popular articles

Rising carbon prices in regulated markets, vagueness on voluntary markets

Regulated carbon markets saw their prices rise in August, while the voluntary market faced difficulties linked to the quality of credits and a lack of liquidity.

Please share:

Carbon prices are on an upward trajectory in regulated markets, notably in Europe and the USA, supported by robust demand and supply constraints.
Meanwhile, the voluntary carbon market is struggling to gain ground due to the slow adoption of high integrity standards and a persistent lack of liquidity.
The widening gap between these two market segments reflects contrasting dynamics, influenced by distinct structural and regulatory factors.

Regulated markets boosted by demand and geopolitical tensions

In August, prices for European Union Emissions Trading Scheme (EU ETS) allowances hit record highs, driven by steady demand from the energy and industrial sectors.
The rise was also fuelled by geopolitical tensions in Ukraine and the Middle East, which strengthened the gas market, directly influencing the price of EU Allowances (EUA).
This close correlation between natural gas prices and European carbon allowance prices highlights the EU ETS’s dependence on regional energy stability.
In the United States, the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI) recorded record prices of $27.47 per allowance in mid-August, ahead of the third-quarter auction.
These increases are attributable to demand exceeding established emissions caps, coupled with a depletion of available allowance reserves since the first quarter of the year.
Analysts expect this tight market situation to persist over the next two years, with average prices projected at $22.9 per allowance in 2024.

The structural challenges of the voluntary carbon market

The voluntary carbon market, on the other hand, faces significant challenges.
Carbon credits from renewable energy projects, for example, saw their prices fall in August to a low of $1.327 per metric tonne of CO2 equivalent.
This was due to the failure of the Integrity Council for Voluntary Carbon Markets to endorse the high-integrity Core Carbon Principles (CCP), due to concerns about project additionality.
The slow adoption of these integrity standards is creating uncertainty among investors and market players, slowing the development of new projects.
Despite the drop in prices, renewable energy projects continued to lead credit issuance on the voluntary market for the month of August, with 16.9 million metric tons of credits issued.
This figure is down on the 21.4 million metric tons recorded in July, indicating a stagnation in demand.
This slowdown highlights the need to clarify credit quality criteria in order to restore buyer confidence.

Expectations and prospects for better regulation of the voluntary market

Lack of clarity on CCP labelling criteria remains a major obstacle to the growth of the voluntary market.
According to industry experts, the Integrity Council for Voluntary Carbon Markets (ICVCM) is struggling to define universally recognized standards, which is delaying the development of high-quality credits.
Several project methodologies, such as improved forest management (REDD+), afforestation, reforestation and revegetation, are awaiting approval to receive the CCP label.
Market players are hopeful that this slowness will be overcome, and that new credit categories will see the light of day by the end of the year.
Speaking on the sidelines of the Innovate 4 Climate conference in Berlin, Hania Dawood, Head of Climate Finance and Economics at the World Bank, emphasized that the market is beginning to unite around the Core Carbon Principles.
However, she warns that the process of adopting these principles and establishing effective governance will remain significant challenges in the years to come.

The need for structural reform to ensure credibility

For the voluntary carbon market to grow sustainably, structural reform is needed to ensure the credibility and integrity of credits.
High-quality criteria need to be clarified and uniformly applied to avoid practices that compromise the additionality and climate efficiency of projects.
This transformation could create a more predictable market environment, boosting investor confidence and diversifying the range of credits available.
The long-term prospects for the carbon market, whether regulated or voluntary, depend largely on the ability of regulators and stakeholders to adapt to new economic and geopolitical realities.
Effective coordination between the various players and clear regulation will be essential to stabilize prices and reinforce the credibility of carbon offset mechanisms.

Register free of charge for uninterrupted access.

Publicite

Recently published in

Large international companies are intensifying their investments in Chinese carbon credits, attracted by the extension of the national system and the growth potential of new projects.
COP28 President Sultan Al Jaber calls on governments to submit ambitious NDCs to accelerate global decarbonization, relying on technology investment and innovation to reach the 1.5°C climate target.
COP28 President Sultan Al Jaber calls on governments to submit ambitious NDCs to accelerate global decarbonization, relying on technology investment and innovation to reach the 1.5°C climate target.
Norway has launched the world's first commercial CO2 transport and storage service, marking a milestone in the management of industrial emissions in Europe thanks to the Northern Lights project.
Norway has launched the world's first commercial CO2 transport and storage service, marking a milestone in the management of industrial emissions in Europe thanks to the Northern Lights project.
Colombia, Kenya, Cambodia, Mexico and Peru are the leaders in the voluntary carbon credit market, thanks to regulatory advances and investor-friendly policies.
Colombia, Kenya, Cambodia, Mexico and Peru are the leaders in the voluntary carbon credit market, thanks to regulatory advances and investor-friendly policies.
Large companies are reducing their investments in decarbonization due to geopolitical tensions, although regulations and consumer expectations continue to push them towards better management of their emissions.
The development of carbon capture technologies is crucial to achieving decarbonization targets, but projects are not progressing fast enough according to experts.
The development of carbon capture technologies is crucial to achieving decarbonization targets, but projects are not progressing fast enough according to experts.
More than half the world's companies are committed to carbon neutrality, but experts condemn the lack of concrete action to achieve this goal, despite ambitious announcements.
More than half the world's companies are committed to carbon neutrality, but experts condemn the lack of concrete action to achieve this goal, despite ambitious announcements.
The price of Australian Carbon Credit Units is set to jump by 56% between now and 2025, according to ANZ forecasts. Prices in New Zealand and China remain stable, in the face of less restrictive policies.
The price of Australian Carbon Credit Units is set to jump by 56% between now and 2025, according to ANZ forecasts. Prices in New Zealand and China remain stable, in the face of less restrictive policies.
Despite the war, Ukraine continues its industrial decarbonization efforts with innovations supported by EBRD and the EU. Pipes.one and Carbominer focus on manufacturing and agricultural efficiency through emission-reducing technologies.
Ørsted is committed to supplying 330,000 tonnes of CO2 removal credits to Equinor over a ten-year period, supporting its biomass carbon capture and storage projects.
Ørsted is committed to supplying 330,000 tonnes of CO2 removal credits to Equinor over a ten-year period, supporting its biomass carbon capture and storage projects.
Baker Hughes launches CarbonEdge™, a digital platform for carbon capture, utilization and storage projects, facilitating risk management and regulatory monitoring.
Baker Hughes launches CarbonEdge™, a digital platform for carbon capture, utilization and storage projects, facilitating risk management and regulatory monitoring.
Germany blocks emission reduction certificates for projects in China after detecting irregularities, calling into question the reliability of carbon offsets on the European market.
Germany blocks emission reduction certificates for projects in China after detecting irregularities, calling into question the reliability of carbon offsets on the European market.
Haffner Energy and IðunnH2 partner to use biocarbon in Iceland's 65,000-tonne e-SAF project, in response to carbon supply challenges.
Eni and Snam are implementing a carbon capture and storage (CCS) project in the Adriatic Sea to reduce industrial CO2 emissions in Italy.
Eni and Snam are implementing a carbon capture and storage (CCS) project in the Adriatic Sea to reduce industrial CO2 emissions in Italy.
TotalEnergies is investing USD 100 million with Anew Climate and Aurora Sustainable Lands to strengthen the sustainable management of 300,000 hectares of forests in the United States and optimize carbon sinks.
TotalEnergies is investing USD 100 million with Anew Climate and Aurora Sustainable Lands to strengthen the sustainable management of 300,000 hectares of forests in the United States and optimize carbon sinks.
According to Rystad Energy, demand for hydrocarbons will remain high. Premium energy basins such as Rub Al Khali and Gulf Deepwater are identified as strategic targets for maintaining production while reducing CO2 emissions.
According to Rystad Energy, demand for hydrocarbons will remain high. Premium energy basins such as Rub Al Khali and Gulf Deepwater are identified as strategic targets for maintaining production while reducing CO2 emissions.
The use of captured carbon dioxide can improve the profitability of carbon capture projects, but economic, technological and regulatory constraints hinder its widespread adoption.
Regional carbon exchanges in China are diversifying their role by testing new sectors for the ETS, developing carbon finance products and facilitating cross-border trading.
Regional carbon exchanges in China are diversifying their role by testing new sectors for the ETS, developing carbon finance products and facilitating cross-border trading.
Asia-Pacific is making progress in CCUS, but high costs and regulatory challenges are holding back progress.
Asia-Pacific is making progress in CCUS, but high costs and regulatory challenges are holding back progress.
Zambia is moving forward on Article 6.2 with a bilateral cooperation agreement with Sweden, aimed at boosting the cross-border carbon credit market.
Zambia is moving forward on Article 6.2 with a bilateral cooperation agreement with Sweden, aimed at boosting the cross-border carbon credit market.
Deep Sky is carrying out preliminary studies in Bécancour and Thetford Mines to assess the potential for CO2 storage and reinforce Quebec's industrial decarbonization.
Woodside Energy acquires OCI Clean Ammonia Holding's low-carbon ammonia project for $2.35 billion, including CO2 capture capacity in Texas.
Woodside Energy acquires OCI Clean Ammonia Holding's low-carbon ammonia project for $2.35 billion, including CO2 capture capacity in Texas.
An analysis by Wood Mackenzie reveals that CCS-EOR could often offer lower net emissions than CCS-Storage, thereby reinforcing the energy transition.
An analysis by Wood Mackenzie reveals that CCS-EOR could often offer lower net emissions than CCS-Storage, thereby reinforcing the energy transition.
The Ministère de l'Environnement du Québec will organize a mutual agreement sale of carbon credits on September 26, 2024, offering a solution to companies in difficulty.
The Ministère de l'Environnement du Québec will organize a mutual agreement sale of carbon credits on September 26, 2024, offering a solution to companies in difficulty.

Advertising