G20: Energy ministers fail to reach agreement

Confronted by differences over coal and the financing of the energy transition, the G20 ministers failed to agree on fossil fuel reduction at their recent meeting in India. Despite urgent calls for a rapid phase-out of fossil fuels, the climate challenge remains pressing.
G20

Partagez:

The energy ministers of the G20 countries, meeting in India on Saturday, failed to agree on a timetable for gradually reducing the use of fossil fuels (oil, gas, coal).

G20: the stakes for coal and differences over fossil fuels

Their final declaration, published at the end of the meeting in Goa, does not even mention coal, one of the major contributors to global warming. But coal is also one of the main sources of energy for many developing economies, including India, the world’s most populous country, and China, the world’s second largest economy.

This failure to reach agreement comes at a time when global temperatures are reaching record levels, causing heatwaves, floods and wildfires, and when the G7 leaders declared in Hiroshima in May that they would “accelerate” their “exit” from fossil fuels.

To explain the impasse, India, which holds the G20 presidency, explained that some members wanted to see a “reduction in fossil fuels” not backed by carbon capture and storage, “in line with different national circumstances”. While “others have a different opinion on whether carbon capture and storage technologies meet these needs”. Alden Meyer, analyst at the E3G think-tank, deplored the failure of the negotiations.

A burning planet, icy disagreements: the G20’s climate challenges in the spotlight

“With record temperatures being reached around the world every day and the impact of climate change spiraling out of control, the world needed the G20 energy ministers to sound the rallying call,” he lamented in a statement.

A coalition of eighteen countries, including France and Germany, led by the Marshall Islands, called last Friday for “an urgent exit from fossil fuels” and “a peak in greenhouse gas emissions by 2025”, arguing that “humanity cannot afford to wait”.

This coalition is calling for a 43% reduction in global emissions by 2030 compared with 2019, in order to meet the 1.5°C limit, as calculated by UN climate experts.

But many developing countries believe that rich countries, as the biggest polluters, should provide more funding for the energy transition. India, in particular, has set itself a target of zero net emissions by 2070, 20 years later than many other countries.

The G20 energy dance: between delicate financing and resistance to the decline of fossil fuels

A report preparing India’s presidency of the G20 calculated the cost of the energy transition at $4,000 billion a year, and stressed the importance of low-cost financing for technology transfer and developing countries, a recurring request from New Delhi.

Some major oil producers are also reluctant to make a rapid exit from fossil fuels. Ed King, of the GSCC climate communications network, blamed Russia and Saudi Arabia in particular for the lack of progress in Saturday’s negotiations. These countries have “blocked efforts to reach an agreement on a tripling of clean energy aimed at reducing fossil fuels”, he deplored on Twitter.

The CEO of United Arab Emirates oil company Adnoc, Sultan Al Jaber, who will chair the COP28 negotiations, said he expected fossil fuels to continue to play a role, albeit a reduced one, with the controversial help of carbon capture or storage devices.

He did, however, consider that their reduction was “inevitable” and “essential”, but that realism forbade doing without them overnight.

The European Commission held a high-level dialogue to identify administrative obstacles delaying renewable energy and energy infrastructure projects across the European Union.
The European Commission held a high-level dialogue to identify administrative obstacles delaying renewable energy and energy infrastructure projects across the European Union.
Despite increased generation capacity and lower tariffs, Liberia continues to rely on electricity imports to meet growing demand, particularly during the dry season.
Despite increased generation capacity and lower tariffs, Liberia continues to rely on electricity imports to meet growing demand, particularly during the dry season.
South Korea's new president, Lee Jae-myung, is reviewing the national energy policy, aiming to rebalance nuclear regulations without immediately shutting down reactors currently in operation.
South Korea's new president, Lee Jae-myung, is reviewing the national energy policy, aiming to rebalance nuclear regulations without immediately shutting down reactors currently in operation.
The French Energy Regulatory Commission released its 2024 annual report, highlighting sustained activity on grid infrastructure, pricing, and evolving European regulatory frameworks.
The French Energy Regulatory Commission released its 2024 annual report, highlighting sustained activity on grid infrastructure, pricing, and evolving European regulatory frameworks.
The United States is easing proposed penalties for foreign LNG tankers and vehicle carriers, sharply reducing initial costs for international operators while maintaining strategic support objectives for the American merchant marine.
The United States is easing proposed penalties for foreign LNG tankers and vehicle carriers, sharply reducing initial costs for international operators while maintaining strategic support objectives for the American merchant marine.
While capital is flowing into clean technologies globally, Africa remains marginalised, receiving only a fraction of the expected flows, according to the International Energy Agency.
While capital is flowing into clean technologies globally, Africa remains marginalised, receiving only a fraction of the expected flows, according to the International Energy Agency.
The U.S. Department of Transportation is withdrawing strict fuel economy standards adopted under Biden, citing overreach in legal authority regarding the integration of electric vehicles into regulatory calculations for automakers.
The U.S. Department of Transportation is withdrawing strict fuel economy standards adopted under Biden, citing overreach in legal authority regarding the integration of electric vehicles into regulatory calculations for automakers.
In 2024, renewable energies covered 33.9% of electricity consumption in metropolitan France, driven by increased hydropower output and solar capacity expansion.
In 2024, renewable energies covered 33.9% of electricity consumption in metropolitan France, driven by increased hydropower output and solar capacity expansion.
The French Energy Regulatory Commission (CRE) has announced its strategic guidelines for 2030, focusing on the energy transition, European competitiveness and consumer needs.
The French Energy Regulatory Commission (CRE) has announced its strategic guidelines for 2030, focusing on the energy transition, European competitiveness and consumer needs.
Madrid paid an arbitration award to Blasket Renewable Investments after more than ten years of litigation related to the withdrawal of tax advantages for renewable energy investors.
Madrid paid an arbitration award to Blasket Renewable Investments after more than ten years of litigation related to the withdrawal of tax advantages for renewable energy investors.
The global renewable energy market continues to grow, reaching $1,200 billion in 2024, according to a report by the International Energy Agency (IEA), supported by investments in solar and wind energy.
The global renewable energy market continues to grow, reaching $1,200 billion in 2024, according to a report by the International Energy Agency (IEA), supported by investments in solar and wind energy.
The Québec government is granting $3.43mn to the Saint-Jean-Baptiste Electric Cooperative to deploy smart meters and upgrade infrastructure across 16 municipalities.
The Québec government is granting $3.43mn to the Saint-Jean-Baptiste Electric Cooperative to deploy smart meters and upgrade infrastructure across 16 municipalities.
New US tariff measures are driving up energy sector costs, with a particularly strong impact on storage and solar, according to a study by Wood Mackenzie.
New US tariff measures are driving up energy sector costs, with a particularly strong impact on storage and solar, according to a study by Wood Mackenzie.
Despite the proclaimed urgency, European climate investments stagnate around €500 billion per year, far from the estimated needs of nearly €850 billion. New financial instruments are attempting to revive an indispensable momentum.
Despite the proclaimed urgency, European climate investments stagnate around €500 billion per year, far from the estimated needs of nearly €850 billion. New financial instruments are attempting to revive an indispensable momentum.
African countries now spend more on debt service than on education and healthcare, limiting essential investments despite significant energy potential. The G20, under pressure, struggles to provide an adequate response to the financial and climate challenges.
African countries now spend more on debt service than on education and healthcare, limiting essential investments despite significant energy potential. The G20, under pressure, struggles to provide an adequate response to the financial and climate challenges.
Four renewable energy producers have been authorised to sell 400 MW directly to Egyptian industrial companies without public support.
Four renewable energy producers have been authorised to sell 400 MW directly to Egyptian industrial companies without public support.
A report by Ember shows ASEAN could supply nearly one-third of its data centres with wind and solar power by 2030 without storage, provided appropriate public policies are implemented.
A report by Ember shows ASEAN could supply nearly one-third of its data centres with wind and solar power by 2030 without storage, provided appropriate public policies are implemented.
Spanish authorities and grid operator REE denied conducting any experiment on the national electricity network prior to the massive outage on April 28, the cause of which remains unknown.
Spanish authorities and grid operator REE denied conducting any experiment on the national electricity network prior to the massive outage on April 28, the cause of which remains unknown.
Three trade trajectories projected by Wood Mackenzie show how tariff tensions could shift demand, prices and investment in the global energy sector.
Three trade trajectories projected by Wood Mackenzie show how tariff tensions could shift demand, prices and investment in the global energy sector.
The European Commission states the Union is on track to cut emissions by 54% by 2030, following updated national plans.
The European Commission states the Union is on track to cut emissions by 54% by 2030, following updated national plans.