EDF and Henri Proglio Face Trial for Favoritism Over 44 Contracts Without Competition

EDF and its former CEO Henri Proglio are on trial for contracts awarded without public tender between 2010 and 2016. The Parquet National Financier estimates the value of these contracts at €36 million, involving consultants close to the executive.

Share:

Comprehensive energy news coverage, updated nonstop

Annual subscription

8.25€/month*

*billed annually at 99€/year for the first year then 149,00€/year ​

Unlimited access • Archives included • Professional invoice

OTHER ACCESS OPTIONS

Monthly subscription

Unlimited access • Archives included

5.2€/month*
then 14.90€ per month thereafter

FREE ACCOUNT

3 articles offered per month

FREE

*Prices are excluding VAT, which may vary depending on your location or professional status

Since 2021: 35,000 articles • 150+ analyses per week

The Paris Correctional Court is currently examining the responsibility of EDF and its former CEO Henri Proglio for accusations of favoritism. The Parquet National Financier (PNF) estimates that 44 contracts, totaling €36 million, were awarded without adhering to the required competitive procedures. These events, which occurred between 2010 and 2016, primarily involve strategic consulting, communication, and risk management services.

The investigation highlighted the existence of a special internal procedure, known as “Tchernonog,” named after the former Secretary General of EDF, Alain Tchernonog. This directive allegedly allowed EDF to bypass formal public tender requirements for services exceeding €400,000. According to the prosecution, several consultants who benefited from these contracts were close to Henri Proglio, raising concerns about the integrity of these practices.

Influential Consultants Under Fire

The PNF targeted consultants who received contracts above the €400,000 threshold, classifying these deals as “formal procedures” requiring competition. Notable figures named in the case include Jean de Belot, a former journalist, and criminologist Alain Bauer, who carried out a mission valued at €650,000 for EDF. These consultants, along with other personalities such as Alexandre Medvedowsky, a former magistrate, all claimed to be unaware that the contracts were in violation of legal procedures.

Meanwhile, Loïk Le Floch-Prigent, a former executive of Gaz de France and SNCF, faces one year in prison due to his previous criminal record. Other sentences sought by the PNF range from 6 to 18 months of suspended prison sentences and fines up to €1 million for some entities involved, such as the consulting firm of former Vivendi CEO, Jean-Marie Messier.

Defense Arguments Focused on Confidentiality

The accused consultants argued that the missions entrusted by EDF, dealing with security and economic intelligence issues, justified a lack of competition due to confidentiality concerns. Alain Bauer defended the absolute need for discretion regarding his work on the “criminalization of the global economy” and nuclear safety. According to him, these topics required a high degree of confidentiality, incompatible with the constraints of a public tender.

However, the PNF dismissed these claims, arguing that favoritism was enabled by ambiguous internal procedures. A 2010 internal note, known as the “Tchernonog procedure,” formalized the possibility of using direct contracts. The prosecution believes that this internal directive was abusively used to justify awarding contracts to consultants close to the executive.

Potential Impact on EDF’s International Markets

EDF’s legal counsel requested the company’s acquittal, arguing that a conviction, even without being recorded in its criminal record, could disqualify the group from accessing certain strategic international markets. The defense pointed out that EDF, now 100% publicly owned since 2023, is currently repositioning itself on key infrastructure projects. A conviction could damage its reputation and limit its international partnership opportunities.

For Henri Proglio, the stakes are also personal. The former CEO, who led EDF from 2009 to 2014, stated that he never intended to bypass the rules, declaring that he has already been “condemned by the media” before the trial’s conclusion. His lawyer, Jean-Pierre Mignard, is advocating for acquittal, emphasizing that there was no personal enrichment on his client’s part.

Upcoming Verdict and Its Implications

The Correctional Court is set to rule on the responsibility of EDF as a corporate entity and on the involvement of the consultants implicated in the case. Among them, Alain Tchernonog was not tried due to health reasons, despite his key role in establishing the controversial procedure. This trial highlights potential governance issues within major French public enterprises and could lead to stricter internal controls on contract awards.

The upcoming ruling is expected to have repercussions on EDF’s governance and the broader management of public companies’ relations with external service providers.

More than 40 developers will gather in Livingstone from 26 to 28 November to turn Southern Africa’s energy commitments into bankable and interconnected projects.
Citepa projections confirm a marked slowdown in France's climate trajectory, with emissions reductions well below targets set in the national low-carbon strategy.
The United States has threatened economic sanctions against International Maritime Organization members who approve a global carbon tax on international shipping emissions.
Global progress on electricity access slowed in 2024, with only 11 million new connections, despite targeted efforts in parts of Africa and Asia.
A parliamentary report questions the 2026 electricity pricing reform, warning of increased market exposure for households and a redistribution mechanism lacking clarity.
The US Senate has confirmed two new commissioners to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, creating a Republican majority that could reshape the regulatory approach to national energy infrastructure.
The federal government launches a CAD3mn call for proposals to fund Indigenous participation in energy and infrastructure projects related to critical minerals.
Opportunities are emerging for African countries to move from extraction to industrial manufacturing in energy technology value chains, as the 2025 G20 discussions highlight these issues.
According to the International Energy Agency (IEA), global renewable power capacity could more than double by 2030, driven by the rise of solar photovoltaics despite supply chain pressures and evolving policy frameworks.
Algeria plans to allocate $60 billion to energy projects by 2029, primarily targeting upstream oil and gas, while developing petrochemicals, renewables and unconventional resources.
China set a record for clean technology exports in August, driven by surging sales of electric vehicles and batteries, with more than half of the growth coming from non-OECD markets.
A night-time attack on Belgorod’s power grid left thousands without electricity, according to Russian local authorities, despite partial service restoration the following morning.
The French Academy of Sciences calls for a global ban on solar radiation modification, citing major risks to climate stability and the world economy.
The halt of US federal services disrupts the entire decision-making chain for energy and mining projects, with growing risks of administrative delays and missing critical data.
Facing a potential federal government shutdown, multiple US energy agencies are preparing to suspend services and furlough thousands of employees.
A report reveals the economic impact of renewable energy losses in Chile, indicating that a 1% drop in curtailments could generate $15mn in annual savings.
Faced with growing threats to its infrastructure, Denmark raises its energy alert level in response to a series of unidentified drone flyovers and ongoing geopolitical tensions.
The Prime Minister dismissed rumours of a moratorium on renewables, as the upcoming energy roadmap triggers tensions within the sector.
Kuwait plans to develop 14.05 GW of new power capacity by 2031 to meet growing demand and reduce scheduled outages, driven by extreme temperatures and maintenance delays.
The partnership with the World Bank-funded Pro Energia+ programme aims to expand electricity access in Mozambique by targeting rural communities through a results-based financing mechanism.

All the latest energy news, all the time

Annual subscription

8.25€/month*

*billed annually at 99€/year for the first year then 149,00€/year ​

Unlimited access - Archives included - Pro invoice

Monthly subscription

Unlimited access • Archives included

5.2€/month*
then 14.90€ per month thereafter

*Prices shown are exclusive of VAT, which may vary according to your location or professional status.

Since 2021: 30,000 articles - +150 analyses/week.