SUBSCRIBE
PROFILE

Legal challenge to the start-up of the Flamanville EPR

Anti-nuclear associations are contesting the start-up of the new-generation EPR nuclear reactor in Flamanville, scheduled to go into service in May 2024, 12 years late. They are taking legal action to contest this commissioning, which they consider to have been rushed.

Share:

Contestation judiciaire EPR Flamanville

Subscribe for unlimited access to all energy sector news.

Over 150 multisector articles and analyses every week.

Your 1st year at 99 $*

then 199 $/year

SUBSCRIBE — 99 $ for the 1st year

Create a free account to read this article

*renews at 199$/year, cancel anytime before renewal.

On July 8, 2024, the associations Sortir du nucléaire, Criirad, Crilan, Global Chance and Robin des Bois lodged an appeal with the Conseil d’État against the decision of the French Nuclear Safety Authority (ASN) on May 7 to authorize the commissioning of the EPR reactor.
They consider that this decision, taken after numerous delays and technical complications, is premature and calls for an in-depth reassessment.
At the same time, the associations are filing a complaint against X in Cherbourg and Paris, with the aim of clarifying irregularities detected in parts of the reactor.
Greenpeace joined both actions, while France Nature Environnement Normandie took part only in the criminal action.
They denounce the fact that commissioning has been accelerated to avoid the legal consequences of further postponement.

Technical and critical issues

Commissioning of the EPR reactor at Flamanville, France, operated by EDF, has been completed after a complex project marked by major delays.
The reactor was originally scheduled to go into service in 2012, but technical problems have continually prolonged the project.
The ASN gave the go-ahead in May 2024, at the end of a difficult period for the site, with accusations that the decision had been rushed to meet strict deadlines.
The associations criticize the ASN’s decision as being influenced by time pressures, claiming that the ASN’s new revelations about problems of forgery, falsification and fraud in the nuclear industry are aggravating the situation.
In January 2024, ASN revealed that it had reported three cases of proven fraud in 2023, one of which concerned a supplier to the EPR construction site.

Implications for the nuclear sector

The legal actions are aimed not only at suspending the commissioning of the reactor, but also at guaranteeing the safety and conformity of the equipment.
The associations hope that these proceedings will lead to a reassessment of control practices in the nuclear industry.
The decision of the Conseil d’Etat and the outcome of the criminal investigations will be crucial in determining the future of the EPR project, and for the future of regulatory practices in the sector.
This challenge highlights important issues concerning the management of nuclear projects in France, and raises questions about the transparency and effectiveness of safety controls.
The outcome of the legal proceedings could have a significant impact on public and professional perceptions of future nuclear projects.
Anti-nuclear associations are seeking to draw attention to the potential risks associated with the commissioning of the EPR, and to demand full transparency in the handling of technical and regulatory issues.

  • Popular on energynews.pro
ONEOK and partners launch Eiger Express project to link Permian to Gulf
BP Restarts Whiting Refinery After Flooding: Regional Market Pressures Emerge
Masdar completes financing for the 2 GW Al Sadawi solar project in Saudi Arabia
Group14 secures $463M and takes full control of its South Korean plant
Solar will dominate more than half of the new power capacity planned in the United States in 2025
enCore Energy completes $115M convertible notes offering
enCore Energy Corp. has completed a $115 million fundraising through convertible notes maturing in 2030, strengthening its financial capacity for upcoming operations.
Vattenfall selects GE Vernova and Rolls-Royce for future nuclear reactors
Vattenfall advances its nuclear project in Sweden by selecting two modular reactor suppliers, GE Vernova and Rolls-Royce SMR, for a potential installation on the Värö Peninsula.
NANO Nuclear Advances to Final Round of US Army’s xTechSearch 9 Competition
NANO Nuclear Energy has been selected to compete in the final round of xTechSearch 9, a US Army initiative aimed at identifying high-potential dual-use technology solutions.
Aalo Atomics raises USD 100 million to launch its first nuclear power plant
Aalo Atomics completes Series B funding, bringing its total to USD 136 million, to build its first modular nuclear power plant dedicated to data centers.
Malaysia Launches Strategic Study on Civil Nuclear Potential
The Malaysian government initiates a national assessment on nuclear energy feasibility, targeting regions facing energy supply constraints and integrating international regulatory requirements.
Premier American Uranium finalizes the acquisition of Nuclear Fuels with Court approval
The merger between Premier American Uranium and Nuclear Fuels reaches a key milestone following final approval of the arrangement plan by the Supreme Court of British Columbia.
Google and Kairos Power to Build a 50 MW Nuclear Reactor in Tennessee
TVA, Google, and Kairos Power formalize an agreement to connect an advanced reactor to the grid, supporting data center energy growth and reinforcing the U.S. nuclear industry.
X-energy and the Pentagon Accelerate Nuclear Microreactor for National Security
The U.S. Department of Defense has signed an agreement with X-energy to develop a commercial nuclear microreactor intended to power sensitive military infrastructure.
NANO Nuclear Raises $209 Million and Accelerates Microreactor Deployment
With cash reserves multiplied sevenfold in nine months, NANO Nuclear intensifies development of its KRONOS MMR and positions itself in the Canadian and U.S. modular nuclear markets.
Equinix secures 20 Radiant microreactors and a nuclear deal in the Netherlands
Equinix signed a preorder for 20 Kaleidos nuclear microreactors and a letter of intent for a power purchase agreement with ULC-Energy, reinforcing its energy supply strategy for its data centers.
Oklo selected for three pilot projects by U.S. Department of Energy
The U.S. Department of Energy selects Oklo and its subsidiary Atomic Alchemy for three pilot reactor projects aiming for criticality before July 2026.
Eleven US companies selected to fast-track small nuclear reactor testing
The United States Department of Energy has selected eleven companies to build experimental nuclear reactors by July 2026, under a programme aimed at meeting rising electricity demand.
South Africa confirms environmental authorisation for Duynefontein nuclear power plant
The South African Minister of the Environment has approved Eskom’s authorisation to build a nuclear power plant in Duynefontein, ending appeals lodged by several environmental organisations.
The United Kingdom prepares major reform of nuclear regulation
An independent group calls for deep changes to speed up the approval of UK nuclear projects and cut costs linked to a system seen as too slow and complex.
Radiant signs contract to deliver nuclear microreactor to the US military in 2028
Radiant has signed an agreement with the Department of the Air Force and the Defense Innovation Unit to supply a portable nuclear microreactor, marking a first in mass production for military use.
Gravelines’ six reactors shut down after massive jellyfish invasion
The Gravelines nuclear power plant, the largest in Western Europe, halted all production after its cooling systems were obstructed by an unexpected influx of jellyfish. EDF plans a gradual restart in the coming days.
IAEA confirms tritium levels well below limits for 14th batch of ALPS-treated water
The International Atomic Energy Agency confirmed that the tritium concentration in the 14th batch of ALPS-treated water discharged by TEPCO remains well below Japan’s operational limit.
Surveys for Kazakhstan’s first nuclear power plant enter active phase
Field studies to determine the location of Kazakhstan’s first nuclear power plant have begun near the village of Ulken, marking a key stage in a project led by Rosatom.
China begins construction of the first two nuclear reactors at Jinqimen
China’s nuclear safety authority has approved the construction of units 1 and 2 at the Jinqimen plant, authorising the start of foundation work for the first reactor.
India launches a two-pronged strategy to accelerate nuclear power by 2047
India unveils a national plan to boost nuclear capacity to 100 GW by 2047, combining large reactors and small modules, with a strengthened regulatory framework and new public-private partnerships.

Log in to read this article

You'll also have access to a selection of our best content.

or

Go unlimited with our annual offer: 99 $ for the 1styear year, then 199 $ /year.

SUBSCRIBE - €99
Consent Preferences