New Principle of Law in France: Protection from the Cigéo Project

The French Constitutional Council established a new principle of law in October 2023, requiring the preservation of the right of future generations to live in a balanced environment that respects health, particularly in relation to the Cigéo radioactive waste storage project.
Conseil constitutionnel

Partagez:

A new legal principle in France has been established by the Constitutional Council. On October 27, 2023, the French Constitutional Council handed down a decision with significant implications forenvironmental protection. This decision concerns the proposed Cigéo burial center for highly radioactive waste at Bure, in the Meuse region of France. While the Constitutional Council has not blocked the project, it has established a new principle of French law that obliges us to preserve the right of future generations to live “in a balanced environment respectful of health.”

A New Environmental Protection Standard

This decision marks an important turning point in French environmental legislation. It goes beyond simple environmental protection, stating that “the legislator must ensure that choices made to meet the needs of the present do not compromise the ability of future generations and other peoples to meet their own needs”.

Reaction from the Collectif de Riverains et de Militants Anti-Nucléaire (Collective of Residents and Anti-Nuclear Activists)

The collective of local residents and anti-nuclear activists, made up of 14 local and 7 national associations, including Attac, Sortir du Nucléaire, France Nature Environnement and Greenpeace, is behind the referral to the French Constitutional Council. They hailed this part of the decision as “historic,” although it does not automatically authorize the Cigéo project as a whole. The collective remains “optimistic” and determined to challenge the declaration of public utility granted by the government in 2022 to this landfill project deemed “titanic and extremely dangerous.” The case will be decided by the Conseil d’Etat.

International influence

This new notion of the rights of future generations is not unique to France. Other foreign jurisdictions, such as Germany, Colombia and some US states, have also introduced similar principles. However, this right is limited and can be waived in the public interest. It takes effect mainly when serious and lasting damage to the environment is at stake.

The Principle of Reversibility and the Constitution

The Constitutional Council has applied in a measured way the Amerindian adage that one is “guardian of the land for one’s children.” This decision has implications for industrial projects, particularly non-nuclear ones, by forcing the State and politicians to strike a balance between industrial development and environmental preservation.

The Cigéo Project

With regard to the Cigéo project, which plans to bury the most radioactive waste in the clay subsoil at Bure by 2035-2040, the Constitutional Council has examined the process in detail. It concluded that there were sufficient guarantees to respect the principle of reversibility imposed by the Environmental Code. This means that the project’s provisions comply with the Constitution.

The next steps

However, commissioning authorization will be limited to a pilot phase designed to demonstrate the reversibility and safety of the facility. This phase will include waste retrieval tests, and waste packages must remain easily retrievable. Permanent closure of the site, which would make it impossible to go back, can only be authorized by law.

Opponents of the project believe that the waste’s shelf life, which can reach hundreds of thousands of years, seriously compromises the rights of future generations and irreparably damages the environment, particularly water resources.

Political and environmental context

The Constitutional Council’s decision comes at a crucial time, as the French government revives the atom to produce more electricity and reduce greenhouse gas emissions. Andra’s Bure site currently houses only a scientific laboratory, with no radioactive waste. Opponents are denouncing the government’s “forced passage” and remain determined to contest the project.

In short, this decision by the French Constitutional Council establishes a new legal principle in France, aimed at protecting the environment for future generations. Although the Cigéo project is not blocked, it will have to meet strict criteria to respect this principle. The question of balancing industrial development and environmental protection remains at the heart of this historic decision.

After several decades without funding nuclear projects, the World Bank has formed a strategic partnership with the IAEA to provide technical and financial support to countries integrating nuclear energy into their energy strategies.
South Korea's Nuclear Safety and Security Commission officially validates the decommissioning of reactor number one at the Kori plant, initiating an unprecedented project for the national industry scheduled to last until 2037.
Uranium producer enCore Energy surpasses three thousand pounds per day at its Alta Mesa ISR complex and sees three new Texas laws as a strong signal for faster nuclear production permits.
The International Atomic Energy Agency expresses concerns over Iran’s enriched uranium stockpiles following the abrupt suspension of inspections at key sites disrupted by recent attacks whose consequences remain uncertain.
NPCIL has announced an extension until September 30 for industrial proposals concerning Bharat Small Reactors (BSR), following increased interest from the Indian private sector.
Facing rising temperatures, EDF anticipates cuts in nuclear production starting early July, primarily due to thermal constraints on rivers used for cooling the power plants.
The preliminary agreement launches planning and site assessment for a tailored AP1000 reactor, following two years of feasibility study, and enlists Westinghouse and Hyundai to support Fortum’s regional nuclear expansion.
Donald Trump's unprecedented decision to dismiss Christopher Hanson, a member of the NRC, provokes outrage among former federal officials and raises concerns over the regulatory independence of the U.S. nuclear sector.
Uranium Energy Corp strengthens its position in Anfield Energy Inc., now holding approximately 32.4% of the company’s shares following an investment of CAD19.55mn ($14.82mn), significantly expanding its strategic influence in the uranium market.
New York State plans an advanced nuclear power plant with a 1-gigawatt capacity to meet long-term energy and economic goals, involving significant investment to enhance regional energy independence.
Niger announces its intention to nationalize SOMAÏR, a mining company jointly owned with Orano, provoking strong opposition from the French company and paving the way for further international legal tensions.
Russia strengthens its economic presence in Mali with new agreements, notably in nuclear energy and gold refining, consolidating strategic cooperation within a rapidly evolving geopolitical context.
The US government grants a fourth payment of $100.45 mn to Holtec International to restart the Palisades Nuclear Plant, pending regulatory approval, marking an unprecedented event in the United States.
EDF announces a major agreement with Apollo to raise up to £4.5 billion via bonds to finance the British nuclear project Hinkley Point C, whose costs continue to rise significantly.
The Élysée proposes Anne-Isabelle Étienvre, current Director of Fundamental Research at the CEA, as General Administrator to replace François Jacq, recently appointed President of CNES.
Greek Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis has announced his country's interest in small modular nuclear reactors to meet national energy challenges and decarbonize the maritime sector within the next fifteen years.
TerraPower, an American nuclear company, secures $650 million funding from investors, including NVIDIA, to develop its Natrium modular reactors in the United States and internationally.
EDF and the French state finalize a €70 billion financing plan for six EPR2 nuclear reactors, including a specific territorial coordination framework in Gravelines led by Michel Marbaix, awaiting European approval by 2026.
Maire S.p.A and Newcleo form strategic partnership to industrialise the development of 200 MW modular nuclear power plants, via a joint venture majority-owned by Nextchem.
A new European consortium launches the design of a small lead-cooled modular reactor, targeting global commercialisation by 2039, with a demonstration scheduled as early as 2035.