popular articles

IRSN-ASN merger: Growing concerns about quality and independence

The planned merger between IRSN and ASN is causing growing concern among employees. The CSE is calling for a one-year postponement, arguing that the current delay compromises the quality and efficiency of the future entity.

Please share:

The planned merger between the Institut de Radioprotection et Sûreté Nucléaire (IRSN) and the Autorité de Sûreté Nucléaire (ASN) is causing growing concern among employee representative bodies.
IRSN’s social and economic committee (CSE), together with its inter-union group, is calling for a one-year postponement of the merger, originally scheduled to take effect at the beginning of 2025. This request is based on the argument that the deadline for implementing this reform is too short, thus compromising the quality of the organization and the smooth running of the future entity.

Concerns about implementation

The CSE has issued an unfavorable opinion on the proposed merger, recommending that it be postponed until January 1, 2026.
In its opinion, the CSE points out that the proposed transitional organization for January 1, 2025 was drawn up in a hurry, which could lead to major dysfunctions.
The members of the CSE alerted the ASN College to “worrying observations” linked to a lack of control over the project.
They point to the risk that this haste will undermine the ASNR’s ability to fulfill its expert appraisal and control missions in the fields of nuclear safety and radiation protection.
The intersyndicale, which includes unions such as CFDT, CGT and CFE-CGC, shares these concerns.
It points out that the time lag between the promulgation of the law formalizing the merger and the operational implementation of the ASNR is grossly inadequate.
In fact, only seven months separate these two stages, a period deemed inadequate for merging organizations with structures and missions as different as IRSN and ASN.

The challenges of quality and independence

The unions are also concerned about the social impact of this merger.
They deplore the absence of an in-depth impact study, which could shed light on the consequences of this reorganization on employees and on the operation of the two entities.
Ecologist MP Julie Laernoes has also taken a stance on this issue, announcing the filing of a bill to repeal the reform.
She considers that the merger could undermine the quality and independence of expertise, while threatening the transparency of the regulatory and control system.
The stakes involved in this merger are not limited to internal considerations.
They also affect the perception of the nuclear sector by the general public and economic players.
The fear of disorganization at a critical time for the nuclear industry could have repercussions on the trust placed in the institutions in charge of safety.
Industry players therefore need to pay close attention to these developments, as they could influence investment decisions and the long-term strategy of companies involved in the nuclear sector.

The need for dialogue and preparation

In view of these concerns, it seems essential to establish a constructive dialogue between the various stakeholders.
The establishment of a clear roadmap and a realistic timetable could help to better prepare this merger, while guaranteeing the continuity of IRSN and ASN missions.
Industry players must also commit to ensuring a smooth transition, so as to preserve the quality of nuclear safety expertise and controls.
The current situation highlights the importance of effective governance and transparent communication as part of structural reforms.
Feedback from employees and trade unions must be taken into account to avoid past mistakes and ensure that the future entity, the ASNR, can function optimally from the outset.
The success of this merger will largely depend on the ability of the players involved to work together and anticipate future challenges.
The stakes involved in this merger between IRSN and ASN are many and complex.
They require particular attention from decision-makers, who must navigate between the imperatives of safety, efficiency and transparency.
Managing this transition will be crucial for the future of nuclear safety and public confidence in the institutions responsible for this mission.

Register free of charge for uninterrupted access.

Publicite

Recently published in

The UK government is easing restrictions on nuclear power plant construction, particularly small modular reactors (SMRs). While this technology is still under development, it attracts several companies but poses technical and financial challenges.
Canadian Nuclear Laboratories (CNL) is expanding its energy technology siting program to include fusion, hydrogen, and battery storage. This initiative aims to attract investors and industrial players to accelerate the development and commercialization of new energy solutions in Canada.
Canadian Nuclear Laboratories (CNL) is expanding its energy technology siting program to include fusion, hydrogen, and battery storage. This initiative aims to attract investors and industrial players to accelerate the development and commercialization of new energy solutions in Canada.
The new Belgian government, led by Bart De Wever, plans to expand the country's nuclear capacity to 8 gigawatts, including the extension of existing reactors and the construction of new units. This decision requires a revision of the 2003 law on nuclear phase-out.
The new Belgian government, led by Bart De Wever, plans to expand the country's nuclear capacity to 8 gigawatts, including the extension of existing reactors and the construction of new units. This decision requires a revision of the 2003 law on nuclear phase-out.
The Indian government is considering amending the Atomic Energy Act to facilitate private sector involvement in civil nuclear energy. Tata Power is closely monitoring these developments, particularly regarding the development of small modular reactors (SMRs), a technology still in the research phase.
The Indian government is considering amending the Atomic Energy Act to facilitate private sector involvement in civil nuclear energy. Tata Power is closely monitoring these developments, particularly regarding the development of small modular reactors (SMRs), a technology still in the research phase.
A mission from the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) has assessed safety practices at the Novovoronezh nuclear power plant, operated by Rosatom. The audit highlighted advancements in operational safety while recommending targeted improvements.
Swedish developer Blykalla has begun construction of a pilot facility to test a prototype of an advanced modular reactor. This project aims to validate key components and safety systems, with the support of industrial partners and public funding.
Swedish developer Blykalla has begun construction of a pilot facility to test a prototype of an advanced modular reactor. This project aims to validate key components and safety systems, with the support of industrial partners and public funding.
Indonesia is accelerating the development of its nuclear program and could become the first country in Southeast Asia to deploy a small modular reactor (SMR) by 2030. Despite competition from renewable energy, Jakarta is betting on nuclear power to diversify its energy mix.
Indonesia is accelerating the development of its nuclear program and could become the first country in Southeast Asia to deploy a small modular reactor (SMR) by 2030. Despite competition from renewable energy, Jakarta is betting on nuclear power to diversify its energy mix.
Georgia Power plans to increase the capacity of its Hatch and Vogtle nuclear plants to address an estimated demand growth of 8200 MW by 2030. The company is focusing on uprates and exploring the addition of new nuclear capacity in the long term.
Georgia Power plans to increase the capacity of its Hatch and Vogtle nuclear plants to address an estimated demand growth of 8200 MW by 2030. The company is focusing on uprates and exploring the addition of new nuclear capacity in the long term.
GEN energija has selected Westinghouse and EDF to conduct a technical feasibility study on Slovenia's JEK2 nuclear project. KHNP, initially in the race, has decided not to submit a bid due to a strategic shift.
The Sizewell C nuclear power plant project in the UK is progressing as planned, without delays or cost overruns. Project leaders presented an initial progress report to parliamentarians, highlighting significant financial and industrial advancements.
The Sizewell C nuclear power plant project in the UK is progressing as planned, without delays or cost overruns. Project leaders presented an initial progress report to parliamentarians, highlighting significant financial and industrial advancements.
The EDF group revises upward its nuclear electricity production estimates for 2025, 2026 and 2027, incorporating the EPR (European Pressurized Reactor) of Flamanville 3 despite delays and fluctuations observed in recent years.
The EDF group revises upward its nuclear electricity production estimates for 2025, 2026 and 2027, incorporating the EPR (European Pressurized Reactor) of Flamanville 3 despite delays and fluctuations observed in recent years.
The Nuclear Safety Authority (ASNR) has validated the continuation of tests on the Flamanville EPR by authorizing EDF to exceed the 25% nominal power threshold, a crucial step in the power ramp-up program.
The Nuclear Safety Authority (ASNR) has validated the continuation of tests on the Flamanville EPR by authorizing EDF to exceed the 25% nominal power threshold, a crucial step in the power ramp-up program.
The CRE (Commission of Energy Regulation) states that the new nuclear price regulation mechanism aims to protect consumers, despite the RN's political opposition.
EDF's project to build a technocenter for recycling low-level radioactive metal waste on the site of the former Fessenheim nuclear power plant is reigniting local tensions, between economic hopes and environmental concerns.
EDF's project to build a technocenter for recycling low-level radioactive metal waste on the site of the former Fessenheim nuclear power plant is reigniting local tensions, between economic hopes and environmental concerns.
Standard Lithium and Equinor announced Smackover Lithium as the official name of their joint venture developing direct lithium extraction projects in Southwest Arkansas and East Texas.
Standard Lithium and Equinor announced Smackover Lithium as the official name of their joint venture developing direct lithium extraction projects in Southwest Arkansas and East Texas.
The release of DeepSeek’s R1 model, with reduced energy requirements, challenges the predicted energy consumption of data centers powering artificial intelligence.
The release of DeepSeek’s R1 model, with reduced energy requirements, challenges the predicted energy consumption of data centers powering artificial intelligence.
Since the startup of the Flamanville EPR reactor in May 2024, nearly 50 significant events have been reported by the ASN, with no impact on safety or the environment. These anomalies are mainly related to human factors and team coordination.
Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and his Polish counterpart, Donald Tusk, signed a landmark nuclear cooperation agreement, marking a new chapter in the energy relationship between the two countries.
Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and his Polish counterpart, Donald Tusk, signed a landmark nuclear cooperation agreement, marking a new chapter in the energy relationship between the two countries.
In 2024, the Nuclear Safety and Radiation Protection Authority (ASNR) handled 71 reports of irregularities in the nuclear industry, compared to 43 in 2023. This marked increase is seen as a sign of stronger oversight and better alert reporting by operators.
In 2024, the Nuclear Safety and Radiation Protection Authority (ASNR) handled 71 reports of irregularities in the nuclear industry, compared to 43 in 2023. This marked increase is seen as a sign of stronger oversight and better alert reporting by operators.
Bayridge Resources Corp. has received a level 2 drilling permit to explore up to 30 drilling sites at its Constellation project in the Athabasca Basin. The company plans to launch a multi-phase drilling program, with the first phase fully funded.
Bayridge Resources Corp. has received a level 2 drilling permit to explore up to 30 drilling sites at its Constellation project in the Athabasca Basin. The company plans to launch a multi-phase drilling program, with the first phase fully funded.
Swedish manufacturer Alleima signs a second major order with Doosan Enerbility for the supply of steam generator tubes for NuScale Power's Small Modular Reactors (SMRs).
Naarea and Phoenix Manufacture are combining their expertise to develop the industrial production of the XAMR, a promising molten salt microreactor. This strategic partnership integrates innovation, 3D printing, and sustainability to tackle tomorrow’s challenges.
Naarea and Phoenix Manufacture are combining their expertise to develop the industrial production of the XAMR, a promising molten salt microreactor. This strategic partnership integrates innovation, 3D printing, and sustainability to tackle tomorrow’s challenges.
Korea Hydro & Nuclear Power (KHNP) has signed memorandums of understanding with Scandinavian players to promote small modular reactors (SMRs) in the Norwegian and Swedish markets, aiming to strengthen its presence in Europe.
Korea Hydro & Nuclear Power (KHNP) has signed memorandums of understanding with Scandinavian players to promote small modular reactors (SMRs) in the Norwegian and Swedish markets, aiming to strengthen its presence in Europe.
The revival of nuclear energy in France generates a constant demand for 10,000 recruits, reflecting the sector's growing attractiveness. A closer look at the challenges of a transforming industry and its inclusive strategies.
The revival of nuclear energy in France generates a constant demand for 10,000 recruits, reflecting the sector's growing attractiveness. A closer look at the challenges of a transforming industry and its inclusive strategies.

Advertising