitutional Council”, he says, “because we’re both in a period when we’re very attentive to the environment and in the midst of a quest to regain our industrial sovereignty”.

Shelf life of waste

When it comes to landfilling waste, the principle imposed by French legislation is to ensure the reversibility of the storage method, for at least several decades, during which time it must be possible to change the method or recover the waste. Yet, argue the petitioners, the considerable period of time – up to hundreds of thousands of years – during which the most toxic waste must be stored before radiation returns to safe levels far exceeds this duration, and mortgages the rights of future generations.

The challenges of solidarity and fraternity

As future generations do not exist, our reasoning is based on our obligations of solidarity and fraternity towards them. The Constitutional Council will have to decide to what extent.

Next steps in the project

France has three surface disposal centers, two in Aube and one in La Manche, which can store 90% of the radioactive waste produced in the country. The most radioactive nuclear waste – high-intensity, long-lived waste – could be stored by 2035-2040 in the clay subsoil at Bure, on the borders of the Meuse and Haute-Marne departments. The site could accommodate at least 83,000 m3, like Finland’s Onkalo repository, designed to house the spent fuel produced by the country’s five reactors over their entire lifetime. Like every nuclear site, Cigéo will undergo a double technical examination by the French nuclear safety authority (ASN) and IRSN, the institute that monitors nuclear risk, which will take around three years.

For the time being, Andra’s Meuse site only houses a scientific laboratory, and no radioactive waste is stored there. The project gave rise to numerous protests. On September 2, a demonstration was again held under heavy surveillance, bringing together several hundred people, including local residents and anti-nuclear activists of various nationalities (French, Germans, Swiss, Brazilians, Colombians), to denounce the government’s “forced passage”.

Russia declares itself ready to retrieve and transform Iran’s excess nuclear materials into fuel, a proposal aimed at easing tense nuclear negotiations between Iran and the United States.
The Moscow Arbitration Court postpones by nine months the trial initiated by Rosatom against Fortum and Outokumpu, seeking nearly three billion dollars following the controversial cancellation of a nuclear project in Finland.
The UK regulator has accepted to examine Newcleo’s advanced LFR-AS-200 reactor, marking a first for a modular lead-cooled technology in the country.
Framatome strengthens its control over the nuclear supply chain by acquiring a 40% stake in Selectarc, France’s sole producer of welding filler metals.
Orano USA has opened a new office in Oak Ridge, Tennessee, to lead the development of a uranium enrichment facility, marking one of the largest industrial investments in the state’s history.
AtkinsRéalis and EDF signed a strategic agreement to integrate their expertise in nuclear engineering, equipment and waste management, while preserving each country’s technological sovereignty.
The British government officially commits £14.2 billion to develop two EPR nuclear reactors in eastern England, in strategic partnership with the French group EDF, with a final investment decision expected shortly.
The International Atomic Energy Agency confirmed that confidential documents were acquired by Iran, raising concerns about the country’s cooperation with the agency.
A new law extends the operational lifespan of nuclear reactors in Japan, enabling them to run past 60 years to meet rising energy demand and reduce reliance on fossil fuels.
Westinghouse plans to invest $75 billion in ten nuclear reactors in the United States, responding to a presidential order aimed at significantly accelerating the expansion of nuclear energy in the country by 2030.
The United States blocks export licenses for nuclear equipment to China, amplifying bilateral trade tensions already marked by strategic technology restrictions and possible retaliatory measures.
Russia requests IAEA intervention to resolve the deadlock involving American nuclear fuel at the Zaporizhzhia nuclear plant, a critical issue for the potential restart of the site currently under Russian control.
NANO Nuclear Energy has appointed Intel executive and former U.S. Department of Energy leader Seth Berl as an independent director to support its strategy in advanced nuclear technologies.
The Cour des comptes is calling on the French government to speed up efforts to locate storage sites for over 280,000 m³ of long-lived radioactive waste, which currently lacks an operational solution.
The French National Assembly’s Economic Affairs Committee mistakenly rejects a crucial article on France's nuclear strategy, causing significant parliamentary confusion and casting doubt on the country’s energy targets.
Czech court authorizes major $18 billion nuclear project, allowing Korea Hydro & Nuclear Power to proceed with the construction of a controversial power plant despite legal challenges.
Italy’s Ansaldo Energia signed a memorandum of understanding with Uzbekistan’s Uzatom agency to cooperate on advanced nuclear technologies, with a focus on small modular reactors.
The US Nuclear Regulatory Commission has approved the uprated version of NuScale’s small modular reactor, paving the way for commercial deployment of compact nuclear projects in the United States.
Korea Hydro & Nuclear Power signed a 26-month contract to assess a site in Uganda’s Buyende region for its first nuclear reactor, in compliance with International Atomic Energy Agency standards.
EDF is challenging the legality of the nuclear contract awarded to KHNP, citing potential South Korean state support in violation of EU rules, leading to a temporary suspension of the Dukovany II project.