Geopolitical Threats and Fossil Energy: IEA Chief’s Opinion

Growing geopolitical threats to global oil and natural gas supplies, coupled with concerns about man-made climate change, are increasingly eroding the appeal of fossil fuels as reliable and secure sources of energy, said Fatih Birol, head of the International Energy Agency, on November 7.

Share:

menaces-geopolitiques-energies-fossiles

Subscribe for unlimited access to all the latest energy sector news.

Over 150 multisector articles and analyses every week.

For less than €3/week*

*For an annual commitment

*Engagement annuel à seulement 99 € (au lieu de 149 €), offre valable jusqu'au 30/07/2025 minuit.

World oil markets are currently focusing on the consequences of Israel’s ground offensive against Hamas in Gaza. They fear it will trigger a wider regional conflict, which could affect oil exports due to an aggressive response from Iran-backed Hezbollah, as well as from Iran itself.

“Oil markets are on edge,” Birol said in an interview with S&P Global Commodity Insights. “The question is whether one or more producing countries are directly involved in the crisis or not. If they are, we may well find that markets would be negatively affected in terms of supply disruptions and oil price rises.”

Impact on oil markets

Fears of the conflict spreading further into the Middle East added to the optimism of the oil markets. The mix of voluntary OPEC+ supply cuts is fuelling this optimism. It is also influenced by the heightened geopolitical risks arising from the ongoing conflict in Ukraine and sanctions against Russia. Western sanctions on Russian oil exports have reshaped the flow of crude oil and diesel to Europe since Moscow’s invasion of Ukraine last year. Yemen has also become a potential flashpoint for global oil markets. This could happen if peace talks with Iranian-backed Houthi militiamen fail due to escalating conflict between Israel and Hamas across the Middle East, analysts warned.

The perception of fossil fuels

Platts last assessed Dated Brent on November 6 at $88.095/b, down from a peak of $95/b following the Hamas attack on Israel on October 7, but up by around $13/b since the start of 2023. Platts is part of S&P Global. “I think if I were not an energy person but a man in the street, I would think that the claims that oil and gas are safe and secure choices for energy are getting weaker and weaker,” said Birol. “This is something the oil and gas industry needs to take on board. They’re losing a lot with the according that they’re a reliable, safe and secure choice for energy.”

Energy market volatility and supply concerns

“When I look at the natural gas markets, what happened two years ago, with the Russia-Ukraine situation and a sudden increase in gas prices, they became volatile and gas availability became a key issue,” he said. “Many Europeans were wondering, ‘Are we going to freeze here or not?’ Coming back to oil, people are on edge: ‘Are oil prices going to explode? What will the price of diesel be here if supplies are disrupted? We’re also wondering who will supply the oil if the Strait of Hormuz is closed,” said Birol. “People are also linking extreme weather events, the use of fossil fuels and their responsibility for worsening the climate crisis.

In its latest monthly oil market report, dated October 12, the IEA said it was “ready to act” by coordinating a release of strategic stocks should an escalation of the conflict in Israel impact oil supplies from the Middle East.

Noting that there has so far been no direct impact on physical oil supplies as a result of the conflict between Israel and Hamas, the IEA said it expected the international community to remain “very attentive” to the risks to oil flows in the region if there are signs that this could have political repercussions across the Middle East. Ever-increasing geopolitical threats and growing concerns about climate change are jeopardizing the reputation of fossil fuels as reliable energy sources. The head of the International Energy Agency, Fatih Birol, issues this warning against a backdrop of increasing pressure on oil markets due to conflicts in the Middle East and sanctions against Russia. The transition to cleaner, more sustainable energy sources seems inevitable, with potentially far-reaching consequences for the global oil and gas industry.

Baghdad and Damascus intensify discussions to reactivate the 850 km pipeline closed since 2003, offering a Mediterranean alternative amid regional tensions and export blockages.
A free trade agreement between Indonesia and the Eurasian Economic Union is set to be signed in December, aiming to reduce tariffs on $3 bn worth of trade and boost bilateral commerce in the coming years.
The visit of India's national security adviser to Moscow comes as the United States threatens to raise tariffs on New Delhi due to India’s continued purchases of Russian oil.
Brussels freezes its retaliatory measures for six months as July 27 deal imposes 15% duties on European exports.
Discussions between Tehran and Baghdad on export volumes and an $11 billion debt reveal the complexities of energy dependence under U.S. sanctions.
Facing US secondary sanctions threats, Indian refiners slow Russian crude purchases while exploring costly alternatives, revealing complex energy security challenges.
The 50% tariffs push Brasília toward accelerated commercial integration with Beijing and Brussels, reshaping regional economic balances.
Washington imposes massive duties citing Bolsonaro prosecution while exempting strategic sectors vital to US industry.
Sanctions imposed on August 1 accelerate the reconfiguration of Indo-Pacific trade flows, with Vietnam, Bangladesh and Indonesia emerging as principal beneficiaries.
Washington triggers an unprecedented tariff structure combining 25% fixed duties and an additional unspecified penalty linked to Russian energy and military purchases.
Qatar rejects EU climate transition obligations and threatens to redirect its LNG exports to Asia, creating a major energy dilemma.
Uganda is relying on a diplomatic presence in Vienna to facilitate technical and commercial cooperation with the International Atomic Energy Agency, supporting its ambitions in the civil nuclear sector.
The governments of Saudi Arabia and Syria conclude an unprecedented partnership covering oil, gas, electricity interconnection and renewable energies, with the aim of boosting their exchanges and investments in the energy sector.
The European commitment to purchase $250bn of American energy annually raises questions about its technical and economic feasibility in light of limited export capacity.
A major customs agreement sealed in Scotland sets a 15% tariff on most European exports to the United States, accompanied by significant energy purchase commitments and cross-investments between the two powers.
Qatar has warned that it could stop its liquefied natural gas deliveries to the European Union in response to the new European directive on due diligence and climate transition.
The Brazilian mining sector is drawing US attention as diplomatic discussions and tariff measures threaten to disrupt the balance of strategic minerals trade.
Donald Trump has raised the prospect of tariffs on countries buying Russian crude, but according to Reuters, enforcement remains unlikely due to economic risks and unfulfilled past threats.
Afghanistan and Turkmenistan reaffirmed their commitment to deepening their bilateral partnership during a meeting between officials from both countries, with a particular focus on major infrastructure projects and energy cooperation.
The European Union lowers the price cap on Russian crude oil and extends sanctions to vessels and entities involved in circumvention, as coordination with the United States remains pending.
Consent Preferences