Russia threatens to take the Nord Stream explosions case to the International Court of Justice

Moscow is ramping up pressure on the investigations into the Nord Stream pipeline explosions, accusing Germany, Denmark, and Sweden of not meeting their obligations under international conventions.

Partagez:

Since the September 2022 explosions that damaged the Nord Stream 1 and 2 pipelines, Russia has repeatedly accused the West, particularly the United States and the United Kingdom, while calling for a transparent investigation. These pipelines, which transported Russian gas to Germany via the Baltic Sea, were critical to Russia’s energy policy, enabling it to bypass land routes, particularly those crossing Ukraine and Poland.

The Kremlin has leveraged this incident to intensify its rhetoric against the West, citing a lack of transparency in ongoing investigations. Maria Zakharova, spokesperson for the Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs, recently announced that Russia is considering taking the matter to the International Court of Justice (ICJ), based on the 1997 Convention for the Suppression of Terrorist Bombings and the 1999 Convention on the Suppression of the Financing of Terrorism. This announcement follows what Moscow calls a “Western attempt to cover up” a sabotage that compromised strategic infrastructure.

Russia’s accusations and ongoing investigations

European authorities launched investigations, but the results have not identified the perpetrators. Germany issued an arrest warrant for a Ukrainian citizen, Volodymyr Z., suspected of being one of the key actors in the attack. Media reports indicate that this suspect fled Poland to Ukraine shortly after the warrant was issued. This complicates the legal procedures, and both Danish and Swedish investigations have closed without identifying any suspects.

Additionally, recent information from the Financial Times suggests that elements of the German investigation indicate that Volodymyr Z. acted with other accomplices. These reports, based on anonymous sources close to the investigation, suggest that the saboteurs had pre-planned the attack, using professional diving techniques to place underwater explosives at critical points along the pipelines.

Impact on Russia-EU energy relations

The impact of these explosions goes beyond material damage. The Nord Stream pipelines were essential for gas transit to Europe, and their destruction marked a turning point in energy relations between Russia and the EU. Before the attack, Germany relied on Nord Stream 1 to secure its energy needs, while Nord Stream 2, newly built, had not yet started operations. These infrastructures were seen by Moscow as strategic geopolitical tools, enabling Russia to bypass traditional routes through Ukraine and reduce the influence of transit countries.

The destruction of the pipelines forced Europe to seek other energy supply sources, increasing its dependence on liquefied natural gas (LNG) imports from the United States and Qatar. Germany, the main client of these infrastructures, has also accelerated efforts to strengthen the resilience of its energy network. However, these adjustments come at a high economic cost and do not fully compensate for the losses since the halt of Russian gas flows.

Legal and diplomatic prospects

Bringing this case before the International Court of Justice could have significant diplomatic consequences. If Russia proves that European countries did not meet their obligations, it could affect the legitimacy of future investigations into similar incidents. However, such a procedure can take years and depends on the recognition of the ICJ’s jurisdiction by the concerned parties, further complicating the situation.

In the meantime, Moscow maintains pressure, claiming that the Nord Stream explosions were planned by Western intelligence services, accusations that the United States and the United Kingdom continue to firmly deny. Russia is also using this issue to strengthen its ties with non-European partners, such as China, and to develop new export routes to Asia to compensate for its energy revenue losses in Europe.

Belgrade is currently finalising a new gas contract with Russia, promising Europe's lowest tariff, according to Srbijagas General Director Dusan Bajatovic, despite Europe's aim to eliminate Russian imports by 2027.
TotalEnergies and QatarEnergy have won the Ahara exploration licence, marking a new stage in their partnership with SONATRACH on a vast area located between Berkine and Illizi.
After four years of interruption due to regional insecurity, TotalEnergies announces the upcoming resumption of its liquefied natural gas project in Mozambique, representing a $20bn investment.
Hungary, supported by Slovakia, strongly expresses opposition to the European Commission's plan to phase out imports of Russian energy resources, citing major economic and energy impacts for Central Europe.
The French group has acquired from PETRONAS stakes in several licences covering more than 100,000 km² off Malaysia and Indonesia, consolidating its Asian presence and its exposure to the liquefied natural gas market.
Israeli military strikes on Iran's Natanz nuclear site destroyed critical electrical infrastructure but did not reach strategic underground facilities, according to the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA).
In response to rising summer electricity consumption, Egypt signs import agreements covering 290 shipments of liquefied natural gas, involving major international firms, with financial terms adjusted to the country’s economic constraints.
The French president travels to Nuuk on 15 June to support Greenlandic sovereignty, review energy projects and respond to recent US pressure, according to the Élysée.
Egyptian fertilizer producers suspended their activities due to reduced imports of Israeli gas, following recent production halts at Israel's Leviathan and Karish gas fields after Israeli strikes in Iran.
Kazakhstan has selected Rosatom and China National Nuclear Corporation to build two nuclear power plants totaling 2.4 GW, a decision following a favorable referendum and coinciding with Xi Jinping’s upcoming strategic visit.
Israeli strikes against Iranian nuclear sites disrupt US-Iranian talks on the nuclear deal. Tehran now considers canceling the upcoming negotiation round in Oman, heightening regional economic concerns.
A report identifies 130 gas power plant projects in Texas that could raise emissions to 115 million tonnes per year, despite analysts forecasting limited short-term realisation.
Facing alarming breaches of uranium enrichment thresholds by Iran and explicit existential threats, Israel launches targeted military strikes against Iranian nuclear infrastructure, escalating regional tensions dramatically.
Japanese giant JERA will significantly increase its reliance on US liquefied natural gas through major new contracts, reaching 30% of its supplies within roughly ten years.
Sustained growth in U.S. liquefied natural gas exports is leading to significant price increases projected for 2025 and 2026, as supply struggles to keep pace with steadily rising demand, according to recent forecasts.
Shell is expanding its global Liquefied Natural Gas (LNG) capacities, primarily targeting markets in Asia and North America, to meet rising demand anticipated by the end of the decade.
Above-average summer temperatures in Asia are significantly boosting demand for American liquefied natural gas, offsetting a potential slowdown in Europe and opening new commercial opportunities for U.S. exporters.
Duke Energy plans a strategic investment in a natural gas power plant in Anderson, marking its first request for new electricity generation in South Carolina in over ten years.
Adnoc Gas commits $5bn to the first phase of its Rich Gas Development project to boost profitability and processing capacity at four strategic sites in the United Arab Emirates.
The European Commission aims to prevent any return of Russian gas via Nord Stream and Nord Stream 2 with a total transaction ban, part of its 18th sanctions package against Moscow.