Rigorous carbon intensity, a prerequisite for the development of low-carbon hydrogen

To meet decarbonization objectives, the deployment of low-carbon hydrogen requires rigorous accounting of its actual carbon intensity, as well as a clear regulatory framework, as highlighted in a recent study by the Oxford Institute for Energy Studies.
Emissions réelles soutien durable

Partagez:

Low-carbon hydrogen is seen as a promising means of decarbonizing hard-to-elect sectors of the economy. However, its high cost and variable carbon intensity, depending on the production chain, pose challenges for policymakers. To encourage its deployment, governments need to ensure that low-carbon hydrogen delivers cost-effective emissions reductions compared with fossil fuels and other decarbonization solutions.
A recent study by the Oxford Institute for Energy Studies, entitled “The value of rigorous emissions accounting for low carbon hydrogen”, highlights the challenges facing the various stakeholders – governments, producers and users of low-carbon hydrogen. Public authorities are particularly concerned about the cost-effectiveness of reducing emissions. Producers need to guarantee that their hydrogen complies with government definitions, while users are looking to demonstrate optimum emissions reductions.

Diverging definitions and metrics

At present, definitions of low-carbon hydrogen vary from country to country, complicating comparisons. The terms “clean”, “renewable” or “low-carbon” cover different carbon intensity thresholds and calculation methodologies, making it difficult to assess the cost/reduction of emissions. A common nomenclature based on carbon intensity would harmonize approaches and avoid confusion. The Oxford study underlines that, beyond definitions based on color or general terms, it is the actual carbon intensity that matters from a decarbonization point of view. “Different calculation rules in the EU, UK and US can lead to very different carbon intensities for the same hydrogen, distorting cost and efficiency comparisons,” notes the report.

The importance of temporal correlation

For electrolytic hydrogen, the carbon intensity depends closely on that of the electricity used. Applying strict temporal correlation, measuring intensity over short periods, gives a more accurate picture of actual emissions. On the other hand, looser rules such as monthly or annual correlation can give the illusion that hydrogen is more virtuous than reality, distorting resource allocation. The study details the impact of different time correlation periods on the carbon intensity of hydrogen, illustrating the significant differences between strict hourly correlation and more flexible approaches. In the EU, the application of monthly rules until 2030 could lead to a carbon intensity well above that of fossil fuels in many countries.

Electrolyser efficiency, a key factor

The efficiency of electrolyzers also amplifies the impact of the carbon intensity of input electricity. With an efficiency of 67%, the additional intensity compared with an ideal electrolyser reaches 66 gCO2e/MJ in the Czech Republic, compared with just 2.1 gCO2e/MJ in Sweden. The difference between the most and least efficient electrolysers in the same country can therefore be considerable.
This amplification effect underlines the importance of choosing the right location and technology for electrolysers. The worst performer in Sweden will emit less than the best performers in most other European countries. Rigorous accounting enables us to direct investments where they will be most profitable in terms of reducing emissions.

Optimizing investments

If low-carbon hydrogen fails to demonstrate its cost-effectiveness in terms of emissions reduction, it risks losing the government support needed for investment. Rigorous emissions accounting, combined with flexible support based on carbon intensity, will enable investments to be directed where they make the most sense, both financially and environmentally.
The study shows that sliding support based on actual carbon intensity, rather than strict thresholds, would reduce regulatory risks for producers, a key finding of the Oxford Institute. According to the authors, this would encourage them to maximize their yields and integrate as effectively as possible into power grids to reduce emissions.

Integrating hydrogen into power grids

In addition to production, the study analyzes the interactions between electrolysers and power grids. Grid connection, coupled with strict time correlation rules, would enable projects to optimize their investments in electrolysers, storage and renewable generation to minimize costs. This would also give them the opportunity to sell surplus green electricity to the grid, reducing overall carbon intensity while improving profitability. National case studies confirm the benefits of this integration, with less impact on hydrogen costs than on environmental benefits.
A rigorous approach to emissions accounting for low-carbon hydrogen is essential to ensure its effectiveness in decarbonization and reduce regulatory risks, thus promoting sustainable and profitable investments for the economy and the environment. Strict time correlation rules combined with support adjusted to actual carbon intensity would simplify regulation and enable optimal allocation of resources, according to the Oxford Institute.

Stanwell announces the end of its participation in the Central Queensland Hydrogen Project, a major international hydrogen production initiative, raising questions about the sector's outlook in the region.
Lhyfe becomes the first French producer to obtain European RFNBO certification, delivering the first batches of certified hydrogen and opening access to new support mechanisms for the industrial sector.
Tree Energy Solutions and CPC Finland will produce 125,000 tonnes annually of e-NG at the Finnish port of Rauma, targeting European and international markets with a significant investment.
The European Commission grants €3.5mn to support preparatory work for a Franco-German cross-border network aimed at transporting hydrogen between the Grand Est region and Baden-Württemberg starting in 2029.
French company McPhy Energy awaits a court decision regarding offers submitted during its judicial reorganization, paving the way for probable liquidation and potential delisting of its shares.
The majority-Indigenous-owned Canadian manufacturer HyVera Distributed Energy is introducing an eCat pellet that instantly produces ultra-pure green hydrogen without external electricity and is counting on two pilot plants to simplify industrial supply.
Underground hydrogen storage, essential to support its growth, continues to face significantly higher costs than natural gas storage, along with major technical challenges hindering its competitiveness against conventional energies.
Singapore-based hydrogen specialist Hydrexia seals a protocol with Indonesian gas giant Samator to deploy purification, transport and storage of hydrogen, betting on rapidly growing local demand and export outlets to the Asia-Pacific region.
Cadiz Inc. signs a memorandum of understanding with British company Hoku Energy for a large-scale energy project including green hydrogen, solar power, and digital infrastructure in the Californian desert, projecting annual revenues of up to $10mn.
BP indefinitely halts its blue hydrogen project at the Whiting refinery in Indiana, raising questions about the future of federal funding and the impact on regional plans for a decarbonized hydrogen sector in the United States.
The Polish energy group ORLEN receives a non-repayable grant of €382 million from the National Recovery Plan to finance its renewable and low-emission hydrogen production initiatives.
Georgia Power and Mitsubishi Power announce successful completion of an unprecedented test incorporating 50% hydrogen into an advanced gas turbine, reducing CO2 emissions by 22% compared to natural gas alone.
Neoenergia has begun construction of one of Brazil's first green hydrogen plants, aimed at supplying heavy and light vehicles, with an investment exceeding 30 million Brazilian reais ($5.99mn).
The SA-H2 fund, supported by international partnerships and local institutional backing, mobilises 37 million USD to develop export-oriented green hydrogen from South Africa, with an initial concrete project announced.
Turbotech reports successful combustion testing of a hydrogen turboprop, developed through digital simulation with Ansys, marking an industrial milestone in light aircraft using alternative fuel.
France Hydrogène responds to the Cour des Comptes report published on June 5, criticising an incomplete reading of updated targets and the economic impacts of decarbonised hydrogen development.
The Belfort Commercial Court has opened a judicial reorganisation procedure for McPhy, while a renewed call for tenders for its asset sale is now set to close on 13 June.
Plug Power CFO Paul Middleton acquired 650,000 shares on the market, affirming his support for the long-term strategy of the hydrogen-focused company.
The Canadian government is funding an initiative to support 40 SMEs in British Columbia’s hydrogen sector, aiming to increase foreign investment and expand international market share.
Developer CWP Global has paused its $40 billion AMAN project in Mauritania due to a lack of buyers for green ammonia despite favourable local conditions.