Tax rebates in Luxembourg: Engie scores a point before the European Court of Justice

Engie wins a victory against the European Commission in a dispute over controversial tax benefits granted in Luxembourg. The CJEU is expected to issue a ruling at a later date following the Advocate General's proposal to annul the European Commission's decision.

Share:

A judge at the Court of Justice of the EU (CJEU) ruled Thursday in favor of French energy company Engie in a dispute with Brussels over controversial tax rebates in Luxembourg worth €120 million.

Advocate General Juliane Kokott proposed to the judges of the CJEU to annul the decision of the European Commission which considered tax benefits granted to Engie as illegal state aid, according to a statement from the Luxembourg-based court. The CJEU ruling will be issued at a later date and the judges who are to deliberate in the case are not bound by the Advocate General’s findings, it says.

Brussels had opened an in-depth investigation in September 2016 into “two financial arrangements” that allowed Engie to partially evade taxes in Luxembourg. This investigation was aimed at tax agreements signed in 2008 and 2010 by the Grand Duchy with the energy company, for the benefit of two companies of the group established in the country: Engie LNG Supply and Engie Treasury Management.

In June 2018, the European Commission had concluded that the Engie group had benefited from illegal tax advantages in Luxembourg and demanded that the Grand Duchy recover €120 million from the company of which the French state is the largest shareholder. Engie and Luxembourg had initially referred the matter to the European Court of First Instance, which ruled in favor of the Commission and rejected their appeals. They then filed an appeal with the Court of Justice, which is currently under review.

The European Commission has already suffered a series of defeats in similar cases. The car manufacturer Fiat (Stellantis group) obtained in November from the CJEU the annulment of a decision of Brussels which demanded that it reimburse 30 million euros of tax benefits to Luxembourg. The Commission also lost to Apple, Amazon and Starbucks in other tax disputes in Ireland, Luxembourg and the Netherlands.

British firm Octopus Energy is considering a £10 billion spin-off of Kraken Technologies, involving an upcoming minority stake sale, and has initiated preliminary discussions with banks to oversee the strategic operation within the next year.
Investment fund Ardian finalises its takeover of Akuo and appoints former Électricité de France executive Bruno Bensasson to steer the renewable-energy developer’s growth towards five gigawatts of installed capacity by 2030.
TotalEnergies is selling half of a 604 MW Portuguese energy portfolio to the Japanese consortium MM Capital, Daiwa Energy and Mizuho Leasing for €178.5mn, retaining operation and future commercialisation of the assets concerned.
Q ENERGY France secures a bank financing of €109 million arranged by BPCE Energeco to build four new energy production facilities, totalling 55 MW of wind and solar capacity by the end of 2024.
Shell announces amendment of two annual reports after notification by Ernst & Young of non-compliance with SEC auditor partner rotation rules; however, financial statements remain unchanged.
The Financial Superintendency of Colombia approves an amendment to Ecopetrol’s local bonds and commercial paper program, enabling issuance of sustainable, indexed, or in-kind repayable instruments.
ABO Energy is selling its subsidiary ABO Energy Hellas and an energy project portfolio of approximately 1.5 gigawatts to HELLENiQ ENERGY Holdings, thus refocusing its strategic resources towards other markets, notably Germany, without major financial impact anticipated for 2025.
Iberdrola announces a supplementary dividend of €0.409 per share for 2024 under the "Iberdrola Retribución Flexible" programme, bringing the total annual remuneration to €0.645 per share, representing a year-on-year increase of 15.6%.
BHP has signed contracts with COSCO Shipping to charter two ammonia-powered Newcastlemax bulk carriers, primarily for transporting iron ore between Western Australia and Northeast Asia starting from 2028.
CBAK Energy and Anker Innovations jointly launch a battery cell manufacturing facility in Malaysia, with a commercial potential estimated at $357 million, further strengthening their strategic partnership in the lithium-ion battery sector.
German energy group Badenova plans to invest $4.64 billion in its energy networks and capacity by 2050, including $232 million committed from 2025, according to the company's recently published annual financial results.
ORIX announces the sale of the majority of its stake in Greenko to AM Green Power and commits a new USD 731mn investment in the Luxembourg-based AMG holding, confirming its strategic repositioning in next-generation energy.
Invenergy seals four further contracts with Meta to supply nearly eight hundred megawatts of solar and wind power to the group’s data centres, lifting total cooperation between the two companies to one point eight gigawatts.
Pedro Azagra leaves his role as CEO of Avangrid to become CEO of Iberdrola, while Jose Antonio Miranda and Kimberly Harriman succeed him as CEO and Deputy CEO respectively of the American subsidiary.
The US investment fund Ares Management enters Plenitude's capital by acquiring a 20% stake from Eni, valuing the Italian company at 10 billion euros and reinforcing its integrated energy strategy.
ENGIE secures a contract to reduce Airbus' industrial emissions in France, Germany, and Spain, targeting an 85% decrease by 2030 through various local energy infrastructures.
Alain Rhéaume, Chairman of Boralex’s Board of Directors for eight years, will leave his position by December, following the appointment of his successor by the governance committee of the Canadian energy group.
Norwegian group Statkraft plans an annual cost reduction of NOK2.9bn ($292 million) by 2027, citing possible job cuts amid rising financial burdens and volatility in the European energy market.
EDF merges EDF Renouvelables and its International Division into EDF power solutions, led by Béatrice Buffon, to optimise its global 31 GW low-carbon energy portfolio and strengthen its international positioning.
TotalEnergies announces a strategic partnership with Mistral AI to establish a dedicated innovation laboratory integrating artificial intelligence tools aimed at enhancing industrial efficiency, research, and customer relations.