popular articles

Russian oil cap, a risky bet?

Moscow, despite Western sanctions, continues to export its hydrocarbons. Since the beginning of the invasion of Ukraine, Russia has earned 158 billion dollars. The G7 then aims to introduce a cap on the price of Russian oil, in the hope of curbing Putin.

Please share:

The Russian oil price cap is being debated. In fact, the G7 is advocating a cap on Russian oil to limit Moscow’s ability to finance its war. Invoked in order to put pressure on a Russian state using the current energy crisis, its implementation raises questions.

While the decline in Europe’s dependence on Russian oil has made it possible to consider this measure, many pitfalls remain. The possibility of reprisals from Moscow weighs heavily in the balance, especially for the most exposed countries. In this context, China and India hold, in part, the keys to the success of this risky G7 gamble.

It is difficult to know whether the desire to exert financial pressure on Russia will bear fruit or whether it will, on the contrary, lead to a potential acceleration of the global recession. The surge in energy prices has largely benefited Russia, whose fossil fuel exports have brought in $158 billion since the war began, according to the Centre for Research on Energy and Clean Air (CREA).

The series of sanctions adopted by the EU clearly shows its limits, in the short term. The EU now wants to limit its dependence on fossil fuels and adopt more restrictive measures towards Russia.

A Europe less dependent on Russian hydrocarbons

The invasion of Ukraine has acted as an indicator of the EU’s energy fragility. According to Eurostat, Europe imported 58% of its fossil energy resources in 2020. In the first half of 2021, Russia supplied 48.4% of the gas and 25.4% of the oil imported by the Europeans.

The EU, faced with an unprecedented energy crisis following the invasion of Ukraine, has therefore set about reducing its energy dependence. This is demonstrated by the REpowerEU program devoted to the Union’s energy independence, adopted a few weeks after the beginning of the conflict.

Russian crude oil imports reached 1.7 million barrels per day compared to 2.6 million per barrel in January. The decline is significant, even though theEU remains the largest market for Russian crude according to the IEA. Imports from the United States replaced 800,000 barrels of Russian imports, while Norway supplied about one-third of the demand.

Nevertheless, the implementation of the Russian oil price cap is proving to be particularly complex.

Cap level and marine insurance

The success of the Russian oil price cap mechanism depends mainly on meeting a certain threshold. The Russian oil barrel is already selling at deep discounts of 30 to 40 dollars.

If it is too low, the cap could lead to retaliation by the Russians, who would halt some production, resulting in an overall increase in the price of crude. If it is too high, Russia will continue to benefit from redirecting its oil out of Europe at the current price.

Ehsan Khoman, MUFG’s head of emerging markets, confirms the importance of the Russian oil price cap:

“If the cap is close to the cost of production, it is comparable to an embargo and Russia will not sell its oil for free but will set it at the market price.”

The cap on the price of Russian oil is also based on the ban on insurers covering the transportation of black gold. A waiver would be granted to purchasers, provided that the prices charged are at or below the cap. Europeans represent 90 to 95% of the players in this marine insurance market and hope to ensure that this measure is respected as much as possible.

The decline in the value of Russian oil exports

Lowering the value of Russian exports is thus the priority of the US-led coalition. The G7 seems to be betting that Russia will favor redirecting its oil to Asia rather than stopping production. In fact, energy exports account for more than half of the Russian government’s budget.

It is unlikely that China and India will go along with the Russian oil price cap. If the attempt to deprive Putin of his oil revenues is successful, a large contingent of Asian consumers would be likely to buy larger quantities of cheap Russian crude.

In this case, Asian refiners would have additional leverage to negotiate prices downwards. The United States hopes that this cap will increase the reduction of Russian crude prices on the market.

The pitfall of circumvention measures

The success of the Russian oil price cap relies on the G7’s ability to rally beyond its coalition. This strategy has already shown its limits in the context of sanctions. In addition, Putin has already announced that he will stop oil exports to countries imposing a cap.

The conditions for redirecting oil exports to Russia’s allied countries are thus of paramount importance. Possible circumvention of maritime insurance by China and India would also complicate the effectiveness of the measure. China would indeed be likely to accept Russian insurance, as would India.

However, trade constraints in Asian markets may favor the G7 plan. Oil demand in the Chinese market has slowed due to repeated lock-ups. Platts Analytics expects China’s oil demand to fall to 95,000 barrels per day, a 0.6% decline.

In addition, Russian crude oil exports to India and China have more than doubled since the conflict began. As a result, the ability of refiners to process higher volumes of Russian oil is now limited.

The cap on the price of Russian oil, while it may reduce Moscow’s oil revenues, remains a measure with uncertain results. The impact of the measure depends largely on the line taken by Russia’s allies and the extent to which the Kremlin’s resident will go.

Register free of charge for uninterrupted access.

Publicite

Recently published in

European Commissioner Dan Jørgensen is in Baku to reaffirm energy cooperation with Azerbaijan, focusing on the expansion of the gas corridor and regional green energy projects.
German Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock ruled out any possibility of reactivating the Nord Stream 2 pipeline, shut down since 2022, despite discussions mentioned by Russia and growing pressure on energy supply.
German Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock ruled out any possibility of reactivating the Nord Stream 2 pipeline, shut down since 2022, despite discussions mentioned by Russia and growing pressure on energy supply.
The United States has sanctioned a Chinese refinery processing Iranian crude, increasing pressure on Tehran and raising concerns over global oil market stability.
The United States has sanctioned a Chinese refinery processing Iranian crude, increasing pressure on Tehran and raising concerns over global oil market stability.
The United States has cancelled oil operation authorisations in Venezuela for foreign companies, disrupting exports and reinforcing the country's economic isolation following Nicolás Maduro's contested re-election.
The United States has cancelled oil operation authorisations in Venezuela for foreign companies, disrupting exports and reinforcing the country's economic isolation following Nicolás Maduro's contested re-election.
The Algerian energy group Sonelgaz is offering its technical expertise to Burkina Faso to strengthen its electrical infrastructure, illustrating Algeria's strategic intention to consolidate its presence in sub-Saharan Africa’s energy markets.
Washington again delays the enforcement of sanctions against NIS, the Serbian energy company controlled by Gazprom, extending the status quo until the end of April according to Serbian President Aleksandar Vucic.
Washington again delays the enforcement of sanctions against NIS, the Serbian energy company controlled by Gazprom, extending the status quo until the end of April according to Serbian President Aleksandar Vucic.
The United States has strengthened its support for Guyana amid Venezuela’s claims over the Essequibo, warning Caracas of a military response in case of aggression targeting the territory or American oil interests.
The United States has strengthened its support for Guyana amid Venezuela’s claims over the Essequibo, warning Caracas of a military response in case of aggression targeting the territory or American oil interests.
No attacks on energy installations have been reported since a partial agreement announced by the United States, marking a pause in hostilities targeting critical infrastructure.
No attacks on energy installations have been reported since a partial agreement announced by the United States, marking a pause in hostilities targeting critical infrastructure.
During a visit to Guyana, U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio announced that any Venezuelan attack on the territory or oil infrastructure of Guyana would trigger a military response, heightening regional tensions.
US Secretary of State Marco Rubio launches meetings with Caribbean leaders to discuss energy security, trade pressures and regional instability, including in Haiti and Guyana.
US Secretary of State Marco Rubio launches meetings with Caribbean leaders to discuss energy security, trade pressures and regional instability, including in Haiti and Guyana.
Hungary’s Foreign Minister travelled to Moscow for talks with Russian authorities on energy security, reinforcing a strategic energy partnership already bolstered by record gas and oil deliveries in 2024.
Hungary’s Foreign Minister travelled to Moscow for talks with Russian authorities on energy security, reinforcing a strategic energy partnership already bolstered by record gas and oil deliveries in 2024.
Donald Trump imposes 25% tariffs against importers of Venezuelan oil, particularly targeting China, which has already condemned an infringement on its economic sovereignty, signaling increased tensions in global energy markets.
Donald Trump imposes 25% tariffs against importers of Venezuelan oil, particularly targeting China, which has already condemned an infringement on its economic sovereignty, signaling increased tensions in global energy markets.
The planned visit of senior US officials to Greenland sparks political backlash in Nuuk, as no new government has been formed since the 11 March elections.
Starting 2 April, the United States will apply a 25% customs duty on all goods from countries trading with Venezuela’s oil or gas sector, Donald Trump announced.
Starting 2 April, the United States will apply a 25% customs duty on all goods from countries trading with Venezuela’s oil or gas sector, Donald Trump announced.
Washington imposes sanctions on Luqing Petrochemical, the first independent Chinese refinery targeted for its alleged ties to Iranian oil, as part of its intensified economic pressure campaign against Tehran.
Washington imposes sanctions on Luqing Petrochemical, the first independent Chinese refinery targeted for its alleged ties to Iranian oil, as part of its intensified economic pressure campaign against Tehran.
A Panama-flagged vessel suspected of belonging to the Russian shadow fleet was detained by German customs after suffering an engine failure in the Baltic Sea in January.
A Panama-flagged vessel suspected of belonging to the Russian shadow fleet was detained by German customs after suffering an engine failure in the Baltic Sea in January.
Amidst war and geopolitical uncertainty, Ukraine must choose between European influence and the strategic promises of the United States, a choice that could redefine its economic and security future, particularly in terms of natural resources.
As Russian gas deliveries via Nord Stream have ceased, Europe is exploring possible solutions to repurpose or replace this major infrastructure within a complex energy transition and diversification of supply sources.
As Russian gas deliveries via Nord Stream have ceased, Europe is exploring possible solutions to repurpose or replace this major infrastructure within a complex energy transition and diversification of supply sources.
Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin are set to discuss the sharing of rare earth resources in Ukraine on Tuesday, including energy production plants and territories rich in raw materials. These resources are at the heart of the ceasefire negotiations.
Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin are set to discuss the sharing of rare earth resources in Ukraine on Tuesday, including energy production plants and territories rich in raw materials. These resources are at the heart of the ceasefire negotiations.
UK Energy Minister Ed Miliband met Chinese officials in Beijing to discuss energy cooperation and reducing greenhouse gas emissions, despite disagreements over Hong Kong, forced labour, and the war in Ukraine.
UK Energy Minister Ed Miliband met Chinese officials in Beijing to discuss energy cooperation and reducing greenhouse gas emissions, despite disagreements over Hong Kong, forced labour, and the war in Ukraine.
American and Vietnamese companies have signed several commercial agreements totaling $4.15 billion, primarily in the energy and aviation sectors, aiming to reduce the trade imbalance between the two countries.
Presidents Vladimir Putin and Nicolás Maduro announced an agreement to expand their cooperation, particularly in the energy sector. This initiative comes amid increased U.S. sanctions against Caracas.
Presidents Vladimir Putin and Nicolás Maduro announced an agreement to expand their cooperation, particularly in the energy sector. This initiative comes amid increased U.S. sanctions against Caracas.
A tripartite meeting between China, Russia and Iran will be held in Beijing to address the Iranian nuclear dossier as tensions surrounding Iran's nuclear programme continue to rise.
A tripartite meeting between China, Russia and Iran will be held in Beijing to address the Iranian nuclear dossier as tensions surrounding Iran's nuclear programme continue to rise.
Guyana’s President, Mohamed Irfaan Ali, reaffirmed his commitment to a diplomatic resolution of the territorial dispute with Venezuela over the Essequibo region as tensions escalate over offshore oil resources.
Guyana’s President, Mohamed Irfaan Ali, reaffirmed his commitment to a diplomatic resolution of the territorial dispute with Venezuela over the Essequibo region as tensions escalate over offshore oil resources.

Advertising