Does cleaning up ships accelerate global warming?

A recent study suggests that reducing sulfur in marine fuels could increase global warming, sparking debate within the scientific community.

Share:

Réduction soufre carburants maritimes

Comprehensive energy news coverage, updated nonstop

8.25$/month*

*billed annually at 99$/year for the first year then 149,00$/year ​

Unlimited access • Archives included • Professional invoice

OTHER ACCESS OPTIONS

7-Day Pass

Up to 50 articles accessible for 7 days, with no automatic renewal

3 $/week*

FREE ACCOUNT

3 articles/month

FREE

*Prices are excluding VAT, which may vary depending on your location or professional status

Since 2021: 30,000 articles • 150+ analyses per week

The question of whether ship fuel pollution control paradoxically contributes to global warming is the subject of intense scientific debate. Since the implementation in 2020 of International Maritime Organization (IMO) regulations aimed at reducing the sulfur content of marine fuels, a new study highlights the unexpected consequences of this measure.

Impact of Sulfur Emissions

According to Tianle Yuan, researcher at the University of Maryland and lead author of the study published in Communications Earth & Environment, these regulations have significantly reduced sulfur emissions from ships, cutting them by 80% since 2020. However, this reduction has also eliminated the cooling effect of sulfur aerosols, which reflect and absorb the sun’s rays, favoring the formation of clouds that are less heat-absorbing than oceans. This phenomenon could have contributed to the record-breaking rise in temperatures in 2023 and 2024. Indeed, the authors of the study estimate that this reduction in emissions could lead to a global temperature rise of 0.16°C over seven years, with a particularly marked impact on the North Atlantic.

Scientific debate

The scientific community remains divided on the issue. Nicolas Bellouin, Professor of Climatology at the University of Reading, points out that this phenomenon, known as “climate penalty”, had long been anticipated. He recalls that the marine industry had tried to avoid the adoption of cleaner fuels by relying on the cooling effect of aerosols. Other scientists, such as Edward Gryspeerdt of Imperial College London, warn of the uncertainties associated with the magnitude of this cooling effect. They believe that the contribution of sulfur emission reductions to temperature increases remains an open question, requiring further research to confirm these results.

Consequences for the Marine Industry

Reducing sulfur emissions was primarily motivated by the need to improve air quality and reduce the impact on public health. However, the results of this study could prompt the shipping industry and regulators to reconsider the current approach, balancing the benefits for air quality with the potential climatic consequences. Jean-Louis Dufresne, climatologist and director of research at CNRS, highlights the complexity of analyzing small-scale climate disturbances over short periods. In his view, it is crucial to continue monitoring the long-term impacts of emission reduction policies to fully understand their effects on the global climate.
The study raises important questions about the balance between reducing air pollutants and managing global warming. Although reducing sulfur emissions has clear benefits for air quality, its potential impacts on climate require in-depth assessment. Future research should focus on the precise quantification of these effects and on finding innovative solutions to reconcile the fight against air pollution and global warming.

Ferrari unveiled the chassis of its first electric vehicle, the Elettrica, while announcing a revision of its electrification targets, favouring thermal and hybrid powertrains for the coming decade.
The main European automotive lobby is calling for looser 2030 and 2035 emission targets, promoting hybrids and carbon-neutral fuels.
Dubai's electricity authority strengthens its electric vehicle charging network through three major contracts with ENOC, Dubai Taxi and Parkin under its EV Green Charger programme.
TotalEnergies and Banque des Territoires create a joint venture to accelerate the rollout of public electric charging infrastructure in French municipalities, with a focus on urban and suburban areas.
Tesla has announced an event scheduled for October 7, hinting at the arrival of a more affordable vehicle amid a limited product refresh and growing competition in the electric vehicle segment.
Dacia presents an ultra-compact electric prototype priced under €15,000, betting on extreme simplification to compete with low-cost Chinese electric vehicles.
Berlin questions the ban on sales of combustion cars from 2035, as German automakers warn of economic and industrial risks for the country.
Stellantis CEO Antonio Filosa calls for adjustments to the 2035 deadline to safeguard industrial activity and accelerate decarbonisation through flexibility mechanisms.
Faced with falling margins and overcapacity, Beijing is restructuring its electric vehicle industry by focusing on quality, standards, and technological upgrading.
An American-built electric aircraft completed a test flight between Stavanger and Bergen, marking a key step in integrating zero-emission air cargo operations into Norwegian airspace.
The visit marks a new step in the cooperation between the United Arab Emirates and Tellus Power, aiming to establish an EV charging station production unit in the Gulf.
Toyota launches production of its first electric vehicle in Europe at its Kolin plant in the Czech Republic, supported by a €680mn investment, including €64mn in public funding.
The Canadian government invests CAD22.7mn ($16.7mn) in eight projects to strengthen the electric vehicle charging network in British Columbia.
Ireland presents an SAF roadmap structured around four pillars, projecting 88,000 tons in 2030 and 318,000 tons in 2035, aligned with ReFuelEU and European support, while Aer Lingus and Ryanair set usage targets.
Electric vehicle charging infrastructure investments are expected to hit $300 billion by 2040, driven by a 12.3% annual increase in global charging port deployments.
The Japanese group TDK’s venture capital fund supports Ultraviolette, an Indian electric motorcycle manufacturer, to help it scale up in a domestic market estimated at over $50 billion within ten years.
U Power announces the signing of a letter of intent to supply 300 battery-swapping compatible electric vehicles in partnership with a Hong Kong-based technology manufacturer, marking a major milestone for intelligent commercial mobility.
According to Ember, only 3% of India’s wind and solar targets for 2032 would be sufficient to cover the entire electric vehicle charging demand, provided appropriate measures are taken for grid management and charging infrastructure.
TotalEnergies holds 23% of the high-power charging market on French motorways, according to data published by Gireve, with more than 1,800 active points across 265 service stations.
The British government is mobilising USD845mn to subsidise electric-car purchases, easing pressure on an industry hit by US tariffs and preparing for the 2030 ban on internal-combustion engines.

All the latest energy news, all the time

8.25$/month*

*billed annually at 99$/year for the first year then 149,00$/year ​

Unlimited access - Archives included - Pro invoice

7 DAY PASS

Up to 50 items can be consulted for 7 days,
without automatic renewal

3$/week*

*Prices shown are exclusive of VAT, which may vary according to your location or professional status.

Since 2021: 30,000 articles - +150 analyses/week.